10 Wrestling Matches Never Meant To Be This Good

Great wrestling from outta nowhere!

Trish Stratus stephanie mcmahon
WWE.com

"Wrestling promotion" has been something of a misnomer for WWE for several years now. Or, in the case of the "wrestling" side of that, nearly four decades.

Vince McMahon's pivot to "Sports Entertainment" was tax-based and tactical in the 1980s, but he was at least a promoter with a promotion, until very recently. For the longest time, television shows promoted house shows, house shows promoted other house shows, and both promoted occasional pay-per-views. All of those promoted the merchandise.

Then, house shows existed to promote television, television shows promoted pay-per-views, and pay-per-views promoted the idea that it was worth tuning in for more pay-per-views when it turned out the show you'd just watched wasn't the end of the known world.

The Network then ushered in everything everywhere existing to promote the Network, but that was a trojan horse for WWE's Content Production era, in which television shows are homogenised within an inch of their creative lives in order to foster a product generic enough to sell for billions to those who only needed the short-form notes.

Nothing promotes anything, but all of it promotes the presentation of an executive trying to put more money in Vince McMahon's pocket. Every great WWE match in 2021 is something of a surprise in this context. These had other things working against them...

10. John Cena Vs JBL (WWE Judgment Day 2005) 

John Cena Jbl I Quit
WWE.com

John Cena and John Bradshaw Layfield might have kicked off a rotten modern trend by keeping their match lowkey at WrestleMania 21.

The pair assembled a massively disappointing WWE Championship match at 2005's 'Show Of Shows', putting forth something less than television standard on a night designed to elevate Cena as one of the company's two brand new top stars.

They were saving their A+ performances for the B-Show.

With expectations subsequently diminished thanks to the first stinker (and the general malaise around the I Quit stipulation after too many turkeys), the pair shocked the world with a bloodthirsty war that rounded out Cena's CV at the top of the card. After months of failed attempts, Layfield found chemistry with a babyface rather than constantly taking countless chickensh*t shortcuts. That this came before WWE had given Cena's inhuman recuperative powers only made the match more impactful.

P*ssing blood and ready to bludgeon Bradshaw with a car part, Cena forced the former Champion to quit in sheer horror rather than through the pain of a hold. It was just one more ingenious element for a contest everybody had already written off.


9. El Torito Vs Hornswoggle (WWE Extreme Rules 2014)

hornswoggle wwelc
WWE.com

"WeeLC" as a title was designed to mock the combatants. As were the miniature weapons and commentators "Micro Cole, Jerry Smaller, JBelf" alongside the usual gang of idiots sat ringside.

Thankfully, El Torito and Hornswoggle weren't taking anything as a joke.

As comedic sidekicks for Los Matadores and the Three-Man Band respectively, the two had enough ha ha to manage every week, but took full advantage of the company's hand's off approach to the match so assemble a total ripper. Torito nailed high spots with a chair, Hornswoggle did the same with a ladder before missing a tadpole splash that had once controversially secured him the Cruiserweight Title several years earlier. Following a rolling thunder, he he connected with it again through an announce table as the audience completely lost their sh*t.

Following a the typically-dreaded but richly deserved 'This Is Awesome' the former Little B*stard made a b*llocks of things by putting Heath Slater through a table with a chair shot, allowing a babyface comeback that saw Jinder Mahal suffer a similar fate. Gripping to the last, Torito sealed the deal with a springboard flipping senton through two chairs for the win.


8. The New Day Vs The Usos (WWE SummerSlam 2017 KickOff)

The Usos The New Day
WWE.com

An outstanding brawl that bettered both their phenomenal contest at July's Battleground pay-per-view and a blinding Hell In A Cell opener, The Usos and The New Day took the 20 minutes they were allotted as fans still filed in.

One of 2017's best matches of the year saw Xavier Woods in particular remind everybody just who the f*ck he was as typical team workhorse Kofi Kingston took residence on the outside and got to watch the match in awe along with the rest of the people taking their seats.

An Uso victory on the night ensured that the pairs would have to go again, but the scale and quality of the performance would have worked them into a slot even if the roles had been reversed. Inordinately awesome doubles sequences en route to the finish confirmed an earnest attempt by both teams to try and carve out a new niche for tag team wrestling in the company that almost never has faith in it. Nothing on the main card could touch this - it was a shame Vince McMahon never wanted to.


7. Beulah McGillicutty Vs. Bill Alfonso (ECW As Good As It Gets)

Beulah McGillicutty Bill Alfonso
WWE

Wrestling's rather unique architecture resulted in Bill Alfonso bleeding for his job as well as his art in this cult 1996 classic with fellow non-wrestler Beulah McGillicutty.

An intergender match very much of its own time rather than the present day, the contest existed in order for the whistle-blowing lunatic to get a level of comeuppance the ECW faithful had waited years to see. His role as a referee that first tried to enforce the rules in a lawless land (before using them to his own advantage alongside Taz and later Sabu and Rob Van Dam) earned him furious disdain from the Philadelphia natives, and Tommy Dreamer's much better half was ready to kick that f*cking whistle of his down his throat as a measure of revenge.

He'd probably rather have gone through that than the bloodletting he actually endured, but it was a vital performance for him at the time. Outed as a figure helping sort colleagues out with WCW contracts, the sustained and brutal beating was part-performance part-apology to the locker room. Fans didn't need this bit of the story to hate him, but it added even more spice when he seemingly took delight in battering Beulah too.

Judged now, it's a strange and slightly difficult watch. In the context of the time, it bordered on the sublime.


6. Elimination Chamber 2012

Elimination Chamber 2012
WWE.com

Largely ignored now in light of bigger and more memorable moments in the years that followed, Daniel Bryan's 2011-2012 World Heavyweight Title run offered so much more than the Sheamus defeat that defined it and transformed his career in the process.

