10 Wrestlers Other Wrestlers Were Scared Of

Striking cold fear into the hearts of men.

Paul Heyman New Jack

This one could've been subtitled, "when appearances aren't deceiving".

Wrestling is full of frightening characters, but most of them are fictional. For example, by all accounts, Glenn Jacobs is a lovely chap who is nowhere near as scary as his Kane character has been for decades on screen. Away from the ring, he's a true gent, and he's one of many false brutes able to separate ring from reality.

This list isn't preoccupied with those who perhaps raise hairs on the back of fan necks though. It's more about those workers who terrified the living crap out of others they shared locker rooms with. There are some seriously chilling souls here, ones who either loved playing up to reputations or were legitimate bad asses who would rather rip someone's face off than talk it out if things got heated.

They all share one thing in common. Every single one had several peers running for the hills or staying up the night before matches with acid reflux at the thought of stepping inside the ring with them. Welcome to pro wrestling's own personal (shoot) 'Hall Of Horrors'...


10. The Sheik

Orig Sheik
Grantland.com

First, the Syrian Desert slicer.

As 'The Sheik', Ed Farhat literally carved a reputation for himself as one of the most fearsome names in the business. When wrestlers talk about him now, they do so with an air of trepidation, almost like they're discussing some otherworldly horror like Stephen King's It.

Not only was Farhat the uncle of fellow hardcore maniac Sabu, he actually pioneered many of the bloodletting techniques his nephew would use in the original ECW. The Sheik was no stranger to juicy matches, and Jim Cornette has spoken on his podcast about how some jobbers would be visibly shaken when they learned who they were working with that night.

Most others knew that the gimmick was exactly that, but there remained a fear buried deep in people's heads that maybe Farhat was insane and would go into business for himself. He was one of wrestling's first realism-skewing madmen.


9. Ken Shamrock

Ken Shamrock
WWE

Chris Jericho might be the reigning AEW Champion, a merchandise-selling machine (who else sells bottles of champagne in 2019?) and one of the most chameleonic performers ever, but he's not an idiot. Even the mighty Jericho was smart enough to know that staying on Ken Shamrock's good side made sense.

In one of his books, Jericho recalled working with Shamrock in the WWF. The spot called for him to slap Kenny around then run from the ex-UFC hard man back up the ramp. The only problem was that Shamrock didn't take kindly to Jericho's 'bullsh*t chops' and got heated for real.

Jericho would be forgiven for doing a "Bad Mama Jama" in his pants.

Shamrock chased him up the aisle and reportedly wouldn't stop even when both tumbled through the curtain backstage. Jericho found out first hand what should've been obvious: Ken Shamrock's shoot fight background made him a wrestling powder keg.


8. Bob Holly

Hardcore Holly Matt Cappotelli Tough Enough Incident
WWE

There are varying reports on exactly what happened during the third season of WWE's faux-reality show Tough Enough in 2002. Some have claimed Bob Holly's beatdown on rookie Matt Cappotelli was something the trainee knew about beforehand. Others have criticised Holly's roughhouse approach towards a newbie.

If Bob was looking to strike fear into the hearts of wrasslin' trainees everywhere, he succeeded.

Holly was another who earned a hard man reputation for taking zero sh*t and sticking up for the industry at every turn. Apparently, he felt guys like Cappotelli were taking WWE's lifestyle lightly, so he decided to teach them a lesson. That, according to guys like Al Snow, JBL and more, was just 'Bob being Bob', even if he was heavy-handed.

The bruises he left on Cappotelli's body became a chilling reminder to rooks everywhere that WWE wasn't an easy gig. Watching his super-stiff blows on someone who blatantly doesn't know how to cope with them is difficult even now.


7. Roger Smith

Wrestlers don't have to be stiff or shoot fighters to be feared. Others, like the inconspicuous Roger Smith, were scary for other reasons. Jim Cornette has spoken on his podcast about how Smith (who once wrestled as Dusty parody 'Dirty Rhodes' and was part of The Assassins) creeped everyone out with his lifestyle.

He told Corny one day that he felt like killing himself and "taking all of his friends with him". That prompted the loudmouth manager to nervously joke that he was never fond of Roger. Other freaky stories about the guy include the time he burned a cross into promoter Nick Gulas' front lawn due to a disagreement over pay, booking or something else.

Roger Smith = statement maker.

Finally, he became legendary in locker rooms for tangling with police. He took a woman hostage and ended up with a SWAT team outside his home. Smith took being feared to a whole new level. His antics gave many backstage goosebumps.


6. Minoru Suzuki

minoru suzuki
NJPW

There's a personal touch to this one from your writer, one who may leave the country if Suzuki-san reads this.

The Japanese hard nut has worked more MMA fights than most wrestlers could only dream of. What's more, he currently has a 30-20 win-loss record, and 22 of those victories came via submission. In other words, Minoru Suzuki could stretch you like Stu Hart in his prime, and he'd probably enjoy doing it.

Anyone who has met or worked with Suzuki could tell you that his mild-mannered presence and polite-but-stoic greetings belie the fighter underneath. He's fairly passive, though one gets the feeling he could snap at any moment if he felt disrespected. It's amazing to watch as grown men and women tip-toe around the guy.

