10 Wrestling Matches Booked Out Of Spite
Wrestling, cruel? Vince McMahon, vindictive? But he puts smiles on faces, pal!
Googling "is spite a powerful motivator" is an eye-opening experience.
From 1000-word thinkpieces to Reddit threads and just about everything in between, there exists a litany of lived experiences of those that have taken this fiercely negative emotion and manifested something broadly positive in their own lives off the back of it.
Vince McMahon is probably not one of those authors, but only because he keeps this particular brand of stubbornness in his default settings. It's every story you've ever heard; from bullying Jim Ross, to losing interest a wrestler because a trusted aide really likes them, to sucking down filet mignon or a "steak wrap" as the rest of his staff go hungry, he's got a mean streak as long as an airport test-passing wrestler's legs.
Spitefulness is fuel to a man in a constant state of idiotic competitiveness with everyone and himself, not least one that's only slept two hours a night for the least 50 years needs. It hasn't hurt him as a promoter either - almost all of the entries in this list are McMahon specials.
He was the man who wanted "Ruthless Aggression" after all...
10. The 2005 Royal Rumble
As spitefully funny as it might be remembering the sight of Vince McMahon no-selling a torn quad with his a*se planted on the canvas like a child, this is not the 2005 Royal Rumble's meanest moment.
Not least because it wasn't planned - real spite involves a certain element of pre-meditation, and that was scarily evident when Daniel Puder entered the titular battle royal to take an on-screen "hazing" for some supposed crimes the year prior.
The Tough Enough winner entered the match third, right as competitors #1 & #2 Eddie Guerrero and Chris Benoit were gleefully beating the sh*t out of each other. Naturally, they paused that conflict to sadistically smash the sh*t out of the newbie, as did entrant #4 Hardcore Holly as a supposedly random drawing exposed itself as anything but.
Puder had infamously caught Kurt Angle out during another borderline-abusive Tough Enough segment the prior summer, and the locker room heavies clearly enjoyed making him pay for this apparent act of disrespect.
The beating was too on the nose for its own good, and the sort of thing that thankfully wouldn't ever happen again.
9. The Big Show Vs Akebono (WWE WrestleMania 21)
For almost all of his time in WWE, The Big Show was considered overweight by his employers.
A quick revisit of the Ross Report archives from shortly after his 1999 signing paint the picture that reflected most of his time before a 2006 sabbatical. The big man was too big in the eyes of his bosses, and no relegation trips to OVW or injury layoffs seemed to be addressing that.
It's fair to say Paul Wight was packing more tonnage than he had during his breakout years in WCW, but wholly unfair to suggest he was the sort of size in keeping with sumo wrestling.
Alas, this was his lot at 2005's WrestleMania 21 when he took two-sports star Akebono in an exhibition that made him look multifariously daft. Long zooms on his dimpled and mostly-exposed a*se were done for the benefit of those guffawing in the Gorilla position rather than any kind of artistic expression, and the match itself failed to illicit anything from an otherwise molten audience.
8. Goldberg Vs The Fiend (WWE Super ShowDown 2020)
How else could one explain it if it wasn't spite?
Never has the assumption felt safer that Vince McMahon hates just about everything he promotes than in the 202s. He's shown open disdain to his talents in front of 24/7 Network cameras, he's fired at will (or at very least signed off on Nick Khan spreadsheet deletions) in mass releases, and he's killed gimmicks dead just for the sake of it so often it's become one of WWE's troubling new normals.
The latter philosophy never looked as apparent than at pandemic curtain-raiser Super ShowDown 2020. He hates his consumer base because they don't pay him as much as shareholder investments or Saudi Arabian paymasters, and both were presumably satisfied enough with the record profits that they didn't care much for Bray Wyatt's spooky clown character getting bulldozed by a visibly ageing WCW relic with mere weeks to go before a planned WrestleMania title defence against Roman Reigns.
McMahon got out of his balmy bed that day and decided that the whole thing sucked (he wasn't wrong, but he shouldn't have booked that either), and crushed Wyatt so emphatically that it took an epic John Cena WrestleMania rebuild to remotely salvage it for one last stay of execution.
7. Tay Conti Vs Santana Garrett (AEW Rampage Pre-Show)
Friday 16th October 2021 brought about feelings that had laid dormant for the better part of two years.
The most tribal of the WWE/AEW fanbases were encouraged to engage in yet another ratings battle that - unlike most of Wednesday's encounters - might have actually scanned as a war. A super-sized SmackDown was front-loaded in an effort to throttle that Friday's Rampage during a rare half an hour overlap between the shows.
In response, All Elite Wrestling added a one-hour YouTube pre-show to their one hour TV show, resulting in 90 minutes of live head-to-head action between the streaming platform and Fox.
Both sides were magnificently petty - WWE utilised Brock Lesnar, Roman Reigns and a monster Sasha Banks/Becky Lynch match, while AEW chased random magic with Bryan Danielson Vs Minoru Suzuki and not-so-random spite with Tay Conti Vs Santana Garrett.
The latter clash had real spice - Garrett/Conti was the first thing that ever defeated AEW in a viewership quarter hour in the earliest days of NXT and Dynamite going head-to-head. With Conti now an AEW regular and Garrett available for the night, a throwback fight night saw one side land a remarkably sly jab.
6. Adam Cole Vs Matt Riddle (WWE NXT, October 2nd)
It was the black and gold brand's biggest match at the time (and it proved to be one of the show's best ever too), but Adam Cole Vs Matt Riddle on the October 2nd 2019 episode of NXT was representative of something much bigger than the NXT Championship.
A certified TakeOver headliner in the pre-AEW era, the match was built up for that specific time because WWE were keen to try and marginalise their new competition from the off.