A very good Elimination Chamber match also featuring Cody Rhodes, The Big Show, The Great Khali and Wade Barrett was elevated into the god tier with a closing stretch that belonged as a singles match on an entirely different pay-per-view.

Santino Marella had only snuck into the match days earlier, but he continued his fairytale journey on the night with eliminations of both Rhodes and Barrett to make believers of an audience that were suddenly desperate to see him dethrone World Champion Bryan in the closing stretch.

Bryan's snarky grin as he realised it was between him and the 'Milan Miracle' played perfectly into the story in much the same way it would in his kicking off of KofiMania several years later, but the challenger's valiant fight only made the Champion nastier. A last-ditch Cobra strike drew an impossibly hot near fall, but Marella was beaten by a snap Yes-Lock for the ultimate heartbreaker.


5. Speed Muscle Vs The Motor City Machine Guns (TNA Impact, June 12th 2008)

Playing with the unknown as the wrestlers themselves played with the form, TNA had nothing to lose by bringing Speed Muscle over to the United States and letting them loose against arguably the most transcendent tag team of the decade.

Expectations obviously weren't low - they just didn't exist. Chris Sabin and Alex Shelley were a scintillating doubles act, but in Masato Yoshino and Naruki Doi they found perfect counterparts to help move the genre forward about 800 years in eight minutes.

Doi's pace was always his unique selling point, and he sold the world on it as he darted across the ring early on. This turbo charged the the Guns, but their levelling up brought the best out in Yoshino and Doi's own double teams. There were as few spots to take a breather as there were gaps between the moves - everything was crisp, clinical and looked like it knacked for six seconds. There was literally no time to sell, but this sprint simply didn't need it.


4. Serena Deeb Vs Riho (AEW Double Or Nothing 2021)

Serena Deeb
AEW

Perhaps the match that suits this list the most, Serena Deeb and Riho were impeccably matched in terms of chemistry and dynamic, but few had this pre-show encounter threatening to steal an entire pay-per-view.

Gifted the prized spot of opening up Double Or Nothing 2021, the pair had the enthusiasm of the first full Daily's Place in over a year, but capitalised on that with a total ripper that much of the main card couldn't even hope to follow.

When the ultra-worker Deeb wasn't folding the former Women's Champion in half with her range of submission holds, she was leathering her with strikes so hard that any pre-match love from the crowd dissipated in an instant. A maestro display from one of the very best in the world, Deeb could have been hot-shotted into the main event without complaint on heat alone.

Riho, to her credit was inch-perfect foil. The match didn't have a story or a build, but often - as astoundingly illustrated here - the in-ring basics are best.


3. Chris Jericho Vs. Ricky Steamboat, Jimmy Snuka & Roddy Piper (WWE WrestleMania 25)

Chris Jericho Vs Ricky Steamboat
WWE.com

A rank encounter suddenly became wonderful when Chris Jericho got the bullsh*t out of the way to have a mini-banger with one of his heroes.

Breathing fire against 'Y2J and breathing life into the deadest part of the show, Ricky 'The Dragon' Steamboat rolled back the years with a spellbinding display that betrayed a bad angle once designed for Mickey Rourke.

When 'The Wrestler' star pulled out, it fell to Jericho to carry Roddy Piper, Jimmy Snuka and the long-retired Steamboat to something watchable on 'The Grandest Stage'. Nobody wanted any of it by showtime, but two all time greats hooked everybody by the end. Even in near-peak form, he couldn't get much from from the formers, but with the latter, he needn't have worried.

Steamboat shocked the watching world here - his timing, movement and mastery sorted him out with a singles clash with Jericho the next month at Backlash, but the real magic spells were cast in these marvellous maximised minutes.


2. Triple H Vs The Great Khali (SummerSlam 2008)

Triple H Great Khali
WWE.com

Has to be seen to be believed, this, but almost nobody ever will because the pair looks so unappealing. And yet, this SummerSlam 2008 title scrap was one of WWE's all-time great throwbacks.

Not only did The Great Khali work an Andre The Giant-level title match against an established star, but Triple H found his 2000 form one last time as a total general that sold and sold and sold until his match finally got over.

Eschewing all the usual tricks that made so many of his matches deathly dull over the years, 'The Game' was "That Damn Good" as making Khali actually look Great and his own offence look like something that wouldn't trouble Hornswoggle.

Perhaps because he never highlighted enough (and his insecurity always stopped him from doing it anyway), Hunter the gutsy babyface could sell, and that's all the midcard attraction needed to pop the crowd. Khali's enormously limited offence looked limitless as a result, and the 'King Of Kings' orchestrated a minor miracle as a result.


1. Stephanie McMahon Vs. Trish Stratus (WWE No Way Out 2001)

Trish Stratus stephanie mcmahon
WWE.com

Whatever the expectations were for Trish Stratus and Stephanie McMahon's insane No Way Out 2001 brawl were blown into orbit by a battle arguably more spirited than the Three Stages Of Hell blood feud decider between Triple H and Stone Cold Steve Austin.

Years before she'd consider herself even competent in the ring, Stratus showed flashes of the legend she'd become by levelling up to a 'Billion Dollar Princess' set out to show that she had both the guts and the genetics to mix it up between the ropes once in a while.

As the angriest version of herself (and for once, the narrative actually called for it) McMahon was genuinely fantastic as a fired up babyface, sick of her opponent's Dad-shagging and very possibly showing glimpses of one of the great lost wrestling gimmicks. Stratus performed some carry jobs in her time, but this absolutely wasn't one.

It has to be seen to be believed. The pair beat the absolute f*cking sh*t out of each other for the good of the cause as if the knew just how high the steaks would be at WrestleMania the following month.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.