10 Wrestling Grudges That Changed The Business

Some real and not-so-real grudges that transformed history and turned miseries into millionaires.

Vince McMahon Jesse Ventura
WWE.com

Wrestling is great.

Real life doesn't afford the opportunity to take every petty grudge, societal ill or enormous personal conflict and permit physical and athletic violence to be the solution. But that's wrestling's stock-in-trade! The best of wrestling remains the best of escapist entertainment, because rarely does the wrestling industry dive too deeply into the things that might be too close to the bone. The issues are instead fairly broad manifestations of actual problems, meaning the route one solution - a fight in a 20x20 ring - suits as a perfect finale. These things are predetermined, and so are the aforementioned acts of violence. Everybody wins!

Or do they? Grudges drive the best of the worked spectacles, but as The Undertaker and every other old-timer will tell you ad nauseam, this is a goddamned business, kid.

The people acting out these morality plays are there to make money for themselves more than the ones they're across the ring from. Real grudges are just as likely to form as those that appear on screen from the mind of a promoter, and unlike the escapist aspect of the industry, both kinds can have enormous consequences...

10. Bullet Club Is Fine

All In Bullet Club
Twitter (@ALL_IN_2018)

It spoke to the political power and financial stroke of Cody Rhodes, Kenny Omega, The Young Bucks and other associated key players in the Bullet Club civil war of 2018 that such a vast number of wrestlers and companies were required to get on board.

Omega and Rhodes headlined an ROH Supercard Of Honor show as well as NJPW's King Of Pro Wrestling event (along with Kota Ibushi), such was the commercial appeal of their drawn-out dissent, and when the wrestlers weren't in the ring, they were expanding on the conflict (and their own storyline world) on Being The Elite.

It was September's All In that served as a proof of concept for All Elite Wrestling, folding in all of the regulars as well as a pro wrestling philosophy markedly different from WWE's. It's ironic - the comedy-laden "Bullet Club Is Fine" plot wasn't the most popular amongst ROH and NJPW purists for how much it leaned on Sports Entertainment trappings, but the spiderweb storytelling took those principles way beyond what the market leader had been capable of and into a brand new era.


9. Stone Cold Steve Austin Vs Bret Hart

Stone Cold Steve Austin Bret Hart
WWE

Not all industry-altering grudges have to be real. The very best ones rarely are.

The very best one wasn't.

Bret Hart and Stone Cold Steve Austin's 1996/97 rivalry is so much more than what mostly gets discussed about it. And that's possibly because what mostly gets discussed is the greatest WWE match of all time. But their WrestleMania 13 classic doesn't happen without months of carefully-constructed character work, the willingness of Bret Hart to get wrestling's next big thing all the way over, and a keen eye from the promotion to finally catch up with pop culture.

Hart returned as a hero at the 1996 Survivor Series, but was the first to notice that heroes weren't cool anymore. In a genius bit of storytelling, he was simultaneously telling the truth and in denial. He tried to brush off Austin's attacks, Shawn Michaels' attitude problems and The Undertaker and Sid's thirst for the title, but those conflicting factors kept screwing him out of his one noble goal. By the time he snapped in the go-home angle to the 'Show Of Shows', fans had been given long enough to get used to disliking their former favourite.

The Submission Match was the elite-level icing on a perfectly prepared cake.


8. The Rock Vs Faarooq

The Rock Faarooq No Way Out
WWE

It goes a little unreported that The Rock may not have become "the most electrifying man in all of entertainment" without the gracious showings of Nation Of Domination leader Faarooq during a key development checkpoint.

Rocky Maivia was every bit as good as every commentator told you, but he was every bit as green as he looked too. The backlash that followed forced through a heel turn, but it was only by gradually growing in confidence and growing out of the Nation did Rock race towards the top of the card quicker than anybody could have predicted. Just over a year on from his debut he was feuding over the Intercontinental Championship with Stone Cold Steve Austin, but 'The Rattlesnake's decision not to actually put him over for the belt was somewhat telling.

Faarooq had no such problem. Not only did Rock replace his former boss as the new "Ruler" of the group, but he beat him in matches and ritually humbled and humiliated him in side-splitting segments. Ron Simmons, gimmick or not, had pedigree and immense respect banked. He cashed it out for the good of getting 'The Great One' all the way over, and nothing could stop him afterwards.


