10 Wrestlers Too Big To Fail (That Failed Anyway)

Big Show, Lex Luger, and more prove there's no such thing as a sure thing in wrestling.

Big Show crying
WWE

Sure things don't exist in professional wrestling.

This is particularly true in 2021, where WWE's erratic booking and destructive "brand first, stars second" mentality have created an environment that rarely allows performers to reach their strongest form. Even when it does, you get a guy like Drew McIntyre: a fantastic wrestler who has dragged WWE through one of its darkest periods, often single-handedly at times, but doesn't draw television numbers.

Almost nobody does. That's the problem. WWE's only guaranteed ratings draws are stars of bygone eras brought back for nostalgia specials, and even those are fading.

This isn't anything new (see: Dusty Rhodes and Kerry Von Erich in WWE), nor is it Stamford-specific. If not for his sublime post-Arcade Anarchy run, culminating in the fantastic Darby Allin match, AEW's Miro may have found a spot on a list like this. WCW continually failed to make the most not only of those coming in with big reputations from other companies, but the younger, hungrier, hyper-talented prodigies banished to the undercard in favour of the bloated egos above.

Imagine if Chris Jericho never jumped ship.

The wrestlers listed here had all the tools to be huge. Unfortunately, inept booking teams, fate, and other forces had different ideas...

10. Drew McIntyre (WWE: 2009-2014)

Drew McIntyre 3MB
WWE.com

WWE cursed Drew McIntyre by telling you he was going to be the biggest of big deals from the moment he left Florida Championship Wrestling.

The towering Scot was Vince McMahon's 'Chosen One.' The WWE Chairman put him over as a "future World Champion" in September 2009, claiming he had personally signed Drew to a big-time contract, and while that prediction would eventually come true, it took around a decade longer than Vince may have liked.

A big, good-looking bruiser packed with promise, McIntyre fell short of WWE's self-created expectations. He was Intercontinental Champion but struggled for upward momentum with his bland heel character and basic working style. Falling out of the spotlight (and seemingly favour with the boss), McIntyre ended up in 3MB three years after debuting. A fun, entertainment sideshow act, but still a sideshow act.

Released by WWE in June 2014, McIntyre told himself:-

"This is on you. This was the dream you wanted. You're gonna have to prove to everybody you are who they thought you were in the beginning."

That undying drive to not go down as one of the PG era's biggest busts has been bearing fruit since 2017, when McIntyre returned as twice the performer he was before.


9. Mike Awesome (WCW/WWE: 2000-2002)

Mike Awesome Taz ECW Championship
WWE.com

WWE's maddening obsession with forcing uniquely captivating wrestlers to abandon that which made them special and shoehorn them into wrestling's most restrictive house style has dulled many a potential stud, from Vader to Shinsuke Nakamura. Former ECW Champion Mike Awesome suffered this in Stamford and Atlanta.

Awesome blew minds in ECW. It doesn't sound as impressive in 2021, when it feels like every 300lb-ish big man can dash and dive like an athlete half their size, but Awesome's combination of power, size, speed, and agility was eyeball-popping. He was risky, too, dishing out and absorbing stiff head-drops and chair shots in a promotion perfectly calibrated to make him look godlike, particularly in his feud with Masato Tanaka.

It was inevitable that he'd have to tone things down in WCW, but the promotion botched the chance to make him a night-one megastar after flubbing the follow-up on his debut assault on Kevin Nash. Later, the Fat Chick Thriller and That 70s Guy characters consigned him to bad gimmick hell.

He then fell afoul of The Undertaker in WWE, sliding down the card after a particularly brutal backstage burial. Awesome never returned to the major leagues after that.


8. Sin Cara (WWE: 2011-2014)

Rey Mysterio Sin Cara
WWE.com

The original Sin Cara was once one of the biggest draws in wrestling.

Tell this to a younger fan and they may well laugh in your face, but it's true. As Mistico, Luis Alvirde was his native Mexico's most bankable star for many years, winning the Wrestling Observer Newsletter's Best Box Office Draw over the UFC's Tito Ortiz and Matt Hughes and WWE's John Cena in 2006. Selling out CMLL's 15,000-capacity Arena Mexico became habitual for him.

