10 Wrestling Matches Built Around Botches
When disaster flips the script, which matches needed awful before awesome?
Regardless of the extensive, often debilitating level of training professional wrestlers endure, botches remain a painful fact of life. From intricate moves landing poorly to inexplicable slip-ups, they vary in degree from the slightly embarrassing to the catastrophic.
While some botches ruin a match (or lead to its ruin thanks to endless “you f*cked up” chants), others are covered so well you’re left wondering if they were planned from the get go. The ability to think fast (and endure the pain of a bad bump) is key to saving and, in some cases, rebuilding a bout to spare it from a less than three star review from Uncle Dave.
More interesting still are the times botches, whether on the mic or during a particularly physical segment, become a key facet of the feud they took place in. Before you know it, the whole build has changed course and the blow-off match’s heat stems from a now oddly convenient accident.
While only the sickest and most twisted of viewers would ever hope to see a botch occur, the following ten provided rock solid entertainment value for all who watched them.
10. Kenny Omega Vs. Rich Swann (IMPACT Rebellion)
Maybe Rich Swann should ease up on the whole headstand thing...
A variety of explanations for the botch-laden nature of the Swann versus Omega bout have been put forward. From Swann getting concussed to his cardio being subpar, the guy’s shouldered pretty much all of the blame.
Seemingly dazed and confused, Swann ate a boatload of v-triggers as the match wore on. A story of the IMPACT champ succumbing to exhaustion at the hands of the unstoppable Omega took hold. While Omega came out of it looking as strong as ever, Swann came out looking subpar and not on the level of his opponent.
Given his delayed reaction after the apron headstand went so horribly wrong, it’s likely Swann was concussed for much of the bout, With whatever they’d had planned originally now out the window, the pair had to improvise, leading to the notably more cumbersome action that followed.
Given Kenny Omega's Belt Collector storyline this year, his dominance actually fit the narratively perfectly. Rightly presented as AEW's premier star, Omega's Thanos-like quest to rack up all the gold has been something of a boon for IMPACT in 2021. For the stars who've challenged him on IMPACT since, Omega's destruction of Rich Swann has simply served as more fuel to the fire.
A shame for Swann but a fairly effective angle in the long run.
9. Kevin Owens Vs. Sami Zayn (WWE Battleground 2016)
Remember when Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn's clash at Battleground 2016 was meant to be their final match together?
WWE sure don't.
It was a simpler time. Sami Zayn was touted as a future top babyface while Owens had already found plentiful success on the main roster as a pitiless heel. Weaving their history in ROH, PWG and NXT into one final blow-off feud, WWE presented the war between the best buds turned bitter enemies as a huge deal. Fans were into it with many hoping to see Sami Zayn finally avenge his NXT title loss to the Prizefighter the year prior.
The story of the match itself changed completely halfway in. After a solid, high intensity start, Sami Zayn's career flashed in front of his eyes following a botched sitting springboard moonsault to the outside. Instead of landing on Owens, Zayn landed his surgically-repaired shoulder on the ring apron (which, for the very rare few who haven't been reminded by WWE 600 times, is the hardest part of the ring).
Like a shark smelling blood in the water, Owens went to town on Zayn's shoulder. Working as both a callback to Owens taking Zayn out in 2015 and a sympathy-builder for the ailing babyface, Zayn's botch rebuilt the second and third acts of their match for the better. The crowd heat throughout and the reaction Zayn received when he finally overcame the injury to send Owens packing was immense.
8. Kurt Angle Vs. Shane McMahon (WWE King Of The Ring 2001)
Despite an astounding level of legitimate tough guy credibility (did you know he won an Olympic gold medal with a broken freakin' neck?), Kurt Angle often played the fool in the early years of his WWE run. Cashing in on the Olympian's unexpected knack for comedy, WWE presented Angle as an often oafish, embarrassment-prone heel.
Shane McMahon, on the other hand, was already garnering a rep for his amazing knack for surviving falls from jaw-dropping heights. The feud between the two heading into King of the Ring 2001 had mostly been played for laughs. Between the humorous set-up and the fact that Angle had already wrestled twice that night, expectations for the bout weren't the highest.
20 years later, it's still in the discussion for the most violent WWE match of all time. Angle was supposed to suplex McMahon through a pane of sugar glass. As the pair quickly learned the hard way, the crew in charge of setting up hadn't recevied the memo. McMahon clattered into the glass before landing directly on his head. While most would've considered calling it quits right there, McMahon moved ahead with Angle slamming him over and over again until two panes were shattered.
