10 Wrestlers Who Became World Champions At The WRONG Time

Fingers crossed nobody else's first WWE Title reign is like Drew McIntyre's.

Drew McIntyre Right Wrong WWE Title
WWE

Timing is everything in life.

It's kinda weird to suggest there's a bad time to become World Champion, but it's true. Winning one of WWE's top prizes should be the pinnacle of anyone's career. Then, reality smacks them across the face with corporate nonsense, promoters who are already looking beyond them, or a global concern nobody could've predicted.

There are some proper big names here. Drew McIntyre, CM Punk, Booker T, Bray Wyatt, Chris Jericho - it's a who's who of in-ring excellence and stunning character reinvention. All of them have something else in common aside from being great at their jobs though: Every single one of those guys lived a 'right man, wrong time' top title experience at some point over the years.

WCW is coming along for this ride too. That company was falling to pieces when three of the finest to ever lace up a pair of boots held the World Title. No, shockingly actor David Arquette has not entered the chat! We're talking linchpins of the 90s midcard who reached main event status when it was too late.

Let's bookend with the same statement. Timing is everything in life. Just ask...

10. Alberto Del Rio

WWE SummerSlam 2011 Alberto Del Rio
WWE.com

...this man!

2011 was a big year for Alberto Del Rio, but it just so happened it was a bigger year for somebody else. CM Punk was the name on everyone's lips following his historic "pipebomb", and the people wanted more of him. Things might've been different had Del Rio been Punk's main adversary, but he wasn't: John Cena was.

That meant Royal Rumble and Money In The Bank winner Alberto was left fighting over scraps for the second part of 2011. He cashed in at SummerSlam and would enjoy a second run with the WWE Title before the end of the year, but neither lived long in the memory. How could they? The 'Summer Of Punk' and Cena's involvement pushed Del Rio down to third place.

WWE probably could've held their nerve and waited to crown Alberto, but they were desperate to keep the drama going and didn't want to make MITB look like a loser's purse. So, Del Rio cashed in then company creative cashed out shortly afterwards.


9. CM Punk

CM Punk World Heavyweight Champion
WWE.com

The man himself and his loyal fans would surely disagree, but CM Punk wasn't ready to become World Heavyweight Champion in 2008. Sure, he'd won Money In The Bank at WrestleMania XXIV and was a popular babyface, but Punk never had the backing of those who mattered most. No, not the fans. Those in the office.

Vince McMahon blatantly didn't see Punk as a proper top liner who could carry the can on flagship show Raw. After cashing in his chips on Edge (thanks to Batista on the 30 June 2008 episode), ol' CM struggled to convince Vince. He wouldn't even get the distinction of dropping the belt properly either, which was rubbish.

Punk was replaced by eventual winner Chris Jericho in a 'Championship Scramble' at Unforgiven in September. His World Title dreams were over (for now) without even being involved in the closing chapter. WWE booked Punk as a 50/50 'he's sort of in our plans but not really' champion over the summer.

That was never going to work.


8. Liv Morgan

WWE Money In The Bank 2022 Liv Morgan
WWE.com

There's a bit of spice to this one, because you might be sitting there thinking the old SmackDown Women's Title definitely wasn't a World Championship. Let's roll with it, 'cause that belt follows the same title lineage as the current Women's World strap on Raw. Therefore, Liv Morgan's 2022 nightmare counts.

Liv won Money In The Bank then cashed in on Ronda Rousey hours later. That lightning bolt of a start should've led to bigger and better things, but WWE creative outright failed to get behind Morgan's reign. Why? They were still obsessed with the thought of Ronda Rousey tackling Charlotte Flair, basically.

Liv was a third wheel.

Booking for her title reign was awful. She defended a messy finish vs. Ronda at SummerSlam, and that earned boos from a crowd who were supposed to view her as an underdog babyface. Come October, WWE had decided to cut things short by putting the title back on Rousey at Extreme Rules.

Morgan was collateral.


7. Booker T

Booker T WCW World Title
WWE

Don't hate the player, hate the game. Nope, not that 'Game'. The "game" in question here was a corporate power struggle for WCW's future. Some at AOL/Time Warner wanted the company gone, whilst others hanging over from Ted Turner's regime wanted it to stick around. There was only ever going to be one winner.

The on-screen product was pricklier than Ted's moustache too. Vince Russo-led nightmare fuel bled all over episodes of Nitro and Thunder every single week, and Russo's own power struggle vs. Hulk Hogan came to a head on Bash At The Beach 2000. Hogan walked out, then Booker T lucked into a World Title win over Jeff Jarrett.

Perhaps "lucked out" is too strong. Book had worked diligently as a key member of WCW's roster for years, but he was pushed during an era when madness reigned supreme behind the scenes. It was clear to anyone with a working pair of eyes that WCW was going to continue floundering.

Nobody knew it'd be a goner by March 2001, but the summer of 2000 was not an ideal time to become World Champion.


6. Scott Steiner

WCW Mayhem 2000 Scott Steiner
WWE

November 2000 was even worse!

Scott Steiner's menacing 'Big Poppa Pump' reinvention terrified people. The ex-tag teamer was so realistic as a bullying muscle man that he carried an edge few other heels in the promotion could match. Thus, sticking the WCW World Title on him at Mayhem late in the year was a solid creative plan.

That was about the only thing solid in World Championship Wrestling. Audiences had evaporated, ratings were shrinking, pay-per-view business was going down, and there were rumblings that someone was either gonna have to buy or kill the company heading into 2001. It wouldn't be long until Vince McMahon was in the conversation as a potential buyer.

