10 Wrestlers Who Butted Heads With WWE Creative (And Won)
Let's do it this way instead.
Everyone knows what it looks like when a wrestler loses an argument with creative. They either come out the following week repackaged as a cryogenically frozen Nazi (that's best case scenario) or a bulletin is swiftly posted up on their employer's website wishing them all the best in their future endeavours.
In most cases, it's better to simply fall in line and accept what the writers have given you, however stupid or demeaning it might seem. You can always do a shoot interview once you've retired where you let the world know your true feelings, but in the moment, you're best off keeping quiet and doing exactly what you're told.
Not everyone has heeded those words of wisdom over the years, though. Several of the industry's biggest stars have at one point or another decided to butt heads with their creative masters, sometimes outright refusing to go along with the script until appropriate (or inappropriate) revisions are made.
And get this: a handful of them actually came out on top, forcing their desperate bosses into last minute rewrites in order to keep everyone happy.
10. Molly Holly
Unlike her in-ring alter-ego, Molly Holly has always seemed like one of the more level-headed members of the WWE family. If someone told you a story about her stamping her feet over a creative decision backstage, you'd probably call them a big, fat liar.
Well, relax: Molly was actually on the side of good here. In 2004, she was so irked by the fact that WrestleMania XX wasn't due to feature a Women's Title match that she began pestering Vince McMahon to change his mind.
In the end, she got him to cave after pitching a radical, never-before-seen storyline whereby the loser of a bout between her and Victoria would have their head shaved bald, live on the Grandest Stage of Them All.
You might be thinking that receiving a high profile match in exchange for all your hair is kind of a raw deal. But number one: hair grows back, memories last forever. And two: she was the original anti-Diva. Going bald was a powerful statement of nonconformity at a time when the company was pushing Playboy Evening Gown Matches.
9. Scott Hall
Because he's a bit of an oddball, and because of his association with Hulk Hogan and Kevin Nash, Scott Hall has picked up a reputation as one of those wrestlers who was completely out for himself, 100% of the time. Given that, this story may shock you.
Back in his WCW days, the artist formerly known as Razor Ramon actually defied Eric Bischoff's instructions in order to put over a young guy. Yeah, that's right: he lost a match he was told to win - for entirely selfless reasons.
This act of disobedience came during a match with Chris Jericho in the late-nineties. Instead of going along with the finish suggested by creative, Hall told the young Y2J to roll him up for a three count, assuring him that he would take the heat when they returned to the back.
That's pretty neat. It's just a shame that his determination to put the young guys over never rubbed off on his nWo leader, else we might have been looking at a very different end to the Monday Night Wars.
8. John Cena
The internet wrestling community is forever accusing John Cena of deliberately keeping the young guys down, but there's really only one concrete piece of evidence we have to support this claim - namely SummerSlam 2010.
Originally booked to lose against the white-hot Nexus, Cena was said to have butted heads with creative just before the show went on air, insisting that he and the rest of Team WWE (but mainly, you suspect, he) should come out on top.
For reasons that we still don't fully understand, they caved to his demands. Big Match John was his side's sole survivor in the seven-on-seven main event, mounting a Superman-style comeback to eliminate both Justin Gabriel and Wade Barrett in the space of 25 seconds.
Edge and Chris Jericho have since gone on record to say that they weren't on board with the decision, and even Cena himself apparently came to regret his actions in retrospect. Couldn't you have had this discussion at the time, lads?
7. Hulk Hogan
It's not exactly a secret that Hulk Hogan and Bret Hart didn't see eye to eye. In fact, legend has it that the Hulkster outright refused to lose to his Canadian counterpart, telling bosses that he was too small for it to be a believable outcome.
Vince McMahon believed it was best for business, however, and managed to agree a sneaky quid pro quo with his franchise player. In essence: he would get his big moment at WrestleMania IX, on the condition that he agreed to lose to The Hitman a few months later.
But here's where Hogan managed to one up his creative masters: he happily walked out in March 1993 and beat Yokozuna for the WWF Title, but then got cold feet when it came to the getting pinned by Bret part of the deal.
Instead, he lost the belt back to Yoko at King of the Ring. The chairman's dream of a torch-passing moment between the face of yesterday and the face of tomorrow never became a reality, and not a single lesson was learned.
6. Ric Flair
Ric Flair has often been described as the Muhammad Ali or Babe Ruth of professional wrestling, which is why it was seen as such an affront when then-WCW president Jim Herd suggested a change of image in 1991.