Cut, bruised and concussed, the jaw-dropping bout continued on completely different to what it had started out as. Instead of funny, Angle was a sadistic brute, stretching a physically shot McMahon before taking him out completely with a top-rope Angle Slam. Despite the concussion, McMahon managed to tweak his psychology just enough to become a defiant babyface, fighting against debilitating odds. Using the botch and the stunned crowd to their advantage, Angle and McMahon put on a near-fatal classic.
7. Shawn Michaels Vs. The Undertaker (WWE WrestleMania XXV)
Often regarded as the greatest match in WrestleMania history, The Deadman and The Heartbreak Kid rocked the Reliant Stadium on an otherwise disappointing night of WWE action.
Going head to head for the first time in 11 years, the Texan titans pulled out all the stops, including Taker's jaw-dropping dive to the outside. A WrestleMania tradition at that point, The Deadman's dive was supposed to go a little differently in 2009. A dastardly Michaels was supposed to use a cameraman (in a fun callback to heel Michaels' penchant for assaulting cameramen during his and Undertaker's '97-'98 feud) to save himself from the incoming Phenom.
Unfortunately, the cameraman (played by Sim Snuka) was too far away and failed to adequately catch Mean Mark on the way down. The Undertaker's head and shoulders wound up absorbing most of the impact in what could've been a career-ending tragedy. The typically indestructible Undertaker added a new shade to his persona for the rest of the bout. Using the scary nature of the fall to his advantage, 'Taker played a surprisingly effective face in peril.
With his opponent on the ropes, Michaels began to show a few subtle signs of his old, heel self. By the time The Deadman finally caught Michaels with the match-ending Tombstone, The Streak appeared to be the most important thing in all of WWE. A fantastic bout from bell to bell, the two legends managed to turn their botch into a blistering heat builder for the closing stretch of their first WrestleMania classic together.
6. Jushin Thunder Liger Vs The Great Sasuke (NJPW Super J Cup ‘94)
To the shock of anyone who didn’t see him in his prime, the masked marvel they call Jushin Thunder Liger was once a super heel. Despite the colourful garb and innovative high-flying offence, Liger’s vainglorious attitude made him a natural foil for masked babyfaces like Tiger Masks I-IV and The Great Sasuke.
Liger met The Great Sasuke in the semifinals of the ‘94 Super J Cup. At the peak of his powers, Liger brutalised his increasingly outmatched foe from pillar to post. The plan had been for Sasuke to mount a surprise babyface comeback and upset Liger with a springboard hurricanrana.
Sadly, gravity had other plans...
Sasuke didn’t get all of his crack at a springboard. Like a fish out of water, he flopped hard to the mat, much to his opponent’s amusement. As the villainous Liger sarcastically applauded his foe’s mishap, a furious Sasuke caught him with a flash pin for the win.
The crowd went wild, both sympathetic to Sasuke’s humbling botch and satisfied that the obnoxious Liger had received his comeuppance. The climax of the bout worked in spite of its catastrophic slip-up, fitting the personas of both men like a glove.
5. Bruno Sammartino Vs. Stan Hansen (WWWF, June 25, 1976 At Shea Stadium)
The potato punch king himself, Stan Hansen, did even more damage than usual when he got in the ring with the iconic Bruno Sammartino at Madison Square Garden. The ace of the then-WWWF was over three years (!) into his second run with the gold when he put it up for grabs against Hansen.
The future AJPW legend wound up dropping Sammartino directly on his head, fracturing his neck in the process. Despite the severity of the injury, Sammartino was back a mere two months later for a grudge match with the master of the lariat. The pair's Shea Stadium rematch was built entirely around Sammartino looking for payback for the neck injury.
The botch, presented in kayfabe as a very deliberate takedown from Hansen, gave Vince McMahon Sr. a big money angle to run with. Due to his poor state of health at the time, Sammartino could not deal out the usual grand scale, 60 minute grappling fests he was known for. Instead, they played more to Hansen's style and put on an angry, fast-paced brawl where an incensed Sammartino had the cowboy running for the hills.
As effective as the match and angle was, the botch ultimately took a severe toll on Sammartino's health. Exhausted from the work load and the chronic pain, Sammartino informed McMahon Sr. he couldn't go on and dropped the title to Superstar Billy Graham in April 1977, 12 months after the Hansen botch.
4. Stone Cold Steve Austin Vs. Owen Hart (WWE Survivor Series 1997)
"Owen 3:16 says 'I just broke your neck.'"
SummerSlam 1997 was supposed to mark the next key step in Stone Cold Steve Austin's ascension to the main event. The Intercontinental title (a prestigious prize and stepping stone to the next level back then) was on the line with champ Owen Hart set to drop it to The Rattlesnake.
