4 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (28 Aug - Results & Review)

Randy Orton and Cody Rhodes get personal; SmackDown's midcard needs work; Sami Zayn ruins all!

CM Punk Sami Zayn
WWE.com

CM Punk yelled about "justice" as he peppered Sami Zayn with some stiff shots towards the end of SmackDown's main event. Neither man was supposed to be involved, but an outraged Zayn and revenge-fuelled WWE Champion couldn't resist getting their licks in as Kevin Owens vs. Gunther vs. Finn Bálor raged inside the ring. That made for a hot closing quarter hour on this week's show.

It was obvious from watching SmackDown that the live crowd were spent. They'd sat through an exhausting marathon taping, and that meant some segments on the blue side played before almost total silence. WWE sweetened things by adding in some cheers or boos where appropriate, but thankfully didn't go too overboard with the piped in noise. Remember those old, 'Oooooo-waaaaah' sounds they used on pre-taped SmackDowns for years?! Those were brutally bad.

Speaking of "brutally bad", some of the Friday night midcard needs some heavy reworking. The women's division is a bit of a struggle again despite Chelsea Green's best efforts (there's only so much she can do in the face of poor booking), the United States Title situation is a nightmare, and there are far too many characters running around with nothing meaningful to do.

Thank the wrestling lords for the main event scene then. This is one of the most ultra-competitive WWE Title mixes one can remember - Punk is champ, and check out this crew chasing him: KO, Bálor, Sami Zayn, Gunther, Cody Rhodes and Randy Orton. That's stacked, which is helping to compensate for some of SmackDown's lesser elements.

Here's all the good and bad.


Downs...

4. Pointlesshausen!

Danhausen Gunther Nick Aldis
WWE.com

Apparently, someone on creative was told: 'Just bloody well get Danhausen on the format somewhere. It doesn't matter where, but he has to be on this week's episode so we can shift some more t-shirts!'. That'd explain why the spooky little goblin's cameo performance was so lacklustre. Not even Gunther's disgusted facial expressions as he pondered exactly what a Danhausen is could save things.

Dan approached Nick Aldis asking to be made ‘Employee Of The Month’, for some reason. Then, Gunther came in to moan about the Triple Threat main event, and looked at Danhausen whilst shaking his head. That’s it, that’s all that happened. Doesn't sound too bad, does it? Well, it was absolutely pointless and not a great use of Danhausen, to be honest.

Realistically, Danhausen is at his best when he's used sparingly. He certainly shouldn't be showing up in segments with serious main event talent like this; not unless there's some purpose behind it. What? Is the 'Ring General' going to accidentally get zapped like The Miz and Kit Wilson then end up back in the NXT UK days? Nah, that's not gonna happen. Keep these dudes away from one another, please. Nothing good can come of them interacting at the moment.

This segment got yours truly thinking about the possibility of Danhausen becoming Nick's assistant. Again, please no. There's no need to force comedy skits into the booking every single week for the sake of it. We've already for enough of that with Johnny Gargano and R-Truth, neither of whom are playing before massive laughs as it is.


3. So Much For The US Title “Haircut”

Baron Corbin Trick Williams
WWE

This United States Title feud is awful, let's talk about it.

Backstage, a concerned Trick Williams asked his irritating chum Lil Yachty if he knew what he was getting himself in for by agreeing to face Baron Corbin at Sunday Night's Main Event. Yachty said all he has to do is last 5 minutes, then Trick can get back the US Title. He walked away (to the gym, apparently), then Corbin cut a promo on Williams and said: “I don’t have to be entertaining, I’m the champ”.

Yeah, maybe not the best line there! Also, he held up the belt and it still has that goofy fur lining all over it. Didn’t Baron say it was getting “a haircut” recently? What happened to that? He looks so daft when carrying that furry, bespoke 'Trick Willy' title around the place, and even more so after saying he wanted to trim the white fur clean off. If that wasn't the plan, then don't mention it during promos. Simple as that.

There's pretty much nothing to get excited about with this rivalry. Williams is feeling less and less like a potential main eventer with every passing week, and the whole 'can Yachty last 5 minutes?!' deal is flat too. Finally, if WWE does choose to put the US gold back on Trick, then what was the point of anything he's been doing over the past couple of months with Baron?! This is content for the sake of content, and that's rarely a good thing.

