10 Wrestlers That Made Fans Change The Channel

Clicker Bait.

Edge Lita Live Sex Celebration
WWE

This is a positive list.

In the wrestling critic game, you see a lot of "too much negativity", "too much Triple H-bashing", and, oddly enough, "too much criticism". So there's almost none of that here.

Outside of this into, there will be no mention of Triple H and his channel-changing heat from the reign of terror and/or The Authority's vice-like grip on the product between 2013 and 2015. None at all.

"Changing the channel" comes with such negative connotations, which is strange considering the war-torn Wednesdays we remain enchanted by and the Monday Night battles that defined the viewing experience for an entire generation of wrestling fans.

Ratings, numbers and other similar measurables can suck the creative spirit out of any industry, but pro wrestling remains a theoretically fantastic destination for rewarding the talent that make the graphs point upwards. Especially outside of celebrated boom periods.

Almost all of the wrestlers in this list took viewers away from an opposing show or simply oversaw a spike in numbers that could be directly attributed to them.

Say what you will about 'The Game', but he never did that.

10. Stone Cold Steve Austin (1998)

Stone Cold Steve Austin Vince McMahon
WWE

'The Rattlesnake' went head to head with Vince McMahon in the main event of the April 13th 1998 edition of Monday Night Raw, but the pair were locked in battle together against WCW for about a year before they finally managed to win a ratings fight on a Monday Night.

It had been the prior April when Austin's babyface turn had truly been cemented thanks to the escalated stakes in his legendary feud with Bret Hart. It turned 'The Hitman' heel, brought about a new version of the Hart Foundation and even triggered a civil war between America and Canada. More important than all of that was the patience shown to stick with it in spite of numbers that weren't racing up. Or ones that were but still couldn't catch Nitro's on the other side.

It's sad to say it but only more exhilarating to watch in archive footage as a result, but Austin's push would have been halted several times in 2020 even if he'd never suffered a neck injury half way through. The ones that make it through the trickier times unscathed as he did are now tragically the exception rather than the rule.


9. Hulk Hogan (1996)

Hollywood Hogan
WWE.com

It was absolutely amazing just how f*cking sick WCW's audience were of Hulk Hogan by the end of 1995.

Amazing because it was high time the insecure old icon got some real-time feedback for his hideously stale act. Amazing because there was literally nothing left to love about a man that was very clearly using and abusing his influence rather making it count. And amazing because WCW were going live with Nitro every week and there was only so much sound-sweetening to quieten some of those boos during his main events.

Going nuts with his booking at the time, Hogan turned to the dark side (a bit) in his war with the Dungeon Of Doom with a series of skits and promos that felt even more out of date than the Billionaire Ted skits portrayed the 'Huckster' as on the other channel.

Far from a slaughter before June 1996, this was a war and Hogan didn't appear to have the heavy artillery for it. Until he turned heel.

An inspired bit of business that still holds up today, Hulk going 'Hollywood' gave fans the cathartic release they'd needed for well over a year in a way that fed the angles, enlivened the broadcasts and got everybody talking. For months, the mere thought of heel Hogan made viewers pine for more of it on the six days Nitro didn't air.

He wasn't alone, of course...


8. The Outsiders (1996)

The Outsiders Debut Wcw
WWE.com

History has reduced WCW's 83 week winning streak between 1996 and 1998 as the pick-me-up WWE desperately needed after years of trying and failing to find the next Hulk Hogan. This is entirely because it's Vince McMahon's organisation that gets to tell the story.

Why should a run of Nitros be diminished in status to how they impacted Raw, rather than just celebrated on their own terms? Well, to ask anybody entrenched in the Stamford bubble, it's because they only did it with WWE stars anyway.

Though Scott Hall spoke with enough Razor Ramon ticks to trigger a lawsuit that put a sharp stop to all that, the Atlanta outfit weren't getting viewers back the next week just to see 'The Bad Guy'. Nor were they overly concerned with Diesel after about a month of Kevin Nash's adjectives.

This was a hot angle with major stars that rapidly moved the soon-to-be-named Outsiders on from anything they'd achieved in the years prior. They were but two men, yet constantly looked like they had a physical and mental advantage over the entire organisation. Believably powerful and threatening, they were everything then that the hundred-strong RETRIBUTION could never be now.


7. Jon Moxley (2020)

Jon Moxley
AEW

Jon Moxley is the rarest of birds in mainstream North American wrestling at present, and not just because he's the first top babyface in nearly 20 years to embody and embolden enough qualities to actually be received as such by the entire audience.

Though the figures aren't comparable to Steve Austin or Hulk Hogan, Moxley can be classified as a "draw" by all contemporary standards. WWE deemed pay-per-view dead in 2014, yet AEW found 100,000 buyers for Chris Jericho/Moxley at Revolution, Moxley/Brodie Lee at Double Or Nothing and Moxley/MJF at ALL OUT. His google rankings dwarf everybody else in the organisation aside from 'Le Champion' and his quarter hours routinely dwarf others on both Wednesday shows.

John Cena was considered a house show hook for years for WWE. If he was there, the audience had at least one good reason to buy a ticket. In an era with no live event component to the business model, Moxley is doing the same - and isn't having a detrimental impact on the midcard below him to remain in the spot.


6. John Cena (2004/2005)

WWE Judgment Day 2005 John Cena JBL
WWE.com

In the months leading up to the money-sh*tting WrestleMania 21, it appeared as though Dave Batista would leave the show as the company's number one man thanks to the scale and placement of his long and tantalising programme with Triple H. On retrospective reading, the numbers always supported John Cena's eventual move to Monday Night Raw.

After months of JBL stabilising but failing to increase SmackDown ratings as the show's Champion, Cena's return from a "stabbing" (he was actually filming The Marine) resulted in the blue brand's viewership bringing the 2004 average up, and ensured the run up to the 'Show Of Shows' was seen by thousands more than had been watching the prior summer.

