10 Wrestlers Who Couldn’t Hide Their Anger At Bad Creative

When you either have to laugh or cry: featuring Drew McIntyre, Jon Moxley and more...

Drew Oasis Thumb II
WWE

It’s genuinely miraculous that this list is limited to just 10 entries. 

Across much of pro wrestling history - particularly the 1990s and 2000s, when puerile gimmickry ruled the world before a thoroughly past-it Vince McMahon monopolised it - garbage is strewn. Wrestling was very, very awful for a very, very long time. It’s easy to lose perspective on AEW, now that it’s ice-cold and Tony Khan scores baffling own goals creatively, but fans should be grateful. Remember watching the Guest Host Era and TNA at the same time? 

The worst of pro wrestling would easily warrant the word count of David Foster Wallace’s borderline impenetrable ‘Infinite Jest’, and Vince Russo’s writing makes that novel read as easily as popular children’s title ‘Guess How Much I Love You’.

Vince McMahon, meanwhile, played a game called ‘Guess How Much I Hate You’ with his audience and talent on a nigh-on weekly basis. The answer was “a great deal”, as he imposed his antagonistic and embarrassing creative on everybody. 

Somehow, despite it all - the Bobby’s Sisters segment, The Revival rubbing their red-raw asses on the ring canvas, the Last Rites match - the vast majority of  underpaid and overworked pro wrestlers adopted a quite remarkable sense of professionalism and simply got on with the job.

Mostly…

10. Drew McIntyre Sings When He's Losing

Drew Oasis Thumb
WWE

At Clash At The Castle 2022, Drew McIntyre lost to Roman Reigns. That day was going to be the day, but they never actually strapped up Drew. 

Drew might have thought, what with the show emanating two countries away from his birthplace, that WWE would put the belt on him. They did not. The main event, opposite Roman Reigns, was spellbinding, furnace-hot, trademark WWE Big Match Drama. It wasn’t ambitious or distinct in any way, and hardly faster than a cannonball, but they pefected the methodical playbook. Then, at the finish, as part of another Masterplan on the part of the Bloodline, a debuting Solo Sikoa removed the referee from the ring, leading to the distraction. Some Might Say that interference should have triggered a disqualification, but Whatever. 

In the post-match, bizarrely, Drew was cast as a Rock N’ Roll Star when he was scripted to perform karaoke with Tyson Fury. What did Drew have to smile about? 

He went All Around The World just to look like a balloon knot. 

A clearly gutted Drew sang ‘American Pie’ by Don McLean and ‘Don’t Look Back In Anger’ by Oasis, and later confirmed to Cultaholic that he wasn’t happy about getting screwed and singing “that stupid song” afterwards.   

It was quite obvious at the time. The awful idea made him look like he’d won a competition to appear at the show as a guest.

A glum competition winner who’d just been made to listen to ‘Be Here Now’. 


9. Paige’s One WWE Regret

Paige Line
WWE

Paige, when making an appearance at Starrcast V, was probed about the most controversial chapter of her WWE career. She said it was the one moment of her run that she regrets. 

At Survivor Series 2015, she was set to face Charlotte Flair for the Divas title, before which she participated in the mandatory contract signing on Monday Night Raw. Nobody remembers a single thing about it other than that line. 

That line was a reference to Charlotte’s brother Reid, who had tragically passed away, aged just 25, in 2013. Charlotte vowed to “fight every single day” just like her family always had. In response, Paige was scripted to say “Your little baby brother…he didn’t have much fight in him, did he?”

This was unconscionable. Wrestling has an awful history with cheap heat, and this was one of the most offensive examples of it - especially since Ric wasn’t prepared to hear it beforehand. 

Paige hardly performed the line with the cackling malice intended, for which she absolutely cannot be blamed. She could barely bring herself to say it, and you can even see her expression twist into an appalled apprehension as Charlotte tees it up. 

She knew it was deplorable. 


8. Ricky Starks Is Bewildered

Ricky Starks Big Bill
AEW

Fightful Select recently reported that Ricky Starks was said to have not been particularly happy about his creative direction in 2023. He initially didn’t fancy teaming with Big Bill, and was dismayed that his momentum slowed to a crawl after his well-received programme with CM Punk and classic war opposite Bryan Danielson at All Out.

This was actually evident on television. 

On the November 25 edition of Collision, Starks and Big Bill cut a promo in which, after attacking Kenny Omega and Chris Jericho, they were asked to explain their actions. 

Starks initially stumbled over his words, and then, when handing over the promo to his partner, said that he barely knows him. “He doesn’t even know my birthday!” 

Starks then asked Bill when it was. “No idea,” Bill deadpanned. 

This was a mildly amusing line, but there was a weird casual element to the promo overall - like Starks was above it all, almost. This trend continued during the infamous debacle that was a duelling promo with the ‘Golden Jets’ at Winter Is Coming 2023.

