10 Wrestlers The Fans Turned On

Wrestling fans can be a fickle bunch, and these superstars found that out the hard way.

Ronda Rousey Booed WWE Survivor Series 2018
WWE

Getting over with any wrestling fanbase is the second biggest battle facing any wrestler. The biggest, is staying over.

How many times have you watched a more than competent match play out to almost near silence from the crowd? Being great between the ropes can bring its own glory, but with great wrestling almost expected nowadays, developing a genuine connection with the fans is what propels a wrestler up the card.

Once there, a wrestler (and the writers/booker) need to work hard to ensure the ensuing story nurtures that connection in the right way. Otherwise, that hard work can be undone almost instantly. Case in point is the current trajectory with Liv Morgan.

This past year has been a breakout one for Morgan, with the fans firmly behind her push to championship contention. But through her cowardly cash-in and subsequent dusty retention with Ronda Rousey, the fans have started to heckle her. You can see that it unsettles Liv, and her reaction isn’t exactly going to get them back on side.

It's not a lost cause however, as Drew McIntyre was facing the same backlash when live crowds returned last year but has since course corrected by going back to what originally got him over in the first place.

But sometimes, the fan backlash is irredeemable, and whilst Liv Morgan looked like she struggled with it, there are some who have bounced back well. Others... not so much.

10. John Cena

John Cena
WWE

Let’s start with the most obvious example.

From late 2003, John Cena’s ascent to the top of WWE was inevitable. As the ‘Doctor of Thuganomics’ he became the most over babyface in the company, with his street smarts and freestyle raps pulling the entire WWE Universe behind him. But when he won the WWE Championship in 2005, something changed.

Positioned against established crowd favourites like Chris Jericho, or under-utilised team players like Christian, the fans quickly bored of what would soon become the ‘Super Cena’ booking, where despite being against the odds, Cena would always rise above it and win. It didn’t help that Cena certainly wasn’t the big match player he would later become and that better in-ring wrestlers were fed to him on a monthly basis.

Although beloved now by the fanbase when he returns, which is great considering how hard he worked inside and outside the ring for the company, the fans never came round to John during his run as a full-time talent. WWE dressed it up as being ‘divisive’, but the clear split was that he embodied the PG-era and was too kid friendly to be seen as cool in the eyes of the adult fan base.

Pushing a talent relentlessly as a babyface despite a clear rejection by the fans is a harsh lesson learnt for WWE. Or so we thought…


9. Roman Reigns

Roman Reigns Blue Eyes
WWE

As part of the Shield, Roman Reigns had the perfect opportunity to develop. Still relatively green in the ring, teaming with established indie veterans like Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose they could hide his flaws and exaggerate his positives in tag team matches.

You know, good booking?

But when the Shield became a main event concern, Vince McMahon knew he had three main eventers-in-waiting but it seemed like there was just one he wanted to get his hands on. As ‘The Big Dog’, Reigns was roundly rejected by the fans because he wasn’t their chosen champion.

Daniel Bryan had been clearly shunted out of the way to make-do for Vince’s new project and the fans responded with an avalanche of support that meant, when Bryan was eliminated from the 2015 Royal Rumble, the rest of that match played out to boos.

Reigns was loathed from that moment on, despite his clear vast improvement. Every crowd had turned on him, and WWE’s refusal to veer from their projected path meant the nowadays ‘Tribal Chief’ was welcomed with a barrage of abuse.

The fans warmed to Roman after his diagnosis and subsequent beating of Leukaemia, but it wasn’t until his 2020 SummerSlam return and brilliant heel turn that the fans truly acknowledged him as a main event player.


8. Cody Rhodes

Cody Rhodes
AEW

For so long, AEW treated Cody Rhodes like royalty. It’s not a stretch to say that without him leaving WWE and showing the industry that life existed outside the market leader, All Elite Wrestling might never have come to fruition.

Fans were drawn to Rhodes, who spearheaded the first main rivalry with Chris Jericho in the maiden year of the company, where he lost the chance to ever challenge for the top belt again. Inspired booking, and the ‘American Nightmare’ went on to have some ace rivalries with MJF and Lance Archer.

But with Cody granted too much control of his character, and his refusal to turn heel, the fans soon turned on him when he began beating their favourites or new arrivals. Somewhere along the way, the fans who treated ‘the son of a son of a plumber’ as a god now booed him out of every building.

Suddenly, every feud was skewed, every promo was interrupted by the AEW fans telling him to ‘shut the f*** up’, and even his own weight belt was hurled back at him after he had tossed it into the crowd.

