10 Wrestlers Who Couldn't Do Their Own Moves

The best spear in wrestling is contended. The worst is not.

Edge Spear
WWE.com

The "this ain't ballet, pal" about wrestling is meant to empathise it's toughness and whilst it can absolutely be a physically demanding and dangerous practice, that isn't entirely true. At it's best, wrestling has a a lot in common with dance. On a surface level, it's about crafting something that looks pleasing to the viewer.

Of course, it's very easy to criticise wrestlers from the comfort of one's desk. It should be said that not only are the men and women on this list better at fake fighting than your Average Joe, they could probably beat you in a real fight and turn you into a puddle formerly known as an Average Joe.

Still, when you consume hours upon hours of wrestling content it's hard not to assume your own tastes and opinions. Every fan will have their own take on who was so good at a certain move that they come to mind immediately when they hear it, and just as likely they'll have thoughts who were the worst at such a technique.

Thank goodness that the following wrestlers, for the most part, had more going for them than just a single move but these are examples of when they just failed to make it look good.

10. The Rock's Sharpshooter

The Rock, Sharpshooter
WWE.com

The Sharpshooter is a move most associate with Bret Hart, despite the fact that it originated in Japan under a name that translates to basically "scorpion hold". This is why it became the Scorpion Death Lock whenever Sting applied it. Hart, the master of the move, was asked in 2021 by Fightful's Sean Ross Sapp about his colleagues who tried to apply it and he was quick to point out that The Rock had always had trouble putting it on.

Looking at Hart's take on the move, it's clear to see why it's beloved. The Hitman makes the crossing over of his and his opponent's legs, as well as his subtle hand placement, look easy. He pulls at his opponent to turn them over, demonstrating their weight and pushes in deep to apply pressure.

This is what submissions moves are about, after all: pressure and control.

The Rock had very little of either when he began applying the Sharpshooter onwards from 2000. Often crossing legs over the wrong way and looking as weak as pond water, the Rock's Sharpshooter has been chastised by both fans and wrestlers themselves.

Still, the Rock got it over because it was the Attitude Era and at this point he could almost do no wrong.


9. CM Punk's Elbow Drop

CM Punk Elbow
WWE.com

Whilst there may or may not be legitimate heat between CM Punk and KENTA over the former's usage of the Go to Sleep, it's hardly the only move in the Second City Saint's repertoire that he's adopted from another. Occasionally, Punk will take to the top rope, point to the sky and drop an elbow like Macho did back in his prime.

Although perhaps not exactly like Macho did.

Not only was Savage capable of getting some impressive air, he was able to lean into the blow mid-flight. Macho was a marksman with the elbow, always leading it to it's mark and making it look devastating. With Punk, he often falls in a bit of a heap. Yes, the elbow is extended but it's not the singular point of impact.

CM Punk made fun of this himself in a 2020 tweet when the WWE on Fox Twitter account put him amongst Randy Savage, Shawn Michaels and Kairi Sane as the best elbow drops in the biz', saying "this isn't a list I should be on".

So at least he has good humour about it. After all, to him it's likely a fun tribute and not there to be overly critiqued anyway.


8. The Miz's Figure Four Leg Lock

Miz Figure Four Leglock
WWE.com

There are some stars that are just born to be heels. Not that The Miz isn't funny and charming when he wants to be but there's just something so delightfully punchable about his on-screen persona.

Ergo, he needs all the help he can get during his rare babyface runs. In 2012, WWE paired him with the legendary Ric Flair in a forgettable "mentor and student" story. In this time, Flair bequeathed his most deadly move to the A-Lister.

And whilst Miz doesn't lock the Figure Four Leglock in quite as impressively as Flair did, where it really falls down is an overall performance issue. Miz doesn't use it to tell a story, he skips right to the end.

Be it of his own volition or the time he's given in-ring, Miz never really bothers to work his opponent's leg during any given match. He never has and he likely never will. As such, this already vapid hand-me-down of a move is less impactful as the prior punishment that makes it effective is missing.

More than this, Flair would spend minutes applying the lock, steadily becoming more intense to amp up the atmosphere. It's what made it so memorable. When Miz applies the Figure Four, he's heaving and grimacing that punchable face before he's even hit the mat.


