10 Wrestlers WWE Gave Up On Too Soon
Great wrestlers don't always get the faith they deserve.
Not everyone gets to make it to the top. It’s unfortunate, but true: sometimes even the most talented performers aren’t rewarded with the pushes that their skills deserve. There are only so many seats at the top table, and those who’ll never find themselves in World Title contention must settle for a spot in the midcard or below.
It’s been a problem since the sport’s birth, and it’s never been more prevalent. While this isn’t exactly a boom period for WWE, wrestlers today are infinitely more athletic, skilled, and well-rounded than they were a few decades ago, and there’s more competition than ever before. From Seth Rollins to Heath Slater, the WWE roster is packed with incredibly talented performers at all levels, and some will have to be content with a career spent putting others over.
WWE fans sometimes get caught up in wanting to see so many of their favourites pushed at the same time, but there just isn’t enough room. That said, WWE haven’t always done the best job of best utilising their talent over the years, and they’ve let a number of uber-talented wrestlers slip through their fingers.
Sometimes, all the skill and charisma in the world isn’t enough to convince WWE that you’re really worth their time. Here are 10 wrestlers that WWE gave up on too soon.
10. Elijah Burke
Elijah Burke was brought into WWE’s OVW developmental system back in 2004. He was fresh off a career as an amateur boxer (with a 103-1 record, nonetheless) and was a good-to-great wrestler blessed with outstanding charisma. Combined with a flashy moveset and a great look, Burke had everything the company look for in a competitor, but his WWE career never really took off.
After a spell managing the doomed Sylvester Terkay on SmackDown, Burke switched over to WWE’s ECW revival. Personally labelled “The Future of ECW” by Vince McMahon, Burke banded together with fellow newcomers Matt Striker, Marcus Cor Von, and Kevin Thorn to form The New Breed. They feuded with the ECW Originals (Tommy Dreamer, Sabu, RVD, and The Sandman) for a while, but were ultimately defeated in their most high-profile match together at WrestleMania 23.
A familiar downward spiral followed. The New Breed continued to pick up losses, and when the stable disbanded, Burke became an afterthought. He was released from his WWE contract in 2008, but found great traction with his D’Angelo Dinero character in TNA, where he currently works as a colour commentator.
Being stationed on the ill-fated ECW project likely didn’t help, but that doesn’t change the fact that Burke was never given a fair chance to succeed, even on the 'C' show. He had everything but size working in his favour, and his lack of mainstream wrestling success is a mystery.
9. Colt Cabana
Always one of the most popular babyfaces on the independent scene, Colt Cabana signed a WWE contract back in April 2007. He debuted as “Scotty Goldman” on an episode of SmackDown just over a year later, but made only a handful of appearances on main roster television and was eventually released following a February 2009 squash loss to Umaga.
Once CM Punk’s right hand man in Ring of Honor, Colt Cabana’s WWE run was an absolute shambles. Despite his obvious charisma and comedic ability, Cabana was rarely given a chance to show the world what he’s capable of. WWE tried to build fan interest with his “Good as Goldman” video series on WWE.com, but he was so rarely used on SmackDown that he was never going to connect with live crowds. At one point, Cabana went a whole five months between televised matches. That says it all, really.
Colt Cabana remains a cult figure on the indy circuit. A perfectly capable wrestler, his real strength comes from his charisma, and he’s comfortably the most notable comedy wrestler outside of WWE and TNA today. He’s built a huge personal brand through his Art of Wrestling podcast, and while he’s likely happy with the freedom afforded by an independent lifestyle, he could’ve been huge in WWE had they given him the microphone more often.
8. Brian Kendrick
Brian Kendrick has been in and out of WWE more times than most over the past few years.
First first run came as “Spanky” from 2003-4, before taking a year away from the Stamford giant and returning in 2005. Alongside Paul London, he became the longest-reigning WWE Tag Team Champion of all-time, and while tag wrestling wasn’t exactly at its peak during their reign, London and Kendrick were an exciting, dynamic set of competitors who rarely failed to deliver.
The 2008 WWE Draft sent Kendrick and London to separate brands and effectively ended the team. While London suffered, Kendrick thrived on SmackDown as THE Brian Kendrick. Flanked by his new bodyguard, Ezekiel Jackson, Kendrick adopted a cocksure rockstar-esque gimmick, and reinvented himself as one of the blue brand’s premier heels.
Kendrick enjoyed a short, fruitful singles run during which he actually became WWE Interim Champion at Unforgiven ‘08, though Triple H eventually walked out with the gold.
