10 Wrestlers Who Are In The Wrong Role

These wrestlers are in serious need of a character/role change going forward...

Bayley WWE
WWE

Casting is arguably the most vital element in ensuring an incoming big or small screen project succeeds both critically and commercially.

Get it wrong, and there's a solid chance your upcoming TV show or movie will struggle to really connect with your paying public. No matter how brilliant and compelling a script you possess.

Get it right, and even the most dreadful and soul-crushing material will likely be overlooked on the back of a simply undeniable performance or showcase of unfiltered charisma.

And the same goes for the barmy business of pro wrasslin', too.

A star can be the most talented worker in-between the ropes on the planet, but without a role or character that fully compliments their personality or gives their fanbase a reason to sit up and truly pay attention, eventually finding themselves getting lost in the shuffle somewhat is almost inevitable.

So, from babyface wrestling machines being made to spurt out Papa H's brand of cocky "comedy", to some of the greatest talents ever to step foot in a squared-circle finding themselves on the outside looking in for way too long, these are those wresters who are in dire need of a new part to play.

10. Lacey Evans As The Veteran Who Despises YOU People

Lacey Evans
WWE.com

It's been well documented just how utterly bizarre WWE's handling of a returning Lacey Evans was towards the latter stages of Vince McMahon's often nonsensical run in the Gorilla Position.

Yet, far from smashing the reset button the second The Game changed in July, WWE seemed content with keeping a flip-flopping star, who had once endeared herself to the masses with her vulnerable vignettes focusing on her difficult upbringing, as a frustrated heel going forward.

And while Evans' decision to turn her back on those who had undoubtedly backed her upon making her long-awaited in-ring comeback in June did generate a decent amount of heat at the time, her desire to gain the "respect she deserved" ultimately saw the former title contender fall down the pecking order.

With SmackDown clearly lacking any out-and-out babyface contenders who genuinely connect with those in attendance at this current moment, having the military veteran hero fighting the good fight would've likely solved said headache in next to no time.

Evans comments after a recent edition of the blue show on trying too hard to please everyone and needing to "go back to basics" hint at a much needed return to that former persona. But will it be too little, too late after utterly burning her bridges with the WWE Universe throughout a turbulent 2022?


9. Matt Riddle As That Dude You Like To Get High With

Riddle Bongo
WWE.com

Matt Riddle likes to get high.

And if that wasn't abundantly clear from the numbers plastered onto just about every piece of his garishly coloured merch pumped into arenas and the WWE Shop, and his never-ending string of bro-ey verbal hints at passing the doobie, then WWE's latest doubling down on the former UFC fighter's favourite form of recreation by having Riddle wander out with a set of bongos to hit (GET IT!?) will likely do the trick for those precious few not in the know.

What's baffling about this latest toke of a development is the fact that just a few weeks ago Riddle found himself embroiled in a gripping blood feud with Seth Rollins, one that could only be settled within the Fight Pit... well until WWE decided to have them fight on Raw a few weeks later, of course.

Instead of capitalising on the potential momentum held within getting the better of The Visionary after such a high-profile and personal war, Trips has opted to all but strip away any of that babyface fire and legitimacy Riddle had been boasting all summer, replacing those riveting aspects with even more painful weed jokes and some suggestive instruments.


8. Tommaso Ciampa As The Miz's Mate

Ciampa The Miz
WWE.com

The chances of Tommaso Ciampa returning from his latest injury setback as The Miz's right hand man, especially with long-time NXT pal Johnny Gargano now calling Monday Night Raw home, do appear to growing slimmer by the week.

But even if Blackheart finally distances himself from The Awesome One upon returning to the main roster, it still won't change the fact that his casting alongside the two-time Grand Slam Champion was odd out of the gates and proceeded to get stranger from there on out.

Having the former NXT Champion act as little more than a scrappy sidekick to a star he claimed could get the eyes of the world on him, Ciampa's showings on the red show after making his call-up to the "big leagues" official not only didn't click with those who had spent the last few years watching him dominate the black and gold brand, but those who didn't have the slightest clue who the bearded baddy was either.

He did at least offer a few flickers of the badass veteran persona still lying in wait recently before his perhaps blessing in disguise injury. So, here's hoping the former D.I.Y. man opts to get the band back together or at the very least cuts all ties with his bright-green "Awesome" Scrappy-Doo character once he's fit and healthy again.


