10 Wrestlers WWE Gave Up On In 2016

A year of lost pushes, suspensions, and releases.

Neville WWE
WWE.com

2016 has been a year of unparalleled roster turnover for WWE. More than 30 wrestlers and other on-air personalities have left the company over the past 12 months, with dozens more coming in to replace them in developmental and in the main roster. The talent pool is almost unrecognisable compared to what it looked like a year or two ago, and this looks set to continue into 2017.

The talent overhaul isn't restricted to hirings and firings, though. 2016 has seen WWE take renewed interest in guys like Dolph Ziggler and The Miz, who looked dead in the water in January, but are now among the most important acts in the company. On the other side of the equation, countless other wrestlers have been shunted down the card and either de-pushed, or abandoned completely.

WWE have a gigantic roster, and it's easy for wrestlers to get lost in the shuffle. The battle for screen time is fierce, and while the company now produce more original weekly programming than ever before, they don't have room to accommodate everybody, and unfortunately, 2016 will likely leave behind a well-stocked graveyard of once promising wrestling careers.

The company have lost faith a number of competitors this year. Some may eventually work their way to prominence, but others have already been released, and 2016 has been a year to forget for many of WWE's employees.

Here are 10 wrestlers WWE gave up on in 2016.

10. Titus O'Neil

Titus O'Neil Darren Young Bob Backlund
WWE.com

Titus O’Neil is a former WWE Tag Team Champion, but he’s never been anything more than a lower-midcard player throughout his time with the company. The former Prime Time Player has rarely been used as anything other than a slightly upgraded jobber, but 2016 has been absolutely brutal to him, even by O’Neil’s standards.

The 2015 Celebrity Dad of the Year actually enjoyed a relatively bright start to the year. He wasn’t exactly striding up the card, but Titus was being featured with increasing regularity on Raw and SmackDown, and looked set to slot into a comfortable midcard role.

That all ended during Daniel Bryan’s retirement ceremony in February, when he O’Neil playfully grabbed Vince McMahon in the aftermath. The result? A ludicrous 90-day suspension (later shortened to 60), and the end of his mini-push.

O’Neil returned to television in May, and he was buried immediately. Rusev obliterated him in front of his family then wrecked him in two consecutive US Title matches, and O’Neil slotted into the year’s worst feud alongside Darren Young, his former tag team partner. From there, Titus inherited the deathly “Titus Brand” gimmick and a sizeable losing streak, and while he remains a good PR figure for WWE behind the scenes, his onscreen career is dead in the water.


9. The Vaudevillains

The Vaudevillains
WWE.com

Once one of NXT’s most popular acts, The Vaudevillains have been a complete flop on the main roster. Their olde timey strongmen gimmicks haven’t gotten over like they did in NXT’s smaller buildings, and they’ve been given few opportunities to show what they can do on the mic and in the ring. They’re below even The Ascension in SmackDown’s tag team hierarchy, which tells you all you need to know about WWE’s opinion of them.

It doesn’t help that Simon Gotch got himself involved in a backstage fight with Sin Cara, of course. That incident looks like the final nail in The Vaudevillains’ coffin, but their slide towards irrelevance started long before that. Gotch & Aiden English haven’t been used with any credibility since accidentally concussing Enzo Amore at Payback, and in all likelihood, they never will be again.

It’s a shame for Aiden English, who has done absolutely nothing wrong through all of this, but perhaps The Vaudevillains were doomed from the start. Their cartoony gimmick was fine in NXT’s carnival-like atmosphere, but it has died a death on the main roster. Repackaging them would mean stripping away the one thing that made them popular in the first place, but it might be their only hope.


8. Darren Young

DARREN YOUNG
WWE.com

How do you make Darren Young “great again?” Not by giving up halfway through, that’s for sure.

Young’s reinvention began quietly on SmackDown before eventually spreading to Raw. Months passed between his first motivational vignette and him and Bob Backlund making their first live appearance together, and by that point, the campaign had all but ran out of steam. The Backlund/Young partnership produced a handful of fun moments, but that’s the extent of it, and their goodwill had long expired by the time they hit live television.

Young attempted to wrest the Intercontinental Title from The Miz’s clutches in the summer, but he failed. The dreadful Titus O’Neil feud followed, and when the story finished without a real conclusion, Young vanished into the abyss. He’s barely been used since, and while it’s unlikely that WWE were ever going to push him to the moon, Young’s revival has been thrown to the scrapheap.

