10 Wrestlers Who Nearly Defected During The Monday Night Wars

You won't believe who the 4th member of the NWO nearly was (actually you will, he is pictured).

Bulldog Nwo At the height of the Monday Night Wars, Raw and Nitro were highlighted by an almost-weekly parade of wrestlers defecting from one company and showing up on the competition€™s program soon after. Think about some of the biggest moments from both promotions during that era: Lex Luger shows up on the first Nitro, Scott Hall interrupts a Nitro match, Chris Jericho interrupts a Rock promo, and the Radicalz take a seat in the front row of Raw. Defections were the norm in the mid- to late 90s through the closing of WCW in early 2001. Look at the WWF and WCW rosters from those days and you€™ll find plenty of examples of superstars who performed for both companies (in Rick Rude€™s case, televised on the same night). But there also are several wrestlers who were either rumored to or very nearly did jump ship one way or the other at some point €“ but for some reason, they decided to stand pat. Some of these guys staying put had a huge impact on the outcome of the Monday Night Wars. So let€™s look at 10 wrestlers who nearly jumped from one promotion to the other during the Monday Night Wars and see what their departures could have meant to the WCW/WWF battle for rating supremacy.

10. Yokozuna

By the time the Monday Night Wars were in full swing, Yokozuna was on the downswing of his WWF career. But that doesn€™t mean that the former champion didn€™t have some value to the competitor. At that time, Vince McMahon and Eric Bischoff would have been gleeful at poaching any former world champion, if only for bragging rights. With Yokozuna, the possibility of a rematch with Hulk Hogan loomed. The possible defection was described by former WCW star Konnan, who was friends with Yoko. He spoke about how the former champ loved K-Dogg€™s character in the nWo and the idea was to have Yokozuna €œcome in as a Samoan gangster and have my back.€ However, things never came to fruition, as Konnan said that Scott Hall tried to quickly facilitate a negotiation between Yoko and Bischoff, which offended Yokozuna. €œHe got offended and he never came in,€ Konnan said. It€™s a shame Yokozuna never got that one last chance to prove himself. Instead, he last appeared at 1999€™s horrific Heroes of Wrestling PPV before passing away a year later.

9. & 8. Shane Douglas And Konnan

Shane Douglas Konnan Okay, it might seem like cheating a little, but since The Franchise and Konnan€™s near-departure stemmed from the same incident, it€™s worth lumping them together. In early 2000, WCW lost a significant part of its talent pool when Chris Benoit, Eddie Guerrero, Dean Malenko and Perry Saturn jumped together to WWF. The foursome fled WCW after Kevin Sullivan was put in charge of booking, which was the last straw for them. They would debut in WWF as the Radicalz and go on to varying degrees of success, with Benoit and Guerrero famously closing WrestleMania XX holding both world championships. But that four that left WCW the day after the Souled Out PPV weren€™t the only ones who tried to leave. According to €œThe Death of WCW€ by R.D. Reynolds and Bryan Alvarez:
One week later, in what came as a shock to many, Busch actually lived up to his word and sent Benoit, Malenko, Guerrero, Saturn, Douglas, and Konnan unconditional releases. Konnan and Douglas did not sign due to the fact that both had bad blood with the WWF from years back (when Konnan was the original Max Moon and Douglas was a supposed dean), and they were therefore unlikely to get jobs there.
Granted, Douglas and Konnan might not have gotten WWF contracts. But then again, Vince would have loved to really rub it in with a half-dozen WCW stars showing up on Raw together, even if it meant sucking it up. At worst, he could have brought them on for a few months during the Radicalz€™s initial run. If there€™s one thing Vince loves more than holding a grudge, it€™s making money. And the sheer numbers of six WCW wrestlers jumping at once could have been tempting enough. Of course, that was about the last gasp in the Monday Night Wars, as WCW would be out of business 14 months later, and Douglas and Konnan would fade out of the limelight a little more.

