10 Wrestlers WWE Shouldn't Rehire
Triple H shouldn't be tempted by ANY of these bold WWE returns post-Vince McMahon.
It's always horrible when you boot up Twitter and see endless smart-arsed comments from fans about which WWE stars should lose their jobs. Advocating that someone lose their livelihood is frankly awful, and it's important to remember that these are men and women with families - they're not just souped-up TV characters.
Rehiring them though? That's a wee bit different.
Triple H must learn from the mistakes Vince McMahon made. Of course, 'The Game' should analyse the former Chairman and CEO's successes, but he has to be wary of leaning on a re-signing policy that's both lazy and deeply unsatisfying for fans/customers. Some wrasslin' returns are best left on the cutting room floor, basically.
Exactly none of the workers listed here would add anything to the current product. In fact, in some cases, they'd actually take things backwards and act as worrying signs that Hunter was cherry-picking the worst McMahon habits to pad out episodes of Raw and SmackDown.
So, nobody's suggesting that these lads and lassies shouldn't be in pro wrestling full stop. That'd be ridiculous, and everyone's entitled to earn their corn. However, they don't deserve another crack at WWE. Here's why...
10. Shane McMahon
There goes the moneeeeeeeeeeey!
The fact that Shane McMahon was scrapped by his own daddy was some start to 2022. Being fair, Shane's ridiculous reported behaviour at the Royal Rumble (he wanted to be the bout's MVP) probably p*ssed everyone off, and it's a sure sign that this 'Boy Wonder' thinks he's the second coming of Brock Lesnar.
WWE doesn't need another Shane O'Mac ego flex, nor does it need those bloody rabbit punches that are less UFC and more playground fight. Don't get it wrong - in his prime, Shane was a credit to the product, but those days are very much over and there's no call for another go-around.
What would McMahon add to Raw or SmackDown anyway? He's an overbearing presence, so playing a background character is never going to suit him. WWE's focus should be on new stars, not the old overseer's adrenaline-spike-loving son.
Those who adore Shane will always have memories via WWE Network.
9. Eva Marie
Eva Marie has had two stints with the company, and both of them have been a complete and utter waste of everyone's time. If that sounds harsh, then try this little experiment. Sit down, really get your thinking cap on and picture even one match that's worth mentioning.
You can't do it, can you?
Eyebrows were raised when news broke that WWE had signed Marie a second time in 2020, and her eventual alliance with Doudrop was only useful for giving the one-time Piper Niven her start on the main roster. Beyond that? Nah, Eva had nothing to offer in-ring or even as a cowardly heel character.
The women's division has some excellent workers in it these days, so it'd be silly to give Marie a third try. She's just never going to match up well against the likes of Becky Lynch, Bianca Belair, Charlotte Flair or... well, anybody else on the scene.
8. Eric Young
Former SAnitY man Eric Young has recently been pondering what WWE life might've been like had Triple H been in charge when he was there. Being brutally honest, it likely wouldn't have been much different for him. Vince McMahon wasn't wrong about everybody he refused to push.
That's not meant to be insulting to EY, it's just that he was better suited to NXT than the main roster. Hey, sometimes that's fine, and it's hardly like earning a decent living on the third brand is some terrible career choice for a veteran wrestler. Young clearly yearned for more though, and he was never gonna get it.
There's no reason to suspect he'd overachieve in 2022 either.
What would the dude do? Hang around the midcard getting slapped by everyone from Gunther to Baron Corbin? Take a page from LA Knight's book, rebrand himself and become a manager for a while? Nope, Eric is better off staying put in IMPACT Wrestling.
7. Erick Rowan
Picture the scene: Erick Rowan returns to WWE and ruins Drew McIntyre's Undisputed Title celebrations by setting a giant spider on him. Suddenly, industry critics are talking about a coming boom, because ratings have gone through the roof for this arachnid-inspired World Title feud.
Or, the renamed Erick Redbeard could continue hanging around the indie circuit and making cameos on AEW programming whenever they give him a call. That isn't a better spot than tangling with WWE's top champions, but the above scenario is about as plausible as Vince McMahon's animal-in-a-cage storyline was several years back.
What a load of absolute dogsh*te that one was.
Does anyone really want to see Rowan return to the promotion, win a few squash matches and then stall? That'd surely be his fate, and it just doesn't sound very fun. He was always limited in-ring anyway, so it's not like the ex-Wyatt Family man would offer much second time round.
6. Lars Sullivan
Oh boy.
There are numerous reasons why Triple H wouldn't entertain Lars Sullivan's return. Firstly, he's been a bit of a PR nightmare in the past. Second, WWE's creative team genuinely tried to turn him into a head-turning 'Freak' who terrified all comers with his intense power-based offence and deceptively-intelligent promos, but it failed.
