10 Wrestlers Who Killed Their Own Push

The higher the pedestal, the greater the fall.

Mr. KENNEDY
WWE.com

Success doesn't always come easy in professional wrestling. While the likes of Kurt Angle and Brock Lesnar seemed pre-ordained to make it in the business, reaching the top usually requires years of struggle and sacrifice. Getting there is only half the battle, however, as pushes can be handed out or taken away in an instant - and if a wrestler can't stay in management's good graces, they'll soon be replaced.

This isn't always the performer's fault, and it often seems like wrestlers are pushed and de-pushed on a whim, without rhyme or reason. Wrestling is a high-turnover sport, and personal mistakes are fatal. A single misstep can send a would-be megastar tumbling down the ladder, and wrestling history is littered with stories of those who've had their push nuked after betraying their employer's trust.

Wrestlers are just as error-prone as anybody else, and the cost of letting your company down is far greater when you live in the public eye, as the performers within know all too well.

From Wellness Policy busts to social media missteps, here are the wrestlers who shot themselves in the foot at the worst possible time...

10. R-Truth

R Truth The Miz Awesome Truth
WWE.com

The idea of R-Truth as a pushed wrestler might seem ridiculous today, but he almost broke out in 2011.

Truth went from working forgettable C-show matches to headlining Capitol Punishment with John Cena, and it all kicked off with an April heel turn. Truth went nuts after losing a number one contender’s bout to John Morrison by destroying his supposed friend before adopting the crazed villain persona that saw him leap up the card.

Truth couldn’t beat Cena for the WWE Championship, but he remained prominent afterwards. He and The Miz formed The Awesome Truth, and soon became one of WWE’s biggest heel forces. The headlined Survivor Series against The Rock and Cena, but Miz turned on Truth in the aftermath, with the reason soon becoming clear.

It was announced after the event that Truth had violated the company Wellness Policy. He was suspended for 30 days, and while this was his first transgression, it killed his push. Truth turned face after returning and formed a hastily thrown-together tag team with Kofi Kingston.

This ultimately went nowhere, and his slide down the ladder continued to where he is today.


9. Mabel

Mabel, King Mabel, Viscera, King of the Ring
WWE.com

Pushing Mabel was one of biggest mistakes WWE made during a difficult 1995.

Shawn Michaels’ face turn had left the main event scene under-stocked with heels, so Vince McMahon chose to try and make a star of Men On A Mission's largest member. This led to a monstrous push for the near-500lber, and Mabel was crowned King Of The Ring that June, much to the audience’s shock (and boredom).

The push lasted just a few months. Mabel was quickly dropped from the top of the card, and while the reason for his sudden removal was never officially explained, a number of his colleagues have attributed it to his wrestling style. Kevin Nash was particularly critical of him, stating that the big man had injured “six or seven” of his colleagues in the ring, including The Undertaker, who broke his orbital bone after taking a botched leg drop from Mabel.

In fairness, Mabel’s recklessness only hastened the inevitable. The crowd didn’t take to him as a main event heel, and his WWE Championship match with Diesel at SummerSlam ‘95 is widely regarded as one of the worst PPV main events in WWE history.

Still, his decline may not have been so steep, if not for his in-ring mistakes.


8. Chris Masters

Chris Masters
WWE.com

Aesthetics have always played a role in determining a WWE superstar’s success.

It’s not as important as it used to be, but having a great look is often the difference between a wrestler languishing in the midcard or flourishing in the main event. It’s therefore no surprise that Chris Masters, who looked like he’d been chiselled from the finest Greek marble, enjoyed a sizeable push upon debuting.

The Master Lock Challenge became a regular fixture on Raw, with Masters challenging a series of wrestlers to test themselves against his seemingly unbreakable Full Nelson hold. He worked with some of WWE’s biggest stars during this time, including Kurt Angle, Shawn Michaels, and John Cena, before personal problems strangled the life out of his career.