7. British Bulldog (1996)

Yes, Davey Boy Smith did defect from WWF to WCW after the Montreal Screwjob €“ and then jumped back to WWF nearly two years later. But the British Bulldog very nearly had one of the most significant defections of them all in 1996, when he almost jumped to WCW to become the fourth member of the New World Order. Bulldog was battling Shawn Michaels unsuccessfully for the WWF Championship in 1996, so he was peaking as a main-event-level star just as the nWo was beginning its ascent. The story goes that Davey Boy had agreed to be fourth member of the renegade group, but he instead signed a new contract with the WWF on the day he was supposed to jump. In line with that thinking, look at who the fourth member actually was €“ The Giant €“ and when he joined €“ just three weeks after the nWo screwed Giant out of the WCW World Championship. It just didn€™t make sense from a storyline perspective. By staying with WWF for another year, Bulldog would with tag team gold with Owen Hart and become the inaugural European Champion, and he of course was part of the reformed Hart Foundation that dominated WWF in 1997. So it wasn€™t all bad to stay that extra year, but had he jumped then, Davey Boy Smith would have been an early member in one of the most influential groups in wrestling history.

6. Owen Hart

This one is a painful wishful thinking exercise for many wrestling fans, and Hart family members alike€ In the aftermath of the Montreal Screwjob, Davey Boy Smith and Jim €œThe Anvil€ Neidhart jumped to WCW with Bret Hart, effectively ending the Hart Foundation. Bret€™s younger brother, Owen, would try to join the rest of the clan despite questions of whether WCW would even know how to use Owen or could pay him the same as WWF, where he was arguably a bigger star than he likely would have been in WCW. However, Owen Hart was unable to leave WWF due to his contractual obligations, and he would remain with the company until his tragic death in May 1999. Even if Owen had been able to leave, there probably wouldn€™t have been a full Hart Foundation reunion. Neidhart and Smith teamed together in WCW, but they never joined forces with brother-in-law Bret Hart (there€™s a Thunder match where Hitman attacked the two and helped Lex Luger defeat them). WCW apparently was unable to recreate the Hart Foundation or face a lawsuit from WWF.

5. Randy Savage

At Halloween Havoc 1996, €œMacho Man€ Randy Savage lost a WCW title match against Hollywood Hogan and then faded into the shadows, as his contract expired. Savage sat at home for a couple months before returning to WCW in January 1997 and kickstarting the last great run of his career, highlighted by his joining the nWo and his rivalry with Diamond Dallas Page. But it was during his holiday that rumors persisted that Macho Man would defect back to WWF after a three-year absence from the company. Savage returning would have leant some established star power to Raw, which was rebuilding around established stars like Bret Hart and Undertaker with Shawn Michaels and Steve Austin. WCW, meanwhile, boasted some of the biggest stars of the 80s and 90s WWF and was in the midst of its 84-week reign in the ratings. Also, had Savage jumped, he would not have been a part of the nWo, which would have created a vacuum in the earlier days of the group. There would have been no memorable feud with DDP €“ which elevated Page to a main-eventer. As with many of these potential defections, there€™s a double-edged sword to leaving one promotion for another. (Savage also was rumored to jump in 1998, but WWF was on the rebound by that time. It still would have been huge and hurt WCW tremendously, but it wouldn€™t have been as earth-shattering as two years earlier.)

4. Hulk Hogan

(This is where it gets tough to rank the wrestlers, but let€™s see how it goes€) When Sting finally faced and defeated Hollywood Hulk Hogan for the WCW World Championship in controversial fashion at Starrcade 1997, it turns out it could have been an exit strategy for the leader of the nWo. Hogan€™s WCW contract expired the following month, and rumors were running rampant that he was going to jump back to WWF, possibly in time for the 1998 Royal Rumble. The speculation, however, turned out to be just that, as Hogan opted to stay on in WCW into 2000. The very thought of Hogan returning to WWF a full four years before he actually did might make a lot of fans giddy and also wonder why he€™s ranked here. It€™s more the context of the situation. Hulk Hogan jumping to WWF just before WrestleMania XIV, right at the cusp of the Austin Era, the genesis of the evil Mr. McMahon and the rebirth of D-Generation X. Where would Hogan have fit in? And how would Hulk and his *ahem* protective nature of his character have detrimentally affected these developments? Sure, fans can salivate about Hogan-Austin, Hogan-HHH and Hogan-Rock when Hulk was much more than a nostalgia act, but how would he have handled this rumored run? It€™s easy to envision Hogan pushing for a top spot on the WrestleMania XIV card, then looking to work with new champ €œStone Cold€ Steve Austin. Remember, two weeks after Mania, Raw ended Nitro€™s streak of winning the ratings war for 84 consecutive weeks. Hogan in WWF definitely would have provided an even bigger ratings bump in the short term, but would his presence have had lasting negative effects on the Austin-McMahon feud that defined the Attitude Era, or on the DX faction that would dominate the scene? Or would Vince recognize he had bigger things going forward rather than looking backward with Hogan?

