10 Wrestlers Who Are The Most Overrated At Precisely One Thing
Does Uncle Howdy really keep you up at night?
The list you're about to read features several names who are subjectively excellent and or objectively very over with audiences.
The list is not entitled '10 Wrestlers Who Are Sh*t', or '10 Wrestlers Who Make Shane McMahon Look Halfway Competent'; it's a list that seeks to debunk certain narratives that have prevailed online because that's what everybody's here for, is it not?
That's how this online fandom deal works; you read a comment, take or insight and say either "Now that you've put it that way, I agree, thank you for illuminating that character motivation/story beat/tease/business success/business failure" or "F*ck off Sludged*ck you biased AEW smark".
Where applicable, as much explanation as possible has been provided in each entry to differentiate "very good, but overrated at one specific thing that they weirdly get credit for" and "This wrestler is sh*t" - although some sh*tty wrestlers do appear on it.
Every last wrestler has a following (well, except Tyrus), but sometimes personal bias coalesces to form a wider narrative that rings hollow to everybody else. Sometimes, a wrestler so skilled at one facet of the game can decline in that area, but people are too invested or even frightened to acknowledge it.
Sometimes, people get scared by a wrestler because they think they have to...
10. Johnny Gargano: Comedy
Johnny Gargano isn't painfully unfunny. He has not unimpressive comedic timing and a certain dorky charm with which he can get away with WWE material - and unless you're Sami Zayn, gutting through it via force of will is the only choice a performer has.
The problem is that the Gargano comedy character only worked in the context of what he had become in NXT mid-annihilation in the Wednesday Night War. 'One Final Beat' was an inadvertently hilarious joke and completely nuked the idea of Johnny Gargano: purveyor of epic matches. All involved in the process realised that the excesses had become cringe-worthy, and via The Way, Gargano's jumped-up knacker character worked in stark contrast. It was light relief from the most humourless, histrionic material imaginable.
The problem now is that this version of the character - still inexplicably nicknamed Johnny Wrestling - has rocked up on Raw, the effect of which is unflattering and alienating. He feels like the lamentably unfunny and grabby "cousin" character in a sitcom that the writers introduce deep into the run in a panic at tumbling ratings.
If you travelled 365 days back in time with a YouTube link to one of his segments and a print-out of his Cagematch listing, you'd never in 365 million years even venture a guess that Vince McMahon had been replaced.
(Unless you've realised that he and Triple H aren't so different.)
9. Braun Strowman: Playing The Agile Big Man
Braun Strowman is good at what he does in short, big dumb fun bursts - and Christ knows that wrestling on the whole needs to get on with it and move on from an endless procession of back-and-forth matches - but the idea that he's an agile big man is just...wrong.
He's not the Great Khali or anything, but then again, what a low bar. Michael Cole is constantly amazed by Strowman's ability to actually move in a non-Yetay way, but it's not one of his more credible calls.
Strowman isn't one of the most agile and dynamic modern hosses. Lance Archer is better at wowing crowds with outrageous feats of which he has no physical right, Jeff Cobb is 100 times the worker, and Keith Lee, despite being past his physical prime, is so talented at a core level that he can work great matches while carefully measuring his jaw-dropping high spots. Strowman meanwhile runs around the ring in an inelegant, almost comedic way, as if he wants to prove that he isn't El Gigante.
He's not even an agile big man by the standards of a bygone era. And that's fine - nobody expects him to be Vader - but they talk about him like he's Vader. And he's not Vader.
It's pure marketing.
8. Andrade: Being A Top Star
There's no shame whatsoever in being a stupidly talented upper midcard star, but many wrestlers don't see it that way.
The desire within them to bump in the first place drives them to a level fans can't begin to grasp. They aren't doing this painful vocation to fill some space on a card; they are doing it to one day achieve their dreams.
Andrade, bluntly, has had his chances.
He played the entitled playboy d*ckhead to perfection in CMLL. He was one of the very best "workrate" guys of the 2010s; his NXT TakeOver: Philadelphia match with Johnny Gargano was a lung-bursting squelcher that hit as hard in the ring as it did the hearts of everybody in the crowd. He failed on the WWE main roster - then again, who didn't - but his AEW run didn't go too well either.
The booking was sh*te. His recruiter gimmick went about as well as Freddie Prinze Jr.'s, but he didn't maximise his minutes or do much of anything to prove Tony Khan wrong when given the chance. He piled on the muscle and hit his opponents very, very hard in beautifully sadistic performances, but aside from "OK, how you know?", he did little else but work ***3/4-**** matches. And again: who doesn't nowadays?
