10 Wrestlers Who Broke The Muta Scale
Blade Runners.
When used with a degree of safety and considerable artistry, blood in wrestling acts as a symbol for violence as opposed to genuine violence. In short, it's a work; the shallow cut is opened over the forehead, to ensure a photogenic and not inconsiderable pour - and to minimise the risk of bleeding out. To sustain the drama, an opponent can re-open the wound, designed to seal quickly, with a worked punch.
Yes, this is entertainment - but as the Great Muta discovered in legendary fashion, the hazards are real. In a notorious 1992 match opposite Hiroshi Hase, Muta entered with crimson face paint and, after a blade job masquerading as a crowbar spot went awry, left with a particularly gruesome crimson mask. As the camera first captured the visual, Muta slumped to his knees - at which point the red stuff poured all over the canvas to form a pool. Blood coated his entire body, and that of his opponent. It was the wrestling tape trader's Faces of Death.
And thus the Muta Scale - the barometer against which all future blade jobs were judged - was born. Even through the grainy VHS transfer, the gore is revolting - though not entirely as definitive as the official title suggests.
Many bemoan the lack of blood in modern wrestling, which is somewhat understandable, much as a certain drama is missing.
But the scope for life-threatening injury is frighteningly high...
10. Shawn Michaels
What's ironic about the first-ever Hell In A Cell match, between The Undertaker and Shawn Michaels at in Your House: Badd Blood, is that it promised the evolution of the steel cage contest - and yet it was the last genuine match of its type in how it was performed. Michaels sold as if suffocated by the mesh, frantically and desperately attempting to escape it and the unstoppable monster within. Nowadays, it exists as something for the performers to just bounce around and off, with the spectacle supplanting any sort of storyline logic.
The blood, as it so often did, helped; the mere sight of Michaels donning the crimson mask - more a cloak, really, given the grisly extent of the gigging - put the stipulation over as this utterly brutal battleground. Referee Earl Hebner failed to obstruct the blade job itself, which is a shame in and of itself and because Michaels must have really hurt himself to set it up. He flung himself back-first on the concrete to dropkick 'Taker against the cell wall. His second attempt was unsuccessful; 'Taker caught and catapulted him, while Hebner failed to mask the angle.
Michaels visibly sliced his own forehead, but it hardly mattered; every other second of this war was a masterpiece, in which blood elevated it to a work of art, not a cheap flea market exercise in carny-ism.
9. Necro Butcher
In which the point was sort of missed. The violence wasn't merely implied; it was real.
The infamous IWA: Mid South Samoa Joe Vs. Necro Butcher war was, in a word, disgusting; punishment glutton Butcher obviously instructed Joe to not hold back. Absorbing a brutal - nay, real - beating was his act, which explains the stomach-churning enzuigiri in the opening melee. The audible thwack of a hand slapping a knee was noticeably absent; Joe connected firmly with the back of Butcher's head. Butcher proceeded to blade immediately, following which Joe opened the cut with a sick succession of shoot headbutts. After more building-wide brawling, Joe spiked Butcher's neck with a gruesome exploder suplex from apron to exposed concrete and brained him with a crown-first, unprotected chair shot. He didn't do this to massage the wound; he did it because the Butcher is a total lunatic. Brained is the operative word; Butcher's actual matter seemed to lubricate the floor. This was a battle fought between a sadist and a masochist, the results of which were absolutely harrowing on both a visual and visceral level.
Dubious though the means were, the end result was inarguable; in 2005, Joe's aura as a killer was entrenched, while Necro Butcher enjoyed a level of garbage notoriety not witnessed since the heyday of the form in the 1990s.
8. Randy Orton
In which the point was completely missed.
At SummerSlam 2016, Brock Lesnar opened a hardway hole in Randy Orton's skull in order to get himself over as a monster - as if breaking the Undertaker's streak and reducing John Cena to Special Delivery Jones two years prior wasn't enough. WWE doesn't allow its performers to blade in the PG era due to its insinuation with violence and association with pro wrestling in its pre-sanitised, outlaw format. As an alternative, Brock Lesnar has been instructed, on more than one occasion, to either scrape or literally drill blood from the scalps of his peers.
