10 Wrestling Matches Fans Can’t Agree On

One man's treasure is another man's utterly tedious hour of self-preservation.

Ospreay Ricochet
New Japan

I'm a fairly cynical purveyor of the wrestling landscape. That said, there are certain matches which are absolutely impossible to discount. Their brilliance can not be denied.

Steve Austin Vs. Bret Hart at WrestleMania 13 was a revelation in state-of-the-art content, unparalleled psychology, and business-busting storytelling. The famed 1990 All Japan Pro Wrestling bout, pitting company Ace Jumbo Tsuruta opposite the man who supplanted him on the night, Mitsuharu Misawa, was similarly revolutionary in that it shaped the in-ring style of AJPW in the years to come, and anointed the company's next figurehead.

A match doesn't have to make a star to reach greatness. The history of wrestling glows with incandescent classics.

Conversely, some matches have polarised the wrestling fandom to such an extent that they have generated an almost philosophical level of discussion. How long is too long? To what extent should wrestling, an industry predicated on pretend warfare, use real violence to get itself over? At which points does methodical become boring?

Those questions will rage on and on - but what follows are the most pressing ever posed...

10. The Undertaker Vs. Mankind - WWF King Of The Ring 1998

Mankind Hell In A Cell
WWE.com

Mick Foley, as Cactus Jack, had long been in the business of using real-life violence to get himself over.

At Clash Of The Champions X in 1990, Foley was tasked with wrestling Mil Mascaras - a performer so selfish that he infamously eliminated himself in the 1997 Royal Rumble match. He was happier to make himself look stupid than make somebody else look good at his expense. Knowing that Mascaras was giving him nothing, Jack made the match memorable by careening off the apron and smashing the back of his skull onto the exposed concrete below. The man was so dedicated to his art that he risked serious injury in the match, the failure of which nobody would have blamed him for.

As Mankind, he took two more psychotic bumps in his 1998 King Of The Ring Hell In A Cell bout with the Undertaker. Falling off and through the Cell, Foley had succeeded in his mission to equalise Shawn Michaels' workrate a few months prior through sheer spectacle. It was an infuriating transgression of wrestling logic to many old school minds. Foley had raised the bar by intentionally destroying himself.

Ultimately, he did not break the more sacred tenet of endangering his opponent. His artistic choice was his own; thankfully, only he is qualified to answer the question.


9. Bret Hart Vs. Owen Hart - WWF SummerSlam 1994

Bret Owen Hart Cage Match SummerSlam 1994
WWE.com

Recognised as a classic by many, those who don't share that viewpoint bemoan its lack of blood. What is a cage match about the crimson mask?

The wider storyline was, quite literally, a blood feud. Owen had turned on his brother, conclusively, at that year's Royal Rumble, to set up their classic at WrestleMania X. Owen won, in a booking masterclass, to stake a claim for the WWF Heavyweight Title at SummerSlam.

The escapist element baffled those complaining quarters also. Bret wrestled the 'Mania match with some reluctance, only intensifying his offence when his younger brother brought it out of him. In the ensuing months, his reluctance gave way to full-on remonstration - and yet, the structure of the match compelled him to run away from the very man he was now desperate to get his hands on.

The cage match, however, was the perfect stipulation; the suspense of it was so unbearable that it reflected the conflicted heart of the rivalry. There were countless creative workarounds within what would have been, in the hands of lesser talents, stymying constrictions. Owen's athletic performance, in particular, was so astonishing that he almost turned face - before underscoring his heel credentials by joining in Davey Boy Smith and Jim Neidhart's vicious post-match beatdown.


8. Mitsuharu Misawa Vs. Kenta Kobashi - AJPW 26th Anniversary Show

Many - your writer included - perceive the series of singles matches between Kenta Kobashi and Mitsuharu Misawa as the absolute high watermark of professional wrestling.

Brutal masterclasses of untouchable psychology, every last move matters and informs what happens next. Absolutely nothing is deployed arbitrarily - and nothing is deployed without a bone-crunching, wince-inducing degree of realism. If you watch pro wrestling to suspend your disbelief, there is no better example of the art.

Some of the series' most ardent supporters, however, find the sheer amount of content in the 31/10/1998 iteration difficult to reconcile with what they are willing to accept as plausible. At 43:42 in length, it is already asking a lot of the audience. Given that the first ten minutes are almost entirely comprised of Kobashi, forever the lesser man of the two, unleashing a savage and (kayfabe) career-best onslaught, their suspicions are understandable. The abuse Misawa takes is inhuman.

