10 Wrestlers Who Were Wrongly Judged On ONE Match

When Vince McMahon, his staff and WWE fans judged wrestlers way too early.

Mordecai Hardcore Holly Great American Bash 2004
WWE.com

Everyone has done it.

Absolutely every pro wrestling fan has sat there, watched one match and judged workers accordingly. It's human nature to make snap judgements on things and then use that as some bullsh*t criteria for the rest of your experience with it. Pro wrestlers, and their skills/size/looks/promos/matches are no different.

WWE do this too, and even Vince McMahon isn't exempt from blame. The single most powerful man in the entire industry has watched just one bout before making up his mind on some world class talents, and he often trusts the opinions of those who either only want to please him or don't really know what they're talking about and just fancy a spot of backstage drama.

This has led to wild claims that some quality wrestlers are "dangerous", "injury prone", "too small", "overhyped" and more. It also works the other way - a few workers have been judged positively instead, with one even being dubbed the "next Hulk Hogan" by those behind the curtain when they smelled money (or the chance to echo the boss).

Often, such bold, sweeping statements are wrong. Very, very wrong...

10. Tazz Is "Dangerous"

Tazz Kurt Angle
WWE.com

Nobody who witnessed it will ever forget Tazz's debut at the 2000 Royal Rumble.

The ex-ECW hard man suplexed the undefeated Kurt Angle out of his boots, then quickly locked on a choke for the submission. This was decisive booking at its best, and it made Tazz look like a million bucks instantly. The problem was that, well, those damn suplexes worried some behind the curtain at MSG.

Both Bruce Prichard and Jim Ross have said on their respective podcasts that a few of the other wrestlers expressed concerns that Tazz was reckless and dangerous between the ropes. That wasn't true, or fair - Angle himself has revealed on his own pod that he was 100% up for every suplex, and called his peer a controlled, safe worker.

Still, mud sticks. Suddenly, Vince McMahon wasn't so sure that the grappling machine who'd played before a huge pop in his most famous venue was trustworthy enough to push. Then, suddenly, Tazz's smaller size became a problem too.

How unfair.


9. Eddie Guerrero Is Too Small (And Injury Prone)

Eddie Guerrero debut WWE match injury
WWE.com

Size has been a Federation hangup since forever.

McMahon famously told Prichard that the late, great Eddie Guerrero was "so tiny" upon first meeting the guy in 2000, and that wasn't a good sign for Eddie's WWE career. He defied those odds though, changed Vince's outlook and eventually became a company legend.

Guerrero nearly didn't get another chance to defy expectations. JR once told a story on his podcast about the doubting glances fired his way when the incoming WCW star suffered a nasty elbow injury during his very first match (with Perry Saturn vs. The New Age Outlaws) in the WWF; that, according to Ross, was a stick the brown-nosers could use to beat his signing policy with.

This "tiny" worker was now injury prone too, or so people thought. Jim knew differently, and he believed Guerrero would make everybody eat those words if he was shown some proper respect and just allowed to get on with things without unnecessary judgement.


8. Mordecai Is Boring

Mordecai WWE
WWE.com

Admittedly, some reading will turn their noses up at this one. Give it a chance though, because it's not like Kevin Fertig was the worst worker on the planet. Was he the best? Absolutely not, but his old Mordecai gimmick probably gave most fans the wrong impression.

Mordecai's pay-per-view debut against Scotty 2 Hotty at Judgment Day 2004 wasn't a rip-roaring success. The slow, meandering style of the newcomer turned a lot of people off, and they weren't willing to give it a second chance. Later, Fertig revealed that it might've been a mistake to pretty much lift The Undertaker's original 'zombie' style and present it to a modern audience.

Wrestling had moved on.

This pay-per-view disaster was a hammer blow to Mordecai's prospects. WWE soured on him quickly, then a real-life bar fight gave the company an out. Fertig, as the vampire Kevin Thorn, proved he wasn't awful when working a faster style in ECW years later.


7. Trish Stratus Is Just Another Diva

Trish Stratus Jackie Gayda
WWE Network

This one came more from fans than anyone inside the biz.

Trish Stratus and Bradshaw vs. Jackie Gayda and Chris Nowinski will forever go down as one of the worst matches in Raw history. The 8 July 2002 dud was painful to watch and more-than-a-little embarrassing for Trish. She was keen to earn her keep as a proper pro, but this fiasco did nothing for her.

Comments online cruelly dismissed Stratus. Forums filled up with criticism towards WWE's bid to push Trish too - WWE's revisionist history conveniently leaves that part out when discussing some 'Stratusfaction' nowadays.

The positive slant on this is that embarrassment only made Status more determined. She went on to have a critically-acclaimed feud with Victoria (their Survivor Series 2002 bout was revolutionary for women in the company) and became one of the most celebrated females the industry has ever seen.

Fans shouldn't have been so quick to judge.


6. D’Lo Brown Is Cursed

Dlo brown
WWE.com

The nightmarish accident which cost Darren Drozdov his career (and almost his life) would haunt D'Lo Brown's own legacy forever. Droz was paralysed and ended up in a wheelchair following a powerbomb-gone-wrong on an October 1999 episode of SmackDown, and D'Lo's push hit the skids.

That was terribly harsh.

Every wrestling match is millimetres away from disaster. The margins are so fine, and D'Lo had worked hundreds of bouts without incident before this. He'd also been regarded as a fine midcarder who deservedly snagged several belts and spun out of the Nation faction with aplomb.