WWE wouldn’t have invested time and effort into “making Darren Young great again” if they didn’t have plans for the guy, but their interest has died. Young himself is a solid all-round performer who probably should have been awarded a few bigger opportunities throughout his career, but this campaign has left him dead in the water. His future? Who knows, but his life coach’s work clearly isn’t working.


7. Apollo Crews

apollo crews
WWE.com

It’s easy to understand what Vince McMahon sees in Apollo Crews. The former Dragon Gate standout is absurdly athletic, exciting, and has one of the most marketable looks in the company. If he were a few inches taller, Crews would be Vince’s ideal wrestler, and he’d have likely found his way into the main event scene by now.

Sadly, it became apparent a long time ago that Crews was called up from NXT far too early. He’s a flashy in-ring performer, but he struggles greatly with microphone spots, and that’s probably why we haven’t seen him in a significant feud since his call-up. When your gimmick is nothing more than “guy who smiles a lot,” you’re probably not going to make significant advances up the card, and Crews barely even shows up on SmackDown anymore.

WWE wouldn’t have called Crews up if they didn’t have plans for him, but whatever those plans were, they’ve clearly been abandoned. He was gifted regular jobber squashes upon arrival and won a brief feud with Sheamus in June, but Crews has done next to nothing since. For now, WWE have given up on the idea of him being anything more than an occasional midcarder, but they can’t fix Crews’ problems until they start letting him show some personality on-air.


6. TJ Perkins

TJ Perkins
WWE.com

The Cruiserweight Classic was a tremendous success, and one of the WWE Network’s most watched shows throughout most of its run. It produced some of the best in-ring action that the company has seen all year, and while guys like Kota Ibushi and Gran Metalik caught the eye, TJ Perkins emerged as its biggest star.

The finals presented TJP as a megastar in the making, and as the first Cruiserweight Champion, he looked like a perfect candidate to lead the division’s revival on Raw. Exciting, charismatic, and an excellent technical wrestler, Perkins’ career hit a downswing as soon as the Cruiserweights returned to Raw. He wasn’t even featured on the first show, and as his feud with Brian Kendrick gradually descended to farce, Perkins’ push died a horrible death.

Perkins was saddled with one of the year’s worst gimmicks, and his popularity vaporised. Now, Perkins’ arrival barely garners a sigh from WWE’s audiences, and while he’s still in the title hunt, there’s little chance he wins it back at Roadblock this weekend. Whatever the reason, WWE lost all interest in Perkins as the Cruiserweight Division’s centerpiece, and Rich Swann has now overtaken him as 205 Live’s top babyface. A disappointing slide for someone who looked like a star in the making a few short months ago.


5. Neville

Neville WWE Raw
WWE.com

Neville’s 2015 wasn’t exactly a roaring success, but 2016 was the year WWE finally gave up on the high-flying Geordie. He has become a near mythical presence, and while he started the year by challenging Kalisto for the United States Championship, he barely even appears on Raw anymore.

Neville suffered a nasty ankle injury while wrestling Chris Jericho back in March, but he seemed like a dead cert for the revived Cruiserweight Division. Neville, after all, is one of the best all-round wrestlers on the roster, and his familiarity made him an excellent candidate to play a leading role as the division re-established itself.

Bewilderingly, Neville has been completely omitted from the division, and there are no signs of him entering it anytime soon. This would be an easier pill to swallow if WWE had other plans for him on Raw, but they don’t: he’s only been used half a dozen times since returning from injury in July, and he’s currently MIA.

If WWE hadn’t given up on Neville, he’d be starring on 205 Live right now. Sure, he might not be the most charismatic performer on the roster, but he has always been an excellent wrestler. He’d absolutely shine on WWE’s newest brand, but that’s not happening anytime soon.


4. Paige

Paige WWE
WWE.com

Paige has been one of WWE’s most newsworthy superstars this year, but not for feats accomplished in the ring. Her injury troubles, two Wellness Policy violations and engagement to Alberto Del Rio have made Paige a regular headline-maker throughout 2016’s second half, but her future prospects with the company have never looked more uncertain.

WWE seemingly lost interest in pushing Paige long before all this, though. Last year’s Divas Championship feud with Charlotte was a complete disaster (particularly when WWE decided that taunting Charlotte’s deceased brother would be a good idea), and Paige barely featured in 2016’s early stages. She’d go missing for weeks at a time, and while she was able to beat Charlotte twice in the summer, she hasn’t been seen on television since June 27th.

