10 Wrestlers Who Were Released For Breaking Kayfabe

Matt Hardy, Paul London, Serena Deeb and others all broke WWE's so-called sacred rules.

Matt Hardy Fired
WWE

Kayfabe is important to wrestling promoters, except when it isn't.

This biz's relationship with carny-like secrets was skewed long before playground arguments about whether it's real or not erupted daily throughout the 90s. Vince McMahon stood before state athletic commissioners on 10 February 1989 and told them that he produced sports entertainment, not "a bonafide athletic contest".

Such an admission didn't stop McMahon's WWF/WWE or any other promotion from occasionally bowing to the traditions of an industry that once believed 'exposure' would kill it. In fact, numerous wrestlers in the modern era have actually been released from their contracts because they "broke kayfabe".

They "broke" rules that were only half-heartedly followed to begin with.

There's a mixture of different eras here, and there were (admittedly) often other reasons that combined with simple shattered illusion to send some workers packing. Much like understanding kayfabe itself, it's difficult to fathom why men and women lost their jobs because someone found out that they weren't really the person they portrayed on TV.

That wouldn't really fly in any other industry, but wrestling's strange fascination with pretence still rages on...

10. The Iron Sheik

The Iron Sheik
WWE.com

Fans today know The Iron Sheik as a constant source of social media amusement, but the man wasn't a walking meme in 1987. Back then, Sheiky baby was a serious, anti-American heel who was in the middle of a heated blood feud with patriotic good guy Jim Duggan.

Police pulled Sheik and Jimbo over in May '87 and found that both were under the influence. Cops also found more drugs when they searched the car. That would've been troublesome enough for the WWF, but it isn't what Vince McMahon was most worried about.

He was more concerned that the pair's red-hot TV angle would be ruined when fans found out they were real-life friends.

McMahon fired Sheik and dismissed 'Hacksaw' - according to Bruce Prichard, Duggan was barely gone before the WWF brought him back. Sheik wasn't so lucky. He'd never reach the same heights in the company again (at least as an in-ring worker), and was only brought back for peripheral roles years later.


9. Kōji Kitao

Earthquake Koji Kitao
WWE

This is the first of many weird ones on this list.

Kōji Kitao had just teamed up with Tenryu to defeat Demolition at 1991's WrestleMania VII when he returned to his native Japan for a match with another WWF star: Earthquake. During that bout, Kitao visibly resisted 'Quake's attempts to do business and received a volley of abuse from the ticked-off American as a result.

Eventually, Kōji decided to kick the referee and get himself DQ'd. Post-match, he grabbed a mic and told the bemused live crowd that pro wrestling was fake. If it wasn't, then he'd easily beat someone like Earthquake. Shortly after this startling series of events, the Super World Of Sports promotion released Kitao from his deal.

Weirdly, SMS booker The Great Kabuki was also relieved of his duties when people found out that he'd told Kōji to shoot during the match. In effect, Kitao had conspired with Kabuki to shatter the illusion of wrestling, which was a strict no-no at the time.


8. Red Bastien & Johnny Valentine

Red Bastien Johnny Valentine
WWE Network

It's not disrespectful to suggest that one must take any old Mike Graham shoot with a pinch of salt. The guy had a tendency to over-exaggerate for style points or shock value - for proof, check out this clip of his interview with 'Kayfabe Commentaries'. In fairness, a lot of ex-wrestlers do that, especially traditionalists.

Graham told Sean Oliver that his father Eddie once caught wind of Red Bastien and Johnny Valentine having a BBQ over at Red's house in the early-70s. That didn't sit well with the promoter, because Bastien and Valentine were selling out cards as natural rivals for his regional business in Florida.

Disgusted and keen to send a message, Eddie called Red's house and told both he and Valentine that they were goners.

The pair had been scheduled for a show that night, but their match never happened. Graham fired both on the spot for breaking kayfabe and partying when they were supposed to tear one another apart. He was worried that fans might see them together.


7. Robbie McAllister

Robbie TNA
ImpactWrestling

The internet would be abuzz today if a contracted WWE star was shown hanging out at Daily's Place taking in some AEW action. Social media wasn't quite the same back then, but message boards still lit up when then-WWE talent Robbie McAllister was spotted at TNA's Impact Zone on 27 March 2008.

Oops.

TNA didn't help matters by making sure to show McAllister off and including a graphic that said, "Dereck (they spelled it wrong) Graham-Couch: WWE Wrestler". WWE officials quickly called Couch and told him to leave the soundstage. He was in big, big trouble, not only for attending a rival's show but also because they had used his shoot name on camera.

The Highlanders survived for another few months before WWE released them that August. It's not hard to imagine how angry Vince McMahon would've been upon hearing that one half of his Scottish tag-team had been caught looking like a fan at a TNA taping during WrestleMania week.


6. Brian Pillman

Brian Pillman
WWE.com

Want some more weirdness?

Originally, Brian Pillman's "I respect you, booker man" outburst (aimed at Kevin Sullivan) was a total work. It was designed to further Pillman's 'Loose Cannon' gimmick and make it seem like he was someone WCW management couldn't control no matter how hard they tried.

That's when things got super strange. Brian convinced Eric Bischoff to legitimately release him from his contract, citing unprofessional conduct as the chief charge, so that fans would buy into the character. Incredibly, Bischoff did exactly that; Pillman then dabbled with ECW for a while before inking a lucrative deal with the WWF.