Lows of 2.5/2.6 in August and September were reversed rapidly, with big nights for the future 'Champ' generating 3.5/3.6 and even a 3.7 at various points in December, January and March, with 3s posted in the aftermath of his title victory over Layfield.


5. Rhea Ripley (2019)

Rhea Ripley
WWE

As good as it got for NXT in the first (and only?) year of the Wednesday Night War with AEW, the last live episode of 2019 saw the black-and-gold brand batting back the idea that only main roster involvement could draw against Dynamite. This, frustratingly, was achieved thanks to careful and patient longterm booking to go along with banger matches. They still know how to do this, yet they choose not to.

Rhea Ripley had arrived on the brand well before the show was on USA or two hours long, unafraid of the dominant Shayna Baszler. Unlucky not to beat her outright in her formal debut, some enormous success over Survivor Series weekend made her challenge inevitable and her victory undeniable.

The pair tore it up in an exhilarating headliner, all while AEW made one of their only major missteps thus far on the other side. People weren't as interested in the original version of the Dark Order popping fake blood in the mouths of the Young Bucks when they could see the 'Queen Of Spades' and 'The Nightmare' knocking seven shades out of each other for one of the industry's most prestigious prizes. The 112,000 difference (NXT drew 795,000 to AEW's 693,000) between the two shows has only been topped by WWE's developmental once ever since.


4. Bill Goldberg (1998)

hogan goldberg
WWE.com

Blah blah blah WCW should have saved this for pay-per-view blah blah showed they were panicking blah blah.

You know that bit of the story (and have probably read it on this author page let along every other site on the internet), but not enough people stop for a second to enjoy the magic of one of the last great moments WCW managed to create. Not least because it was one that no WWE homer could remotely claim as their own.

'Hollywood' Hogan was the hideously wonderful creation of Eric Bischoff, Hulk himself and the WCW braintrust, and had maintained a vice-like grip on the company's beloved Heavyweight Championship for the better part of two years when Goldberg bulldozed him for it in July 1998. Big Bill was all theirs too - a unique offering when the company desperately needed one, the ex-NFLer clearly wasn't built for a long time but a f*cking really good one. And did many times look better than inside the packed Georgia Dome in July 1998?

WCW needed more than mere moments to reverse the company's ailing fortunes. But as a wrestling organisation ran by a television company, the 6.91 rating (translating to over 5 million viewers), this one glorious night confirmed their most recent creation as a bonafide smash hit.


3. Brodie Lee (2020)

Brodie Lee
AEW

On the September 9th 2020 edition of Dynamite, AEW managed to break a million viewers for the first time since October 16th 2019. This despite the fact that the show had been moved around the schedule due to TNT's commitment to the NBA, and the ongoing global b*stard that had caused the scheduling kerfuffles in the first place.

This was cause for celebration, and several acts and angles could theoretically take credit for the result - including the uncomfortable promotion of Matt Hardy, who was last seen looking to be suffering from serious head injuries at a pay-per-view days earlier - but Brodie Lee can justifiably stand atop the rest just as he did at the end of the episode.

His demolition of Cody and The Nightmare Family weeks earlier completed the improbable (second) overhaul of The Dark Order, anoiting the stable as AEW's most potent thread and its leader as the pitch black counterpart to heroic Heavyweight Champion Jon Moxley.

The whole product is strong, but as the Dark Order have now proven on and off screen, there's even greater strength in numbers.


2. Edge (2006)

Edge Lita Live Sex Celebration
WWE

It'd be unfair on the "Rated-R Superstar' to reduce his ratings-grabbing maiden run with the WWE Championship to nothing more than sex and violence, even if that's what they put on his official t-shirt at the time.

Edge cashing in Money In The Bank on John Cena (itself a first) at 2006's New Year's Revolution was the first moment audiences in revolt against the omnipresence of 'The Champ' had been given reason to believe it might not always be like this.

The bloodied and battered "babyface" was beaten by the well-rested Challenger in fairly quick fashion. His loss promised curiosity views before Edge and Lita promoted some mid-ring shagging as further motivation to turn up.

Raw shot up over half a ratings point for that, but went up higher for a grisly title defence against Ric Flair, and stayed there as Cena and the new titleholder promoted their rematch for the Royal Rumble. The run was never meant to extend beyond that destination, but this was much to the chagrin of those that had loved Raw's new energy with Edge on top. He'd passed several crucial tests in a matter of weeks.


1. Stone Cold Steve Austin (2001)

Stone Cold Steve Austin
WWE.com

The story had to conclude - as most stories do - with an actual ending. In this case, it was the climax of an era and gradual demise of Stone Cold Steve Austin's incredible aura.

Oddly enough considering who helped him reach the top of the mountain in the first place, there was a certain Bret Hart quality to Austin's 2001 heel stint. Some of it was really f*cking good, but nowhere near enough people were watching to justify it.

Hardcores were rewarded with dynamic performances in the ring as well as a cavalcade of wholly unique and refreshing comedic performances. But the casuals were sent packing, satisfied enough with WrestleMania X7 and catching The Rock in films instead that they didn't even want to browse what 'The Rattlesnake' was selling, let alone buy it.

The Raw after Austin's heel turn generated a strong 5.7 rating against a 4.8 exactly 364 days later, and the year-on-year pattern was relatively consistent. His body and mind were in no fit state to continue either - the golden goose was cooked and WWE had failed to ready another to continue the feast.


WWE Quiz: How Well Do You REALLY Know Stone Cold Steve Austin?

stone cold steve austin
WWE.com

1. What Was Stone Cold's Birth Name?

In this post: 
Lita EDGE
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.