7. Charlotte Flair's Moonsault

Charlotte Flair Moonsault
WWE.com

Being able to flip your entire body over in the middle of the air is insanely impressive. It's a skill that requires a bit of rewiring of your instincts that tell you that your feet should stay on your ground and by no means should your head ever be below them. The Moonsault is perhaps even worse, since the move is done backwards, facing away from your landing spot.

That being said, just because you're able to flip doesn't mean you've mastered a move.

As Charlotte Flair demonstrates on a frequent basis, timing your rotation is imperative, as is making sure you stick the landing. It probably doesn't help either that she's very tall and even more so that she has a history of cheerleading, so it's in her nature to land on her feet. As it is, most of her Moonsault landings are rough at best as she flips too soon and lands on her ankles rather than pressing her opponent flat.

On the other hand, Moonsaulting to the outside means she at least has to land on her feet which she does almost every time. Shame then that her standing Moonsault always miss her opponents by so much that she may as well have jumped off the turnbuckle and landed in a different area code.


6. Shane McMahon's Punches

Shane McMahon The Miz
WWE.com

Shane McMahon is about the furthest you can get from technical wrestling. Even in his younger years, jumping into his Dad's ring to play alongside all those pro athletes, nobody ever pretended that he was more than a glorified stuntman.

And he was great at this, so it distracted crowds for some time from his God awful fundamentals. Since his return in 2016 though, McMahon has been the subject of mockery for what are surely the world's worst worked punches.

No wonder he's not much of a wrestler if he can't even make a punch look good. As a passionate fan of MMA, and trained in Muay Thai and Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu, Shane leans too far into wanting to look "realistic". His swift and incredibly short movements are all clearly inspired by boxing jabs. However, this is just not how things are done in wrestling.

Full arm extension and thrust are the name of the game, and Shane displays neither.

It's hard enough to take the boss' jumpy upstart son seriously as a legitimate fighter in his own right but it's the seriousness with which Shane seems to present himself. He probably whispers sweet-nothings to that "Best Wrestler in the World" trophy every night.


5. John Cena's STF

Cena STF
WWE

In a 2020 episode of WWE's Untold series, Edge recalled his match with Cena at Unforgiven 2006 and tells the story of how Big Match John accidentally choked him until he passed out via a nasty combination of STF and ladder.

Though he laughs it off in a way that pro wrestlers do, since it's just a part of their job, it's a harrowing visual and thought. Clearly, it had an effect on Cena because ever since that moment his submission hold has gone from being genuinely dangerous to looking absolutely ludicrous.

To be fair, that is a pretty good reason to adapt a move but there has to be a happy medium.

To give it it's full name is to describe it perfectly: "the stepover toehold face-lock". Edgy fans of WWE's Ruthless Aggression days might lament that the name of Cena's move went from STFU back to the simple STF when the PG era rolled around, but in truth it's been more of an ST this whole time.

When Cena cinches it in, there's no face-lock. Instead of grabbing his opponent by the chin, he instead cross-faces them. Not only does this mean Cena isn't putting pressure on his victim's spine, which is the point of the full-body hold, but it's clear to anyone watching that escaping it would need little more than a duck of the head.


4. John Cena's Springboard Stunner

John Cena Stunner
WWE.com

John Cena was a fantastic figurehead for WWE's promotional appeal. In the ring, his character is a great role model. Outside of wrestling, he's a promising actor and an honourable humanitarian. It's a shame that his actual wrestling has always been so limited because everywhere else he succeeds.

And whilst Cena is known for, and has largely got by on, his five moves of doom, he occasionally adds a sixth.

Cena's victory over Rusev at WrestleMania 31 is a sour taste many WWE fans remember, but there was something else that night that caught everyone off guard. In a show of otherwise rarely seen creativity, Cena hit his first "springboard stunner" by running into the ropes, bouncing off of them and taking his opponent down with a cutter.

On first viewing, it's kind of cool because it is so surprising. But even occasionally when it didn't look bad, it still never looked great. The momentum of Cena running one way and then suddenly moving towards his opponent backwards made for an awkward sell. And, most of the time, Cena could never get his hands around his dance partner's head precisely.

Cena used the springboard stunner for all of about six months in 2015, in a period that is fondly remembered as some of his best ring-work, despite a new move that commentary consistently had to remark as one he never "got all of".