Inside the ring, Suzuki is a workhorse for sure, albeit a snug one. He's the walking definition of 'strong style', and he clearly doesn't shy away from physicality. His rich history in MMA, wrestling, kickboxing and the shoot-style UWF prove that Suzuki is a bad ass who loves a scrap.


5. Brian Pillman

Brian Pillman Loose Cannon
WWE.com

If Brian Pillman's 'Loose Cannon' gimmick was an ice cream flavour, it'd be anything other than vanilla.

He completely reinvented his fortunes by creating an off-the-wall character and convincing several in the industry that he'd lost his damn mind. 'Loose Cannon' became something Pillman played relentlessly in and out of the ring; Eric Bischoff has spoken about times he and others genuinely feared for Bri's sanity.

It was all a work, but not many knew that. The fact he was able to tear down established relationships with people he'd known for years and reposition himself as someone to be feared is astonishing. In the mid-90s, there were few better at working the boys than Brian Pillman. People actually believed he was crazy.

His short-lived stay in ECW turned heads, and his ability to work WCW into releasing him so he could sign for great money in the WWF was super-villain like genius. Everything about Pillman's run as the character reeked of psychotic behaviour only a deranged soul could dream up.


4. André The Giant

andre the giant
WWE.com

Get the mammoth André The Giant to the bar, put a drink in his hand and call him "Boss", and you'd likely get on with the legend. Drinking stories from his remarkable life are well-told, but there's no doubt the giant struggled with his size, health and the attention his massive frame garnered everywhere he went.

He also wasn't fond of those who didn't respect the locker room.

Bruce Prichard told on his podcast how André wasn't fond of working with The Ultimate Warrior, especially when he found out that Warrior wasn't trying to fit in with friends backstage. When they wrestled a series of house show matches on a tour loop, the giant made sure to let 'Wa-yee-ah' know not to f*ck around by stiffing him and generally being uncooperative with the babyface sensation's comebacks.

Others knew that André could be a handful if he didn't like you. Get on the wrong side of the big guy and you were going to have a rough night. That was just the way it was, and that (along with his immense stature) made Warrior and more terrified of working with him.


3. Bruiser Brody

Bruiser Brody
WWE.com

The entire aura behind Lex Luger's 'Lex Express' rise in the early-90s would've been shattered had WWF fans witnessed his scared expression when the wild-eyed Bruiser Brody stopped selling his punches in 1987. Right there in the middle of a cage match, Brody decided to quit playing along and stared a hole through the well-muscled newcomer.

Uh oh.

Lex wasn't the first to ponder if Bruiser was genuinely dangerous. That threatening mystique was something Brody would pride himself on throughout his career, and he successfully managed to freak Luger out. According to The Wrestling Observer's report later, Brody told Lex afterwards that he didn't have a problem with him, but said the match 'just wasn't working'.

He might've told Luger that when he stopped selling. Per the Observer, a ringside fan reportedly heard Lex yell to referee Bill Alfonso, "Get the door open, he's nuts!", though this isn't audible in some fan-cam footage from the event.


2. New Jack

New Jack
WWE

Just look at those eyes.

ECW's hardcore-happy brawler wasn't going to win any awards for 'Best Technical Wrestler' during his prime, but then that wasn't what New Jack was all about. He was there to give fans exactly what they wanted, and his weapons-laced stunt sequences played out like a live music video to the sounds of 'Natural Born Killaz'.

New Jack didn't shy away from violence, and his infamous part in the 'Mass Transit Incident' had the entire wrestling world debating right and wrong. When ex-bounty hunter Jack was around, people knew they were going to see blood, glamourised brutality and probably some balcony dives.

Paul Heyman said during a 2016 Q&A tour that he couldn't hope to manage New Jack's insatiable need for destruction. So, he let him be and typically accentuated his strengths. That, as the ex-ECW chief also explained, isn't to say that most wrestlers were thrilled when they found out they were taking a beating.


1. Haku

haku 2001
WWE.com

Call him Haku, call him Meng, call him Tama Tonga, but don't call him anything disrespectful. Unless, of course, you fancy having someone bite your nose off or like going toe-to-toe with someone countless wrestlers have called the single toughest man in the entire industry.

Haku's exploits are stuff of legend, and it's no surprise that he tops this list. Put it this way: Bobby Heenan said during a shoot interview that André The Giant confided in him that he was scared of the man. That says it all, and so does the fact Kevin Sullivan witnessed him bite a chunk of flesh out of some poor fella's back and spit it back at him.

That's just for starters.

Shane Douglas once watched in awe as cops maced Haku without any success, and Heenan couldn't fathom what he was seeing when the Tongan reached into another chap's mouth with two fingers and snapped off some teeth. He's wrestling's most feared for a reason, and everyone in the biz knows it.

What other workers were wrestlers legit scared of? For more wrestling, check out 10 Wrestling Facts We Didn't Know Last Week (Nov 29) and 10 Small Details Wrestling Still Can’t Get Right!


Watch Next


In this post: 
New Jack
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.