10 Wrestlers Who Changed Their Perception In A Heartbeat

Holy molars.

Dr Britt Baker
AEW

It's most often a gradual process, changing one's opinion of a wrestler. There's rarely a flashbulb epiphany moment that jumps out at you mid-match.

"Jimminy jillickers, that's the 763rd time I've seen Dolph Ziggler do a superkick. Maybe I was never meant to watch a wrestler go over a decade working in the same company having undergone very little to no character development."

Dolph Ziggler appears to have lost his edge. Maybe there's something else to do on this planet.

*Rubs eyes, ventures outside to fly a kite as Beethoven's 6th, Pastoral plays in one's ears*

It's quite typical of WWE, to make you resent a very capable wrestler for making a living, and this change of perception, for better or worse, does usually happen there. Should they have the temerity to not want to risk their long-term financial security, a resentment creeps in; conversely, years and years of thankless graft is sometimes rewarded by a fanbase when a brush with opportunity helps illuminate how deserving a performer actually is of it - Becky Lynch in 2018, and Kofi Kingston in 2019, for example.

Sometimes, however, a moment of genius - or self-own most foul - can summon success or failure quicker than a Masato Yoshino rope-run...

10. Dr. Britt Baker (DMD)

Britt Baker Yuka Sakazaki
AEW

Before:

Pushed, promoted, presented, posed: Britt always felt so obviously like a plan in the early days of Dynamite, one hatched to charm a mainstream that never did end up watching. Britt Baker: Wrestling Dentist received polite reactions, but you could see the wires; the company very much wanted her to get over big, and with that came a steep expectation. AEW must see something in her, the fans reasoned, and were let down when they didn't. Baker's work wasn't dire, at all, to counter the narrative, but it wasn't major league quality.

In a heartbeat:

Baker turned heel on the Dynamite cruise in a promo loaded with hilarious deadpan disdain. She turned the dial up in subsequent weeks, in fabulous and very effective arrogant spiels. Elevated by her prodigious instincts to extract every morsel of a reaction with an improvised pause and frown, that Baker stood out on those spectacular pre-Revolution Dynamites underscored just what a talent she is. And then the bell rang...

...and she was awesome then, too, working so much tighter, and with a delight on her face at the sight of her own blood. It was permanent ink with which to paint something unforgettable. A wrestling dentist is in fact an incredible achievement, and this was brought into crystal focus when she was incredibly - wonderfully - pious about it.


9. Damien Sandow

Aron Rex
Impact Wrestling

Before:

A hugely entertaining performer with a rare ability to draw real heat, peak Damien Sandow was a great act. His face was sculpted to be punched, he cut a tremendous promo, and the intellectual gimmick, while a bit too cartoonish in presentation for the main event scene, was very effective; some of you morons feel personally attacked when confronted with a second syllable. Sandow wasn't a ring general, and probably wasn't true World Champion material, but, on the evidence of his stunt double schtick, he had range beyond his greatest hit.

Or did he?

In a heartbeat:

You'll have read Mark Twain's sage words "It is better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to talk and remove all doubt". Rather a lot of former WWE talents have created a spin on it: "It is better to remain silent and be thought under-utilised than to drop a rubbish Pipebomb and remove all doubt".

Aron Rex's TNA debut was a calamity. The smugness of it, Jesus Christ; what worked for heat as Damien Sandow did not work one f*ckin' iota for Rex Against The Machine. A smile that knowing and superior had to suggest an industry-breaking masterplan, but it was, with no substance "I can get over, I'll just do what I like!"


8. Sin Cara

Sin Cara
WWE.com

Before:

If you bought the hype without experiencing the performer, you were expecting the athletic evolution of Rey Mysterio. More rotations. Longer hang time. Higher leaping ability. The very name of Mistico summoned visions of an acrobat who could work a ***** match on a tightrope, the buzz was that deafening. Those who were aware of the performer knew Mistico had the ability to warrant the rep; he was a huge star in CMLL - a major drawing card and a spectacular attraction - and it seemed WWE had timed their recruitment of the next Rey Mysterio perfectly. Triple H was certainly confident, anyway, since he was very keen to parade the bag of magic beans he'd just purchased.