3. Eva Marie's Sliced Red

Eva Marie
WWE

Marie’s move-set rarely got more complex than running sentons and back elbows. However, in 2015, All Red Everything returned to the company after a hiatus with a surprising new move passed onto her by her trainer Brian Kendrick.

Sliced Bread #2 demonstrated the beauty of fluid wrestling drilled down to one perfect second. Kendrick would run almost vertically up the turnbuckles with his opponent in tow, rotating over them and forcing them onto their back. It was a move that exemplified the cruiserweight’s agility and finesse.

Now, credit where credit is due, it’s not an easy move to pull off because in order to look good it requires a lot of confidence and careful footwork. These are things Marie rarely managed to demonstrate as it felt like WWE were always shoving her onto TV well before she was ready. So, this is very much a case of running - up the ropes in fact - before you can really walk.

Marie's Sliced Red had all the flat-footedness of a baby deer and looked like someone climbing a particularly imposing staircase in roller skates. It was clear that her opponents were doing most of the work to make sure everyone got out of it safely.

It’s probably not surprising that her next gimmick had her finding excuses to wrestle at all, and we were all the better for it.


2. Billy Kidman's Shooting Star Press

Billy Kidman Shooting Star Press
WWE.com

The Shooting Star Press might be one of wrestling's most beautiful moves. The end-over-end rotating flip from the top rope requires grace and precision to hit perfectly.

On the one hand, there are those that believe that Billy Kidman was one of the most entertaining acts of his time. He was also one of the first men to bust out a Shooting Star Press on TV, instantly creating conversation amongst fans.

And sometimes it looked incredible! But only sometimes. Quite a lot of the time, it looked like Kidman had beef with gravity. He barely got any air, his rotations were late and his landings were sloppy. If you can't pull off a move time-after-time and make it look picture-perfect, especially in Vince McMahon's clinical sports entertainment world, then you should perhaps reconsider it - doubly so if it has the potential to be dangerous.

Unlike other entries in this list, Kidman "couldn't do" his move for more reasons beyond his own inconsistency.

In an August 2004 episode of SmackDown, Kidman hit one of his worst attempts at the Shooting Star Press on Chavo Guerrero, landing wrong and with some serious velocity. This drove his knee into Chavo's head, legitimately concussing his opponent. As such, the SSP was blacklisted at the company, meaning that both Kidman and his tag partner Paul London had to find new signature moves.


1. Edge's Spear

Edge Spear
WWE.com

It's the job of wrestling announce teams as much as the in-ring workers themselves to sell. Commentators will tell you how impactful something is supposed to be with how they react to it. But without any distractions, and with the right comparisons, it's fair to say that Edge's finisher is not as powerful as Michael Cole's frenzied call of "spear!" implies.

The Spear has been a signature move for a great number of major stars - Roman Reigns and Goldberg among them - in part because it's a simple and understandable technique. The attacker throws their entire weight into an airborne tackle, taking their opponent down to the mat, and perhaps most importantly knocking the wind out of them by burying their shoulder into their enemy's gut.

Except Edge doesn't do this, and never really has. He wraps his opponent in an embrace, pushing the flat of his bicep into them.

Despite being part of some of the company's most rewatched moments, Edge's Spear has always more resembled a Running Hug when properly scrutinised. This was exemplified the most during his runs where he assembled a three-man team alongside Rhyno.

Rhyno's Spear might've gotten a unique title inspired by his namesake, but it deserved it's own moniker because just how deadly it looked. It didn't even need Joey Style losing his mind chanting "GORE GORE GORE" on commentary... although, let's face it, it didn't hurt either.


Watch Next


Contributor

Coming from a content creation background that now spans over two decades, Psy cut her teeth on personal video production and community radio. Originally joining the team as a writer and presenter, she added video editing duties to her responsibilities over time and became the longest-standing editor of the irreverent gaming show Tues Your Own Adventure. Psy has worked on many previews and reviews, long-form editorials (either her own, or supporting as an editor), as a frequent quizmaster and more. Praised for the two-pronged attack of her hard work ethic and light-hearted editing style, Psy is otherwise known as a font of retro video game knowledge which has caused her to rack up many gaming quiz wins. Outside of WhatCulture, Psy runs First Aid Spray Podcast - a long-running channel that focuses on Resident Evil in all of it's forms. You can follow her on BlueSky at http://psywhite.bsky.social and Instagram at http://instagram.com/therealpsywhite