10 Wrestlers With The AEW Stink

Admit defeat on those that are no longer Elite...

Penta Oscuro
AEW

Tony Khan's purchase of Ring Of Honor has yet again caused more shifting of wrestling's tectonic plates.

It'd be the preserve of the ultra-optimistic ROH hardcores to assume that the company will function and run as it once did, not least considering Khan's already-full plate. That's not to say he couldn't or wouldn't delegate duties to somebody experienced enough to book it as a separate brand, but at this point in AEW's celebrated tenure as a promotion, there'll be panic if he doesn't.

Andre The Giant foreshadowed his legendary WrestleMania programme with Hulk Hogan by noting that "three years is a long time", but who knew his garbled menace could prove so prescient decades later? AEW's existed long enough for the highs to be contextualised, the lows to be critically analysed and the future to be forecasted with enough evidence informed by the recent past.

With that, regrettably, comes the the reality of some wrestlers feeling a little more past their sell-by date, rather than being as Elite as the company initials might once have suggested. Not everybody can thrive in a promotion, but the more time Khan spends on ROH, the more chance there is of the likes of these feeling even more past their best...

10. Orange Cassidy

Orange Cassidy Adam Cole
AEW

With AEW operating relatively successfully as a roster rotation promotion, it's a shame the statistical spreadsheets haven't found a way to make Orange Cassidy just as popular as a part-time performer.

An awesome and over gimmick even now that its been over-exposed, the persona works as well as it does because it proves All Elite Wrestling to be the place for pro wrestling artistic impression. But, criminally, the company have allowed the joy to feel a little diluted. Or at very least wear thin. Danhausen's debut during Cassidy's match with Adam Cole forced the former to crack a wry smile, as if he knew he was about to be ousted as AEW's most popular novelty megastar.

Though the circumstances are never ideal, a compromise may have been reached as result of Cassidy's shoulder injury suffered at Revolution. Absence makes the heart grow fonder, and the recovery time should provide a much-needed break - his first since the group launched with him as a key signing in 2019.

And speaking of launch signings that need a break, and Orange Cassidy-related content...


9. Matt Hardy

Matt Hardy
AEW

The arrival of Jeff Hardy in AEW will provide the company with a number of thrilling short term outcomes fans will loudly praise.

An immediate face off with Darby Allin and Sting brought about a mix of dream pairings rooted in a nightmarish past. Speaking of the past, look no further than the EVPS - The Young Bucks rematch will be hot even if it doesn’t reach the peaks of their 2017 ROH classic.

This entry doesn’t exist to take a sh*t on a nostalgia run that should at very least generate a few eyes and be classified as “nice”.

But after that, what?

Matt Hardy’s AEW CV is a ropey one. A cursed feud with Sammy Guevara didn’t elevate the younger star as planned, and the Hardy Family Office’s nonsensical construction and unsatisfactory motivations has at times made thrilling TV shows feel like clogged toilet bowls.

It's not just Private Party and The Butcher & The Blade that found themselves marooned…


8. Andrade

Andrade El Idolo
AEW

There were fewer wrestlers released across both 2020 and 2021's mass WWE cuts that felt more can't-miss than Andrade.

Gifted with a propulsive engine that powered his hybrid lucha style into something far more dangerous and a gazillion dollar look to go alongside it, it seemed staggering that Vince McMahon had failed to maximise his earnings with the former NXT Champion.

Regrettably, there's been far too much of the same going on with him in these supposedly sunnier climbs.

He might be turning a corner, but the fact that this can only be posed as a question rather than presented proudly as an exclamation speaks to the titular stink. At this point, it’s simply not enough to have that Rampage ripper against Sammy Guevara and Darby Allin. Especially when they do it against almost everybody.

The AHFO split from Matt Hardy is the make-or-break moment for Andrade. How he thrives in its aftermath will test his mettle not just as an in-ring maestro, but as a true top level singles star.


7. Jake Hager

Chris Jericho Jake Hager AEW
AEW

Jake Hager has happily walked behind Chris Jericho since AEW launched in 2019, playing the bodyguard role reasonably well when he wasn't expected to do a great deal more.

His natural deadpan leant credence to his task as the Inner Circle's simpleton hoss, but as the group have splintered in recent months, it's become even more apparent how far below his old and new colleagues he is in the AEW pecking order.

A failure to emerge with much credit after laboured efforts against Dustin Rhodes and Jon Moxley in AEW's first year did that reputation no favours, and only when tagging with 'Le Champion' has Hager felt anything close to the peak standard expected on Wednesday nights.

Jericho legendarily bantered off Hager's old "We The People" catchphrase on the second ever episode of Dynamite, but that deathblow might need undoing in the months to come if the former World Heavyweight Champion finds himself on the outs. It was a bit stupid and it did come from bad creative, but at least it was over.


6. Kip Sabian

Kip Sabian
AEW

Kip Sabian has recently been clocked in AEW audiences with a bag on his head in a character that appears to mirror the strange demonstration made by actor Shia LaBeouf on red carpets back in 2014.

The concept is as dated as the wrestler himself feels.

Back when CM Punk and Daniel Bryan were struggling to crack WWE infamously thick glass ceiling, the groundswell of support was crucial in aiding their ascension. It cannot work any other way, and moreover, why should it? It’s unideal to present the organisation as systemically inept in the first place, but at least if the performers are white hot, the anti-capitalist narrative is simpatico.