Embroiled in a heated, classic rivalry with The Hart Foundation, Austin was pencilled in to take Owen down convincingly with his Stunner finish. The incredibly slow, anaemic schoolboy he rolled him up with instead left many in attendance confused and disappointed in what had otherwise been a great match. The messy end stemmed from Owen Hart botching a piledriver, compressing Austin's vertebrae and causing a brief moment of paralysis. Strangest of all was Austin himself had injured Masahiro Chono with the exact same move and mistake several years prior.
Hart, now the champion once again, began boasting of the injury he'd dealt The Bionic Redneck while Austin continued prepping for a premature return from injury. Still in dreadful pain by November, Austin's rematch with Hart was a squash. The less than five minute beatdown served to both protect Austin from any physical over-exertion and punish Hart for injuring the promotion's soon to be golden boy.
The SummerSlam botch served not only to build their Survivor Series match, but as a key feature in several major Austin storylines including his highly acclaimed feuds with Vince McMahon and Triple H respectively.
3. Sami Callihan Vs. Eddie Edwards (Impact Wrestling- June 7, 2018)
The baseball shot heard around the world led to a rebirth of sorts for Eddie Edwards. Known for his technically sound, hard-hitting bouts with the likes of American Wolves partner Davey Richards, Bobby Lashley and Naomichi Marufuji, the talented, if slightly bland, Edwards found a new side of himself in 2018.
During a post-match brawl, Sami Callihan placed a chair by Edwards' head before hitting it with his baseball bat. What no one had prepared for was the bat bouncing off the chair and into Edwards' face. The force of the rebound shot broke Edwards' nose and orbital bone with many saying he was lucky the damage wasn't even worse.
Despite reportedly feeling terrible about the botch in reality, Callihan used it to his advantage on screen for maximum heel heat. Edwards, meanwhile, used the setback as a creative opportunity to reboot his image. Returning to TV as a dangerous, hardcore brawler, Edwards ultimately won the feud with Callihan, defeating him both at House of Hardcore and in an unsanctioned bout on Impact.
The unsanctioned match proved an effective climax to a blood feud born of an all too real disaster. With the implication that the facial injuries had driven him to madness fresh in everyone's heads, Edwards was booked to attempt a murder on Callihan before cooler heads intervened. An incredibly dark moment for Impact, the feud remains a talked about fan favourite to this day.
2. Mandy Rose And Dana Brooke Vs. Shayna Baszler And Nia Jax (WWE Monday Night RAW)
First Mandy fell, then Mandy rose...
The Florida weather simply wasn't feeling WrestleMania 37. The first event with a live crowd in over a year, The Show of Shows was delayed by a vengeful storm. It was almost like God himself had finally returned for revenge after Vince McMahon scored an upset win on him and Shawn Michaels at Backlash 2006.
Needless to say, the stage was wet and slippery. What happened to The Golden Goddess could have happened to anyone. Brushing off her unfortunate stumble, Rose made her way to the ring and wrestled without any further incident.
However, as Titus O'Neil can readily confirm, WWE are not the types to let a slide, well, slide.
The next night on RAW, Rose and Dana Brooke got another crack at Nia Jax and Shayna Baszler's Women's Tag Team Championships. This time, it was Nia Jax who took a tumble or two (though she refrained from discussing the state of any orifices this time thankfully). Visibly furious, Jax went right after Rose. Scared of The Irresistible Force, Rose and Brooke high-tailed it out of there, taking a count out loss in the process.
And to think, just one year prior, Mandy Rose was in one of the most popular angles WWE had running...
1. The Undertaker Vs. Mankind (WWE King Of The Ring 1998)
Going into King of the Ring 1998, The Undertaker was dealing with a broken foot. While most mere mortals would deem that a good enough excuse to avoid physical activity, The Deadman was gearing up for a Hell in a Cell clash with Mankind.
Arguably the most dangerous WWE match of all time, it is infamous for the two death-defying drops Mankind takes early on in the bout. The first one, a fall from the top of the cell to the announcers' table below, was planned. The second one, a fall through part of the cell roof to the ring below, was not.
As Jim Ross suffered an out of body experience at ringside, Mick Foley lay in a bloodied, broken heap in the ring. One of his front teeth had relocated to his nose and there wasn't an ounce of his anatomy that wasn't injured in some way or other. Suddenly, The Phenom's broken foot didn't seem all that bad.
Whatever the original plans for their match were, 'Taker and Foley had to call an audible after the cell roof let them down. With Foley delirious with pain and anything else they had in mind for the top of the cell now out of the question, the two stumbled through a bloody, angry brawl for the next 10 minutes.
Along with leaving several years of his life behind in Pittsburgh that night, the change in story mid-match altered Foley's connection with audiences. Usually depicted as a dangerous eccentric across three differing personas, the match's eventual emphasis on his toughness moved him into more clearcut babyface territory. The scariest botch on this list, it was also one of the most creatively well-handled, ensuring an unforgettable classic was born.