He faded away shortly after. Though he’d established himself as a great villain, his appearances became increasingly sparse, and he was released in July 2009 amid reports of significant personal problems.
There’s a strong chance WWE will bring the current Cruiserweight Classic participant back to help flesh-out Raw’s new Cruiserweight division, but Kendrick will never reach his old level. Unfortunately, his personal issues got the better of him, and WWE opted to cut him loose rather than help him through them.
A giant shame, as Kendrick looked to be on his way to becoming a major star.
7. D.H. Smith
Now wrestling as Davey Boy Smith Jr. in Japan, D.H. Smith comes from a legendary bloodline.
As The British Bulldog’s son, Stu Hart’s grandson, and Bret Hart’s nephew, Smith had an immediate pathway into the business, and he bolstered his great genetics with immense strength and power inside the ring. Though he struggled with charisma, Smith had all the tools to be a permanent fixture in the upper-midcard, but he was fed on scraps through his WWE career.
Smith initially ran afoul of the company’s Wellness Policy just two weeks after his 2007 debut, and was quickly relegated to Sunday Night Heat. After struggling to impress, WWE saw fit to push him back down to their FCW developmental territory, but Hart re-emerged alongside Tyson Kidd and Natalya in 2009. The Hart Dynasty were able to capture tag title gold on two occasions, but they dissolved in 2011, and Smith was released shortly after.
Since leaving WWE, Smith has developed into one of the best “big man” wrestlers on the planet. He’s still as strong as an ox, and after adding significant technical acumen to his game, there’s not a wrestler alive that he can’t hang with. You’d think that WWE would always have a use for such a multi-talented second-generation athlete, but alas.
6. Evan Bourne
Better known as Matt Sydal, Evan Bourne was a high-flying indie standout who was a rare highlight during one of WWE’s darkest periods.
Bourne always dazzled with his vast array of flips and tricks in the ring, but was torn from ECW before getting a chance to wear the hold, and found himself lost and rudderless on Raw. His in-ring performances were never in doubt and the fans were always on his side, but his only real success came as a one-time WWE Tag Team Champion.
Sadly, Bourne fell victim to injury and fell victim to the Wellness Policy multiple times during his six-year WWE tenure. There were times when WWE let Bourne take the stabilisers off, and when they let him go out and do his own thing, the fans loved it. Unfortunately, WWE never looked like they had any real faith in him as a singles star, and while Bourne’s own poor decisions undoubtedly played a part, his size (5’9”, 185lbs) likely didn’t help either. Nor did his debilitating injuries, which left him pinned to the sidelines for a long time.
Now working for New Japan Pro Wrestling and a host of indies across the globe, the former Bourne is once again demonstrating just how good a wrestler he is on the global stage. He’s supplemented his eye-catching high-flying style with serious mat wrestling chops to become a very well-rounded wrestler.
Had WWE not given up on him in 2014, Bourne could’ve been a big star, and a major player in the upcoming Cruiserweight division.
5. Kenny Omega
Current Bullet Club leader Kenny Omega is the only wrestler on this list to never make his main roster debut for WWE. Indeed, many wrestling fans don’t even know that Omega was briefly under WWE contract from 2005 to 2006, competing solely at their Deep South Wrestling territory.
Working under Bill DeMott, John Laurinaitis, and Bob Holly, Omega has frequently criticised his time in DSW since being released. Claiming the opportunity to train with British wrestling legend Dave Taylor was the only positive experience, Omega states that WWE did very little to help develop his abilities in DSW, and when he requested his release, the company made no effort to retain him.
Omega has since proved WWE’s lack of faith to be a huge mistake. In NJPW, Omega is a multi-team singles and tag team champion, and notably defeated the legendary Hiroshi Tanahashi to win the company’s IWGP Intercontinental Championship this past February. He’s not just a great wrestler, but one of the biggest gaijin (foreign) wrestlers in Japan today, and he has absolutely perfect his villainous anime-inspired “Cleaner” character.
Having reportedly turned down numerous WWE contract offers throughout 2014 and 2015, Omega and his stablemates The Young Bucks have been openly goading The New Day since the start of the year. Perhaps there’s a chance we’ll see Omega wrestle for them again, but for now, he goes down as one of WWE’s most mishandled prospects.
4. MVP
Everything about Montel Vontavious Porter screams “superstar.” From his look and charisma to wrestling ability and star quality, he had everything he needed to become and World Title-level player for WWE. MVP pulled off his flashy gimmick with bravado and flair, and while there was always a long line of wrestlers ahead of him when it came to World Title contention, he could’ve helped lead WWE for years to come.