In a heartbeat:

The man could not jump on a trampoline for f*ck's sake lol. He was meant to clear these distances on his own in his capacity as a high-flying professional wrestler, and he couldn't pull off professionally what toddlers can do recreationally. He was cursed to drive on the wrong side of the road in total darkness, the poor prick, and the second he botched on his debut, the hype was revealed to be just that.


7. Braun Strowman

Braun Strowman Sami Zayn
WWE.com

Before:

Mason Ryan if his parents were related and banged in a swamp, Braun Strowman was yet another immobile lummox signed because Vince McMahon is, in fact, going to Vince. Strowman's early perception was shaped, unfairly, by Vince and his modern history of indulgent failure, and it wasn't helped by the idea that we were none the bloody wiser. As the Black Sheep of the Wyatt Family, Strowman, whose cherublic face made him look green on sight, barely moved, and since the Undertaker reportedly refused to work him, he drew another comparison of failure shorthand: Hade Vansen.

In a heartbeat:

James Ellsworth took a terrific, harrowing splat bump for Strowman, getting him over as a competent hoss, but it was Sami Zayn who extracted the potential from within him in a cracking mini-series that summoned the dynamic and explosive side of Strowman'a game. Their Last Man Standing match was a particular triumph; Strowman got himself over as relentless killer who as a more advanced athlete had no need to rely on a methodical, stalking gait - an awesome, propulsive performer with, for a brief time, an aura as a legit monster.


6. Edge

Edge Lita
WWE.com

Before:

A certain, intangible something lowered the ceiling on Edge. A superb wrestler with a great look - even a profound respect forged through those TLC wars - he never resonated as a true headliner despite being a tremendous all-rounder. Perhaps it was the babyface role - even stretching back all of those years, WWE's preferred, jovial verbiage was a ruthless shortcut to fans not taking a headline act seriously. This is a company that has spent much of its lifespan plagiarising itself, and still hasn't realised that Steve Austin was at his least over in 2001. Edge's 2004 heel turn helped, but the character and presentation felt somewhat derivative of his 2000 days.

In a heartbeat:

Edge clicked from upper midcard mainstay to headliner - as fast as sperm - with a cucking. By taking on real-life mistress Lita as manager in 2005, Edge rocketed to the main event as a top shagger - a truly reprehensible figure fans hated and, more significantly, were jealous of. Lita's thong was Phoebe Cates' red swimsuit to a generation of horned-up adolescent wrestling fans, and Edge seemed to grasp true, ticket-selling heat at last and with the most smug of sh*t-eating grins.


5. Hulk Hogan

Hulk Hogan BROTHER
WWE Network

Before:

Sure, he talked b*llocks, and yes, he was as carny as the scent of fried doughnuts, but he was your childhood hero. My childhood hero. He fought for the right of every man* in vibrant, loud, simple spectacles in which he glistened so spectacularly that he had to be done for. His plight looked dire. He was working himself to the bone to overcome the baddies out there, and when he shook his hair from side to side, and it looked like a golden retriever shaking itself dry, it were as if he genuinely needed your help to do it. He looked magnificent, his theme reduced us all to total lame-os by playing air guitar to it, and even his politics career was so audacious as to draw a begrudging respect.

In a heartbeat:

*About that...

If he was a carny, you had to be eight feet tall to go on his ride. The racism furore that struck Hogan in 2015 ruined his perception irrevocably - he literally admitted to being a racist on tape - because he never truly apologised for it. Contrary to that theme, he did take trouble for quite some time by instead blaming the evils of modern technology on his downfall, and not his own awful conduct.


4. Alex Riley

Alex Riley cage
Twitter, @KileyJrWWE

Before:

One of the more glaring wastes of talent, even in an era of landfill, Alex Riley was quite incredible on the second season of NXT. He exuded a ridiculous poise and charisma in an environment designed to humiliate the talent. So good was Riley in the role of the overbearing a*shole who simply wins at life, it felt like you were watching the first chapter of his three-disc DVD set. Even more impressively, Riley, a raw athlete with abundant potential, showed considerable range by getting over in the babyface role. He radiated a star quality. The man couldn't not be a star.

