10 Wrestlers That Should Ask WWE For Their Release

When you can't change your situation, change yourself: the wrestlers who should abandon their WWE gimmicks and start afresh.

When Daniel Bryan signed with the WWE, his mentor William Regal warned him - and the way Bryan tells it, these are his exact words - €œYour wrestling career is what you did before this. Anything after is just a bonus.€ And that€™s the thing that people don€™t get about WWE: their spiel about being an entertainment conglomerate isn€™t just empty corporate rhetoric. €˜WWE Superstars€™ are used to having ten minute matches cut down to six or less; to being denied permission to be creative in the ring; to having to tone down their natural inclination to steal the show, because they€™re too low down the card to wrestle as though they matter. In the last few years, more than a few developmental or lower card WWE performers have asked for their release in order to simply go out and wrestle. They recognised that they weren€™t going to be used the way they wanted to be, or earn the money they wanted to, and opted to leave - on good terms - before their value depreciated any further. Similarly, wrestlers like Colt Cabana and the Young Bucks have proven that you can earn as much or more on the independents as you can on the mid-to-lower end of a WWE contract, if you€™re prepared to work your tail off, manage yourself and become your own cottage industry. There are few employment benefits to being a WWE performer, and in many cases the upside that comes from being on television can be cancelled out if those appearances are in nothing segments or humiliating losses. Let€™s look at a few current members of the WWE roster who€™d likely be better off taking a cue from Solomon Crowe or Ricardo Rodriguez and asking for a release.

10. Titus O'Neill

Ahhh, big Titus. He€™s clearly got a size and strength upside, he can talk, and he has the ability to connect with the crowd, but when the Primetime Players first split they immediately turned him heel on Darren Young, thereby nullifying the last few months of hard work as a babyface. Part of O€™Neill€™s appeal is that genial grin atop that bulldozer of a body. The winner of the MEGA Celebrity Dad of 2015 award, he edged out actors Stephen Amell, Ashton Kutcher and Vin Diesel and soccer legend David Beckham: men far more famous and easy on the eye than him. Thaddeus Bullard has the hard work and media presence aspects of being a top WWE superstar down pat€ but he€™s forty years old next year, and has yet to receive a significant push. More worrying is the fact that he was just suspended for two months for getting cheerfully physical with a WWE Chairman who€™s been notorious for encouraging that kind of behaviour for a quarter of a century. However, even before that frankly bizarre disciplinary action, it€™s been obvious for a while that WWE have no plans for Titus O€™Neill to move up in the card. Astonishingly, the Primetime Players have only won tag team gold once in four years of teaming up, and there€™s no obvious reason as to why that might be when the tag team titles swap hands so often. It€™s certainly a good indication of the lack of interest WWE have in the team or in its constituents, though. From all appearances, Titus O€™Neill is wasting the last good years of his wrestling career in a company that will always have their eye on someone else: but there are dozens of opportunities out there for a man with his size, presence, work ethic and track record to shine. It might be a good idea to take Big Dave€™s advice and go now before you're pushed, Titus.

9. Neville

A far more problematic inclusion in this article, the former independent stand-out PAC made such huge strides as an all-round performer while working on NXT that it seemed like a crime for him to be called up to the main roster. Us longtime WWE fans can usually tell who the company will decide to get behind and who they won€™t. True, it€™s a self-fulfilling prophecy much of the time, but megastars like Daniel Bryan are the exception rather than the rule: a perfect storm of talent and timing that seemingly can€™t be denied. It€™s said that Neville€™s biggest strikes are his size and his promo skills: well, they said the same thing about Daniel Bryan, and while Neville isn€™t Bryan€™s technical equal, Bryan couldn€™t fly like that in a million years. But that€™s not going to make a blind bit of difference if the company don€™t take that risk with him. The other problem is that Neville has another thing in common with Bryan: their intense styles are brutal on the human body. Neville is thirty this year, and has been wrestling for twelve years. Every wrestler works hurt - but will the style that got him signed get him over before it gets him injured? Right now, Neville€™s been on the main roster for nearly a year, and hasn€™t had a major feud of his own, or the television or mic time to get properly noticed by a casual WWE audience who aren€™t already familiar with what he can do. He€™s been booked as a human finishing move: he could easily blink and find that three more years have gone in exactly the same fashion. In fact, that€™s actually more likely than that he€™ll get the TV time needed to advance further up the card. This year is likely to be a make or break time for the Geordie superhero. Time to fly, Neville.