Paige has gone from a divisional centerpiece to a complete afterthought. The Women’s Revolution has completely passed her by, and while the likes of Charlotte and Sasha Banks soar, Paige is nowhere to be found. She’s still injured, but after her recent removal from Raw’s opening montage, it’s tough to say where she goes from here. An ideal world would see her make a full recovery and become a staple in the women’s division once again, but who knows how much goodwill Paige lost through her two suspensions.


3. Alberto Del Rio

Alberto Del Rio Mexamerica
WWE.com

Alberto Del Rio’s second WWE run is a tale of wasted potential. He returned from a year-long hiatus to defeat John Cena for the United States Title at Hell In A Cell 2015, which sounds like a successful re-debut on paper, but ultimately proved disastrous. The “MexAmerica” angle with Zeb Colter made no sense from the start, and while Del Rio was able to hold onto the US Title for a few months, he was soon absorbed into the ill-fated League Of Nations.

The League was a huge failure for each of its members, and all four of them were immeasurably weakened by the time they split. Having already lost his title to Kalisto, Del Rio went back to obscurity, and while he did participate in this year’s Money In The Bank ladder match, he was no more than a spot-filler.

ADR was eventually drafted to SmackDown, but he was rarely featured. WWE had clearly lost all interest in doing something with the guy, and by mid-August, he found himself on the receiving end of a 30-day Wellness Policy suspension. This effectively spelled the end for him, and Alberto agreed his release with the company on September 9th.

Allegedly promised a main event push as part of his original return, it’s little wonder Del Rio grew disillusioned with life in WWE. For whatever reason, the company lost all interest in pushing him by the end of his United States Championship run.


2. Karl Anderson & Luke Gallows

Karl Anderson Luke Gallows
WWE.com

Few acts went from something to nothing faster than Karl Anderson & Luke Gallows this year. The former NJPW duo made an explosive debut by hopping the barricade and destroying The Usos on an episode of Raw, and eventually, they connected with their former Bullet Club colleague AJ Styles to form The Club.

Everything seemed to be going well, and Anderson & Gallows looked like they were being set-up as the tag division’s biggest heels. Misfortune was just around the corner, however: their use was eventually restricted to playing Styles’ fall guys in feuds with Roman Reigns and John Cena, but the worst was yet to come. The Brand Split sent The Club their separate ways, and Gallows & Anderson have but nothing but flounder since being forced to strike out on their own.

The feud with The New Day was particularly damaging. Anderson & Gallows became a two-bit comedy act focused more on crude humour and bad skits than doing damage in the ring, and they lost to the Tag Team Champions time and time again. Their credibility was ground to dust, and while recent weeks have seen them drop the lab coats and retirement packages, WWE have done little with Gallows & Anderson since. Once one of Japan’s most prominent tag teams, they’ve become a set of glorified enhancement guys on Monday Night Raw, and the damage might be irreparable.


1. Cody Rhodes

stardust wwe
WWE.com

Wade Barrett, Damien Sandow, and a number of other popular superstars left WWE in 2016, but none were more newsworthy than Cody Rhodes. The former Stardust left of his own accord on May 22nd, citing long-term frustration with his position in the company as a primary reason, and it’s hard to blame him.

WWE never gave Rhodes a real chance to succeed as a singles act. Stardust worked for a while, but the act’s use expired the day he stopped feuding with his brother, Goldust. Cody’s WWE career had lost all direction by the end of his run, and losing to Arrow star Stephen Amell was the most meaningful thing he’d done in the year leading up to his release. It was a dire situation for the son of one of the most revered professional wrestlers in history, and thus, Cody Rhodes tendered his resignation.

Rhodes had pleaded with management to let him drop the Stardust gimmick and return to his old persona over his past six months of employment, but they weren’t interested. All he wanted was the chance to succeed as Cody Rhodes again, but WWE weren’t willing to give him an opportunity to do so, and if you believe the man himself, they shot down countless storyline ideas without reason.

WWE’s loss has been everyone else’s gain, however. Cody’s schedule has been non-stop since leaving WWE, and with appearances for companies as diverse as PWG, TNA, and EVOLVE under his belt, Rhodes will make his NJPW debut on January 4th. He’s one of the most in-demand wrestlers in the world at the moment, and his release has worked completely in his favour.


In this post: 
Neville
 
Posted On: 
Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.