10 Wrestlers That Have Suffered Since WWE WrestleMania 35
The only way is down.
Is WrestleMania a lie, or are the cracks around its once-proven truths starting to show?
WWE have dined out on forcing through "WrestleMania Moments" in recent years, often at the expense of logical narrative. Network specials donate time to dovetailing personal journeys that often shine spotlights on the lows of reaching the supposed personal and professional apex rather than the obvious highs. The shows themselves have become long to a fault - main events will continue to play subdued hums for years to come as long as the punters expected to pop have been sat there for seven hours.
'The Showcase Of The Immortals', by definition of that very nickname, should be the destination that solidifies stars forever. Yes, even a showpiece event has to have a midcard, but the increased prestige of the occasion used to set up as much as it paid off. Now, a taste of the good life is all some of these sacks of sh*t will ever get to appreciate, so fleeting and flawed is the fame.
It's not an exact science of course (as a sister piece for to this piece later this week will examine...), but WWE's pinnacle hasn't ever been as precipitous.
10. Tony Nese
Babyfaced in spite of his incredible abs earlier this year, the Tony Nese/Buddy Murphy Cruiserweight Championship clash held in front of a half-empty Metlife Stadium was a little bit of a banger, but the title switch didn't represent any sort of change for the division at large.
Murphy's 'Best Kept Secret' nickname was all too true throughout his reign - his contests were rarely pushed beyond the pre-show despite consistently over delivering on the measured expectations of the early-arrivers at pay-per-views. Never rewarded beyond the swathes of online praise his performances received, Murphy's loss didn't make a new star in Nese, nor did the match set anything in motion for either of them going forward.
For Nese, this was merely an unfortunate byproduct of the poisoned chalice he was now forced to sip from. For the Australian outgoing champion, a switch to SmackDown in a post-WrestleMania Superstar Shakeup should have been his overdue escape hatch.
However...
9. Buddy Murphy
Buddy Murphy did so little during his first few months on SmackDown that it was actually made into a minor storyline point when he was finally-sort-of-but-not-really welcomed into the show over the Summer months.
Initially batting back Kevin Owens' attempts to speak up for him against Shane McMahon to remind everybody he was a heel, Murphy then took a sh*tkicking from Roman Reigns as part of the wretched whodunnit angle featuring Daniel Bryan and Rowan. This at least triggered a blinding contest with 'The Big Dog' weeks later and a follow-up victory over Bryan too, but both were false dawns for the blue brand star who somehow remains a 'Best Kept Secret'.
Frustratingly so, too. Both major matches delivered, and even though Bryan puts everybody over when he can, that victory in particular felt significant for something or other, even if defining what that was required careful crafting in the subsequent weeks. Murphy didn't get anything like that, instead becoming Just Another Guy on a roster full of them.
Great talent is usually too great to stifle and his time will surely come again, but moving up that WrestleMania Kickoff card beyond the battle royal seems unlikely.
8. Curt Hawkins & Zack Ryder
More pre-show favourites having a big night in New Jersey here, with Curt Hawkins and Zack Ryder's victory unquestionably the peak of their singles and doubles careers within WWE despite the former having his lovable loser running gag gimmick axed by virtue of the win.
Stripped of cynicism, this was a worthy moment for two hard-working wrestlers who make no secret of their pro wrestling adoration. The pair have a thoroughly enjoyable podcast dedicating to collecting figures, and not just because they couldn't exactly do one on accolades. The win was, somewhat predictably, all show and no "where-are-we-gonna-go?", though.
Far from being joke champions like the B-Team or Braun Strowman and a f*cking child, the former Major Brothers received an inconsequential two-month run before The Revival took back what they probably shouldn't have been booked to lose in the first place.
Keen to be "toyetic", both Ryder and Hawkins will presumably receive countless new action figures depicting their attires for the night (tributes to Christian, and the New York Jets, respectively), isolating the titular "suffering" to life chasing the 24/7 Title on Raw.
7. The Miz
Worth noting here, as with Curt Hawkins and Zack Ryder, that nothing about Miz' real life in 2019 could be considered suffering - the former WWE Champion has recently welcomed his second daughter into the world, whilst his reality TV vehicle alongside wife Maryse speaks to his broad appeal beyond the sometimes-limited scope within WWE.
But speaking of that scope, it's just not been a good time to be The Miz: WWE Superstar.
Failing to get some comeuppance on the night itself, Miz lost at WrestleMania then struggled on against Shane McMahon until the programme concluded with him as the inarguable loser. 'The A Lister' didn't get a single measure of revenge against 'The Money', nor was he given any sort of upward momentum as he left the feud behind.
A competant sh*t-stirrer with Miz TV and a performer so perfectly pitched with WWE polish that he'll never not be valuable to them, Miz' duff spell speaks to the form that preceded it. Giving the Intercontinental Championship (and the matches he contested for it) life, he now looks underserved doing nothing despite having career security and safety the watching world would envy.
6. The Usos
WrestleMania 35 provided sweet solace for The Usos after years of being overlooked on the event and a maiden appearance in 2018 lost to its position following Ronda Rousey's remarkable, glowing display.
Jimmy and Jey were again on multi-man duty defending SmackDown Tag Team Championships, but were at least on the right end of the result, getting by The Bar and cobbled-together Ricochet/Aleister Black and Rusev/Shinsuke Nakamura pairs. Heavy favourites, they prevailed in a predictable match with a predictable outcome, but for two industry grafters, it was the least they deserved.