7. WWE Vs Its Own Audience

Triple H
WWE

Now commonly shared thanks to the meme engagement accounts on X, the Triple H lecture towards basically all disillusioned WWE fans on the July 21st 2014 edition of Monday Night Raw has rightfully become infamous for how stupid and self-destructive it was.

You know the one - "me and my friend Mark are going to complain on the Internet" and so on. It might have been an in-character dig at fans yet again not getting on board with John Cena (or Roman Reigns, or Randy Orton, or anybody else they relentlessly and transparently forced on people), but it was cutting and spiteful and the company was eventually made to pay for it. The drop in viewing figures between 2014 and 2022 was a steeper one than television averages by orders of magnitude, and the slide was, ironically, only truly arrested by Paul Levesque taking over when Vince McMahon resigned in disgrace.

WWE will hopefully be less of an antagonistic company in the future, but the damage was already done. By chasing off millions, they created the call for their own competition. AEW exists because they WWE wilfully destroyed their own monopoly.


6. WCW Fans Vs Hulk Hogan

Hulk Hogan WCW Bash at the Beach 1996
WWE.com

Hulk Hogan was so uncertain of whether or not to turn heel at Bash At The Beach 1996 that WCW had to prepare Sting to do the honours just in case. But when he dropped the big leg on Randy Savage to kick off the New World Order storyline, he triggered a chain of events that would change the fortunes of two major promotions and countless wrestlers for decades to come.

He had to do it too. Short of the brief period before the novelty wore off in 1994, WCW fans were sick of Hogan's schtick whilst he was still with WWE. Beyond business growth, 'The Hulkster' offered them nothing emotional to cling on to, and everything to despise. When he gave them that, they gave World Championship Wrestling everything.

There's a timeline where the industry is different beyond reconciliation if Hogan never turns. WWE's business was recovering from it's 1995 nadir, but things such as the rise of Stone Cold Steve Austin or even anything Attitude-adjacent might never have occurred without WCW's homework to copy. ECW's influence was only ever going to stretch so far, but the Atlanta outfit was real competition for the first time ever and McMahon and his many new talents were more than ready for the war.

To say it was a paradigm shift undersells it - Hogan pulling the pin out of that specific grenade created an explosion wrestling desperately needed.


5. CM Punk Vs The Elite, 2022

Hangman Page CM Punk
AEW

As of this writing, CM Punk won't be wrestling anywhere, let alone in AEW.

Recent rumours of his shocking WWE return have been diffused by those within the company, and though there'll be plenty that hold on to the idea that all of that's a work, it's been reported by at least two fairly reputable sources and has, for now, become the accepted narrative. Many, many fans will be glad to hear this.

His run in All Elite Wrestling was a utopian dream at first; a glorious parade of detailed and dynamic matches that hit every nostalgic sweet spot while gracefully building a bigger picture programme in which he rose to be AEW World Heavyweight Champion. All of that folded in a feud with MJF that earned plenty of consensus votes as the best story in company history, but it proved to be the beginning of the end.

Having beaten everybody in his path, Punk wanted the belt, but the now-infamous promo exchange with Hangman Page changed everything, and everything became everything else. This spilt over during the even more infamous "Brawl Out" press scrum, which ultimately resulted in everything else that followed in 2023...


4. CM Punk Vs The Elite & Friends, 2023

CM Punk Jack Perry
AEW

CM Punk made it to one of the biggest wrestling shows of all time by working Samoa Joe in an immediate cult classic at All In London, but as tensions built between the warring factions along the way, it became increasingly likely he wouldn't make it much further.

This was as good as confirmed when things got physical backstage literally minutes before 'The Voice Of The Voiceless' was set to go out to the ring. Punk and Jack Perry were involved in a real fight after the former Jungle Boy referenced an argument they'd had over fake glass down the lens of the camera during the pay-per-view pre-show. The situation followed weeks of stories emerging about who could and couldn't be on Collision with Punk, who was and wasn't welcome in AEW locker rooms, and what exactly was the nature of the relationship between Punk and boss Tony Khan. When Khan himself revealed that he was left "fearing for his life", it was clear things were untenable.

AEW released the former World Champion "with cause" later that week, preparing in the process to embark on a new era conclusively without one of the most divisive figures in industry history.


3. Hulk Hogan Vs Jesse Ventura

Vince McMahon Jesse Ventura
WWE.com

As far as heel voices in the booth went, there was perhaps no rival of Hulk Hogan's more convincing than Jesse Ventura. And it could have well been thanks to getting in the way of any attempt at fiction.