8. Alex Riley

It€™s got to be hard, getting to the point where you nearly grab a spot for yourself€ and then find it slipping from between your fingers. That€™s where Kevin €˜Alex Riley€™ Kiley was four years or so ago, and nothing€™s changed much for him since then. He€™d been in developmental since 2007 when he was called up to take part in the second season of the game show version of NXT in 2010. Teaming with his pro, The Miz, Riley would act as his sycophantic stooge until summer 2011, when he rode a decent swell of support to a babyface turn and a feud against his former employer. A programme with Dolph Ziggler over the United States Championship followed, and then a nagging hip injury forced him off television for a few weeks. He€™s never returned to anywhere near the same spot since then. Sporadic appearances on television, the dreaded €˜losing streak€™ angle, more injuries and still more injuries meant that since early 2012 Alex Riley has spent far more time out of the ring than in. Determined to break back in and get noticed, he€™s tried to create a buzz on social media: debuting a ferocious heel character, angry about being overlooked. Roley claims to eat, sleep and breathe wrestling, and that he gave up a $200k executive position to pursue his dream. However, that year carrying Mike Mizanin€™s bags aside, he€™s been in WWE developmental now for coming up to nine years. Although he€™s got a good look, with size and intensity, and some quality mic skills when he€™s focused and confident, that big call to the main roster isn€™t happening: he€™s lucky to claw his way to an in-ring spot on NXT. If wrestling is really his passion, he€™s in the wrong place - at least for him. Riley€™s not getting enough ring time to improve to the point where his matches can get him over, and his tired €˜rage€™ gimmick isn€™t being helped by the addition of a bitter note. A mutual release and a move elsewhere - trading on the independents, or in New Japan - would probably be the making of him.

7. Damien Sandow

It€™s a mystery how Aaron €˜Damien Sandow€™ Haddad is still employed by WWE. He loitered around WWE developmental under various gimmicks for six years between 2002 and 2012, only managing four months on the Smackdown roster in late 2006, and finally debuted proper as Damien Sandow in May 2012. In that time, he€™s done almost nothing in the company. He€™s won no singles gold, and his Money In The Bank briefcase win was such an afterthought that he was booked to lose his match in a nothing segment on a nothing RAW. None of this is for lack of trying, or for lack of talent either. Sandow is good-to-great in the ring, an experienced and polished veteran with nearly fifteen years experience. He€™s dynamite on the mic, and his Lebanese ancestry gives him a unique look in the WWE. What€™s better is that he got over with casual and hardcore fans with his €˜Damien Mizdow€™ gimmick, playing Hollywood ego The Miz€™ stunt double, an angle that was never designed to do anything but fill time. There are still cheers for the man every time he manages to claw his way to TV time, and he got one of the best reactions out of anyone on the roster at the Royal Rumble this year, despite having barely appeared for the company for months. But it€™s time for Haddad to recognise that, for whatever reason, WWE doesn€™t have a single thing going for him anymore. He€™s a performer that anyone else could build a business around. It€™s time to find the business that€™s prepared to do it.

6. Tyler Breeze

Matthias €˜Tyler Breeze€™ Clement is a genuinely great professional wrestler who€™s managed to turn the Prince Pretty character from a lower card curiosity into a potential moneymaker on the strength of his performances in NXT alone. But his main roster debut was always going to be a problem. Breezy is slender compared to even the average man in WWE. His slight build wasn€™t an issue on NXT, even against brutal powerhouses like Samoa Joe, because the team at NXT know how to book that kind of character and that kind of match. That€™s not the case on WWE programming, where the average TV match goes five to ten minutes, if that. It€™s not a long enough time to tell any story except the most obvious or the most cliched. In 2016, what little momentum Clement arrived with has vanished. There are plenty of ways to rebuild the Tyler Breeze character for the main roster - but given Vince McMahon€™s dismissive attitude towards the gimmick and the performer, WWE aren€™t likely to consider any of them. That€™s not to say that Clement€™s time in the WWE has been wasted. He€™s clearly become the wrestler he is through his time in NXT, and even four months wrestling in front of large crowds is time well spent. But he can€™t be making a vast amount of money, and it€™s pretty likely that a well-managed independent career could make him nearly as much, and allow him full control of his career and character to boot. There€™s no stigma in concentrating on the independents these days, and no shame in acknowledging that, through no fault of your own, you€™ve reached a level in the company you work for. In the next few months, it may be time for Clement to consider acknowledging that for himself.

