10 Wrestlers With The WWE Stink

Was the smell Edge spoke of actually his booking? WWE are leaving these 10 talents with a stench.

Sonya Deville
WWE.com

Whatever you'd classify "WWE stink" as, Seth Rollins was absolutely swimming in it in 2019.

Drowning, in fact. As Universal Champion, he'd taken on the role of company figurehead down to tweeting out rash and defensive statements towards fellow wrestlers and fans that embarrassed him when the company profoundly failed to live up to the standards he set.

In October, it directly impacted him - his Hell In A Cell main event against The Fiend Bray Wyatt was an instantly infamous display of company incompetence at its absolute worst and as Champion and normal human being, he ate mountains of sh*t.

After losing the Universal Championship to Wyatt in their rematch, Rollins permitted himself to step back from social media and indeed the company's catbird seat, and instead took to doing what he evidently does best - wrestling. Pandemic era rippers with Kevin Owens, Drew McIntyre, Dominik Mysterio and others reframed him as the WWE-style ring general he'd become, and few character shifts eventually helped him arrive at the Seth Freakin' Rollins version of himself which has connected tremendously with live crowds that literally sing from his hymn sheet.

He's an example the following wrestlers should look towards with optimism - the dreaded stink doesn't need to be for life, even if it's absolutely rotten right now. And it is with...

10. Edge

Edge WWE
WWE.com

If "WWE Stink" were a fragrance, the bottle would be purple and Edge would be at the centre of the absurdly expensive idiosyncratic television ad.

The Hall-Of-Famer making his comeback at the 2020 Royal Rumble was the company's first truly magic moment of the decade. Part of the magic was wrapped up in the thinking that he was a big enough star to transcend the tropes and trends that had plunged WWE into self-parody for years. Instead, he embraced the playbook.

The pandemic threw everything for a loop, but even a full crowd wouldn't have wanted his lethargic WrestleMania 36 brawl with Randy Orton to exceed 20 minutes let alone 30. His fake-feeling babyface intensity was a long way removed from the earnestness of his Rumble return, and this was reflected when his battle royal win the following year didn't generate ratings for Raw and NXT in the ways the company presumably expected. The less said about his current heel turn the better, not least because he's been yap-yap-yap since it happened and the put-upon-crowds are greeting it with silence of Jamie Noble chants.

In the interest of fairness (and sticking with the semantic field of legalese because 'The Rated-R Superstar' and his cronies love it so much) the jury will be out on The Judgment Day until Rhea Ripley and Damian Priest's progression can be accurately assessed. But Edge himself feels swallowed up by the one-note-joke of a role and it could be a long time before he escapes.


9. Sonya Deville

Sonya Deville
WWE.com

Sonya Deville, as of writing, is once again just an active wrestler.

This, of course, is the first problem. It's a tale as old as time in World Wrestling Entertainment - the Sports Entertainers are sh*t compared to the variously title'd admin assistants that kayfabe run the show. It was a role Deville assumed with some honour before succumbing to malice like the rest of them, and she’s at long last been punished by a board of directors that have somehow put up with these villains in the roles for upwards of 20 years now.

Her slow stroll back to the squared circle was completely understandable after the real life home invasion she experienced alongside Mandy Rose in 2020, but the all-too-familiar heel feuds against Naomi and then Bianca Belair have positioned her as an idiot too single-minded to keep one job and too rusty to do the other.

Nothing’s allowed to be forever in WWE, and she’s talented enough to be one good run away from getting shot of the titular stink. If only she’d not been doused in it in the first place.


8. GUNTHER

Drew Gulak Gunther
WWE.com

It’s not even the silly name.

It might have been had he taken the original one and shared his handle with a legitimate nazi war commander, but Gunther is no more egregious than a Cesaro or Riddle or any of the many others over the years. Not really, anyway.

Not least because this guy ain’t Walter.

