10 Wrestlers Who Must Return To Impact Wrestling
It's time for these names to make an Impact again.
TNA/Impact Wrestling is in the midst of massive upheaval. Behind the scenes, it’s rumored John Gaburick has lost power, while Jeff Jarrett appears to be the new captain of the ship. Dutch Mantell has been brought in to lead creative, but the great unknown is that we don't know how involved the management team at Anthem is going to be.
Besides all that, the company has lost quite a few marquee names over the past few weeks. Featured acts in the Hardys, Drew Galloway, Jade, Brooke, Maria and Michael Bennett are all gone. Gone!
There are a few replacements heading Impact's way, but the perception right now is the company has continually dropped the ball when it comes to contract negotiations. They need to create a more positive image for the promotion, and one way to do that is to bring back some familiar faces that fans have been missing. Those returning wrestlers would also fill in the depth chart on the roster, which has been incredibly thin since the debut on Pop TV.
However, this step can be difficult. After all, WWE has locked up quite a few former TNA stars like Bobby Roode, Eric Young, Samoa Joe, Austin Aries and A.J. Styles. That doesn’t mean there aren’t quite a few names still available at the moment. We're going to take a look at wrestlers who could (and should) realistically return to Impact in the near future (for example, Jay Lethal and "The Bucks of Youth" would be listed here, but they are both locked up in two year deals with ROH).
10. The Hardys
You can’t really talk about wrestlers who need to come back to Impact without bringing up the Hardys.
Ever since the move to Pop TV, TNA has been experiencing their weakest ratings since their Fox Sports Friday afternoon show over a decade ago. Upon their debut at their new home, the promotion completely lacked any buzz...until Matt Hardy became “Broken.” Before that, he was doing some of the best work of his career as Big Money Matt, but he wanted to do something bolder.
He started with dyed hair and a weird accent, but it became so much more. He created his own universe, one in which sentient drones exist and a magical lake can transform a person into a past gimmick. His creation got people to tune into the show, and at Final Deletion, Impact drew its highest ratings on Pop. While those numbers began slipping back to normal levels, Matt and Jeff remained the biggest stars on the show and began picking up crossover appeal.
However, a change in management caused them to be ousted from the company because their creative freedom was going to be greatly limited. The two decided to test their luck on the independent scene, and possibly WWE down the road. While that might be the better financial move for the two, it would be a shame to see their Impact run end for good.
Over the past couple years, they’ve been one of the few success stories to speak of in the promotion, and it would be interesting to see what they would have done under new management.
There’s still time for the two sides to make up (providing their ROH deals aren't long-term), which hopefully will happen relatively soon. If nothing else, the cinematic world they’ve created deserves a better form of closure.
9. Mr. Anderson
Mr. Anderson joined TNA with high hopes. His WWE run ended on a down note, and he seemed to have a ton of untapped potential. While he did capture the TNA World Heavyweight Championship, he still never felt like a top player. However, the booking team behind him was a constant mess, with major changes in power continually shifting behind the scenes during his time there.
His character turned too many times, and he was involved in so many bad feuds (Sam Shaw, Bully Ray) that any excitement around him was long gone by the time he exited the promotion. At 41-years-old, he’s not likely to be the top guy over the course of the next couple years, but he could still be valuable as a featured performer.
Ken has proved he can be a great talker on the mic, which is always a valuable asset for any promotion. Once his days as a wrestler wind down, he could transfer over to the role of a manager or onto commentary. He’s also running a wrestling school in Minnesota (along with Shawn Daivari and Molly Holly), and could help provide new talent for the promotion when they’re ready.
After catching so many bad breaks throughout his career, it would be nice to see Ken go out on a high note. A reunion between him and Impact with a clear creative vision in place could be beneficial to both parties.
8. Awesome Kong
Okay, so Awesome Kong's last showing in TNA as a member of The Dollhouse didn't go so hot. But there are a couple of reasons to be excited that another opportunity would go much better for her.