5. Zack Ryder

The sad case of Zack Ryder has been written about for four years now. Previously the posterboy for getting over without any support from creative, a man who grabbed the brass ring only to find it was a glazed doughnut, Ryder is mostly famous now for being screwed over. He€™s not a wrestler, he€™s a sad sack in boots and trunks. Right now, Matthew Cardona is in the best shape of his life and still only thirty years old. He can still become the star wrestler he always wanted to be€ but is that what he really wants? He claims to love wrestling, but he works in a third string tag team on the developmental brand, and these days seems perfectly content to languish wherever WWE dump him. Is that because he€™s a mark for the WWE, rather than a man passionate about wrestling as an art and an industry? It€™s looking more and more as though, having accepted his lower card jobber role, Cardona only wants to be able to say he wrestles for the same company that featured Hulk Hogan and €˜Stone Cold€™ Steve Austin. That sounds harsh, but as a fan of the performer if not his cheesy character, it€™s even harsher to see what€™s happened to him. I would properly mark out for the man if he requested his release tomorrow and took a better, tighter, more intense version of that good-time bro gimmick to a career on the independents, or even a spot in New Japan.

4. Natalya

It€™s pretty clear that WWE have no spot open for Nattie Neidhart on the main roster any longer. She€™s thirty-four this year, a sixteen year veteran and a main roster WWE Diva for eight years. Right now, WWE€™s female division has never had a higher profile, despite their faults in presenting it so far. Has Natalya been the focus of that progress? Have the WWE chosen to market the Diva most identified with €˜being a proper€™ wrestler over the last few years as the centrepiece of the Diva€™s division? Of course not. And the promotion of Charlotte, Becky Lynch and Sasha Banks to the main roster, along with the presence of Paige and the lurking possibility of more Bellas in the future€ all of that renders Natalya an also-ran on the main roster, a veteran without a spot anywhere except on the Total Divas show, where her bizarre crazy-cat-lady character is literally the most obnoxious thing on the worst show that WWE have a hand in. There are so many opportunities for female wrestlers - something Nattie Neidhart absolutely is, over and above being a Diva - that there weren€™t when she was first signed. She should investigate some of those possibilities, before her best years as a wrestler are behind her. What she€™s been told to do for the last few years in WWE has been beneath her as a performer and as a representative of the Hart legacy.

3. Wade Barrett

I don€™t even know where to begin here, and it€™s not the first time I€™ve said it. Stu €˜Wade Barrett€™ Bennett is a great wrestler with an awesome upside. He€™s got technical ability and main event level brawling talent, brilliant mic skills and facial expressions, size and - currently - a great look with a piratical beard and a ripped, rangy musculature. Forgetting the completely over Bad New heel gimmick and the much less popular King gimmick for a moment, his character€™s kayfabe bare knuckle champion back story is a perfect fit for all of that. The man should be on Randy Orton€™s level by now, raking it in and ready to drop into a main event slot whenever one becomes available. Instead, Barrett is the saddest toy in the whole damn store, a vast, sucking black hole of talent and effort. In a stable of four people, the guy with the most potential of all of them is the one earmarked to take the pinfall in multi-man tags. That makes no sense. No sense at all. At thirty-five years old, already plagued with injuries, he€™s clearly been cast aside by WWE creative. In 2016, Stu Bennett needs to take a long, hard look in the mirror and head off after Drew Galloway to come back to the UK, clean house and clean up.