Walter was a physical colossus even if he didn’t boast the height of a behemoth or the size of a super-heavyweight. Walter was an elite-tier wrestler capable of hanging with other elite-tier wrestlers that afforded WWE the rarest of hardcore fanbase wins once in a while in the new wrestling war against AEW. Walter was unlike virtually everybody else.

Gunther is every other Sports Entertainer. And not even because of the new bright red gear or the name change or the music change or the breaking up of his stable or the obvious and bewildering reduction of the chop’s importance.

Gunther is every other Sports Entertainer because he locks up, runs headlock spots, catches a dive as SmackDown rolls on, grabs a hold until the fans can be a*see to clap the babyface back into action and then runs through his signature spots with less than half the vim and vigour of old.

A violent monster can be one by any other name. But Gunther - and possibly Walter now, how knows? - categorically isn’t that in WWE.


7. Lacey Evans

Lacey Evans
WWE.com

It was never destined to end well, any of this.

WWE debuted "The Story Of Lacey Evans" on April 8th and she was on television by May 6th flexing her biceps and soaking up the support of the fans. This was always the plan. It's the rest of the story that shouldn't have been.

Evans went into the weeds describing the very, very difficult like she'd had before landing in WWE the first time several years ago. It covered addiction, abuse and various emotional and physical challenges she's faced in her life, and didn't shy away from literal descriptions of the hardships. WWE had already shown some negligence by not adding content warnings nor associated support lines, and the exploitative nature was destined to boil over eventually. But it happened in a way nobody could expect.

Ahead of introducing her to a live audience for the first time, ring announcer Samantha Irvin spoke to the viewers down the hard camera lens whilst asking the audience to show Evans the requisite respect. WWE audiences are remarkably subservient it would seem, because the people did despite the obvious heel trope.

She's since been moved to Monday Night Raw amidst some controversy and public opinion that WWE have atrociously misread the situation. Her first feud will only be all the more telling.


6. Mustafa Ali

Mustafa Ali
WWE

Mustafa Ali is trying.

No, not the name of his new Netflix special nor a criticism of him as a person, but a realistic reflection of the current situation he finds himself in in the latest chapter of his strange, strange WWE story.

When he last held down regular television work, Ali was trapped beneath a gimmick so utterly risible it destroyed the credibility of almost everybody who came into contact with it. RETRIBUTION was a relentless nightmare, often made worse by the attempts of the wrestlers involved to wake up. Ali cut scathing Twitter promos trying to justify everything from the awful ring names to the lousy booking, but he was fighting somebody else's hideously uncreative battle.

And after a protracted absence around contract issues and Ali's attempt to leave, he returned to television to go 50/50 with the usual Raw midcard lot and took to Twitter with some very Vince McMahon-friendly comedy.

Everything about the man's guile is admirable, and perhaps that's the problem - he's not in a place where such a thing is typically rewarded.


5. Dolph Ziggler/The Miz

dolph ziggler miz
WWE.com

It's a draw for the long-standing utility men, if only because they often go through purple patches where their obvious upsides are used to benefit something, even if that something might not lead to something else.

Both were busy over WrestleMania weekend, with Ziggler winning and losing in matches against Bron Breakker that served as misguided attempts to get the newcomer over as the most credible version of himself. Meanwhile, Miz was well cast as Logan Paul's partner and attacker either side of their WrestleMania tag team match against The Mysterios.

Since then, it's been back to the old reliable grind, but the old-reliable-grind-feeling is one of the many reasons WWE lost their monopoly in 2019. Miz and Ziggler aren't individually at fault, but few represent the foibles of the modern system more than these two. Up and down the card they go, filling in as needed on both sides of the heel/babyface divide whilst reading out their own Wikipedia pages as way to put over their achievements in a manner that completely does away with it being the emulation of a sporting pursuit.

If they didn't look like people who would smell exquisite on the reg, the WWE stink lines would probably visible to the naked eye.


