10 Wrestlers Banned From Using THEIR OWN Moves
Even the Undertaker couldn't cross the boss...
For somebody with balls the size of grapefruits, Vince McMahon was always something of a bitch.
He didn't want his talent to get dropped on their heads. Rampant chair shots were fine, but come on, it was the Monday Night Wars! There was a company and its independent contractors to put out of business!
No Japanese Ocean Cycle suplexes, no Burning Hammers, no Ganso Bombs: Vince dictated a safer and slower in-ring style premised on theatrical stalling and flat-back bump-and-feed offence. He didn't want his talent to burst through their matches too quickly nor soar through the skies with too many risky rotations, either.
Of course, Vince didn't do this out of the goodness of his heart, oh no. There were towns to make, an exhausting amount per week, in a loop that required his performers to drive themselves around in decent fettle.
This is why those moves were banned. There was an element of safeguarding to his restrictions, but it could be argued that the damage accumulated was still rather too much.
Sometimes, however, the promoter has little to do with it...
10. Andrade El Idolo
Andrade's spinning back elbow is a much-missed weapon from his arsenal; a perfectly-timed jaw-wobbler of a move, it is nearly up there with Kenny Omega's V-Trigger as the strike most likely to cause a concussion. It's invariably executed so safely that it only appears that way.
Of course, it isn't executed anymore: as Andrade teased on Twitter, he's no longer allowed to use it. It is easy to both infer and understand why.
Chris Jericho is one of AEW's top stars, and smashed his difficult, unprecedented task of launching the promotion as a television mainstay. In yet another extraordinary career reinvention, he has slimmed down and somehow rediscovered in 2008/9 form - but initially, he was playing the bulked-up heel bully. As part of the transition to top star heavyweight, he took on a new finisher, the Judas Effect.
He's protected the f*ck out of it, too; only Jon Moxley has kicked out of it in more than three years. He's done such a tremendous job with it that, despite not looking great, it is taken seriously as a guaranteed match-winner.
Andrade's is better, but Jericho's is more over, he was in AEW first, and he's a far bigger star.
That is how it works.
9. KENTA
There's no such thing as a curse; it's a bullsh*t supernatural phenomena, much like ghosts, werewolves and Kane.
That said, KENTA is justified in believing in them. Brought into NXT amid much fanfare, as the face of WWE's new drive to become a proper wrestling company on the side, his run was a disaster. He had already peaked, and suffered two separate serious injuries before making it to Vince McMahon's world. Because this was Hideo Itami, he barely made it there, only appearing on Kickoff shows as part of the 205 Live crew. Itami didn't even get a real botched main roster run.
Compounding this horrendous luck, he wasn't allowed to use his own finish for ages, and it was the coolest and most plagiarised of the 21st century. CM Punk had become synonymous with the Go To Sleep in WWE, and the company, pelted by chants of "CM Punk!" whenever they botched something - which was rather a lot - were wary of inviting yet more. WWE did soften on this, and Itami finally started to hit it after some lovely teases, but he wasn't allowed to hit the ground running with it from the off.
KENTA himself would likely appreciate the irony of the following entry...
8. CM Punk
Now, there were two reasons why CM Punk retired his Pepsi Plunge which, to the uninitiated, was a top-rope variation of Triple H's Pedigree.
Firstly, it was murder on the knees, which he drove into the mat from the top turnbuckle at a distance many fans, your writer among them, take for granted. The Pepsi Plunge was a young man's move, and he was intelligent enough to abandon it when he realised that he'd already been well established as an early cult hero of the nascent independent movement. He swapped the move for KENTA's GTS to in all likelihood troll fans who buried him for taking liberal inspiration from the Japanese scene.
Secondly, here's the thing: the fact of the matter is, there was never any chance of Punk bringing back the Pepsi Plunge in WWE because it was a cooler and more spectacular version of Triple H's finish, and nobody is cooler than Triple H. He rides a hog, wears a leather jacket, and gets sucked off by Divas onscreen. Not even on a special occasion did Punk bust it out again.
Triple H was right to do this, of course, since it was his move first and he was in WWE years before Punk was.
Them's-uh the breaks-uh.
7. The Undertaker And Kane
In a strange development, WWE implemented a blanket ban on the piledriver.
Citing safety concerns, shortly following the public listing of the company amid mounting pressure from the Parents Television Council, WWE did away with a move in 2000 that, like virtually any other, is entirely safe when executed correctly. Astonishingly, it took a full decade thereafter for WWE to ban unprotected chair shots to the head. Brain-scrambling weapon shots impossible to gimmick were fine, but a risky move done safely in the hands of professionals was not.
This directive was brought to you by the same company that said "A shallow cut opened up by a blade is bad, but Brock Lesnar is allowed to risk concussing people (which actually happened) because we can pretend he went into business for himself".
It's almost as though the better the worker was, the more likely they were to get punished.
That can't be true, actually, since Kane was affected by the edict: yes, for a very brief time, both Kane and the Undertaker were banned from using the Tombstone, replacing it with the Chokeslam and Last Ride respectively, before WWE softened their stance.
6. Seth Rollins
Not his own move, per se; the Curb Stomp was popularised in North America by Super Dragon, whose version was awesome.
Grabbing an opponent prone and face down on the mat by their arms, Dragon took one of the coolest things in wrestling - moves delivered to the head - and doubled the fun. With one swift and gruesome-looking strike, he kicked them in the back of their head and smeared their face across the canvas.
Seth's was unique enough to make it his own; his astute knowledge of the WWE style created a sense of theatrical anticipation around it; even if it didn't look as dangerous as Dragon's, the lurking menace of his body language enhanced it.