Many people - chief among them Andrade himself - project mega-stardom onto him and feel his AEW run was a disgrace.
But he just lacks "it". He dresses for the part impeccably, but you can't play it so easily.
7. Bray Wyatt: Portraying A Sinister Presence
Bray Wyatt is meant to be scary.
That is the entire crux of his character. He is meant to be unhinged, disturbed, volatile. You are meant to believe that he is dangerously close to snapping at any given moment, and as such, everything he does is meant to be loaded with unease and suspense.
Is it?
His delivery is fine, but his act is hardly nightmare fuel. His cackling, demented laughter bit is almost a cliché of the troubled human being, in that this is the first thing a hack aspiring ac-tor would do in an audition for such a part. When he builds those moments that near an eruption, his dialogue is much too convoluted. His blank stare, when LA Knight slapped him for a second time the other week, was as close to unnerving as he's got upon returning - but he was always better at studying horror than embodying it.
Kota Ibushi, when he enters what is somewhat tragically known as his 'Murderboi' state, genuinely evokes an unsettled reaction. It helps that he is very erratic and that it actually feels like there's nothing behind those eyes. Eddie Kingston, at AEW Double Or Nothing earlier this year, did a more convincing job of looking capable of doing something truly abhorrent.
Wyatt is over, a draw, and a very impressive amount of people have bought what he's selling - but even Nailz was scarier.
6. Will Ospreay: Working Classic Matches
There's a potential misunderstanding to preempt here.
Will Ospreay, whether you like the man or not, is a phenomenal professional wrestler. If you think he's a glorified gymnast, you're frankly a moron. Gymnastics is a sport so strenuous that only the very gifted and committed can do it to a high level, for one, and Will Ospreay chops harder than WALTER. He is an excellent, top-tier professional wrestler in every aspect of the in-ring game: execution, storytelling, drama.
He is also capable of generating a deep emotional response through his tremendous psychology, but - and this is through no fault of his own - he has been unable to do this in New Japan Pro Wrestling for a number of years now because the fans are prohibited from cheering and reacting without inhibitions.
Ospreay's crushing G1 Climax loss to Kazuchika Okada this year almost worked as well as it did because of the restrictions, in that the drama was so powerful that the fans couldn't help themselves but break protocol. But still: effective crowd psychology is what drives a true pro wrestling classic, and the match would have been better had it played out in front of 10,000 people screaming themselves hoarse. Many of us extended latitude towards pandemic wrestling when there was no alternative to closed-set tapings, but it's hard to do the same thing in 2022 now that, watching wrestling from the west concurrently, we don't have to.
It's harsh, particularly since NJPW - albeit under duress - are doing the right thing. But what truly marks a classic wrestling match is the definitive feeling that you've just watched something undoubtedly special. A classic isn't bittersweet. A classic isn't something that could have been better, significantly so, than it was.
In the years to come, Ospreay's pandemic-era output will be considered the Avatar of pro wrestling: an outrageous technical achievement lacking in both soul and a cultural footprint.
5. Austin Theory: Being The Next Big Thing
Framing a talent as the next big thing is an almost pointlessly cruel booking trope.
Instantly, the booker is telling and not showing the story beat, and the talent must immediately embody the characteristics of a megastar to stand a chance of pulling off the role.
Has it even happened once?
Brock Lesnar was handed that literal title, but nobody bought it until he actually evolved into a special talent. Randy Orton's early push while slightly less on-the-nose also struggled because Vince McMahon, desperate to restore the glory days, was too insistent about it. Drew McIntyre bombed so badly as the 'Chosen One' early in his career that his resurgence was built around it in a meta spot of character development.
And now, Austin Theory is the latest character to be saddled with the tag. Is he really the future face of WWE?
In a very literal sense, yes, because he has what they have always looked for. He's tall, cut and telegenic. He's more than capable of reciting arrogant heel material in a smooth way. If you built Vince McMahon's ideal of a sports entertainer from the ground up, he'd look like Austin Theory - and that's the problem. He's a 7 at everything, lacks true charisma, and has a midcard quality that cannot be shaken.
And, in an era where we no longer have to endure Vince's oppressive tastes, it's all the easier not to fall for it.
4. Michael Cole: Commentary
The critical acclaim WWE generated by operating at a better standard than "total dog sh*t" under Triple H was remarkable.
Because he scrapped the 24/7 division, scripted his WWE Superstars to say the word "wrestling" and elongated virtually every match length by five minutes, he was considered the saviour of WWE. That's one thing - snark aside, Vince McMahon would never have promoted anything as outstanding as GUNTHER Vs. Sheamus at Clash At The Castle - but the standard elsewhere was insanely generous.