But so too was Misawa himself. A stoic destroyer, his aura was built through his unprecedented perseverance. The final quarter of the match is a sickening exchange of dangerous neck-centric suplexes - each struck with such ferocity that it was almost impossible to believe that the two men could fight through them. But fight through them they did, in storyline and reality. Those suplexes looked hellish because they were hellish.

The psychology behind the finish wasn't just believable - it was self-evident.


7. John Cena Vs. The Rock - WWE WrestleMania XXVIII

Cena Rock
WWE

Some fans have it that the first match between The Rock and John Cena was a modern classic - one which compensated for its basic action with a classic narrative of two equals contesting a close battle for dominance. The not inconsiderable crowd heat, the all-important barometer, measured its success.

Others found it dreadfully overlong and self-indulgent, and their stance is justified upon revisit. The Rock was sucking air at the five minute mark - a clear indication that a match of such epic duration was beyond him. Cena, too, called the action with a volume that was noticeable even by his curtain-revealing standards. The heat in the match's promotion was much more tangible than in the match itself, so it could well be argued that it failed. Wrestling matches are supposed to reach a crescendo at the finish - Rock Vs. Cena I peaked before the bell rang.

Like most matches, it's best to judge it on its finish.

Conventional wisdom has it that The Rock won cleanly - but he didn't so much win as Cena lost. The match was built for a calendar year - but it acted as a trailer for the proper feature. It was, arguably a waste of time. For a match that should not have exceeded fifteen minutes, it's almost appropriate.


6. Will Ospreay Vs. Ricochet - NJPW Best Of The Super Juniors Day 6

Ospreay Ricochet
NJPW

The Will Ospreay Vs. Ricochet BOSJ match caused such a furore that wrestling fans were joined in their social media meltdown by those within the industry.

Most infamously, Vader was repelled by what he perceived as a psychology-devoid spotfest. To him, it was ballet, not wrestling. He was joined by Jim Cornette, who felt that Ospreay and Ricochet would make more money as, and would be better suited to, roles as stuntmen in martial-arts movies. The argument was that style took jarring precedence over substance - but it could also be said that the style was the substance. Ospreay and Ricochet were peacocks - and the match acted as a courtship ritual for the support of the crowd.

For your writer's money, aspects of it were taken too far. A death valley driver to the apron should be sold with the utmost conviction. That it wasn't - without a sub-thread of fighting spirit body language to justify it - was tough to digest.

The wrestling business relies on the suspension of disbelief to prop it up. In their own progressive way, Ospreay and Ricochet, with their unfathomably convoluted sequences and rotations, did just that.


5. John Cena Vs. Bray Wyatt - WWE WrestleMania XXX

Cena Wyatt
WWE.com

If a story contains zero dramatic tension, does it really work?

The storyline heading into the John Cena Vs. Bray Wyatt match at 'Mania XXX was Bray Wyatt's insistence that Cena, far from a man of virtue, was in fact an illusion - the gurning face of an "era of lies". Wyatt was intent on turning Cena into the monster he convinced himself he was. Cena, meanwhile, was intent on rising above (I'm sure we've been here before) and proving that he was a swell guy - one who just happened to kick people's heads in for a living.

On the night, Wyatt adopted a masochist role - willingly absorbing and enjoying the punishment Cena doled out, cajoling him into intensifying it yet further to reveal the monster within. Many praised the unique, story-heavy match structure, feeling that it was a welcome deviation from the standard WWE norm.

Others, meanwhile, felt the novel plot was undermined by its protagonist. Cena was never likely to turn heel on the night, and moreover, he had already shown no qualms about deploying the barbaric offence Wyatt had attempted to draw from him. At TLC 2010, Cena (quite fittingly) buried opponent Wade Barrett under a stack of raining chairs. In comparison to that, the threat of Cena smashing Wyatt with the steel steps was tame.

Undermined by both reality and storyline positioning, the story had too few stakes to resonate.


4. Andre The Giant Vs. Hulk Hogan - WWF WrestleMania III

Hogan Andrre
WWE.com

Andre The Giant Vs. Hulk Hogan at WWF WrestleMania III remains, nearly thirty years later, the most famous wrestling match ever - but does that automatically deem it worthy of merit, in and of itself?