7. Raquel Rodriguez As The Smiling Powerhouse

Raquel Rodriguez
WWE

Another star who has experienced a bit of an underwhelming use of their abilities in the wake of finally being called up to WWE's main roster, the former Raquel González and one-time NXT Women's Champion found herself being nudged straight into one of Vinnie Mac's tired, go-to caricatures from the get-go.

Producing the sort of ear-to-ear grin that likely haunts Finn Bálor's nightmares, the now-Rodriguez set about smiling her way to crickets and indifference in arenas, with WWE depressingly wasting little time dropping the no-nonsense and most compelling elements of the former developmental champ's persona.

In their place was a happy-to-be-here attitude and an over-reliance on others, with Raquel's staggering power game and explosive arsenal still not doing much to convince fans this is a star worth taking seriously.

Thankfully, the former NXT and main roster Women's Tag Team Champion was given a chance to show her teeth ever so slightly in the wake of Damage CTRL taking out her partner a few months back. But since then, Rodriguez has been slotted right back into her beaming babyface juggernaut role; one that absolutely nobody should have any real fears of coming up against anytime soon.


6. Braun Strowman As A Monstrous Hero

Braun Strowman Jinder Mahal
WWE.com

Braun Strowman's returning presence as a babyface monster hellbent on teaching WWE's resident big and somewhat smaller baddies a lesson felt like a bit of a misstep from the second he ripped through an already laughable tag division.

And while it is worth noting how The Monster of all Monsters' recent showings have still produced a decent amount of big-man excitement in arenas and led to some rather unexpectedly monstrous YouTube numbers, there's still no doubt a ton more money to be made from the colossal force as a larger than life, unstoppable heel.

Jumping back to arguably Strowman's most electric and successful stint in the business to date, the sight of the absolute wrecking ball villain causing chaos backstage from 2017-2018 via the flipping of vehicles and ripping down of equipment felt like a far better use of his freakish strength and short fuse.

And with Strowman once again legitimately pissing off some corners of the locker room with his latest ill-advised Twitter remarks on "floppy floppers", perhaps leaning into that real-life animosity and having Strowman target some of the roster's fan-favourite high-flyers with his powerful antics of old could ultimately stock SmackDown with a genuinely detestable powerhouse heel once again.

Anything beats a roaring babyface bully attempting to put on "47-star" classics, I suppose.


5. Bryan Danielson As The BCC's Talent Scout

Bryan Danielson Daniel Garcia Wheeler Yuta Blackpool Combat Club ROH Pure Title
AEW

The sight of Bryan Danielson rocking up on AEW programming in the closing stages of All Out 2021 was enough to leave just about every wrestling fan on the planet frothing at the mouth over the sort of world class dream matches and run the now-WWE legend could pursue in the coming years.

And though The American Dragon has most definitely added some classics to his already stellar back catalogue during his time in the All Elite sun, it does still feel as though the company haven't fully gotten all they can out of the undoubted all-timer since becoming an AEW wrestler a year or so ago.

Forging the Blackpool Combat Club alongside William Regal and Mox has most definitely added another layer to Danielson's character in recent times, becoming the group's de facto talent scout and the driving force behind the BCC laying the foundations for the future of the business.

Yet, his need to further reinforce this violent ensemble has largely seen his own personal quest for greatness take a backseat, with Danielson still not holding gold under the AEW banner and perhaps losing more big matches than he needs to in his bids to give something back to the industry.

Who knows how much longer fans will have the honour of witnessing the brilliance of Bryan. So, maybe it's finally time for Danielson to focus on one more run at the top, and leave the BCC schooling/scouting to Claudio Castagnoli for a while, in what could act as his final spell as a full-time icon.


4. Baron Corbin As A Wrestling God

JBL Baron Corbin
WWE.com

The character of Baron Corbin hasn't exactly clicked on a number of occasions over the years. But one aspect of his many shades of villainy that has rarely been called into question is his ability to genuinely piss off thousands with a mic in hand.

So, the reveal of John Bradshaw Layfield being brought back into the mix as a returning Happy-less Corbin's manager/mouth-piece felt like a peculiar call last month. And the decision to have him branded as the second-coming of the "Wrestling God" only added to the oddness.

Since arriving on the main roster back in 2016, Corbin's issues have largely stemmed from the character not being able to make the transition from perennial heel loser to genuine main event bad guy to be reckoned with. And this can be traced back to the fact that "bum-ass" Corbin has routinely come up short on the biggest stage.