For starters, Kong has lost a lot of weight recently. She seems to be in great shape. She was struggling through back injuries during her last run, which slowed down her in-ring work considerably. Unless anything major happened lately, she should be more agile than she has been in years.
Second of all, she'd be booked by Dutch Mantell once again. He was the one who brought her in and pushed her so effectively during her original TNA stint. If she was booked anywhere near as well as that again, it would end up being a great signing for Impact.
With the departure of Jade, Rosemary badly needs some new opponents to work with. Having her feud with (and presumably go over) Kong would also be a nice boost for the younger wrestler's career.
Hopefully there's no longer any heat between Kong and management, and she can have another run that brings her back to her former glory.
7. Jade
As noted, the Knockouts Division is badly going to need a lot more talent if they want to ever come close to reaching their past level of success. The great thing is, though, with Mantell at the helm he will likely bring in a lot of really unique women wrestlers who have been overlooked by WWE. However, the company should first reach out to Jade before letting her possibly sign with NXT.
Jade is a talented wrestler who wasn't given a lot of attention by the creative team. She was fine in The Dollhouse, but the group quickly devolved into a bunch of jobbers. After she broke away and turned face, she felt a bit aimless (despite holding the title) until her feud with Rosemary began. The two put on some hard-hitting, entertaining hardcore brawls you won't find in the women's division of WWE. Just as it felt like Jade was catching on, her deal ran up.
It would be foolish of Impact to not try to bring her back on board. She's a good in-ring performer, and at 27-years-old, she's only going to continue improving over the next few years. If she does end up coming back, she would likely be featured a lot more under the Jarrett/Mantell regime and could be the champ again in no time.
Don't let her get away, Impact!
6. Shawn Daivari
Ariya Daivari is currently employed by WWE, and is most often found jobbing in quick matches to Cruiserweight talent, but his older brother Shawn continues to be out of the major leagues of wrestling. It's time to fix that.
While the older Daivari is known to be protective of his character and how he wants to be portrayed, he’s proven to be a great talker and solid in-ring worker over the course of his career. He first debuted in WWE in 2004, so he has a ton of experience, and despite being around for so long he’s he’s only 32.
Daivari was screwed over during his last run in TNA (as Sheik Abdul Bashir). He was slated to be the head of the World Elite stable, but the role was given to Eric Young. He wasn’t ready for that kind of push at that stage in his career. Daivari’s impending feud with the Main Event Mafia fell apart, and he remained directionless and incredibly frustrated before volunteering to win the pink slip in the Feast or Fired match. He then had a brief run in Lucha Underground, but his angle there also fell apart when Big Ryck left the promotion. It's been nothing but bad luck for him.
A return to Impact should be much more encouraging for Daivari, because Jeff Jarrett was the one who pushed for his signing the first go-around. With Double J back in charge, the talented wrestler may finally get that credible run he’s been seeking for years.
5. Low Ki
In order to play up the prestige and importance of the X Division Title in the new era, it would serve the company well to look to their past. TNA is nearly 15 years old, which means there aren’t many people they can bring back from the early days of the promotion and treat as a legitimate legacy act.
Jerry Lynn is retired. A.J. is in WWE. The Flying Elvises have sung their last song. But Low Ki is still out there and “only” 37-years-old. Despite so many years in the business, he's kept in fantastic shape, and would likely have a few more years of great matches in him.
TNA rarely treated Ki as a big deal during his time in the company, which is a shame as he’s one of the most distinct wrestlers of this generation. His offence is brutal, and he carries himself with a confidence few others possess. Add in his deceptively deep voice, and you have someone that stands out in a positive way.
While he was treated as an afterthought in the Beat Down Clan in his last run, Jeff Jarrett and Mantell may see a bit more in him these days. He would lend a credible name to the X Division, and would be a great talent for Trevor Lee to work with while being groomed for potential stardom.
With so many former X Division stars either in WWE or out of the business entirely, it would be satisfying to see Ki receive one last big run, and a series of opponents to kick the heads off of.
4. Joey Ryan
It’s time to make Impact sleazy again.