End it ASAP.


2. It’s Been Downhill Since The Promo

Chelsea Green Lash Legend Nia Jax
WWE.com

Chelsea Green’s promo with Nick Aldis a few weeks back on the 14 August episode was tremendous content and character work, but WWE’s creative for the interim Women's Champ has been rotten ever since. This week, she and Tiffany Stratton lost a subpar tag-team match to Nia Jax and Lash Legend. Green’s orbital bone injury was the big story, but her bid to show serious heart backfired when Jax laid her out with a tame-looking squash finish.

At times, everyone here felt like they were moving through mud, and the whole deal with Green has been messy. She’s either cleared to compete or she isn’t - they can’t have it both ways. That promo with Aldis should’ve been a springboard for Chelsea, but she’s still coming across as someone seriously out of her depth and is already back wrestling in nothing matches. Plus, there isn’t much to look forward to with Nia challenging in the near future.

If their work here was anything to go by, then that could be a stinker of a title match that does Green zero favours. She'll always be fighting against the 'utility player, not the star' tag, which is expected, but...give her a chance at least. WWE's writing has been all over the place since she earned rapturous applause for standing up to Aldis threatening to strip the title from her.

The nightmare outcome to this whole scenario is that Jax unthinkably wins the title just so Rhea Ripley has a heel to beat when she returns. Please say it ain't so.


1. A Nothing Challenge & A Feud Nobody Wants

Nikki Bella Paige
WWE.com

Paige challenging Jacy Jayne for the Women’s United States Title was a complete disappointment, sadly.

It was fairly short, boring, and it never felt for a second like Paige could win the title. On top of all that, the live crowd seemed to view the bout as a means to sit on their phones or go visit the rest rooms. That's a quite vicious takedown from the core audience considering how much noise WWE made about Paige's comeback at WrestleMania 42.

Then, post-match, Nikki Bella ambushed Paige with a sloppy spear as the live crowd sat on their hands. Hmm, Nikki vs. Paige could well be a low point for the women’s division when it happens. Unfortunately, Paige’s WWE comeback has been pretty rubbish, and The Bellas Twins (when healthy) have been stinking up the joint far too often as well. Put those struggling legacy acts together and you've got a true recipe for disaster in waiting.

Read the room, Triple H. Nobody is particularly enthused for Paige vs. Bella (Nikki or Brie once she's healthy again), and that isn't going to change. If they even dare to try and stick this on the lineup for SNME, then it'll be the designated p*** break match. Either that or Baron Corbin vs. Lil Yachty.

Here's the deal: Paige isn't especially over as a babyface in her own right at state of play in late-August 2026, and Nikki has been flattering to deceive since she returned last year too. Don't forget how miserable some of her matches vs. Stephanie Vaquer and Becky Lynch were.


Ups...

4. Tidy Enough Debut For Tatum

Tatum Paxley Alexa Bliss Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

Onto the good that SmackDown had to offer, but we're taking the gentle approach to positivity for this opening entry.

No, this wasn't the best match you'll ever see between Tatum Paxley and Michin, but it was an improvement on the women’s tag match and Paige vs. Jacy Jayne if nothing else. Plus, Tatum’s Cemetery Drive finish looked great here. Like, honestly, that's a total winner of a finishing move. It has a nice swing to it, and there's a meaty thump for the landing.

Personally, this guy isn't sure exactly how much juice Paxley’s union with Charlotte Flair and Alexa Bliss has, but it’s a good featured spot for the NXT newbie. So, choosing to look on the bright side here. Tatum will learn lots if she's put in house show 6-woman tags alongside her onscreen pals, and it's clear that Michin's job was to guide her through this debut performance as best she could. In that respect, Jade Cargill's minion did well.

Side note: WWE top brass needs to have a word with some of the women about how low impact some of their strikes and moves look nowadays. That didn’t wreck this match by any means (again, the finish in particular looked sweet), but it's just a general observation. A few of the strikes in these matches outright failed to connect, because workers were far too busy focusing on the next thing they're about to do. Slow it down a bit, please.

Minor grumbles aside, Paxley vs. Michin was the best women's division match on the show.