3. Shawn Michaels

Shawn Michaels Outsiders When Scott Hall and Kevin Nash left WWF in summer 1996 and kicked off the hottest angle in professional wrestling, they also kicked off 84 consecutive weeks of WCW winning the ratings war. It also was the lowest low point for WWF during the Monday Night Wars. If a top star was looking at things dispassionately and only with his wallet in mind, he certainly would be tempted to jump to WCW for guaranteed money. For the Heartbreak Kid, the temptation was more than just money and ratings €“ Hall and Nash were Michaels€™ best friends in WWF, good enough friends that he and Triple H broke kayfabe with them in the infamous MSG Incident. Michaels, who was champ throughout summer 1996 has admitted in interviews that it was €œvery hard€ to resist the temptation to jump to WCW. He acknowledged in a SLAM! Wrestling interview that there €œwas never a formal offer from€ WCW, but that €œmy buddies always said the door was open there.€ While he sums up leaving WWF as a €œbrief thought€ that he €œquickly discarded,€ Michaels could be seen throwing hand signs to his buddies during promos (and vice versa), so he clearly had his friends on his mind during this period. HBK leaving for WCW in 1996 would have been devastating to WWF and very well could have tipped the scales even farther in WCW€™s favor. Without Michaels, there wouldn€™t have been a D-Generation X, which was a major driving force not just throughout the Attitude Era, but also in the rise of one of the most important people in the company today, Triple H. How would he have fared without a DX? It€™s almost too big of a €œWhat if?€ question to pose.

2. Bret Hart (1996)

Next to the Outsiders, Bret Hart was probably WCW€™s biggest defection from WWF during the Monday Night Wars. Sure there were other big stars who jumped, but Hart was the leader of the biggest heel faction in the promotion and the WWF champ who was screwed out of his title on his way out the door. And WCW almost had him a full year earlier. Hart was on the cusp of signing a three-year, $8.4 million deal with WCW in late 1996, but instead opted to sign a 20-year deal to stay with WWF, a deal that Vince McMahon clearly could not honor. It would end up leading to Hart€™s departure a year later via the Montreal Screwjob, at which point WWF turned the corner and began rising from the ashes. But if Hart had signed with WCW in 1996? Who would have faced €œStone Cold€ Steve Austin in the star-making submission match at WrestleMania XIII? Who would Vince have screwed at Survivor Series? Without Hart in WWF in 1997, it€™s unclear if Austin has that career-defining moment that led to people chanting his name. Without Hart, there certainly wouldn€™t have been a Montreal Screwjob, which was a catalyst for WWF€™s rise.

1. Ric Flair

In 1998, Ric Flair was engaged in a heated battle of his own with WCW over missing a show to watch his late son Reid wrestle. He was kept off television for months and slapped with a lawsuit as WCW president Eric Bischoff pretty much decided to make it personal with Flair. This led to the Nature Boy countersuing and trying to get his WCW contract nullified so he could possibly return to WWF. Granted, the 1998 version of Ric Flair was nowhere near the man who made a splash in WWF in 1991. But next to Sting, no man during the Monday Night Wars signified WCW more than Naitch, and Vince McMahon would have loved to have had Flair show up on Raw. Remember that even in late 1998, WWF had just recently ended WCW€™s 84-week ratings dominance and was still see-sawing week to week. Big-time defections like Big Show, Chris Jericho and the Radicalz were still months (or more than a year) away. A Flair defection would have represented a major coup for WWF, much like Bret Hart was for WCW in late 1997. The difference was the Flair was a known commodity to WWF fans, a former two-time WWF champ and Royal Rumble winner. Losing one of the biggest stars in the company€™s history could very well have been the death knell for WCW, accelerating the end of the Monday Night Wars. Flair also might have brought some other talent along with him, such as Arn Anderson and others who felt that WCW could turn on anyone at any time for anything. In the end, it took an additional four years before Flair made his return to a WWE ring, which really is a shame, because a Flair/Rock feud in 99 would have been gold. But that€™s a story for another day€

Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.