Vince McMahon's whims were quite insane, particularly when he suddenly stopped caring about them. Rollins revealed to Loudwire that Vince's "big concern was that kids could it to each other".
This wasn't remotely a bad protest - too many tragedies happen even if they're few and far between, so much so that every company should really underscore that wrestling should not be attempted at home - but it was very weird and very Vince that he said "F*ck it, the move was over, let's bring 'er back!" a few years later.
5. Seth Rollins (Again)
Another temporary ban that has since been lifted, this story if nothing else underscores the extraordinary way in which time unfolds in wrestling.
At Night of Champions 2015, Sting lost what was just his fourth match in WWE. For those keeping count, Sting lost to Triple H at WrestleMania 31. Then, he won a pair of Raw matches - he defeated the Big Show by DQ, after which he won the subsequent impromptu tag match alongside John Cena opposite Show and Seth Rollins - before Rollins defeated him at the pape. This means that - yes! - Sting went 50/50 in his WWE run. One of the most beloved babyfaces and iconic characters in wrestling history had the same winning record as f*ckin' Mojo Rawley or someone.
It was thought to be Sting's last ever match, since a botched Buckle Bomb, which was subsequently outlawed, brought an end to his career.
Remarkably - and imagine reading these words in 2015 - the Buckle Bomb was eventually reinstated and Sting came out of retirement to work an all-time great legend run as part of which he worked a ****1/2 match alongside Shingo Takagi.
4. Randy Orton
Randy Orton introduced a new, vicious move to his repertoire in 2007 following a suggestion made by former WWE road agent Arn Anderson.
It was an inspired choice in that it legitimised the heel character and Orton as a performer overall; he was stigmatised as a failed experiment after Triple H was through with him in 2004, and in the two years since, WWE overcompensated with cheap heat in his role as the antagonist of Eddiesploitation. The move was a great device because it allowed Orton not to just play the flawless if methodical mechanic. It added a brutal flash of danger to his style. It was abandoned shortly after he concussed Vince McMahon and, beyond the odd special occasion, was retired until 2020.
WWE relaxed the restriction, allowing him to perform a more safe and drastically more ironic version of the move in which Orton, who hates NXT even more than the most hardcore AEW tribalist, slaps his thigh to excuse himself from the risky timing of the original move.
While ironic, it is also sensible: Orton himself admitted to talkSPORT in 2020 that "it's kind of hard to 'work' for lack of a better term".
3. AJ Styles
The Styles Clash has a strange history, one that scuppered its pioneer from using it for a few weeks in WWE.
For years and years, AJ Styles executed his unique facebuster variation with zero incident, which was very impressive, given the rapid and convoluted set-up spots he dreamed up in Ring Of Honor in particular. While counter-intuitive for his opponents to take - unlike the vast majority of throws, the head mustn't be tucked - AJ's safety record was near 100%. Provided that one crucial step was taken (or rather not taken), the landing was as gentle as wrestling gets.
That was until AJ left TNA in 2014 and left a veritable spree of injuries in his wake. Both Yoshi Tatsu and Lionheart suffered broken necks, while others were only narrowly spared such a significant injury.
New Japan did an altogether too successful job of marketing the Styles Clash as a dangerous move to capitalise on the controversy; WWE were reluctant to let him use it, and he didn't, despite Michelle McCool using her own variation a few years prior, until Chris Jericho per Inside The Ropes slyly pitched it to Vince without telling him the name, and kicked out to prove it was safe.
2. Samoa Joe
Samoa Joe's Muscle Buster is a great finish.
The recipient is bent into an ungodly position, trapped in the hermetic seal of Joe's massive arms, and driven back-first into the mat. Or compressed back-first into the mat, because that's what it looks like. It's one of the most painful-looking bumps that isn't delivered to the neck or head.
Ideally, anyway; tragically, when Tyson Kidd took it, in a 2015 dark match, the injury to his neck was so severe that his career ended then and there. He was lucky to survive. It was described by everybody involved as a total fluke. Kidd told Chris Van Vliet earlier this year that it was just "one of those things". Joe went to the hospital with him. There are "zero" hard feelings.
Joe continued to use the Muscle Buster, albeit at a less acute angle, in NXT - but by the time he was "promoted" to the main roster, his Coquina clutch was emphasised in favour of it. The Wrestling Observer Newsletter reported that it was banned not because it was deemed unsafe, but rather out of respect for Kidd.
Joe himself disputes this, claiming his not using the move for a significant period on the main roster was his own artistic decision.
1. The Hurricane
It's a familiar tale, and one that brings this list to a close: virtually every cool move was banned by Vince McMahon for much of the 21st century because they looked very cool, dangerous and required a mastery of the pro wrestling form to execute safely.
But here's the thing: shouldn't WWE, as the biggest wrestling company of all time, hire the best masters of the craft and encourage them to execute the most spectacular moves ever seen?
That's the way it should go, surely. Instead, they are the recognised global leader in doing too many chinlocks. That might be an old take, but then again, the weekly TV is still a bit methodical, isn't it?
Helms' Vertebreaker was amazing - the sort of thing that would make Jim Ross say "Holy sh*t what's that?" when he isn't referring to an extra playing ring girl - but he was told not to use it very swiftly.
To his eternal credit, the Hurricane was one of the first athletically gifted but hardly monstrous performers who first learned how to game the WWE system. He was actually a pioneer in this regard: he got over by going the whole hog with a silly act expressly designed to pop Vince McMahon's dumber impulses.
He made a career out of it. Can't do that with a super indie-friendly finish.