Lesnar was infuriated at Orton's ability to kick out of the F5 - ironically for Braun Strowman, this was considered a burial at the time - and responded by caving Orton's skull in. This wasn't a mere deep cut, the antithesis of a blade job; Orton missed a month of ring time with a concussion slap-bang in the age of CTE awareness. What's even more ironic is that Vince McMahon told Wade Barrett, minutes before the same event six years earlier, that the Nexus had to be destroyed in order to send the crowd home happy.
Unhappy is one thing, but traumatised and sickened, apparently, is another.
7. Jun Kasai
Just look at the scars on that motherf*cker's back. It looks disgusting.
What's weird about Jun Kasai, who you can probably infer from the picture alone is a proponent of the garbage match, is that he isn't a worker akin to the dearly departed Mr. Pogo - a man, bless him, devoid of any discernible wrestling talent - he's d*mn sound mechanically. He doesn't perform in garbage matches because he cannot perform in traditional matches. Much like Necro Butcher, Jun Kasai is pro wrestling's version of a Marina Abramovic, or an Orlan - a performance artist concerned with self-destruction, more so than he is a professional wrestler in the strictest sense. He can go, but chooses to gig. Testing the personal threshold of pain and the stomach of the audience may not be art. Mileage varies. But, for those with an affection for mutilation, Kasai must be the 1989 vintage Ric Flair.
Examples of his shattering the Muta scale are numerous; lacerating his back and face is just what he does in a wrestling ring - something highlighted by his decision to wear a white contact lens in his left eye, which only serves to render the image that much more prominent, that much more grotesque.
6. Bill Alfonso
Scrawny, bratty referee Bill Alfonso just barely warrants the designation of "wrestler," but this triumph of an impromptu match wasn't just unexpected: it was inconceivable.
Alfonso, like every wrestling referee, was trained in the dark arts of bumping. Ditto opponent Beulah McGillicutty. But that was about it; neither performer was athletic nor experienced enough to craft an actual wrestling match. However, the superb grasp of their respective characters, a winning match layout, and the simple, supreme novelty of the sight gag converged to create something great out of virtually nil resource. Beulah suckered Alfonso in with a bait and switch, bruising his knuckles with a hidden baking tray, before the tone of the match was set. It was Alfonso's inexperience that made it; he cut himself far too deeply, creating the indelible spectacle of a stuck pig - fitting, given his mannerisms throughout. He struck Beulah with a low blow and choked her to generate immense heat from the crowd. Then, in an hilarious, blackly comedic note, he signalled for a moonsault, a move he had no chance of pulling off. Beulah's comebacks were timed perfectly, engineering a totally delirious atmosphere.
Paul Heyman, known tall tale teller, has it that Alfonso lost a third of his blood. That may be bullsh*t, but the job of the booker is to lionise his talent. That this match lives on in the memory is a testament of his genius.
5. Mass Transit
Again - "Wrestler" is a stretch. Erik "Mass Transit" Kulas was not a trained professional wrestler, though he somehow worked his way into a spot as one, replacing Axl Rotten on an ECW house show that has entered the darkest annals of an already pitch-black industry.
It was Kulas' inexperience of wrestling etiquette, as much as his nonexistent mechanics, that was his undoing; he rubbed the boys the wrong way with his over-enthusiasm-slash-arrogance. With his parents in the crowd, he wanted to put on a show they would not soon forget. He also told New Jack that he wanted to get colour. This double drop of irony manifested as a police enquiry in the guise of a wrestling match; Jack, with the aid of a surgical scalpel, sliced Kulas open skull - not skin - deep. As Kid Kash (rather too gleefully) has it, Kulas, upon realising the grim gravity of his situation, let out a high-pitched squeal. The wannabe wrestler was reduced to the child his state recognised him as.
Kulas broke the Muta scale, and New Jack broke the in-ring code by punishing Kulas' own transgression with too much zeal. Mercifully, the only existing footage is comprised of slow pixelated blurs and still images.
The viewer cannot be similarly broken through its mostly hidden horror.
4. John Cena
The temptation, when supporting the argument for blood in pro wrestling, is to argue for its (relatively) safe, easy and documented history of getting a babyface over.