Five years later, Alvirde became one of the first wrestlers to fall in WWE's quest to find "the next Rey Mysterio." Thrust onto television without a developmental run, thus giving him no time to prepare for the adjustment from Lucha Libre to WWE's vastly different house style, he debuted as Sin Cara in March 2011 - and promptly flopped. Occasionally spectacular (but never to the extent he was in CMLL), Alvride was buried under a mountain of botches, bad booking decisions, and reported backstage issues, until he was let go three years later.

The former Hunico, Jose Rodriguez, inherited the Sin Cara gimmick following Alvirde's departure, but the character was irreparably damaged - and Rodriguez was never a draw (or a wrestler) on his predecessor's level.


7. Roman Reigns (WWE: 2012-2020)

Roman Reigns the rock
WWE.com

Vince McMahon spent the best part of five years projecting Roman Reigns as his company's all-conquering, money-drawing babyface centrepiece, creating one of the most vitriolic fan backlashes in wrestling history.

Cynical pundits pegged Reigns as the Shield member McMahon was most likely to push (rather than Dean Ambrose or Seth Rollins, both of whom appealed more to modern "workrate" fans' sensibilities) after the group's inevitable split. So it transpired, with McMahon and Reigns swimming against an irrepressible tide of negativity at the top of the card, worsening a toxic relationship with WWE's audience that almost certainly contributed to the chronic viewership slide.

The Raw on which The Shield split drew 4.27 million viewers. Today, the show doesn't even pull half of that.

So damaging was McMahon's dedication to keeping his head stuck in the sand that pockets of fans started turning on Reigns within months of his return from a life-threatening second battle with leukaemia in 2019. When that happened, it appeared nothing could save Roman's stock with the audience.

Until August 2020, when WWE finally pulled the trigger on the heel turn that may have stopped this from becoming a problem in the first place. The Head of the Table is great - and one of the best things on current WWE programming.

Why did it take so long to get here?


6. Dean Ambrose (WWE: 2012-2019)

dean ambrose raw
WWE.com

From a WWE standpoint, the most frustrating thing about Jon Moxley isn't that he has been an invaluable boon to AEW since its emergence as WWE's closest competition since TNA was in its prime, but that he could be doing this on Vince McMahon's watch.

WWE let the coolest wrestler on the planet slip away. They jobbed him out to exploding televisions, had him carry around a named potted plant, forced him to wear a gas mask and get butt cheek injections to prevent him from Each and Every Single One Of You, and scripted cruel lines taking aim at his real-life friend's leukaemia against his will. By January 2019, Ambrose said "screw this," told WWE he wouldn't be renewing his expiring contract, and started living his best life again.

Where Ambrose was shackled by WWE's wackiness, Moxley is a perfectly balanced bad*ss babyface. He makes you want to go out for a drink with him but never want to fight him. Mox is tough, but never to the point of corniness, and funny without ever reverting to the rodeo clown of old.

He could have been this in WWE (albeit without the deathmatches) had the company any idea how to book any vaguely funny wrestler as anything other than jesters.


5. Bret Hart (WCW: 1997-2000)

Bill Goldberg Bret Hart
WWE Network

Bert Hart crossing over to WCW fresh off his last run as WWE Champion should have helped Ted Turner's company strengthen its Monday Night Wars position amidst its legendary 83-week run of ratings domination, as WCW not only nabbed the competition's best pure wrestler, but one of its biggest stars.

Instead, Bret's was one of the company's worst main event runs.

Hart never fully recovered from the Montreal Screwjob. Leaving WWE in the worst way imaginable, he joined WCW on a bumper contract but, like everyone else in that company during its latter years, was booked like sh*t. A 60-day non-compete clause meant he was forced to debut as a guest referee for Larry Zbyszko vs. Eric Bischoff at Starrcade 1997, underwhelming Ric Flair feud, and other disappointments, coupled with 'The Hitman's' own escalating disinterest as creative shot down idea after idea, was a poisonous cocktail.

Then came the Goldberg-induced concussion that effectively ended his career. Forced to relinquish his WCW World Heavyweight Championship and retire from the sport soon after the thrust kick heard around the world, it was the most miserable note in a miserable run.


4. Sting (WWE: 2014-2020)

Sting WrestleMania 31
WWE.com

That he was already 55 years old by the time he debuted there meant WWE were never going to get prime, WCW-calibre Sting, though even before injuries forced him into a temporary state of retirement, Vince McMahon somehow contrived to squeeze as little juice as possible from the legend that got away.