Then, Droz happened and everybody forgot that. Sure, it was grim, but Brown didn't warrant insults about the safety of his ring style, and he definitely didn't deserve the severe scrutiny that'd be given to all of his matches afterwards. One single moment would come to define D'Lo's entire career, and that's plain sad to think about considering all he'd achieved.


5. Tom Magee Is The Next Hulk Hogan

Tom Magee Bret Hart Still
WWE

Time for something a little bit different.

Vince McMahon's eyes lit up when he watched Bret Hart carry Tom Magee to a house show stunner in October 1986. Obviously, when asked for his thoughts on the match at the time, McMahon would've omitted "Bret Hart carry" from the prior sentence. He thought Magee was going to be his next Hulk Hogan.

Hart wrote in his autobiography that he didn't receive a lot of praise for the bout. Instead, Vince and his hangers-on flocked around Tom. They showered the newbie with serious praise, and everybody agreed that he was a World Champ in waiting. Bret knew that wasn't the case - he eagerly watched Magee's follow-up matches knowing they wouldn't come close to his carry job.

They...weren't great. Typically, everyone fawning over Magee soured on his prospects after watching efforts against such luminaries as Terry Gibbs, Barry O and 'Iron' Mike Sharpe. Suddenly, McMahon didn't see dollar signs any longer, and Tom's star faded as quickly as it had burned.


4. Goldberg Is Capable Of Long Matches

DDP Goldberg WCW Halloween Havoc 1998
WWE.com

Halloween Havoc 1998 gave many the wrong impression about squash match machine Bill Goldberg too. WCW top brass thought the wrecking ball had to start working longer bouts if he was going to be a sustainable headliner, which is fair enough, but those lengthier showings badly exposed flaws in Goldberg's game.

That 10-minute cracker with DDP was the exception, not the rule.

No, 10 minutes isn't especially longer for a pay-per-view main event, but this was Goldberg; WCW's phenom was known for running through opponents in less than two mins. That suited him, because big Bill was always limited as a worker. Unfortunately, Havoc '98 fooled everybody into thinking he'd turned a corner.

WWE fell into this trap when they hired Goldberg in 2003. His 13-minute clash with The Rock at Backlash that April exposed him again, and he wasn't booked properly until a second run started in 2016. The DDP match tricked people in power positions big time.


3. Mick Foley Is Only Good For Big Bumps

The Undertaker Mankind
WWE.com

Ask 100 wrestling fans to name one Mick Foley match and 99 (if not 100) will recall his blistering Hell In A Cell epic with The Undertaker at King Of The Ring 1998. If pressed for another, those same folks might remember a similar HIAC effort opposite Triple H at No Way Out 2000, and a few hardcores might mention something about Vader.

That's all Mick was good for, right? Big bumps? Wrong.

Foley is constantly judged on the 'Taker bumps. Few stop to think back to classic matches he had with Shawn Michaels (IYH: Mind Games in 1996), Sting (WCW Beach Blast 1992) or Steve Austin (Over The Edge 1998). Yes, Mick loved a dramatic stunt, but he was a much more capable wrestler than most give him credit for.

Even Vince McMahon was lured into this line of thinking years before HIAC. He told Jim Ross that Foley, as Cactus Jack, wasn't up to snuff and would break his heart if he hired him for the WWF. The Vin-man got that one wrong, eh?


2. Booker T Is Overhyped

Buff Bagwell Booker T
WWE.com

It's mad to think that future two-time WWE Hall Of Famer Booker T was almost discarded along with fellow ex-WCW man Buff Bagwell because of one dodgy match. Their clanger on the 2 July 2001 edition of Raw was roundly considered a washout, and it went some way towards McMahon saying 'f*ck that' about WCW as a standalone brand.

Booker was lumped in with Buff. Think about that.

Bagwell wasn't horrible during his peak, but he was never anywhere close to Booker as a worker. T had proven himself for years in WCW, and he'd carved his own path to the top. Plus, he was one of the few WCW headliners who looked like a stick-on to succeed in the WWF. Then, that Raw match happened.

Booker also broke Steve Austin's hand during an early angle, which didn't go down well with the locker room doubters. He was off to a rough start, but that'd change once guys got to see that Book wasn't overhyped at all.


1. Chris Jericho Is A WCW Flop

Chyna Chris Jericho
WWE.com

Chris Jericho must've felt pretty low when Vinnie Mac hauled him into the office and told him his WWF contract wasn't worth the paper it was printed on. The then-Y2J wrote about this in one of his first books, and admitted that he didn't see that nosedive from incoming WCW star-underwhelming WWF hire coming.

Then, he gave Chyna a black eye and things really broke down.

McMahon was appalled by this, but Jericho said it was an accident and that Chyna knew the risks - everyone in wrestling gets hit at some point. Still, his back-to-back pay-per-view bouts with her at Survivor Series and Armageddon disappointed Vince, and he started to view Jericho as somebody he couldn't trust.

That stink hung around over Jericho's head until early-2000. He'd been judged for an accidental stiff shot during one match against Chyna, and the boss didn't think his overall work was up to scratch either. What a brutal time for a future great.

What other wrestlers were wrongly judged after one specific match? For more WWE, check out 20 Things You Probably Missed From WWE Raw (June 14) and 10 WWE Hires That DOOMED Other Wrestlers!


Watch Next


In this post: 
Mordecai
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.