It was clear that it impacted Cody’s final few months with the company and was a main driver for his sensational return to WWE when his AEW contract expired. No one could believe it, least of all the fans, who accused the man they had turned their back on of betrayal.

Wrestling fans, eh?


7. Edge

Edge 2004 Draft
WWE.com

There was a time in wrestling where Edge wasn’t that interesting. Despite his recent ill-judged heel turn and Judgment Day venture, Edge still had people talking. Even if the content was crap, and the whole Judgment Day thing is crap, the Rated R Superstar was still engaging.

Not so much in 2004.

A serious neck injury in early 2003 curtailed his push to the top during the famous ‘Smackdown Six’ era, and when Edge returned to Monday Night Raw in 2004, fans had high hopes he would pick up where he left off.

Except, he really didn’t. Always solid in the ring, Edge just lacked any sort of character as he tried to transition from chilled surfer guy into a gritty, no-nonsense badass. The fans didn’t latch onto it, and when he began going over young up-and -comers like Randy Orton and Shelton Benjamin, the crowd made their feelings known.

Shockingly, this culminated in Edge, who was a babyface at the time, being booed in his hometown of Toronto at SummerSlam 2004. Eventually, it led to a much welcomed heel turn later that year, and once the whole Matt Hardy incident sparked into life the following year, Edge was a made man as a vile heel.

Nowadays, Edge generates some of the biggest pops of the night. Back in 2004, the fans just wanted him to go away.


6. X-Pac

Xpac European
WWE.com

This one is just plain disrespectful.

Like the Cena entry earlier, it is nice when an underappreciated worker is finally given their flowers in the latter stages of their career. Unfortunately for Sean Waltman, it wasn’t until deep into his semi-retirement that those compliments became common.

A truly inventive presence on the wrestling industry during the early '90s, Waltman exploded onto the scene as the 1-2-3 Kid, shocking the world with his win over major star, Razor Ramon. He would go on to be an integral part of both the nWo and Degeneration-X, considered the two most influential stables in wrestling history.

X-Pax was a tremendous in-ring talent, and was used as a litmus test by Vince McMahon to see if new additions on the roster could actually go. If they could have a good match with X-Pac, then they were fine. Similar to how Dolph Ziggler has been used over the past few years.

Unfortunately, as we entered the 2000s, fans tired of X-Pac, and whilst everyone else in DX moved on, he clung to the aesthetic and the attitude, similar to how Reigns did with the Shield. ‘X-Pac Sucks’ chants echoed whenever he was involved and the horrendous term ‘X-Pac heat’ was coined.

Nowadays, Waltman is a respected voice in the wrestling community, but he deserved way better from the fans.


5. Bayley

Bayley Sad
WWE

It was nothing more than sheer incompetence from Vince McMahon and the awful creative that caused the fans to turn on Bayley.

In NXT, ‘The Hugger’ was one of the most popular stars on the show, forging a genuine connection with both adults and kids who bought into her relentless enthusiasm and desire to never give up. It was as if someone found a way to tweak John Cena’s character to appeal to everyone. Sure, she was kid friendly, but that didn’t make her a child.

But in the often child-like mind of Vince McMahon, that’s exactly what she was.

Once on the main roster, her childish tendencies were turned up to 11, and eventually, the fans turned on what became a tedious character. Roundly considered one of the worst segments in wrestling history, the ‘This is Your Life’ hosted by Alexa Bliss made Bayley out to be a complete loser. She hadn’t even been kissed!

To double down on the horrendous creative, the entire story was heading towards Bayley dishing out a vicious and cathartic kendo stick beating on ‘Little Miss Bliss’, but when the time came, she just didn’t have it in her and Bliss duly delivered one of her.

The now ‘Role Model’ was then faced with trying to sell her decision in an awful backstage interview where you could see that she knew she had lost the fans.

It’s a good thing Bayley is so damn talented and managed to fight her way back to the top of the division.


4. Goldberg

Goldberg Goldust Wig
WWE

WWE tried to paint Goldberg like he is one of their legends, but he really isn’t. Yes, he was a major star during the Monday Night Wars, and for 18 months, was one of the hottest acts in WCW.

WCW. Not WWE.

When ‘Da Man’ finally entered McMahon Land after the expiration of his lucrative TimeWarner contract, he was thrust right into the same role as before, with Vince and Co. hoping that lightning would strike twice.

In his first match with The Rock at Backlash, the fans booed Goldberg. He wasn’t one of their own, The Rock was and he was in the midst of a sensational heel run. Big Bill’s next feud was with Chris Jericho, who again, the fans chose over Goldberg.