This was Night One of a new wrestling and the mandate was clear - Dynamite was to be challenged not with a show that gradually built to the biggest matches, but with the biggest matches, and all the time.
Predictably, the show couldn't keep doling out these massive matches on a weekly basis, not least considering how it flew in the face of Triple H's rather measured approach to the show over its peak years. The increased desperation was clear within the first year of a supposed war that ended up being something of a massacre.
5. Triple H Vs CM Punk (WWE Night Of Champions 2011)
"Am I f*cking going over" was supposedly the only question Triple H had for certain WWE writers when he was running Raw with his deathly dull iron fist in the mid-2000s. By 2011, he could answer the question himself.
Unfortunately for CM Punk, "f*ck yeah I'm going over!" wasn't ideal for the run he was on.
'The Voice Of The Voiceless' had already returned a touch too early from his transcendent WWE Championship victory at Money In The Bank, then won a rematch against John Cena in less-than-clean fashion then found himself battered by Kevin Nash and dethroned by Alberto Del Rio. Detonating a Pipe Bomb had started well, but suddenly he was losing way more than he was winning.
The intended Night Of Champions clash with Nash would have surely gone his way, but when 'The Game' stepped in for his injured mate, the figurative betting may as well have been suspended.
Hunter had fumed on-screen with a couple of Punk's near-the-knuckle gestures and remarks, and presumably couldn't wait to plant him with a Pedigree like all the rest. This useless result was never returned to after the fact - Hunter and Punk were teaming by the next pay-per-view, and the 'Straight Edge Superstar' was about as iconoclastic as an Edge t-shirt by the time he finally regained the gold months later.
4. Lita Vs Mickie James (WWE Survivor Series 2006)
Trish Stratus' September 2006 WWE departure was so soaked in sincerity that almost nobody predicted it and even fewer imagined it was the actual end.
At an Unforgiven pay-per-view in her hometown, the beloved multi-time Women's Champion snared the strap yet again in a blinding battle with career rival Lita. Audiences trained to WWE's mean streak were stunned - Stratus was permitted to retire with the title and bask in all the glory that came with it, so when Lita was suddenly back in the picture ahead of her own planned exit in November, most safely assumed things would go the same way.
Wrong again.
Heel Lita put over Mickie James on her way out, which would have jived with all dignified traditions had she not been stripped of those before getting out of the building. Following the defeat, her retirement was converted into one last shaming of the woman who'd taken virtually all of the heat for the real life situation that had occurred with her, Matt Hardy and Edge a year prior.
Cryme Tyme were despatched to sell her personal belongings as she sold horror in the ring, including underwear, yeast infection cream and a vibrator because fundamentally stunted men rule wrestling and probably always will.
3. Bret Hart Vs Shawn Michaels (WWE Survivor Series 1997)
Far be it for this to be yet another journey through perhaps the most journeyed-through match in wrestling history, but it's worth remembering that Vince McMahon didn't have to book the match that gave him and his two top performers so many headaches in November 1997.
Or, he didn't have to unless he wanted some of the grief that came with it anyway.
Speculated on in Dave Meltzer's excellent and exhaustive Wrestling Observer documentation of the events at the time and then in Bret Hart's own fastidiously detailed autobiography, McMahon's buyers remorse upon re-signing 'The Hitman' in 1997 may have been evident as early as Survivor Series the prior year.
Commentating on Hart's return as if six months off had turned him into a knackered old veteran rather than the ex-WWE Champion that had just comfortably gone an hour in a WrestleMania main event, McMahon seemed to be sidelining him from the off.
The intentional breaking of Bret's contract in October of '97 was seen as confirmation of this scepticism towards Hart, as was the stubbornness in the booking of the Montreal match in the first place alongside its infamous and unforgettable finish.
2. Team WWE Vs The Alliance (WWE Survivor Series 2001)
One can't fairly speculate on how the great WWE Vs WCW on-screen war might have been waged (and won or lost) had the latter won the real Monday Night one in 2001, but it'd be nice to think it'd go better than concluding with Goldberg Vs Sting or another combination of Nitro main eventers everybody had seen countless times before.
Because that's what Vince McMahon foresaw when he openly admitted to being "tired of this Alliance crap....this Invasion crap" during a Raw promo that set up a Survivor Series final battle.
He was patently as bored of it as the rest of us, even though he'd been the one booking it in the first place. A ten-man tag was set, culminating in Steve Austin (Alliance) tussling with The Rock (WWE) scrapping for the umpteenth time over stakes that supposedly transformed the world as we knew it.
The mere inclusion of 'The Rattlesnake' and 'The Great One' exposed this as a fallacy, as did the post-show Monday Night Raw. Jerry Lawler was reinstalled as a commentator, McMahon and Austin were reset as heels and babyface rivals on the original side of their divide, and ex-Alliance stars worth anything were reestablished as WWE Superstars looking to make the grade.
1. The Bloodline Vs The New Day (WWE Monday Night Raw, September 20th 2021)
Less about the wrestlers within the company and more the ones on the other side, WWE offloaded one of the biggest matches they had left at just a few days notice as a grip on ratings demographic control loosened.
September 2021 marked something of a zenith for All Elite Wrestling's bold next steps, having unveiled CM Punk, Adam Cole and Bryan Danielson within the last 30 days and conclusively moved forward with Hangman Page as the successor to Kenny Omega's throne. All Out 2021 was forecasted as the company's highest selling show ever, critical acclaim for the event was reaching WrestleMania X7-levels, and the fabled seven figure viewership had become the norm.
Unsettled by all of this, WWE raced ahead with the obvious Survivor Series matches two months early. Dragging The Bloodline and now new WWE Champion Big E over to Monday Night Raw for the pure and obvious sake of it, the match performed well but didn't arrest the consistent slide (it never does) even after AEW slipped from their own pedestal.