4. Bron Breakker

Bron Breakker
WWE.com

Somebody ought to be ashamed of themselves for the current position Bron Breakker finds himself in. Which, incidentally and as of this writing at least, was under the captive command of some f*cking red druids in Orlando somewhere.

One of the few instant shining lights from the aggressive rebadging of the developmental in 2021, Breakker had enough dumb jock intensity, a jacked physique and an absolutely wicked spear. A minuscule number of matches under his weight belt needn't have mattered. The same skill set worked well enough for Goldberg didn't it?

What didn't work for Big Bill was WWE's attempt to turn him into a long match practitioner/jack-of-all-trades in 2003. Draining and dull pay-per-view bouts squeezed every bit of aura out of him, and it is already happening again with Rick Steiner's fired up son. Rather than a squash merchant, the NXT Champion is working drab formula bouts that expose his limitations, his engine and his it factor.

A return to house shows for the brand might up his reps in a way where such things won't be required, but this basically acts as effective developmental anyway - he'll be expect to have sludgy chinlock matches on Raw and SmackDown so he might as well have them on NXT too. Pity the fun ended so quickly.


3. The Usos

The Usos
WWE.com

Roman Reigns is going away soon. A bit.

'The Head Of The Table' will work a reduced schedule over the summer months, stopping by to make some television towns and the big three stadium shows between July and September, but the Undisputed WWE Universal Champion theoretically won't be half as present as he has been for the duration of his lengthy and slightly exhausting stint on top.

Why has this entry about The Usos more about Roman Reigns the current SmackDown Tag Team Champions? Well why else? They exist purely to stand next to him, and he often only exists to just stand there. Any shred of artistic flare the company might have once shown with regards to the cousins finally turning on their gaffer was dropped cold as they became goons and losers taking his bumps and working his dark matches.

And they're not the only shattered part of that act that might benefit from 'The Tribal Chief's potentially absence.


2. Paul Heyman

Roman Reigns Paul Heyman Undisputed WWE Universal Champion
WWE

Is this the worst run of Paul Heyman's WWE career?

Roman Reigns' "special counsel to the Tribal Chief' is doing much the same as he was alongside Brock Lesnar and CM Punk, and their original union in 2020 was absolutely the missing piece of the brand new Reigns heel puzzle, but what's been his purpose since then?

He stands next to Reigns. He stands next to the ring posts. He stands next to The Usos. And repeat. The former ECW chief has found his path as a probably WWE lifer, and few could have predicted that when relations were at their absolute worst between him and Vince McMahon following his 2006 departure. But cordial business relations between two promoters doesn't necessary make for good television, not least when it's clear just how much he's been prepared to nestle himself under McMahon's thumb.

Heyman doesn't run interference in the way he used to, and over-egged his parts when the inevitable questions of loyalty were asked during the Reigns' programme with Lesnar. Pulling funny faces used to be an accoutrement rather than the entire bit. Like much of the act, it's too phoned in to feel fully functional.


1. Drew McIntyre

Drew McIntyre Roman Reigns
WWE.com

Drew McIntyre being splashed all over the marketing for September's Clash At The Castle stadium show in Cardiff (as well as being credited for willing the show - or a version of it - into existence) has convinced plenty of folk that he's actually going to be the one to dethrone Undisputed WWE Universal Champion Roman Reigns on the night.

This might be the wisest play - the company will absolutely draw parallels between Davey Boy Smith's historic SummerSlam 1992 win over Bret Hart, and the company will do everything to make the show feel like its one of similar prestige. But in terms of 'The Scottish Warrior' himself, the boat has sadly been missed.

Now Just A Guy who can at least pretend to be The Guy, he earned all of this having admirable played company figurehead during the depths of the pandemic. But one too many comedy programmes, that f*cking sword, and losses to Reigns before he's managed to get the big win have left him to be the man playing the role of WWE headliner rather than simply being one.

Credibility counts, and the company stole far too much of McIntyre's when he needed it most. How they present him in the months to come will be crucial if they want the grand Cardiff win to feel even remotely imminent.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.