Masters left for several months to attend drug rehabilitation following a painkiller addiction in May 2006. He returned as a lower-card wrestler that summer, but brought the Master Lock Challenge back, with Cena becoming the first man to break the hold in December.

Chris slid down the card thereafter, never truly returning to his pre-rehab position, and was eventually let go following two Substance Abuse & Drug Policy violations in November 2007.


7. Rusev & Lana

rusev lana
WWE.com

Rusev and Lana have incurred plenty of misfortune throughout their WWE run. They found initial success as a pro-Russia, anti-USA heel act, with Rusev picking-up the United States Championship, and establishing himself as a monster heel. That came to an end through his feud with (and subsequent burial to) John Cena, and the duo split shortly after.

The couple decided to make their real-life engagement public on social media. This supposedly didn’t sit well with management, as Lana’s onscreen character had just left Rusev for Dolph Ziggler, while Summer Rae had proposed to ‘The Bulgarian Brute.’ Both performers saw their status dwindle in the aftermath, with Rusev’s push greatly diminished, and Lana publicly shamed by The Rock on an episode of Raw.

Lana was reportedly being considered for the Raw General Manager’s role at the time, but this was shelved. Nobody knows for sure that these punishments came as a result of Rusev & Lana’s actions, but they were too close together to be pure coincidence.

The duo have since reconciled, and their relationship has made it onto television, but neither has been pushed to the same extent since.


6. Evan Bourne

Evan Bourne Shooting Star Press
WWE.com

A dizzying high-flyer with a penchant for the spectacular, Evan Bourne got himself over with the WWE faithful through his flashy wrestling style.

He debuted as part of ECW’s New Talent Initiative in 2008 and challenged for the brand’s Championship that October, but dislocated his elbow while wrestling Matt Hardy, ruling him out for five months.

Bourne returned, and although he was never pushed as anything more than a midcard attraction, he at least had a consistent role on the card. 2011 saw him win his first piece of WWE gold when he and Kofi Kingston became WWE Tag Team Champions. They defended the belts throughout summer and autumn, but problems would soon arise, and Evan was handed a 30-day suspension for violating the Wellness Policy that November.

He and Kingston were still Tag Champions, but they lost the belt shortly after Evan’s return. They received their final rematch in January 2012, and but were unsuccessful, and Bourne incurred his second Wellness Policy suspension afterwards. Bourne broke his foot while suspended and he never reappeared on television.

He sat out the remainder of his contract after initially returning to the ring at a March 2013 live event, with his Wellness troubles the likely cause.


5. Triple H

Shawn Michaels Triple H Curtain Call
WWE

Kayfabe is well and truly dead in 2017, but that wasn’t necessarily the case in 1996. Vince McMahon had blown it apart by admitting wrestling was fake a few years prior, but “protecting the business” remained a priority onscreen and throughout locker-rooms around the world, and particularly among those of an old-school mentality.

Unfortunately for himself, Triple H was at the heart of one of WWE’s most notorious kayfabe-breaking incidents that year, when, along with fellow Kliq members Scott Hall, Kevin Nash, and Shawn Michaels, ‘The Game’ took part in the infamous Curtain Call incident at a Madison Square Garden house show. The group hugged and embraced each other as an “farewell” to Hall and Nash, who were set to leave for WCW, and management were enraged.

Faces and heels just couldn’t be seen fraternising in such a way, but Hall and Nash were departing, and Michaels was WWE’s top star. This meant that the punishment fell solely on Triple H, who went from championship contender to borderline enhancement talent in just a few weeks. He’d eventually become one of the biggest stars of his generation, of course, but Hunter suffered in the immediate aftermath.

He took full acceptance of his punishment, and was crowned Intercontinental Champion five months later.


4. Mr. Kennedy

Randy Orton Kennedy
WWE

It looked like Mr. Kennedy was on course to become WWE’s next big heel at one point.

The brash grappler had gotten over with his bold personality, booming voice, and trademark ring entrance, and the company were set to mint him in 2007. Kennedy was to be revealed as Mr. McMahon’s illegitimate son, and an apparent heir to his kingdom, resulting in a major push that would see him win the WWE Championship in early 2008, then wrestle Triple H at WrestleMania 24.