Sting was the last big WCW name to cross over to WWE following McMahon's buyout in 2001. He arrived in an incredible Survivor Series 2014 debut, wiping out The Authority, before becoming a needless sacrifice in a long-dead war kept alive only by the pettiest wrestling promoter of all time.

Presented ostensibly as the final fracas in the old WCW vs. WWE war, Sting vs. Triple H at WrestleMania 31 was a farce, as McMahon couldn't suppress his urge to take one last shot at Billionaire Ted's old powerhouse. Sting fell there, then fell again when a serious neck injury seemingly ended his career opposite Seth Rollins at Night of Champions 2015.

Sting eventually left WWE having never worked the long-sought-after Undertaker dream match. A fun late-career special attraction run was sacrificed so that Vince could remind fans that yes, he won the war.


3. Lex Luger (WWE: 1993-1995)

Lex Luger MSG
WWE

Lex Luger tripped over so that Roman Reigns could plummet.

One of WWE's first notable failures as a Hulk Hogan replacement, Luger's legacy has been unfairly tainted by his inability to replace the figurehead of Vince McMahon's campaign to move wrestling out of the territories and onto an international stage. He was supposed to be a like-for-like replacement. Vince wanted the aesthetic of another big, blonde muscleman coming through the main event door as another one departed. If it worked in the '80s, it'll work in the '90s, pal.

WWE went all-in on a wrestler who emerged as one of the sport's most promising rookies in the late '80s. The Lex Express took him around the States after his original Narcissist run but couldn't get Luger over at a main-event level, and certainly not to Hogan's level. Thus, Vince McMahon dialled back on plans to give him the World Heavyweight Championship, Lex flopped, but found a new way to send shockwaves through wrestling two years later: by jumping ship to WCW on the first episode of Nitro.

Had he come around 10 years prior, perhaps Luger would have stood a better chance in Vinceland.


2. Goldberg (WWE: 2003-2004)

Triple H taunts Goldberg 2003
WWE.com

"Hide the weaknesses, amplify the strengths" is one of the golden rules of booking professional wrestling, and key to Bill Goldberg's WCW success.

Though greener than an envious Grinch when he entered the company, WCW made something of the former NFL defensive tackle by rarely stretching him beyond his capabilities. Yes, he was more Two Moves Of Doom than Five, but it didn't matter when he could get over as an explosive bull of a man capable of running through the competition in less time than it took his opponents to lace their boots that evening.

That's how Goldberg became a key Monday Night Wars player and high-drawing forrce for WCW. By the time he joined WWE in 2003, he was more refined, already a star for his work under Turner, and somebody fans had a real hunger for as one of the last few big names to cross over from WCW. Keeping him credible should have been easy.

Alas, WWE once again refused to make an exception for an exceptional performer, forcing Goldberg into longer, more demanding matches that didn't suit his skillset, then jobbing him out to Triple H at SummerSlam 2003. Goldberg ended up taking the World Heavyweight Title from The Game one month later, but his goose was already cooked by that point.


1. Big Show (WWE: 1999-2021)

big show wwe
WWE.com

Like Andre the Giant before him, Big Show should have so few televised WWE singles losses on his record that you should be able to recall each one and outline why it was so memorable without thinking for more than a few seconds. Beating him should have meant something. Game-changing moments like WrestleMania III will never be recreated, admittedly, but toppling Show should have been a task akin to scaling Mount Everest.

And yet Show lost a colossal 603 matches (per the Internet Wrestling Database) during his time in Stamford. By the time he left in February 2021. he had been run into the ground by over two decades of constant face/heel turns, crying on air, lame gimmicks, and WWE's complete inability to protect and preserve him as any kind of monstrous threat, despite his obvious gifts.

Wight should have spent years as the most arresting and imposing spectacle wrestler - a giant updated for evolving modern palates - before transitioning to his Jobber to the Stars phase. Instead, he dropped to that level almost on arrival.

His four WWE/World Heavyweight Title reigns say little about his legacy (such performers shouldn't need the belt to be over). You'll remember the Big Boss Man driving off with his dad's casket or his many, many tears before any of those runs.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Big Show
 
Posted On: 
Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.