In Sabian’s case, more fans are likely to side with AEW than rally against it. There’s no way for this not to sound patronising, but right now Kip’s a heck of a hand and not a lot more.

The gimmick isn’t without an intriguing end goal, but the company have dropped sh*t cold before. That brown grocery bag could get Kevin McAllister’ed any day now.


5. Varsity Blondes

Varsity Blondes
AEW

Brian Pillman Jr and Griff Garrison's treatment in the recent pre-Revolution Casino Battle Royal suggested that a recent dalliance with The House Of Black may have left a mark even after the toxic juice cleared.

They’re on a humiliating run at present, and though a rankings system needs losers as much as it does winners, those looking at the lights are supposed to be people you pay to see defeated or hope to see pull through.

Are the Varsity Blondes either?

Pillman Jr flushed a lot of good will away with a series of odd choices on and off screen. Garrison, meanwhile, failed emphatically to get even a measure of comeuppance for the physical and mental torture he suffered at the hands of Malakai Black. They’re not people to get behind, but, as babyfaces, they’re not people to boo.

A reckoning might be coming one way or another. The doomed feeling around the duo suggests either a heel turn or split is forthcoming, and one or both can’t get here soon enough.


4. The Dark Order

The Dark Order Hangman Page
AEW

Once a rejuvenated presence alongside Brodie Lee and a reinvigorated one with Hangman Page, The Dark Order have faded from relevance (and often from view) since Page became AEW World Heavyweight Champion.

Though the group were still on hand to run off redDRagon in the closing moments of the Revolution pay-per-view headliner between Page and Adam Cole, they are seemingly doomed to a life of jobbing on Dynamite and Rampage forever more unless they formally sever ties with the AEW World Heavyweight Champion. He certainly seems to want to do that too, which could inadvertently divide fans between the two sides should they part ways for good.

Once, this might have been quite charming, but the magic of the group has fizzled to the point where they probably should too. A heel turn now might scan as insensitive, but a formal and gentle split wouldn't sting in the same way. It's okay for groups to outlive their usefulness and part ways amicably - it'd be smart of AEW to remind fans of that.


3. Men Of The Year

Ethan Page Scorpio Sky Men Of The Year Dan Lambert
AEW

Within the confines of the kayfabe AEW likes to keep, the Men Of The Year act is all over the f*cking shop.

Scorpio Sky is a wrestler who tweets his employers to ask why significant success in their mandated wins/losses ranking system isn't generating more title shots for him. The post-Revolution TNT Title win was overdue, but the failure of his push up to this point was damned by how many viewers immediately assumed he’d be a transitional champion.

Ethan Page debuted at Revolution 2021 and has only been a Man Of The Year in the sense that he has literally existed on television for the last 12 months. His singles form doesn't put him in the tier with Sky, but the duo are nowhere near tag gold either. That speaks to something, but it isn't progress.

And speaking of speaking, Dan Lambert as a mouthpiece has never quite worked either. The American Top Team gaffer rules on the stick, but the very barbs he lauched at Cody Rhodes and other from his Jim Cornette-shaped platform should theoretically stick to his charges too. We're asked to ignore that just because, but yet again molehills become mountains when there's no major success to speak of in the one thing that still matters most - winning wrestling matches.


2. Best Friends

Best Friends Trent Chuck Taylor Rocky Romero Orange Cassidy AEW
AEW

There's a certain wholesomeness about Best Friends that may in fact never subside, and a number of grandiose payoff matches have suggested that the longer term the feud, the more powerful the catharsis will be when they come through.

But. But but but. But but but but.

They're a bit cr*p, aren't they?

One awesome match once every six-to-eight months doesn't make a worthy stable, but with the recent dissolution of The Inner Circle, the collapse of The Pinnacle and the likely eventual ruination of Jurassic Express, Death Triangle, Dark Order and The Elite (again) potentially leaves Trent, Chuck and the gang as the last holdouts from the original collection of AEW groups. It's only because they've never hit heights that Best Friends don't feel part of that discussion, save for the occasional angry face Trent has pulled since returning with a shaved head.

Kris Statlander is great, but even she feels anchored by association. Friendships are good, but in wrestling they're permitted to fall apart. Now's the time.


1. Penta Oscuro

Penta El Zero M
AEW

Even typing "Penta Oscuro" as if it reflects any significant change beyond one of the lamest AEW entrances ever gives more credit to a gimmick that is a shift in name alone.

Penta wrestles as Penta always has done since AEW launched in 2019, f*cking around while knocking out terrifying head and neck drops without care for the transparent tonal dissonance. Short of the brief spell he wore Joker attire, the Oscuro look doesn't differ that wildly from the attires he's used either. And Alex Abrahantes is an even more infuriating presence than he was when he wasn't dressing like he'd robbed a Halloween costume shop without settling on a single theme.

He can contribute to total rippers in the same way he always did, as proven during the wicked Revolution Buy-In trios match against The House Of Black. Beyond that, Death Triangle have sadly lived down to the first part of their name rather than serving as the backbone of a nascent trios league. This cartoonish rebadge doesn't bode well for addressing this doomed concern.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.