The plans quickly unravelled when Kennedy ran afoul of the Wellness Policy shortly before the planned reveal. The push was scrapped, and Hornswoggle was unveiled as McMahon’s son instead, bringing the storyline to a hugely disappointing conclusion.

Kennedy dwindled upon returning.

He remained in the spotlight for a while, but he never came close to reaching the heights he would’ve, had he not gotten himself suspended. His career soon unravelled through a spate of injuries, before Randy Orton supposedly convinced WWE officials that Kennedy was reckless in the ring, and had injured him on a backdrop.

Kennedy was released shortly afterwards, forever marking his WWE run as a case of “what could’ve been.”


3. William Regal

William Regal King of the Ring
WWE

If wrestling was a fair and just business where a wrestler's success is determined on skill alone, William Regal would have retired as a multi-time World Champion. A sublime technician and excellent talker, the Englishman had all the tools required to become a top superstar, but ultimately saw his prospects diminished through a long streak of personal issues.

His biggest missed opportunity came in 2008. As Raw’s General Manager, Regal won the 2008 King Of The Ring tournament, and immediately became one of the brand’s top heels. Finally, after years of struggle, the wrestler born Darren Matthews was set to become one of WWE’s most powerful onscreen characters, and there was even word that he was due for a WWE Championship run.

The run was derailed when Regal was suspended for 60 days following his second Wellness Policy violation, however. This information was made public two days after he'd lost a "loser leaves WWE" match to Mr. Kennedy, and his late-career hopes were dashed.

The push was dead in the water, and Regal returned to his old midcard role upon return, never looking like a true contender again.


2. Jack Swagger

Jack Swagger Zeb Colter
WWE.com

Though Jack Swagger’s untimely push as World Heavyweight Champion essentially killed his prospects of making it as a long-term WWE main eventer - work that one out - he underwent a significant rebuild after connecting with manager Zeb Colter in 2013. Drawing influence from the Tea Party political movement, the controversial duo gained mainstream media coverage with their new gimmicks, and Swagger’s career was finally on the up again.

He earned the right to challenge for Alberto Del Rio’s World Heavyweight Title after winning the 2013 Elimination Chamber, but made a huge error of judgement just two days later. Swagger was arrested for DUI and possession of marijuana in Gulfport, Mississippi. He was defeated in just 10 minutes at ‘Mania and his push evaporated. The “Real American” persona was greatly toned down as he slid towards the lower-card, and eventually became a non-factor on the WWE roster.

Swagger remained under contract until 2017, when he was finally released. He had become utterly listless by the time of his departure, and while his previous title run didn’t bode well for his main event prospects the second time around, his long, slow demise kicked-off with his arrest.


1. Rob Van Dam

Rob Van Dam WWE Champion
WWE.com

Rob Van Dam was an immensely popular upper-midcarder throughout his WWE run, and became a company staple after debuting during the Invasion. He drew huge face reactions despite his Alliance allegiance in the storyline, and his momentum continued after its conclusion, with RVD scoring a multitude of secondary title reigns.

True main event success eluded him for years, but this changed in 2006. Van Dam finally cashed-in his Money In The Bank briefcase to challenge for John Cena’s WWE Championship at ECW One Night Stand, and his victory was the ultimate feel-good moment for the Extreme faithful. Two nights later, RVD went one step further by claiming the ECW Championship for the first time in his career, finally cementing his status as a major player in WWE.

Trouble was right around the corner.

RVD was arrested for drug possession on July 2nd, and his push went down the drain. The next two nights saw Van Dam drop the WWE Championship to Edge, then the ECW Title to Big Show, before serving a mandatory 30-day suspension.

It took him five years to climb the mountaintop in WWE, but only three days to throw it all away, and he was out of the company by the following year.


In this post: 
Mr Kennedy
 
First Posted On: 
Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.