With that in mind, having JBL consistently tell fans how brilliant and vital his new protégé is without the company having the cojones to simply show them how dominant and important he is, through, you know, winning matches of any real importance, feels like another sidewards or even backwards step for the long-time mid-card gatekeeper.

Dump the loud-mouth bully and have the loud-mouth Corbin End the Days of all in his way with a steak in one hand and a cigar in the other, I say!


3. Luchasaurus As Kane 2.0

Luchasaurus Fuego del Sol
AEW

Make no mistake, Luchasaurus is one hell of a prehistoric performer on his day.

And throughout much of his time walking the earth whilst signed to Tony Khan's All Elite promotion, the Jurassic Express powerhouse managed to establish himself as one of the most beloved and bizarre creations the industry had to offer, regularly pulling off superhuman feats of athleticism whilst endearing himself as a dino dude to get behind.

This unexpected effectiveness as one half of the vibrant Jurassic twosome alongside Jungle Boy Jack Perry has made the concept of the towering masked force turning into a Kane 2.0 of sorts a touch difficult to digest for many over the last few months, mind.

Donning a spooky new black variation of his joyfully surreal persona, the idea of a dastardly dinosaur doing the evil biddings of a devious Christian Cage very quickly ran out of steam... and that was before his second heel turn on his one-time best pal in a matter of months.

Simply put, the entire Luchasaurus gimmick doesn't really pop in quite the same gloriously weird way when acting as a Right Hand of Destruction. So, perhaps AEW would be wise to have the Austin Matelson underneath the mask opt for a different title and intimidating look whilst he's doing business with Captain Charisma.


2. Bayley As The Relentless Heel Leader

Bayley WWE
WWE.com

Following in the footsteps of the likes of Seth Rollins and Becky Lynch before her, Bayley's recent comeback to the WWE landscape at this year's SummerSlam quickly saw the crowd-favourite returning star awkwardly shoved into the role of diabolical heel leader for the sake of giving Bianca Belair a sparring partner for a few months.

Now that's not to say that Bayley isn't fully capable of playing a part on the Dark Side, with The Role Model putting in some of her finest work to date whilst battling as a baddy against old nemesis Sasha Banks throughout 2020.

Yet, after her shameful treatment at WrestleMania 37 and subsequent spell on the sidelines from July 2021 onwards, fans were very much ready to back a returning Bayley as she looked to reestablish herself as one of the company's leading ladies.

Instead, Bayley's obsession with taking "CTRL" of the women's division alongside Dakota Kai and IYO SKY has seen the star repeatedly spurt out hollow threats and instantly forgettable putdowns of the various faces occupying the roster and rarely marking herself out as a credible threat to Belair's reign in the process.

In all honesty, Damage CTRL in general would likely benefit from a post-WarGames break-up. But Bayley in particular is in desperate need of a change in direction; be that towards being a more opportunistic and selfish solo heel or simply going back to babyface basics with the one-time Hugger.


1. Johnny Gargano As The Cocky Face

Johnny Gargano JBL
WWE.com

In Johnny Gargano, Triple H should know better than just about anyone else on the planet that he possesses a supremely gifted worker who can operate as perhaps the most naturally sympathetic babyface his entire roster has to offer; outside of the evergreen Rey Mysterio, admittedly.

Throughout his run on Papa H's black and gold show, Johnny Wrestling showcased relentless reserves of underdog fire and a genuine connection with the audience that just about every booker on the planet would kill to have at their disposal.

So, what did The Game opt to do the second his one-time NXT pride and joy finally agreed to return home and actually sign on the main roster dotted line? Cart him out as a D-Generation X-Lite, smarmy hero, focused more on painfully taking the piss out of his rivals than trying to achieve his own dreams in-between the ropes.

Because of course he did.

The early signs were so promising, too. The former NXT Champion let his childhood "impossible" ambitions to become a champion on WWE's main stage and wrestle at WrestleMania be known on night one, and reminded those watching on what could be achieved when you bet on yourself. All to the sound of unfiltered and deafening support.

Fast forward a few months and it's starting to feel more like Johnny lost a bet to someone backstage and is being forced to deal out soul-crushing one-liners and Miz/Lumis storyline developments as a punishment. What a waste.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Bayley
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Gareth has 6 years experience writing and presenting articles/videos covering all things professional wrestling within the fantastic WhatCulture team. Gareth is also a life long wrestling fan, so is clearly living the dream!