TNA had Joey Ryan before he became a huge indy darling, so every passing month he makes them seem more and more foolish for not giving him a decent opportunity.
Ryan made his debut in the company on Gut Check, and despite being the best, most ready for prime time talent they had in the competition, he wasn’t offered a contract. Only through fan backlash did the promotion finally give him something, but it was bungled from the start. Ryan’s heat in the story was with Taz, but since The Human Suplexing Machine couldn’t wrestle, he was shoehorned into an angle with Al Snow which failed to gain much traction.
Ryan was finally given a deal, but management never got the character. He’d ref some matches, sexually harass a few Knockouts and team up with Matt Morgan. The thing is, despite Ryan’s character being sleazy, there’s something likable about it. TNA just made him a creep who was booked as the weakest member of the roster. Unsurprisingly, it didn’t work.
Ryan continues to make waves on the indy scene, and has been featured in a few viral videos over the past couple years. He knows how to create a buzz. He has his supporters, and could be of great help in getting lapsed fans to give Impact another chance.
3. Alex Shelley
Paparazzi Productions is ready for a sequel.
Alex Shelley has been competing in NJPW and ROH to various levels of success over the past couple years in tag team action, but what he truly deserves is a great singles run.
He first joined TNA way back in 2004, but management never quite saw something in him. Everything good he was given was quickly taken away, like a pairing with Kevin Nash and a mini-feud with Mick Foley. It’s not that Shelley was bad in his role in the least - but creative didn’t seem to get his appeal.
The thing is, the man is funny. He has a dry, sarcastic humor that stands out in the world of largely bad wrestling comedy (you won't see him begging people to buy his ice cream on a weekly basis...for example). Besides that, he’s really good in the ring.
He may not be heavyweight championship material, but he’s certainly deserving of a decent push if he were to return. He could excel in the X Division and provide a veteran presence there, or be a pesky Chris Jericho-like heel and work against some of the bigger names in the promotion.
Chris Sabin would also be a welcome return to Impact when he’s free, but Shelley has been the more entertaining personality of the two on television. He is long overdue for a big singles opportunity.
2. Maria
From a pure in-ring ability standpoint, Maria may have been the weakest member on the Impact roster next to Mahabali Shera. But from a pure character standpoint, she's been one of the best in the promotion since her debut.
What makes her departure such a big loss is the sheer amount of time devoted to her character and her storyline with Allie. For most of 2016, the biggest angle in the Knockouts Division was the slow burn for Maria vs. Allie. Surprisingly, it was one of the best written angles the company has ever conceived. Besides a few clunky segments along the way, fans genuinely seemed interested in seeing the two finally fight.
While there has been a lot of turmoil behind the scenes over the past few months in TNA, it's still pretty mind-boggling to think management didn't have Maria locked into a deal before booking the wedding episode...but, such is life in Impact.
Hopefully Maria (and her husband) return to the company soon, because there's a big story that needs some closure, and plenty of other angles for her to be involved with in the future.
1. Drew Galloway
There were rumors making the rounds that Impact tried to re-sign Drew Galloway and were planning on making him their Heavyweight Champion. That seemed like a great call. It’s too bad the company dropped the ball on their negotiations with him, as he’s someone who the company should build around in the coming years.
Ever since he left WWE, Galloway has been one of the biggest stars on the independent scene. He’s also done great work in TNA, and proved he could be a versatile top-level babyface, which is something Impact has badly lacked throughout the vast majority of its existence. In a frustrating move, they turned him heel and blew a big opportunity to finally have a likeable good guy leading the way.
Galloway was still effective as a heel, but he was cast in the wrong role. Still, there was plenty of time to right that wrong had they brought him back.
They screwed up big time.
It's hard to say where he'll land in the future. WWE may offer him a big money deal, or he may stick around on the independent scene and choose which days he wants to work. If that's the case, then Impact would provide him much more freedom to do what he wants. He would also restore some goodwill to the promotion by proving the management team cares about talent who wasn't just around for their past era.
Out of any former TNA wrestler out there, Galloway is the one who could help them out the most over the course of the next few years.