Forcibly removed from the rails by Omega’s undiagnosed bout of diverticulitis and Jericho’s excruciating comedy stylings, Starks didn’t exactly help. 

Either he was very good at acting, or he seemed genuinely nonplussed at the prospect of working with Chris Jericho for a second time that year. He actually forgot that he defeated him at Revolution.

Jericho suggested that his opponents name their team “Big Billie Starks”. It was a terrible line. If it was indeed a reference, it flew over everybody’s head. 

A soul-destroyed Starks said, curtly, “Well, that one fell flat”. 


7. Alexa Bliss Tries Her Best

Alexa Bliss This Is Your Life
WWE

In the worst feud of 2017, Bayley as a babyface died a death. 

There exists such a thing as “sister emotions”. No, not Shane McMahon marvelling at his sister’s “cute puppies”, as he did in a 1999 interview with Michael Landsberg - but emotions that are close to others. Sarcasm is a relative of and often precedes anger. It’s usually what you feel before entering a melt-down. Anger also manifests as embarrassment - and Alexa Bliss looked very embarrassed when she had to perform ‘This Is Your Life’ in May 2017. 

In the segment, Alexa claimed that Bayley still plays with dolls and once won an award for sportsmanship. The segment was legendarily awful. When the crowd weren’t shouting “What?”, you could audibly hear them groan. When Alexa pressed Bayley’s old teacher - who claimed that her father had to sit in class with her to prevent her from crying - she stumbled over her words. Knowing how badly it was going and how much worse it was going to get, Alexa could only babble nervously. In a bizarre running joke, Bayley’s father also escorted her on dates with her high school boyfriend.

Bayley, who hardly looked happy herself, eventually tried to bring the segment to an end. She got her ass kicked lol. 

It is segments like this that make Paul Levesque look like Mark Twain in comparison. 


6. Jon Moxley Likes To Be Taken Seriously

Jon Moxley Smart Mark Sterling
AEW

Jon Moxley likes to be taken very seriously. This is both good and bad. 

He has the balls to back himself and, in winning rather a lot - if not almost constantly - he has remained a threat throughout a very long AEW run. This is good. You can’t be Chris Jericho, and lose more often than you win. 

Conversely…

AEW wrestlers come and come and come and come and come, and very rarely go, and yet Mox always gets a feature match on pay-per-view. He often wins even if it makes less than zero sense in the narrative. At Revolution, he teamed with Claudio Castgnoli to defeat FTR. The losing team ended up in the World Tag Team title tournament; Mox never once expressed an interest in going for the belts. 

Mox - perhaps haunted by his WWE run - likes to be taken seriously to an extent that it can sometimes border on the unprofessional. 

He “wrestled” MJF’s onscreen lawyer Smart Mark Sterling on the All Out 2020 go-home Dynamite. Now, it was a bad comedy match, and a frivolous means of promoting what ostensibly was a serious pay-per-view main event. The idea behind it was an exercise in contrasts. MJF bloodied Mox in the post-match. It was meant to be the moment in which Mox realised that, away from the gaga and theatrics, MJF was a man to be feared. 

Only, Mox never realised this: he outright said, before the finish of the match, “This is terrible television”.


5. Drew McIntyre Also Hated The Rematches

Drew McIntyre Big E
WWE.com

Back in late 2021, a lot of wrestlers seemed to give up. They didn’t stop going for it in the ring; if anything, the subject of this entry over-compensated for his terrible and meaningless creative direction by going to war and marking his body red so that he had something, anything to show for it. 

A culture emerged, however, in which WWE wrestlers seemed to stop caring about repercussions. The old “walking on eggshells” culture no longer existed; virtually everybody of renown publicly buried the Survivor Series concept. Drew McIntyre meanwhile, before he turned it into a career-making gimmick, took to trolling on social media. 

Back in October 2021, WWE plotted a novel story in which the question was asked: can Big E and Drew McIntyre co-exist ahead of their upcoming match? 

On both October 4 and October 18, the rivals teamed up against Bobby Roode and Dolph Ziggler. It wouldn’t be remotely surprising, if it was revealed that Vince McMahon simply forgot about the first encounter. Not that you cared at the time, much less three years later, but Big E and Drew could in fact co-exist. They simply won both matches. 

Rest assured, Drew registered his disgust throughout the world, tweeting “Well I am a sucker for first-time matches”.  


4. Jon Moxley Wants Out

Chronicle Dean Ambrose II
WWE

Just after debuting for All Elite Wrestling, Jon Moxley unleashed his frustrations with the WWE creative process on Talk Is Jericho. 

‘The Emancipation of Jon Moxley’ was one of the most infamous podcasts in the short history of the medium. It was the Frye/Takayama of audio: Mox, not one to speak candidly or much at all, unleashed an unexpected barrage of pure verbal violence. He had to get all of it - the toxic atmosphere, the humiliating creative, the instruction to mock Roman Reigns when his close friend faced another battle with leukaemia - out of his system. 