He had played WCW, and somehow talked them into scrapping his contract for "breaking kayfabe". In reality, the masterful Pillman was giving himself leverage for negotiations elsewhere. Bri could use WCW as a bargaining chip during discussions with the WWF.

Pillman worked everybody, including his employers.


5. Bart Gunn

bart gunn dr death
WWE

Poor Bart Gunn.

The midcard tag star did nothing wrong by blasting his way through the WWF's ill-advised 'Brawl For All' tough man competition in 1998-1999. That tournament was designed to ready 'Dr. Death' Steve Williams for a series of matches with head boy Steve Austin. Instead, it ended Bart's run with the company.

Gunn battered Williams in the second round, which scuppered federation plans to push the rugged 'Doc'. Plodding on, the promotion finished the tourney then fed legit hard nut Bart to Butterbean at WrestleMania XV. The whole thing was a disaster, and it exposed that 'Dr. Death' wasn't actually the toughest heel on the roster.

The outright stupidity of airing a real fight league that was supposed to produce a fresh kayfabe challenger for 'Stone Cold' should not be overlooked. Gunn was released from his contract a short while after 'Mania, presumably because they were p*ssed that he'd spoiled main event booking.


4. Paul London

Paul London Vince McMahon
WWE

Vince McMahon came away with one of the most unintentionally-hilarious lines ever when he told Bruce Prichard, "I can't be on TV if I'm dead". That conversation took place right before WWE shot the infamous limo explosion angle on the 11 June 2007 edition of Raw.

That episode is notable for something else: Paul London's WWE career effectively coming to an end.

The high-flyer smiled broadly as a stoic McMahon passed him in the hallway backstage. Others wore blank expressions, but not Paul - he decided to rip the living sh*te out of a serious angle that was supposed to end the boss man's on-screen presence forever. London would eventually pay for that.

His push halted pronto, and WWE decided to split Paul's popular tag-team with Brian Kendrick later in the year. Then, London was mocked on TV as an example of what can go wrong if wrestlers mimic Shawn Michaels too closely (?!) and finally released in late-2008.

It took them a while, but WWE got there in the end.


3. Matt Hardy

Matt Hardy Edge Lita Thisisego
WWE

Even more weirdness awaits.

2005 was a tumultuous year for Matt Hardy. Officially, WWE released him on 11 April due to "unprofessional conduct" (there's that old chestnut again), but there was another reason. Matt had gone public, without WWE's knowledge, with details about an affair between his girlfriend Lita and Edge.

Wrestling forums, magazines and other news outlets swarmed to cover the story and squeeze as much drama out of this very-real situation as they possibly could. Meanwhile, WWE tried to distance themselves from the controversy, at least at first. Before long, they decided to try and turn Hardy's heartache into a money-spinning storyline.

It's often forgotten that WWE just wanted Matt to go away quietly in '05. He refused to do so, and didn't seem to care about the consequences of going public with his broken heart. The company released him, tried to move on, realised there was cash to be made in amongst all the kayfabe-breakage and seized their opportunity.


2. Paul Orndorff

Mr Wonderful Paul Orndorff
WWE.com

Bill Watts was a no-nonsense promoter, sometimes to his own detriment. The gruff 'Cowboy' butted heads with wrestlers during stints in charge of territories like Mid-South and groups like his UWF. Later, Watts failed to endear himself to rosters in WCW and the WWF due to his old-fashioned and strict management methods.

According to an old Jim Duggan shoot (it was on YouTube but has since disappeared), Paul Orndorff felt the wrath of one very specific 'Cowboy' rule during the territory days. 'Mr. Wonderful' was supposedly given his marching orders for daring to lose a fight with some punters in a bar after the matches.

That was not allowed under Watts' rule.

Duggan claims the fight took place in Arkadelphia, Arkansas. Orndorff found himself outnumbered by a group of gents, and ended up taking a kicking for his troubles. That didn't sit well with Bill, because it made the wrestlers look weak, so Paul was fired on the spot.


1. Serena Deeb

CM Punk Straight Edge Society WWE
WWE.com

It's incredible that this happened as recently as 2010.

On 20 August that year, Serena Deeb was informed that her WWE contract would be terminated immediately. When she asked why, company officials told her that she hadn't been "living out" her on-screen character in public. In other words, she had been spotted drinking in bars with her peers.

Why was that an issue? Well, it shouldn't have been, but Deeb was part of CM Punk's 'Straight Edge Society' faction. The 'Saviour' spoke of rescuing "lost souls" like Luke Gallows, Joey Mercury and Serena from serious addictions, and WWE were annoyed that Deeb wasn't following her gimmick on the road.

Think about that. She was sacked for failing to act like her fictional character in real life. In 2010. ELEVEN YEARS AGO. Serena's release came after she'd already pre-recorded some more segments for SmackDown - that meant she still appeared on the 27 August show despite already being dismissed one week before.

What other wrestlers were ultimately released for breaking kayfabe? For more wrestling, check out WWE Fastlane 2021: 10 Nightmares That Could Happen and 10 Things We Learned From Paul Wight On Talk Is Jericho!


Watch Next


WWE Quiz: How Well Do You Know Matt Hardy?

Matt hardy Laugh
WWE.com

1. What Is Matt's Full Name?

In this post: 
Matt Hardy
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.