Michael Cole is still Michael Cole; very polished to an extent that is synthetic, his calls are exposition heavy, he clutches your hand through basic story beats, and he rarely feels like he's holding an organic conversation. And the screaming, holy hell the bloody screaming.
When something ostensibly exciting happens, the man is much too eager to let you know. It is beyond forced, and the generally bleak atmosphere of a WWE TV show brings the desperation into further focus; if something were that exciting, you'd see the fans going apesh*t. Ultimately, Cole still makes it feel that bit more fake.
He is a bit more loose now, and he has devised a cheat code of referencing smaller promotions to put over a wrestler's background, but the only appreciable difference is that he sounds slightly less like there's a weapon poking into his back.
3. Edge: Promos
Edge is a very good promo who, over the course of a legendary career, has built deep interest in his most iconic matches. He is remembered as fondly as he is because he was the complete package.
His delivery is tremendous, often very funny, and he generally cuts a major league presence. As a heel - when he isn't wrapped up in bobbins supernatural pretentious nonsense that thinks it is cleverer than it is - he has that evil glint in his eyes, and while it's exaggerated, his hammy approach to the role works very well in the context of WWE's broad theatre.
Since he returned, however, it's as if he's trying too hard.
Playing a babyface, predominately, he has weighed himself down to the depths of near-embarrassment with material that is very, very heavy. What should have been welcome, necessary respite from the wacky low-stakes drivel that Vince McMahon pumped out more often than not was actually the opposite end of that extreme.
Edge's bulging forehead vein and spittle-frothed delivery is almost a parody of intensity, and at times, he seems to audition for a role in film with his Kubrick stare - and, again, the lighting and the staging ruthlessly undermine the notion that his spiels are authentic things meant to be taken very, very seriously.
He was far better as the ultra-cocky, uncaring bastard.
2. FTR: Bringing Back Old School Wrestling
FTR an excellent tag team. This entry isn't designed to rubbish their achievements, since their 2022 is rivalled only by the Young Bucks' 2021 as quite possibly the best in-ring year that any tag team - ever - has put to record.
The idea that they are the rugged, old school, less choreographed contrast to the Young Bucks however is absurd.
Stylistically, they are very much removed from the Young Bucks, but in terms of match structure, what they do is far more similar than a lot of people seem to think. Their matches are complex, embrace a high volume of twists in momentum, and lovingly embrace melodrama. The Young Bucks are perceived in some circles - circles that adore FTR - as am-dram-level purveyors of soapy storytelling that you'd never see in a "real" fight.
But how many fights have you seen, as the scintillating dramatic peak nears, where the gang members hold one another's hands in support for a camera-friendly close-up?
Or: how many territory matches have you seen that very meticulously build to a moment like that?
FTR don't call it in the ring. They choreograph their movements - in a way that you might even call contrived! - to extract the loudest reaction from a modern crowd that holds an expectation, raised on WWE, of a certain premeditated cinematic flair.
And that is absolutely fine. Seminal at its very best. They've committed some of the best ever tag team wrestling to tape.
FTR are a phenomenal tag team, easily amongst the very best of all-time - but it's weird that they get more praise for doing something that they don't than for what they do.
1. The Miz: Being Underrated
The Miz enjoys quite the narrative, one that is helped enormously by the fact that he did something admirable once upon a time: he withstood the sociopathic SmackDown locker room of the 2000s, evolved into a starring role with a commendable work ethic, and generally "won at life" and was deserving of the victory.
All of these things are true, but the Miz remains a mechanically rotten pro wrestler who has sunk several storylines and, ultimately, was lucky to boast charisma and show a devout loyalty to "the WWE" during an era (the early 2010s) in which any semblance of star power was prized as something more than it was because the wider landscape was so polluted with the blandest of bland crap.
The Miz this year had the worst match Cody has worked since his OVW days. The Miz's feud with Dexter Lumis is wretched. His chair shots are Hulk Hogan-level bad. His character is beyond stale. He was dragged to one very good bout all year by a man working only his second ever match. In that scenario, the performer who has worked over 2,000 matches should not be the broomstick.
Several of those 2,000 matches were pretty good, some even great, but has the Miz ever wrestled a good match against somebody who isn't great?
This sh*t with the Miz verges on the parasocial; while it's good for him that his wife is 10, how does that help anybody, who isn't a freak, get through his matches?
"He can't properly apply the finish he's executed or at least attempted for over a decade, but he seems happy. Therefore, I am sports entertained."
What?