4. Tyler Breeze
There is a reason Tyler Breeze spent three years working the supermodel gimmicks in NXT before being called up to the main roster, and it's not because hes a bad good performer. Breeze has well and truly committed to a gimmick that simply will not ever succeed on the main roster. The model schtick has been done before and it will probably be done again, and it hasn't been successful since the 80s. For one reason or another, fans just don't like characters who constantly remind them they are much more physically attractive they are. Unfortunately for Breeze, this is the basis of his character. After finally being promoted to the main roster (on a Smackdown show, it must be said), Breeze knocked off Dolph Ziggler at 2015's Survivor Series before being awkwardly paired with Summer Rae in a partnership that was so bad it was split up after just a month. No valet could get this character over. The Rock declaring Breeze as his adopted son couldn't get this character over. The model gimmick isn't ever going to be a success, despite the cries of internet fans.