Steiner's push featured some of the best heel work WCW TV had seen in years, but it was coming far too late in the day to rescue anything. Scott's chippy personality and scathing comments to come about everyone from Triple H to the McMahon family didn't exactly guarantee he'd be part of some crossover project either.


5. Bray Wyatt

Bray Wyatt WWE Champion
WWE

On paper, winning the top prize less than two months out from WrestleMania should be a blessing. It defo wasn't for Bray Wyatt. Yes, he did have shock value when winning out at Elimination Chamber 2017, and Bray did bag a tidy payday for working a main title bout on the biggest show of the year, but his title dream was never built to last.

Vince McMahon was stumbling around looking for something new almost as soon as Wyatt won the thing. Randy Orton would beat Bray at 'Mania, then McMahon landed on Jinder Mahal of all people. The (negative) hysteria surrounding Jinder's ascent ensured that Wyatt's 49-day run as champ was forgotten.

Bummer.

Bray was one of WWE's most creative souls, and he had been for years by the time Chamber 2017 rolled along. Seeing him get his flowers was lovely, but then writers mucked it all up by looking past Wyatt when they should've been looking to him.

He was the victim of a boss who didn't really know what he wanted.


4. Chris Benoit

Chris Benoit WCW World Title
WWE Network

Tony Schiavone ushered in the new millennium by promising that Souled Out 2000 would set the tone for WCW's year and decade to come. That's laughable looking back, because the group would only exist full-scale for another year and change. Meanwhile, Chris Benoit's career with the company would only run for another 24 hours.

That didn't stop bookers from putting the big gold belt on him.

Benoit beat Sid Vicious for the World Title in a spirited main event. Then, he handed the title back to WCW chiefs and left for the WWF before Monday's episode of Nitro made air. The timing couldn't have been worse from WCW's perspective, but...what the hell were they smoking anyway?! Benoit didn't want to be in the promotion anymore, let alone World Champ of it.

His head had been turned by the lure of better organisation over on the McMahon side. Maybe showing this kind of faith in the Canadian in 1998 or 1999 would've sold him on staying put longer than he did. Instead, Benoit, Eddie Guerrero, Dean Malenko and Perry Saturn fled for greener pastures.


3. Kofi Kingston

Kofi Kingston WWE Champion WrestleMania 35
WWE.com

'KofiMania' was never meant to happen.

An injury to Mustafa Ali meant WWE needed a replacement for the gauntlet bout on the 12 February 2019 SmackDown. Kofi Kingston stepped into the breach and entered a performance so impressive that fans rallied behind thoughts of a late-career main event push. Vince McMahon was listening, but seemed unsure.

Eventually, the WWE boss decided to go with it and crowned Kofi WWE Champ at WrestleMania 35. That's when the unfortunate truth smacked everyone on the chops: McMahon had given them their fun, but he didn't view Kingston as a sustainable champion. Still, Kofi survived through until October when Brock Lesnar squashed him on the FOX debut edition of SmackDown.

Vince's plan? Pivot away from the underdog story he hadn't wanted in the first place towards attractions like Brock vs. former UFC man Cain Velasquez instead. The audience hated that, but this was McMahon's sandbox. There's an argument to be made that Kofi would've fared better had Triple H jumpstarted his run as boss earlier.

There's no way Hunter would book Kingston to look so second rate, surely.


2. Chris Jericho

Chris Jericho Vengeance 2001
WWE

Speaking of McMahon, he left Chris Jericho depressed before his big night at Vengeance 2001 by joking to The Undertaker that business must be in the toilet if they were putting the belt on 'Y2J'. How's that for a vote of confidence from the guy in charge? Jericho's head had to be swimming with self-doubt.

There was some truth to what Vince was saying, unfortunately. The WWF was in a state of flux post-invasion angle ending, and Triple H was just about to launch his return. He was the big hope to turn things around again, not Jericho. That meant the Canadian star's double win over The Rock and Steve Austin was tainted before it even happened.

Remember, timing is everything.

McMahon wasn't going all in on turning Jericho from upper midcarder into main event made man. Therein lies the problem - Jericho was a placeholder as Undisputed Champion until Triple H could return and beat him at WrestleMania X8. Everyone knew that was coming as soon as Hunter popped Madison Square Garden in January.

It'd be back to the midcard for Jericho after a middling three-month reign.


1. Drew McIntyre

Drew McIntyre WWE Title
WWE.com

WrestleMania 36 will always be the weirdest one.

Drew McIntyre deserves immense credit for the way he handled himself though. The Scot showed maturity and talked about the impact of a global pandemic on the world at large rather than focusing solely on his personal ambitions. Winning the title in front of literally zero fans live had to suck by comparison to what he thought would be on offer after winning the Royal Rumble though.

There's no doubt about that. McIntyre had become the top babyface in the land overnight by Claymore Kicking one Brock Lesnar out of the Rumble and then winning the 30-man favourite. People were firmly on Team Drew heading into 'Mania, but then March 2020 hit and the place was turned upside down by COVID.

Nobody could’ve foreseen that, obviously, but McIntyre’s win still belongs on a list like this one. He didn't get to hear the glorious pop of a 60/70,000-strong crowd after pinning Lesnar. Instead, Drew returned to a practically empty Performance Center backstage, then bizarrely wrestled Big Show in a match taped for Raw.

The fact he didn't get to wrestle in front of an actual audience even once during his first WWE Title reign is a crying shame. 

What other World Champs were crowned at the wrong times? For more WWE, check out 10 DUMB WWE Face Turns (We Didn't Want To Admit Were GENIUS!) and 10 Times You Didn't Realise Wrestlers Were Saying 'Goodbye'! 


Watch Next


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.