As far back as 1986, 'The Body' had attempted to bring wrestlers together around the idea of unionisation, but his plans were thwarted by none other than 'The Hulkster' himself.

Speaking on Stone Cold Steve Austin's podcast's in detail about the situation, Ventura said;

"It was WrestleMania 2. Two weeks before it, all the publicity had gone out. The advantage was ours...I stood up in the dressing room and I gave a speech to the boys and...I said, ‘if we go together and simply tell the media we are not wrestling unless union negotiators by federal law come in and give us the opportunity to unionise.’ The next night, I got a phone call from Vince who basically threatened to fire me if I ever brought it up again and read me the riot act...When I sued Vince, we had to depose him. My attorney...said, ‘Mr. McMahon,’ he said, ‘has there ever been a union in wrestling?’ Vince [replies], ‘no.’ [The lawyer asks] ‘Anyone ever try to form one?’ Vince sat a minute, he says, ‘well, yeah, as a matter of fact, Jesse Ventura spouted his mouth off about it once years ago.’ And my attorney goes, ‘well, how do you know that? Did you hear him? No? Well, how did you know he spouted his mouth off?’ He didn’t even hesitate. ‘Hulk Hogan told me’."

Ventura was initially in disbelief, until the trial revealed the motivation behind Hogan's betrayal of trust. He explained;

"Well, in the trial, we got the [financial] records of WrestleMania 3, the big one, him and Andre [The Giant], well, Hogan made more money than all of us combined, including Andre...So, naturally, he didn’t want a union...the picture was crystal clear to me, that he sold us out because he was getting taken care of and he didn’t want nobody else horning in on the good deal he had.”

Ventura worked with the company until 1990, being forced to stay on terms with both Hogan and McMahon. But with the best opportunity lost, the conversation - outside of a passing fancy in 2020 - never really came up again.


2. Bret Hart Vs Shawn Michaels

Bret Shawn Raw
WWE.com

There is - thankfully - just about nothing left to say about the Montreal Screwjob a full quarter of a century after it took place. But we still speak about the ramifications to this very day, because we live in the ramifications to this very day.

Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels had to implode when they did, both men needed to be out of the main event picture for Stone Cold Steve Austin to ascend without unnecessary obstacles and distractions, and the post-WrestleMania clean slate (a generous description of WWE's fairly lean roster, but a fresh set of wrestlers all the same) was vital for 'The Rattlesnake' to feel like the true top of the pile. What happened after that changed the industry, and what remained in the aftermath was a monopoly blown to bits by 2019 to allow for AEW to exist. It is simply still as pivotal as that.

Survivor Series 1997 saw to it that 'The Hitman' was unceremoniously out of the picture, and though the rivalry between Hart and Michaels didn't directly lead to the career-shortening injury 'HBK' suffered just two months later, his spiralling personal problems were only expedited by this bitter dispute. A breakdown of some description was headed Michaels' way - the physical kind just got there first.


1. Sasha Banks Vs Bayley

Sasha Banks Bayley NXT Takeover Brooklyn
WWE.com

Good Friends, Better Enemies was the legendary subheading of an In Your House with a legendary main event, but if Shawn Michaels and Diesel's wild No Holds Barred marked something coming to an end, Bayley and Sasha's 2015 classic (and fabulous sequel) proved to be the start of something special.

The road to total equality unfortunately remains a long and rocky one in pro wrestling, but never had North American women's wrestling felt so vital, on-the-pulse and game-changing as it did when 'The Hugger' and 'The Boss' went to war over the NXT Championship.

As with 'Big Daddy Cool' and 'HBK', Banks and Bayley were real life best friends, and the competitive and collaborative will to coax all-time displays out of each other became a staple of their iconic series. TakeOver: Brooklyn played host to a long-awaited title win for Bayley and a match that was firmly the most important of the 2010s for WWE. Fans tore the roof off SummerSlam's venue one night earlier before the show itself, and nothing topped it for the remainder of the weekend. An Iron Woman rematch the following month was yet more history made, and never had the chants been louder for this to be replicated everywhere across the company.

By WrestleMania 32 the following spring, the "Divas" division was dead and buried, with the Women's Championship reborn in the process. The three years that followed brought about an all-women's pay-per-view, overdue gimmick match inclusion across the calendar year, and a WrestleMania 35 main event.

It all started with the believable spark of hatred between two women that clearly loved their work.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.