Nothing worked, and big Lars was eventually released in January 2021. Since then, he's spoken about anxiety issues. Obviously, everybody hopes that Sullivan can conquer those problems and find personal happiness, but that's another reason not to bring him back - being around the pro wrestling sphere, and the pressure-filled environment of WWE, probs wouldn't do Lars much good.
If he can be happy outside wrestling, then more power to him. From a strict business perspective, Trips has nothing to gain by persevering with an aborted push Vince McMahon desperately wanted to work out before finally giving up on it completely.
5. AOP
AOP pair Akam and Rezar aren't the first would-be promoters to make an arse of their upstart enterprise, and they definitely won't be the last. However, the circumstances surrounding their postponed/cancelled Wrestling Entertainment Series promotion makes for grim reading, and it'd be a miracle if fans gave the duo another chance.
Hell, it'd be amazing if wrestlers gave AOP another chance.
This writer isn't going to lie - he'd pop if the Authors Of Pain emerged as surprise one-off challengers for The Usos, or something like that. Such excitement would be extremely short-lived though, because... well, where do Akam and Rezar go after that?
There's no room for another squash match heel team on the WWE roster right now. The Viking Raiders kinda have that covered, and it'd slow their roll terribly if AOP roared back into view. Akam and Rezar might fancy another crack at playing promoter anyway, so maybe they wouldn't be interested in WWE's advances.
4. Braun Strowman
BRAAAAAAAAAAUN!
One can already see those tweets if Adam Scherr popped back up on Raw as burly bruiser Braun Strowman. Like AOP, there'd be a bit of short-term buzz if the ex-Universal Champ showed back up to launch into a feud with someone like Roman Reigns or Drew McIntyre (assuming McIntyre is getting the belt).
It shouldn't happen though. Strowman's giant quota has been filled by Omos, and WWE would find diminishing returns might hamper his return anyway. In-ring, the company burned through all of the destructive, wrecking ball chaos they could think of; they even gave the guy f*cking "Choo! Choo!" train noises towards the end, for crying out loud.
Braun has never been the most adept on the mic either. His talking mountain approach is forced and often accidentally comedic, and that'd be problematic if WWE wanted him to be taken seriously. The ship has very much sailed on Strowman as a going concern for this company.
3. Jeff Hardy
It's hard to know what the future holds. Tony Khan has intimated that AEW will stick by Hardy for now, but the 44-year-old's personal struggles are well-known and have hampered his career once again. For now, Khan has made it clear that Hardy will only be welcomed back to AEW upon completing a successful treatment program.
If Jeff leaves All Elite and becomes a free agent, Triple H might be tempted to bring him back as a midcard legend who can work with WWE's youth. That's the charmed benefit of being so well-respected as a worker and well-liked behind the scenes, but Hardy in WWE yet again doesn't feel like something that should happen.
Again, his personal and professional situations are both very, very difficult at the moment - and personal trumps professional in all departments.
2. Ric Flair
Triple H is a self-confessed Ric Flair mark.
That's not a bad thing, but it could lead 'The Game' to believe that his idol has "one more run" left in him. No, not as a full-time wrestler (or even a part-time one), but as an on-screen authority figure character or manager. After all, Ric can still promo with the best of them, right?
Truthfully, his mic work has been hit or miss for years. WWE's newfound looseness might suit Flair, but he also has a tendency to go into business for himself and try to rekindle the glory days of his 1980s pomp. Let's make something perfectly clear: Ric should not be outshining anybody in 2022.
Few honestly believe that he'll be able to resist another match after coming through that "last" one in late July. If Trips gets fooled into thinking that Ric deserves one more bout in WWE, then he's in for a nasty wake-up call. That tag effort at Starrcast, whilst interesting, was a rough watch.
Here's hoping it's the legend's last.
1. Nia Jax
Wrestling fans have had it out for Nia Jax for a multitude of reasons for years. This entry is concerned with how downright sloppy Nia was inside the ring. She hurt a few peers by being dangerous, and her TV character was dreadful by the end.
A tag-team run alongside Shayna Baszler and brief romance with Reggie couldn't save Jax from turning into one of WWE's worst full-timers. Triple H has a much better monster female worker on his books anyway - Doudrop is safe, believable and has serious potential. Nia, meanwhile, is yesterday's news.
Bringing her back would be a big mistake.
Quiz most people who watch WWE television weekly and you're unlikely to find anyone who really misses Jax. The women's division is actually better off without her, and that's just the way it is. WWE should focus on the future, not the past.
What other wrestlers should WWE avoid rehiring? For more like this, check out 10 Precise Moments When WWE PG Era Careers Ended and 10 More WWE Stars Who Desperately Need New Gimmicks!