Triple H didn’t help matters by crushing any momentum Goldberg could have built up by defeating him at SummerSlam 2003 in the Elimination Chamber, but the WWE fans just weren’t into Goldberg as much as the WCW fans were five years before. When he returned in 2016, he was treated as a conquering hero, because 13 years had passed. Nostalgia is a hell of a drug.

It certainly wasn’t because he was a beloved superstar during his first run.


3. Goldberg Again

Goldberg Owens
WWE.com

So let’s talk about his second run.

As previously stated, Goldberg’s shocking return in late-2016 was fantastic. As a tie-in to the new WWE 2K game, Goldberg’s inclusion meant he was called upon for some media rounds and he routinely called out Brock Lesnar, especially after their only match 12 years before was an atrocity.

Lesnar, who had become the big bad of WWE, accepted and an unlikely rematch was set at Survivor Series. Nobody saw what was coming.

Goldberg sent the fans wild with an immediate spear, and less than a minute later, he had squashed the biggest monster in WWE; the man who had broken the Undertaker’s streak and made John Cena look like a jobber at SummerSlam.

It was masterful stuff, and set up a potential rematch at WrestleMania 33. Then Vince McMahon got greedy and Goldberg paid the price.

The long running storyline between Kevin Owens and Chris Jericho was reaching its logical conclusion with a WWE Universal Championship match at 'Mania. Both men were the most popular thing on the show and the fans were waiting patiently for that burgeoning rivalry to get a main event spotlight. But with Goldberg’s return so well received, Vince relegated Owens and Jericho, and had Goldberg squash Owens for the belt at Fastlane 2017.

The following night on RAW, the fans booed Goldberg mercilessly and that aura he once carried has never returned. Thankfully, WWE never made that mistake again.

Oh, wait...


2. The Rock

Brock Lesnar The Rock
WWE

One person impervious to losing the fans must surely be The Rock, right? Wrong!

In 2002, The Rock was flirting more and more with his transition to Hollywood, although it would take a long time for him to become the certified box office draw and highest paid actor in the movie business. With his appearances fleeting, The Rock left WWE after his iconic clash with Hollywood Hogan at WrestleMania X8.

When he returned a few months later, Rocky thankfully ended The Undertaker’s poor WWE Undisputed Championship run at Vengeance '02, teeing him up for an exciting defense against King of the Ring winner, Brock Lesnar.

‘The Next Big Thing’ was certainly that, and his and Rock’s pathway to SummerSlam was well documented with some brilliant training videos showing just how much the match meant to them. When the two finally met in the ring, something happened that nobody saw coming.

The fans began to turn on The Rock, realising that he would be leaving the company again for another stint in Hollywood, and they threw their support behind the young, future headliner that was hell bent on maiming him. The Rock’s heroic comeback was met with jeers and Lesnar’s eventually coronation with loud cheers.

These reactions would eventually inform Lesnar’s quick face turn that autumn, whilst The Rock used that reaction as the catalyst for his fantastic Hollywood Heel turn.


1. Ronda Rousey

Ronda Rousey
WWE.com

This one was never in the plan.

Ronda Rousey’s first year in WWE was an unmitigated success. Her debut alongside Kurt Angle against Triple H and Stephanie McMahon was masterful, and when she hit the main roster, she hit the ground running. The fans were behind her and she quickly claimed the RAW Women’s Championship.

Then, WWE misjudged Becky Lynch’s popularity and Ronda’s was in jeapardy.

With the fans sick of Charlotte Flair and not Becky getting opportunities, the sensible storyline was for the ‘Lass Kicker’ to turn on her friend. However, the fans sided with Becky, who quickly became the most popular women on the roster. After that, a wild fist from Nia Jax cemented the Irish talent as the biggest star in the company.

Immortalised in blood, Becky soon became ‘The Man’, with fans chanting her name through every Rousey promo. At Survivor Series, as Flair obliterated the former UFC Champion with a kendo stick, the fans chanted for Becky more, leaving a clearly distressed Rowdy One to look at them in confusion.

Every promo began to stumble, as the champion’s ego was clearly bruised at Becky’s surge in popularity. Eventually, Vince McMahon had no other option but to turn Rousey heel, and, considering the tirade of abuse she has dished out to wrestling fans since then, Ronda has never forgiven fans for it.


In this post: 
Ronda Rousey
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

A wrestling fan for over two decades, a proud father of an awesome little girl. Am also an international best selling independent author of mindless action novels!