3. A Promo Train Worth Seeing

CM Punk Kevin Owens Nick Aldis
WWE.com

Kevin Owens came out to kick off the show and add emotional weight to Sami Zayn costing him the match vs. CM Punk last week. According to KO's speech, his mother had travelled to watch the show despite going through health problems, then Sami ruined everything for him. It was supposed to be a perfect moment until that darn El Generico stuck his beak in.

Interrupting, but probably fairly due to the fact Kev kept bringing him up, Punk then walked out to get in KO’s face. They didn't get the chance to come to blows though, because Gunther and Finn Bálor followed. Sure, this was all fairly standard WWE promo train stuff you've seen a hundred times or more, but it did lead to Nick Aldis making a Triple Threat main event: Owens vs. Gunther vs. Bálor; winner gets a crack at the WWE Title.

It was worth watching for that announcement, Kev’s emotional context involving his mum and Gunther being a top class heel. The strength of the characters involved carried this one, and sometimes there's nothing wrong with that. Actually, it's a blessing for the writing team to know they've got personalities so powerful they can make magic out of paper thin material. That's not meant as an insult to the actual scripting here, or anything, but it's another observation.

This is a tremendously robust main event scene on SmackDown right now, and that's awesome to see. Long may it continue, and long may Owens continue adding real human depth/realism to his storylines.


2. Fun Ride To Close (And More Sami Chaos)

Sami Zayn Finn Balor Gunther CM Punk
WWE.com

Firstly, it's important to address the finish to this headliner. It won't be for everyone, and it defo makes no sense that a match type with no disqualifications as a general rule just...ended without a proper outcome. What do they think this is, Hell In A Cell 2019?! Joking. If this leads to a Fatal-5-Way or something then it’ll be worthwhile. The WWE Title mix is super-competitive, at least, and there are so many branching stories to focus on or play around with.

Kevin Owens vs. Gunther vs. Finn Bálor in the main event Triple Threat was a great watch despite the fact some folks watching will detest the non-decision. It had bags of action, and it looked like anyone could come out on top. Then, Sami Zayn poked his nose into title business again by dragging Finn out of the ring mid-pin and punching referee Dan Engler. That again screwed KO out of a win, because he’d hit a stunner on Gunther and looked like scoring the 3.

From there, Zayn wiped out another official and put a stop to the match by wrecking shop before CM Punk attacked him. There were enough bells and whistles swirling around to distract from the lack of a true winner. You know what? That's perfectly acceptable on weekly episodic television here or there, and it's not like anybody in attendance felt shortchanged by what they were seeing.

There was star power, a good clip from the 3 guys officially in the match before the run-ins, then they got to see some follow up belt shots that proved logical after last week's shenanigans. More, please.


1. Tit For Tat

Randy Orton Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

Nice pink suit, Cody. Tell us you plan to go heel without telling us you plan to go heel, sir!

Randy Orton tried goading Rhodes into punching him in the mouth, thus giving up their match at Sunday Night's Main Event and the chance to challenge for the WWE Title again. In a memorable promo, he badmouthed Cody’s mother, his wife and even his dog, but Cody wouldn’t bite. Then, Rhodes showed a little devilment himself by saying we’d find out if Randy is a once in a lifetime superstar like his dad Dusty, or a total screw up like his own father Bob. Ooft!

That was good, intense stuff. Both guys managed to find a neat workaround for the lack of violence by getting personal and trying to provoke the other, but they know what's at stake so stopped short of slinging some uppercuts. You can add Cody and Randy to the long line of top talent hunting down CM Punk for the WWE Title. It's legitimately fantastic to have so many main event level workers on the prowl for that gold all at once.

Overall, this boiled down to tit for tat between old friends turned enemies, but it kinda had to be considering they can't hit Cross Rhodes or RKOs for the time being. This is every bit what their rivalry heading into 'Mania 42 should've been before someone at TKO towers decided one Pat McAfee should be the focal point. Better late than never, huh?

Another round of this personal bite would be lovely before the match in Atlanta on 6 September.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 11 Things You Didn't Know About WWE's Tatum Paxley and 13 Things We Learned From Dark Side Of The Ring: Zach Gowen!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.