Everything since has been a let down.
Their run-ins with the law, whilst trivialised with John Cena on Raw Reunion, have left a bitter taste for some, and this feels reflected internally by their booking of late. Virtually AWOL from television let alone the brand's Championship picture, the brothers' overdue move to Raw following the 'Show Of Shows' didn't remotely relight their momentum - the pair were repeatedly unsuccessful in their attempts to take the flagship straps.
The New Jersey 'Show Of Shows' spotlighted their gradual growth in the prior 12 months. Everything's been stunted since.
5. The IIconics
Yet more title-winners crowned for the moment on the night without the company thinking of how to effectively manage their reign, comedy acts Peyton Royce and Billie Kay were clearly thrilled to win gold on the 'Grandest Stage', but ultimately weren't remotely equipped to stop a joke reign turning the belts themselves into a punchline.
Caught in the crossfire of the decision to take the newly-created titles from Sasha Banks and Bayley, The IIconics already had a bit of an uphill struggle, but it was as if WWE wanted the problem to go away by itself rather than addressing the damage that had already been done.
Royce and Kay are so so good at what they do, but what they do isn't have captivating matches, which is exactly what those belts required. Women's wrestling remains on a precarious precipice, and the rank reduction of prestigious prizes does nothing for a "Revolution" or however they'd choose to brand it now.
As well as being unfairly maligned for bad decisions, The Aussies seemingly received less television time as a result, too. A multi-pronged disaster, it will rank high amongst the year's worst booking decisions.
4. Drew McIntyre
Injury has robbed Drew McIntyre of television time for much 2019's long and fascinating summer stretch, but his time away couldn't really be timed any worse.
The 'Scottish Psychopath' enjoyed a humorous spell as Shane McMahon's sidekick following the 'Show Of Shows' but the position was ultimately reductive - Drew had taken years to reestablish some agency in an organisation he'd once been booted from for being a busted flush, but his NXT stint and last year's main roster successes were both scuppered by a lack of coherent direction either side of the 'Showcase Of The Immortals'.
Consensus says he could and should just be pushed as an unstoppable monster again when he returns, not least with Paul Heyman currently at the creative helm. This is likely to work too, but as his 2019 has thus far suggested, where and how the company build him beyond being unbeatable remains a great unknown.
3. Aleister Black
At WrestleMania 35, Aleister Black wrestled the second of four matches that weekend, announcing himself as a reliable workhorse and somebody capable of popping four different crowds on very different evenings. Not quite a polymath, he'd nonetheless positioned himself as an extremely reliable and dynamic future headliner.
To celebrate this, WWE put him in a wardrobe.
Spending weeks upon months in a f*cking empty room challenging nobody in particular to "pick a fight" with him, Black's fleeting appearances with the ne'er-do-wells on the other side of his door have been greeted with half the response his original outings had because it's no longer clear what's actually going on with the character.
Yes, before WrestleMania he was a goth with his own creaking platform entrance and an ill-explained bond with the 'One and Only', but at least the matches were admirable showcases of his seriously impressive sh*t. His first major outing after leaving the broom cupboard against Cesaro did more for the 'Swiss Superman', whilst subsequent squashes have advertised his offering far less than one of his old pre-WrestleMania hot tags.
There's a wonderful, wonderful talent literally and figuratively trapped in the system at present. Black and his fans will be hoping the impeding draft can trigger a much-needed rethink.
2. Rusev
Rusev's recent Raw return felt several lifetimes removed from his WrestleMania 35 appearance alongside Shinsuke Nakamura, but his summer disappearance shouldn't have been paid off by such a pathetic return.
It's not as though the ill-matched and ill-conceived pair were doing a great deal either side of the 'Show Of Shows', but a distinct lack of interest then should have foreshadowed how the rest of the year would ultimately play out for a man once kept undefeated for nearly an entire year on the main roster.
This is not the Rusev that once looked like a serious contender to John Cena. This isn't even the Rusev that was over as a f*ck with Aiden English. This simply isn't Rusev Day.
'The Bulgarian Brute' might well be finished in WWE if they thought so little of him that this was their main idea for his long-awaited comeback, but that disinterest won't magically sever a bond he's built (and rebuilt) with the audience over the past several years.
1. Kofi Kingston
Sadly some craic few fans wanted to confront for the longest time has now been given enough evidence to become objective - Kofi Kingston's WWE Championship reign peaked when he won it.
An incredible victory over Daniel Bryan after an incredible match capped off an incredible story for an incredible man. All huge, career-defining endings. All things Kingston simply couldn't follow up on.
The quintessential Good Wrestler in 2019, the New Day man's matches with Dolph Ziggler, Kevin Owens, Samoa Joe and Randy Orton have been just fine at their very best and actually pretty f*cking dispiriting at their worst. A deeply sympathetic and deserving babyface, Kofi's fire felt forced from the moment he joined Seth Rollins in a post-WrestleMania celebration.
This isn't to say he hasn't done wonderful things in his newfound position of power - a Network special on his trip to Ghana was almost as moving as the scenes when he scooped the prize in New Jersey - but few would complain if Brock Lesnar flattened him when the pair go to war on the first Fox edition of SmackDown.