The entire match was based around whether or not Hogan could hoist Andre up for the body slam, much less win, so it was obvious that the Giant was never going to leave his feet. The match practically guaranteed tedium - and tedious, it was. A prolonged squash, all Andre did for ninety percent of it was lay waste to Hogan with a stately procession of body slams and bearhugs - before Hogan made his trademark superman comeback. The action was taken to the outside - but somehow devolved. Hogan removed the protective matting, in an attempt to drill Andre with a piledriver, but was back body-dropped onto near enough the soles of his feet.

Writing about the match in these descriptive terms is ludicrous. Who cares what happened before the slam? The slam made the money. The slam is all that matters. And that is the question posed years later: is wrestling art, or just enterprise?

Hilariously, the match is announced as having a one hour time limit. It couldn't not have, given that it was a main event contest for the company's top prize, but the thought of that going an hour would have killed the business it wound up elevating.


3. The Final Deletion - TNA Impact (July 5, 2016)

Matt Hardy The Final Deletion
Impact Wrestling

You knew it'd appear on this list. The second of 2016's trifecta of controversial wrestling matches, The Final Deletion barely resembled one in the traditional sense.

An intentionally ludicrous procession of lawnmowers, drones and dilapidated boats, the match/angle/something-completely-new-entirely was filmed at Matt Hardy's North Carolina "Compound". Hammily acted and performed with patent, rehearsed contrivance, it was something entirely new to an industry many bemoan for its lack of originality. It tapped into the so-bad-it's-good pop culture sweet spot previously occupied by Rebecca Black's Friday and movies like The Room.

The ridiculousness was the entire point, but those who condemned it for that very reason perhaps missed that wrestling was ludicrous before brothers Matt and Nero bastardised it beyond recognition. Wrestlers are unable to see camera crews inches away from their face. Wrestlers will act surprised when they are invariably interrupted during promos. Wrestlers do everything possible to protect one another under the pretence of hurting one another. The very basis of the industry is rooted in brain-melting paradox.

Wrestling feuds, events and matches are so homogenised in 2016 that they often bleed into one another to become indeterminate. The Final Deletion was, if nothing else, memorable.


2. Goldberg Vs. Brock Lesnar - WWE Survivor Series 2016

Goldberg Lesnar II
WWE.com

The outcome of this match has been discussed to death - but what about the content?

On second viewing, what little there is was elevated by supreme body language on the part of Lesnar - one of the many intangibles within his act that the man does not get enough credit for. As the two squared off, the usual sneering bluster was absent. Lesnar looked almost anxious. This expression turned to outright fright when Goldberg no sold his corner barrage and pushed him to the floor. Feigned overconfidence gave way to a stellar sell-job when Lesnar took that first spear. The man looked decimated when he lost.

For what it was, it was performed very well - but what was it? If fire exists where there is smoke, the match was WWE's attempt to create a UFC-style sudden knockout in a WWE ring. But doesn't UFC exist for that purpose?

If you paid $60 (or £15 - UK fans got a much sweeter deal) for the match on Pay Per View, would you have felt short-changed? The WWE Network has a lot to answer for. Mediocrity - and now shock value - are excused by the low, low price of just $9.99 a month! The first four years are free!


1. Bret Hart Vs. Shawn Michaels - WWF WrestleMania XII

Hart Michaels III
WWE.com

In terms of pure content, Bret Hart Vs. Shawn Michaels at WrestleMania XII is the most divisive match of them all.

A one hour Iron Match between two of the most technically gifted WWF wrestlers ever, it promised so much - and, to some, delivered very little. One thing it did get right was its logical thread. Unlike so many of its successors, it didn't go for a cheap early pop - one commanded at the detriment of coherence. The Iron Man match so often suffers from an incongruous early pinfall, the likes of which is never effective in a singles match. Obviously, preservation is a core concept, and kicking out uses up more energy than is often communicated to the audience - but it rarely rings true.

Hart and Michaels circumvented that by tying the first hour zero falls apiece. Was that a sign of understated and cerebral storytelling - or a result of the two infamous egotists refusing to show one another some ass?

In any event, even if you perceive the excruciating pace as more methodical than boring, the so-called science behind it was compromised by Hart's suspicious selling - something he was otherwise a master at. His opponent on the night may have contributed to his slight unprofessionalism.

On re-watch, the potato shots render it a curio - but it's nowhere near the best match these two had, let alone one of the best ever held.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!