2. Sheamus

Incredibly, at one point Sheamus was the next big thing, a man who won the WWE Championship from John Cena in 2009 after only 166 days on the main roster. He went on to win the Royal Rumble, King Of The Ring, and - probably more importantly in the eyes of management - have a competitive feud with Triple H. That allowed him to be the one to write the Game off television after a sustained beatdown following his win at Extreme Rules in 2010. That€™s a hell of a first few years in the company, but what€™s happened since then is anyone€™s guess. Like the other entries on this list, Sheamus€™ lower status on the card isn€™t for lack of trying or for lack of talent on the part of Stephen Farrelly, the man behind the Celtic Warrior gimmick. Sheamus has a completely unique look, and no - I€™m not talking about the mohawk and braided beard. He€™s a big old fella, and that whole pale-as-parchment ginger thing he has going on is going to be a goldmine for years to come. That kind of upside just doesn€™t come along that often. He€™s not great on the mic - but he€™s not sh*tbox either, just cheerfully average-to-good. He€™s older than he looks, though: able to pass for early thirties, Farrelly is actually closer to forty, having just turned thirty-eight two weeks ago. Despite his heavy-fisted brawling style and remarkable ability to take a convincing beating in the ring, Sheamus has a relatively minor history of injury, and could easily have the better part of a decade left in him as a top level performer. The question is, should those years be spent as glorified enhancement talent in WWE? He may have recently lifted the WWE World Heavyweight Championship, but he was only ever going to be a plot point in Roman Reigns€™ slow, painful rise to the top. Before and since, Sheamus has been an afterthought for creative. In fact, on the same show that he cashed in the Money In The Bank contract to win the company€™s top title, Sheamus was literally booked to be a joke, a punchline in the New Day€™s comedy act. He was booked to appear completely inferior to Reigns in every single way during their brief feud over the title. There aren€™t many wrestlers capable of coming back from that kind of casual burial. If his real life buddy Stu €˜Wade Barrett€™ Bennett does head off, Farrelly could do worse than going with him. Drew Galloway, Stu Bennett and Stephen Farrelly could take advantage of their Scottish/English/Irish heritages to form a big bruising faction that would make the League Of Nations look like Little League.

1. Dolph Ziggler

If ever a man has needed a fresh start in a new company, it€™s Nick €˜Dolph Ziggler€™ Nemeth. It€™s not that long ago that Dolph Ziggler was one of the three most over performers on the roster. When he cashed in the Money In The Bank briefcase on the night after WrestleMania 29, he got a pop as big, if not bigger than any of the megastars that were on the big show itself. A year and a half later, his performance at Survivor Series actually did steal the show, as Ziggler was booked to be the MVP of the biggest match on the card, eliminating three men as the last man left on his team to win the match and remove the evil Authority from power. Those are starmaking turns, the former given him by the crowd, the latter a gift from management. So what the hell happened in 2015? Allegedly, he booked a stand-up comedy gig at the end of 2014 without the consent of the office, and was booked to lose the Intercontinental Championship immediately afterwards, a title he€™d only just reclaimed after his stellar Survivor Series. Then there was the Lana/Rusev/Summer love rhombus, a hideous angle that stalled all four careers for months and may have permanently damaged him as a fan favourite. He was supposed to be the charismatic babyface hero in the storyline, but came off so horrible douchey, so obnoxious, that he nearly pulled off the opposite crowd reaction to his Money In The Bank win in 2013, almost turning himself heel. Now, a legitimate heel turn might actually save him - but are WWE audiences able to turn around on him themselves? Can they place their faith in Nick Nemeth as a performer and Dolph Ziggler as a character once again, after being burned so often? Consensus amongst hardcore fans appears to be that he€™s done for: that years of inconsistent booking and casual burials have combined to render Ziggler a bad joke. However, if this set bombs there€™s always the chance that a fresh act and some new material could set the crowd on fire again. If anyone€™s got the testicular fortitude to go steal the show somewhere else, it€™s the Show-Off.

Contributor
Contributor

Professional writer, punk werewolf and nesting place for starfish. Obsessed with squid, spirals and story. I publish short weird fiction online at desincarne.com, and tweet nonsense under the name Jack The Bodiless. You can follow me all you like, just don't touch my stuff.