He was frustrated, to a profound extent, and this was actually apparent before Jericho pressed record. On an episode of ‘Chronicle’, as Dean Ambrose - or Jonathan Good, frankly - Mox, in a low mood throughout, couldn’t hide his anger at the way in which his grand return had been handled. 

It was thick with subtext. In the opening scenes, spliced between training footage, Mox opined “I just want to grapple”. 

He didn’t say - but might as well have - “...not the dumb crap they make me do”.

Performing in pseudo-kayfabe, towards the end of the documentary, Mox almost completely dropped the facade, saying - and how ironic this would become - “I’m not going to read some script and play out some happy little fantasy”.


3. Becky Lynch Is SEETHING

Becky Lynch Charlotte Flair
WWE

Nothing meant anything towards the end of Vince McMahon’s run as booker. 

The belt swap angle was emblematic of this, but then again, so was everything. The idea that a champion would have to drop their belt because the colour of the strap did not match the branding of the television show was just atrocious. The synthetic corporate fakeness meant more than the concept of achievement. 

Becky Lynch was an outspoken critic of WWE before Paul Levesque took over - she was baffled by the Survivor Series brand warfare concept in particular - and was clearly irked at the idea of being made to participate in such an angle. She was already down on the idea, as expressed with a facial expression loaded with sarcasm. Then, frustration mutated into anger when Charlotte Flair - with whom Lynch wasn’t on the best terms - decided to be very awkward.  

Lynch, as revealed on an episode of Broken Skull Sessions with Steve Austin, was meant to grab Flair’s belt and “be Becky Two Belts” again for a moment, after which she was meant to duck out of a fight against Charlotte. 

Instead, and this was actually quite funny, Flair, much like a small child entering the terrible twos phase, tested the boundaries and dropped the belt. Becky threw the other belt at Flair. 

A fight almost broke out backstage after this intensely awkward scene. The characters in this era of WWE were so childish that they almost literally cried over spilt milk.


2. Big E SHOOTS HARD!!

Big E
WWE.com

Now, Big E is a remarkable human being. 

Almost supernaturally positive, he was instrumental in making the New Day work within what was at the time an omni-broken WWE system. It was very much a group effort, but after the group almost immediately pivoted to a babyface role to lean in on the fact that fans hated them, Big E’s enthusiasm was so radiant that they pivoted again almost as quickly. Big E was an explosive powerhouse built in the WWE mould, and just had a way of firing you up. Really, that WWE took as long as they did to strap him up with the WWE Championship was promotional malpractice.

At one point, though, Big E felt the same strain of WWE’s awfulness, just like everybody else did. When he was made to recite the line “We’re going to take the shine off the Shining Stars”, he very quickly apologised by hurriedly saying “I didn’t write that” before hitting the New Day’s catchphrase. 

“Anger,” thus, is the wrong word - but this is the closest the man has ever come to a feeling that merely orbited the idea of dissatisfaction. 

Can you imagine being that writer? The one person to have very mildly annoyed Big E? 

That’s almost as difficult to do as Tony Khan getting through a sentence without saying the word “great”. 


1. Steve Austin Goes OFF

Steve Austin WWE 2004
WWE

Steve Austin was the biggest drawing card in the history of pro wrestling in the United States. Hulk Hogan enjoyed more years on top, but in 1998, Austin drew more for a shorter period of time. 

In 1999, his star power was so incandescent that he was almost tested with wretched creative - he sympathised with Vince McMahon’s daughter and made up with Vince himself as he navigated the dismal Corporate Ministry saga - and still drew the highest ratings in the history of WWE’s flagship programme. 

He spent much of 2000 injured, and returned to a different promotion, almost. It’s strange that 2002 is known as the launch of the ‘Ruthless Aggression’ era. That year is more Attitude Era “coded” than 2000. Some awful stuff happened in 2000, to be absolutely clear, but compared to 1998, the year was irreverent, genuinely quite funny and, with the addition of Mick Foley as Commissioner, even somewhat wholesome. 

Austin returned as a dour guy so hellbent on revenge that he’d kick anybody’s ass, whether they were a credible suspect in the hit-and-run or otherwise. He interfered with the new wavelength - the WWF didn’t just turn him at WrestleMania X-Seven in some for-the-sake-of-it Vince Russo twist - but the fans quickly gained perspective. 

Austin was destroyed as a megastar in 2001. That’s when the Russo analogy becomes apt. He turned often enough to make the Big Show look like Ricky Steamboat, and when things got no better after the Invasion was put out of its misery, Austin, on the Byte This web show, went off.

“The writing’s pretty sh*tty. I don’t know if anything is gonna change with the creative bastards, but something better and damn fast”. 

All of those critics you think are “biased” against WWE: Austin 3:16 says he buried them first.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!