Unless you're Triple H circa 2003-2005, or a particular or subverted story is being told, the babyface usually bleeds. The sight of blood triggers our naturally sympathetic tendencies. Then again, in 2017, within a world as broken as ours is at present, perhaps the foundation of blading no longer exists. Still, there is so much precedent. Dusty Rhodes bled like a battlefield casualty en route to capturing the hearts of his public. Steve Austin's crimson forehead punctuated his breakthrough performance at WrestleMania 13 with an indelible, marketable visual. Tommy Rich, a beloved territory-era babyface, knew that red equalled green.
This tactic did not work for John Cena at Judgment Day 2005, at which he pulled off a ridiculously unhinged blade job during his match with JBL (whom so many bled at the sight of, indicting his main event credentials somewhat). As violent and memorable as the match was, it did not translate to Cena's lasting acceptance in the babyface role; the jeers returned in full voice in the days and weeks afterwards because the crimson mask only served to briefly mask Cena's inconsistency and paradigm-problematic character.
On this evidence, blading is not a shortcut, but rather a lagniappe.
3. The Undertaker
The Undertaker and Brock Lesnar's first Hell In A Cell match was a multi-sensory masterpiece; what it lacked in lunatic bumps and crazed athletic catapulting, it compensated for with disturbing sound design - 'Taker never sounded so human as he did when howling in pain at Lesnar's hand-breaking tactics - and unpleasant, gory, bloodbath visual effects.
As the match lurched towards its final third, Lesnar drilled 'Taker in the head with the ring steps. Before the camera cut away, you could see 'Taker not-so-subtly withdraw the blade from his elbow pad - which made his commitment to the cause all the more impressive. He didn't slash the soft centre of his forehead to fashion a crimson mask; he sliced at the point of impact, opening a hole above his eye. The blood poured from said hole like a deluge - a grotesque flash flood of blood that elevated Lesnar into the grand pantheon of wrestling monsters.
Lesnar was built as this destructive force of nature in 2002; 'Taker sold that premise superbly and literally. He resembled Carrie at the end of it, adding to the horror flick overtones.
2. Vince McMahon
Vince McMahon has one simple demand of his talent roster: he would not ask them to do anything he wouldn't do, which is reasonable enough on the surface. Unfortunately for them, McMahon is ostensibly both slave-driver and veritable lunatic, and routinely works inhuman hours well into his twilight years. He also remains fond of absorbing incredible punishment in the name of putting an angle over.
He didn't f*ck around at Survivor Series 2003; perhaps sensing that he was missing the grand stage of a WrestleMania and the bigger star of an opponent in Hulk Hogan, McMahon delved into shortcut territory early. Immediately is the more appropriate word; he bladed after just one worked Undertaker punch. Now, this being Vince McMahon, we can't be too sure if the deep slice was altogether accidental, or if he knew d*mn well what he was getting himself into. The man, after all, is method and mad to the bone.
"Assisted" though it was, you cannot deny the effectiveness of his selling on the night. His match with the 'Taker, reductively, was a procession of punches and a protracted dissection of his leg - but he sold the onslaught as if starring in a body horror video nasty, all hoarse screams and wide-eyed tremor, thereby elevating it into something far more than the sum of its meagre parts.
That his blade job lives longer in the memory than Shawn Michaels', who mutilated himself on the very same show, underscores how many buckets he filled.
1. Eddie Guerrero
This was blood in wrestling at its dramatic best and harrowing worst - an eternal symbol of the undecidable debate.
Eddie Guerrero sliced an artery in his forehead when he bladed beneath the timekeeper's table at Judgment Day 2004, perhaps momentarily frazzled at the stiffness of JBL's prelude of a chair shot. The effects were immediately and distressingly apparent; as Guerrero slumped against the barricade, both face and chest were drenched in blood. The red stuff sprayed from his forehead like a malfunctioning prop in a comedy horror. The blue WWE ring canvas was soon stained crimson. Eddie could only wobble, jelly-legged, barely able to stand on it - which lent the remainder of the match an unbearable and indelible dramatic heft. It was all too real.
What is worrying in hindsight, and what renders WWE's later blade ban understandable - even if it was imposed by the influence of corporate sponsors - is that Eddie Guerrero was a master of his craft.
The margin for error is as thin as the line between life and death itself. To date, there are no records of a wrestler dying as a result of exsanguination - but the risk is sufficient to accept the real death of the blading art.