He experienced a decent level of success as United States Champion, but he never elevated beyond that point. MVP took off through his feud with Matt Hardy in 2008, but even with his heat with the crowd at a peak, MVP struggled badly when he and Hardy were finished. He continued to float around the midcard for a few more years before eventually receiving his release in 2011, which he requested so he could live out a dream of wrestling for NJPW.
MVP achieved more than most WWE midcarders, but he was capable of so much more. He had every single attribute the company could want in a main eventer, and has since proved that by playing a huge important role in TNA from 2014-15. Currently a free agent, MVP was widely-tipped to return to WWE as part of the 2016 Brand Split, but this has yet to materialise.
3. Drew Galloway
It was clear that WWE had big plans for Drew Galloway upon his debuted. Branded Vince McMahon’s personal “Chosen One” and a future WWE Champion, Drew embarked on a successful opening run that saw a credible Intercontinental Championship reign come his way. It looked like WWE were set to deliver on the self-built Drew Galloway hype, but like so many before him, Galloway faded badly after losing the belt.
He re-emerged as part of the 3MB jobber stable with Jinder Mahal and Heath Slater in 2012, and found himself stuck with the comedy rockstar gimmick for the remainder of his tenure. While Slater himself was a natural in the role, Galloway had far too much potential to spend his peak years screwing around as a WWE enhancement talent, and he was released from the company in 2014.
Galloway was far from the finished article when he debuted, and fans were vocal in their criticism of his early push. As Drew became more and more seasoned, however, his in-ring abilities improved exponentially, and he’d developed into a great wrestler by the time he left the company.
Since then, Galloway has become one of the hottest tickets on the American and British independent circuits, and can be found tearing it up for companies like TNA, Evolve, and Scotland's ICW on a weekly basis.
Lord knows what happened for Vince to go from seeing Galloway as “The Chosen One” to a comedy jobber, but had the company shown a little more faith, Drew would be a major player in today’s WWE.
2. Damien Sandow
The recently-released Damien Sandow is one of this list’s saddest inclusions. Have been in the WWE system from 2002 to 2007, Sandow returned to the company through Florida Championship Wrestling in 2010, and became a permanent fixture on the main roster with his Intellectual Savior of the Masses gimmick in 2012.
Natural on the microphone, a great character actor, and a skilled in-ring technician, Sandow quickly became one of WWE’s premier heels. His snooty intellectual act was hugely over with the crowd, and he was making giant leaps up the card whether working on his own, or alongside Cody Rhodes as one half of the Rhodes Scholars.
Sandow’s career looked to be heading for the stratosphere as he won the 2013 Money in the Bank briefcase, but his failed cash-in on John Cena started a long, slow decline. Taking on a grim impersonation gimmick, Sandow soon found himself hired as The Miz’s “stunt double.” Despite being lumbered with a gimmick that would kill most careers, “Damien Mizdow” was a gigantic hit.
Sandow became a hugely popular babyface against all odds, but his career floundered as soon as he and Miz split, and he was released this May.
Damien Sandow is the perfect example of a perfromer who took every idea that was thrown his way, good or bad, and made the most of them. WWE had a huge chance to push him as a top level babyface when his alliance with The Miz ended, but they opted not to, and thus concludes one of the biggest “missed opportunity” stories in wrestling history.
1. Ethan Carter III
WWE had absolutely no idea what they had on their hands with Ethan Carter III. As Derrick Bateman, the current TNA worker spent four years in WWE development from 2009 to 2013. He was a competitor on NXT’s fourth season, and with Daniel Bryan as his mentor, he made it to the competition’s final three before being eliminated.
He’d return for NXT’s fifth season and started sporadically appearing on WWE television, but never really made a mark. Bateman, however, continued to feature prominently on NXT television all the way up until his 2013 release.
Adopting the EC3 monicker upon debuting in TNA a few months later, he was introduced as owner Dixie Carter’s spoiled nephew, and has since become a cornerstone for the Nashville-based promotion. A two-time TNA World Heavyweight Champion, Ethan Carter III can go toe-to-toe with anyone in the ring and on the mic, but it’s his character work that really stands out. While competent as a babyface, EC3 has become one of the best arrogant heels in the business, and a genuine franchise player in every sense.
Given the level of acclaim he’s received since joining TNA, it’s baffling that WWE couldn’t find something better to do with him. As Bateman, EC3 was rarely used as anything other than a comedic goofball, and while he was fine in that role, his work since leaving WWE proves he was destined for bigger and better things.