In a heartbeat:

Riley, pummelled by the WWE system and, allegedly, a John Cena sabotage campaign, sought to reinvent his career. He went real literal with it, using jail cell imagery to express his creative confinement, and since he was as proficient at Photoshop as his NXT colleagues were at cutting promos about moustaches, he made a bit of an e-fed ass of himself. It's the worst Photoshop of all time. It's so bad that it actively makes a case for scripted promos.

And when Kevin Owens carved up on Twitter, there was no coming back.


3. Drew McIntyre

Drew McIntyre Erick Rowan Spider
WWE.com

Before:

Drew McIntyre was always one of those theoretical WWE headliners that the company likes, aims to protect, and is capable, but, over time, the realisation hits that this talk stems more from backstage reports and our projections than onscreen evidence. After a run with Dolph Ziggler that fizzled out - it went a year and didn't erupt at WrestleMania, such is the way - Drew was a monster who brutalised Dean Ambrose out of the company one month, a sudden, was-this-always-a-thing lackey for Shane McMahon the next. His serious heel persona verged on the bland and almost the silly, what with his various synonyms for "beating up".

In a heartbeat:

After a mid run as a heel in late 2019, he turned babyface out of nowhere in December, at which point he was presumably encouraged to cut loose, because he was a revelation as an easygoing presence who had adapted his real, witty side on camera without - as yet - reciting sh*tty material. He lounged on the barricade, called himself sexy, and gently heckled the crowd, doing a sort of wrestling stand-up act that didn't, unlike Seth Rollins', make one want to gouge one's eyes out.

This one promo saw him demolish Suplex City in minutes.


2. Seth Rollins

seth rollins
WWE.com

Before:

People seemed to like the idea of Seth Rollins as 2019 Men's Royal Rumble winner more than they loved it. There was never a sense, unlike with a Steve Austin (1998) or a Daniel Bryan (2014), that it had to be him, nor of an Undertaker (2007), which while not life-affirming at least guaranteed something big time. It was process of elimination; it was as if WWE fans had settled for Seth, which later bred a resentment. Rollins wasn't vociferously rejected as the tippy-top guy - his defence against AJ Styles tore the house down, and most reasonable people knew that the Baron Corbin feud was not his fault - but he wasn't on fire, either. He was boring and a tad unlikeable in his Mandated WWE Babyface Promos. Perhaps because...

In a heartbeat:

Rollins absolutely lost it on Stomping Grounds Eve, at which point, in defiant response to the apathetic response to his own hard work and the scorn WWE had invited with its Wild Card bullsh*t, he proclaimed WWE to be the "best pro wrestling on the planet, period". A heartbeat is literal in this case; he pressed send tweet and turned heel, as a whining bubble boy with a d*ck-headed penchant for flexing his bank bank balance and a beyond deluded claim to being the best wrestler in the world. He wasn't. WWE wasn't. But people knew this and hardly blamed the guy before he begged for it.


1. Tensai

lord tensai
WWE.com

Before:

Albert or whatever he went by was always a big unit who never grasped the performance element of wrestling - the "goddamn gaga" as Jim Cornette would put it. He grunted a lot, and was a convincing brawler when paired with the right (Chris Benoit) or most inexplicable (Kane) opponent, but he was never particularly charismatic, nor was he a great talker, and so he never made it in WWE under its preferred expositional soap opera format. He reinvented himself in Japan as as no-nonsense throwback monster and thrived, before the in-ring standard went positively apesh*t, as a spectacle who could go in singles but especially tags. Aura built and buzz generated, he ventured back to WWE, and...

In a heartbeat:

Maybe Hiroshi Tanahashi is just really, really good.

Lord Tensai was such an on-the-nose gimmick - did you know that spending some time professionally Japan will turn you into the most ancient Japanese man imaginable? - and it failed because everybody knew it was Albert, and expressed as much with that obnoxious drone-chant. They limited what Bernard did - he only mildly roughed people up, and did not f*ck them up - and he was basically just Albert in a goofy costume straight out of 1995 WCW.


In this post: 
Britt Baker
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!