He wanted his company's biggest name to drop the whole Nature Boy thing and become a Roman Gladiator, apparently even encouraging him to shave off his trademark bleach blonde hair to appear more tough and menacing.
Flair wasn't having any of it, and point blank refused to go along with Herd's plans, a stand-off that eventually saw him stripped of the World Heavyweight Championship and then fired from the company altogether on the eve of the Great American Bash.
Sounds bad, but consider how the future 16-time world champion spent the next year of his career. He signed a fat contract with Vince McMahon, won the 1992 Royal Rumble and then defended the WWE Championship at WrestleMania. That has to be a win.
5. Shawn Michaels
Renowned as one of the great mischief-makers of the nineties, Shawn Michaels must have butted heads with creative a million times, and given how fearful those heads were of losing him to WCW, he probably came out on top more often than not.
Most of this kind of stuff has been kept behind closed doors, but one of thing of which we're pretty sure is that the Heartbreak Kid's backstage antics put paid to Vader's chances of winning the WWE Championship at SummerSlam 1996.
HBK was said to have taken concerns about the former WCW star's stiff in-ring style to the creative team, effectively telling them that he wasn't happy about having to lose to such a careless opponent.
Unsurprisingly, it was Vince McMahon's favourite who won the ensuing stand-off. Michaels retained his belt at SummerSlam, and Vader - despite being a hugely over figure - goes down in history as one of the best wrestlers never to wear WWE's biggest prize.
4. Alundra Blayze
Like Bret Hart a couple of years later, Alundra Blayze was deemed surplus to requirements to the World Wrestling Federation in 1995, one of several victims of the company's renewed focus on pinching the pennies.
The only problem was that, at the time, she was still the reigning Women's Champion. And creative were therefore faced with the unenviable challenge of having to convince her to lose the title before her contract expired in December.
After failing to come to a compromise, Blayze rocked up on Nitro - reprising herr old ring-name of Madusa - with Vince McMahon's belt, throwing it into a trashcan live on air in one of the most infamous moments of the Monday Night Wars.
We're putting that one down as a massive win in her favour. How can it be anything else? She made an instant impact in her new stomping ground and made a complete mockery of her former employers all on the same night.
3. Steve Austin
Even Stone Cold Steve Austin, one of wrestling's most enduring heroes, didn't manage to retire without once or twice coming to blows with creative, the most famous example of which being his refusal to job to Brock Lesnar in 2002.
His reasons here weren't entirely selfish, in fairness. He wasn't so much disgusted by the idea of losing to a rookie as he was worried that giving away such a momentous result after just a couple of weeks of build would go down as a wasted opportunity.
In the end, Austin dug his heels so far into the ground that WWE heads had to scrap their plans altogether. He then left the company temporarily - but returned a short while later still able to command a headline spot at WrestleMania XIX.
In fact, they spent the next decade begging him to make cameo appearances on any pay-per-view held within a three-hundred mile radius of his Texas home. So much for putting the dissenting voices in their place.
2. Shawn Michaels (Again)
Another example of Shawn Michaels warring with his creative masters came during 1997, when the Heartbreak Kid was feuding with The British Bulldog over the European Championship.
According to legend, the original plan here was for Michaels to become a mega-heel after defeating his opponent at the UK-hosted One Night Only in September, with Bulldog then winning the belt back at another event across the pond a couple of months later.
But HBK had other ideas, apparently lobbying for the feud's outcome to be changed so that Bulldog wouldn't be given his chance at a rematch (and, fittingly, that he could effectively hand the belt, gift-wrapped, to best bud Triple H instead in December).
Vince McMahon's franchise player got such a taste for beating the hometown hero that he did it again just a couple of months later in Montreal, this time getting the better of Bret Hart for the WWF Title at Survivor Series. But that was only a minor match of minimal consequence.
1. Hulk Hogan (again)
Perhaps it's only right that Shawn Michaels, after pulling rank so many times over the course of his own career, should have been on the receiving end of a last-minute creative switcheroo himself.
This one came on the eve of SummerSlam 2005, where HBK took on Hulk Hogan in the long-awaited first-ever clash between the two wrestling legends. Hogan was always supposed to win, but the original idea was for there to be a rematch a couple of months later.
But that's where The Hulkster allegedly got into a little bit of a disagreement with creative. He didn't really fancy having a multi-match series, and asked them instead to make it a one and done type deal, with him going over and no rematch.
All of this would be completely unverifiable were it not for the fact that Michaels let the world know how irked he was by the whole affair by comically over-selling his opponent's every move when they got in the ring together. And, to be fair, it was completely hilarious.