10 Wrestling Matches Ruined By One Botch
Botches don't just ruin matches, they can ruin careers, pushes and people's faces.
This isn't ballet, folks. Ignoring the inherently insulting nature of that phrase, ballet being extremely difficult after all, but professional wrestling is a super difficult dance between multiple people, portraying violence in the most graceful of manners. Things are going to go wrong. Drawing attention to these 'botches' isn't the most respectful of ways to cover all of this.
Then again, this is the internet, right?
Many major wrestling matches in history have been ruined by botches, more often than not a case of overly complicated booking gone wrong. Why involve handcuffs when you can have dudes just beat the sh*t out of each other? Introducing these wacky bits and pieces is just asking for things to go wrong.
The problem is that botches are often the only thing remembered from these matches, as the great work is forgotten in a blaze of awkward falls and Billy Kidman's wonky Shooting Star Presses. Get everything right and you'll be lucky to get a pat on the back; that's your job, after all. Get one thing seriously wrong? Who knows how bad it can get.
Your face might even explode.
10. Billy Kidman Vs. Steven Regal - WCW Nitro 1999
They don't call it high-risk without good reason. Billy Kidman's Shooting Star Press was never the most graceful of top rope attacks, but he did manage to hit it more often than not. Kidman carved himself out a pretty handy niche as a staple of WCW's cruiserweight division.
WCW being WCW, it didn't keep its junior heavyweights tied together at the waist, meaning fans were frequently treated to cross-division dream matches like La Parka vs. Booker T, Saturn vs. Psychosis and this beauty: Steven Regal vs. Billy Kidman.
Kidman had the match won, believe it or not, and Regal was in a prone position as the former Flock member took to the ropes with shooting stars in his eyes. Alas, the top rope got in Kidman's way on the way down, and his body made contact with the edge of the turnbuckle.
Unsurprisingly, the entire match was rendered obsolete in the face of a botched Shooting Star Press. Kidman picked up the win after an inside cradle but there was only ever going to be one focus of the conversation in the moments afterwards.
At least Kidman didn't crush Regal's face with his knees, right?
9. Roman Reigns Vs. Kevin Owens - WWE Royal Rumble 2021
Kevin Owens and Roman Reigns have fantastic chemistry, always have, always will. It isn't difficult to imagine a better WWE where these two are absolute megastars, every bit the Stone Cold Steve Austin and The Rock that the company wants them to be. If WWE hadn't spent so much time focusing on stars of the past and had committed to building a new generation of heroes, Reigns and Owens would be on top of all the posters.
The two have been feuding for the last couple of months, a beef that came to a head at the 2021 Royal Rumble in a Last Man Standing match. For the first 20 minutes or so, this was excellent - further proof of the excellent understanding these two professionals have. Everything was building to a thrilling climax, albeit one clouded in the usual nonsense that surrounds a Last Man Standing match.
Then, the handcuffs.
The match was fine when it was Reigns and Owens falling off things, but the introduction of the handcuffs and the difficulty Paul Heyman had in unlocking them rendered all that work useless. A referee just stopping the count was the sh*tty cherry on what had been a really enjoyable cake. To round things off, Reigns just slapped a choke on Owens and that was that.
It might be harsh to say the match was ruined by the botched finish, but the match was ruined by the botched finish.
There.
8. The Great Khali & Natalya Vs. Big E. & AJ Lee - WWE RAW 2013
Watch the video above and you'll be somewhat confused as to why this match is featured in this list. Actually, The Great Khali is always good for a botch, right? Shockingly, the Punjabi Nightmare had nothing to do with the mangled finish of this match, cleverly edited in the aforementioned video.
Natalya locked AJ Lee in the Sharpshooter and Lee tapped frantically, a fairly standard finish except for the fact Natalya had relinquished the hold. It is difficult to say that the botch 'ruined' the match, per se, but it did plenty of damage to any hope of a better presentation of WWE's women, for a short while at least. Everyone came out of the match looking like a fool, which is less than ideal considering the then-fledgeling careers of Lee and Big E.
Until then, the match had been more than serviceable, which should be considered a triumph, you know, considering The Great Khali was involved and all that. Things didn't get any better after the fact, as Natalya waited for the referee to raise her hand, only for the official to tell Nattie that she needed to reapply the hold and get AJ to submit, all over again.
Pretty good editing in the video though, for sure.
7. Stone Cold Steve Austin Vs. Owen Hart - WWE SummerSlam 1997
The use of the word 'ruined' is a divisive one. This has gone down in history as one of the most important and memorable matches of all time, but that has nothing to do with the match itself. That memory is almost exclusively based on the near-tragic circumstances of the ending, and the series of events it set in motion that eventually made Stone Cold Steve Austin the biggest star in wrestling. It also ensured his early retirement. Did the botch ruin the match? It ruined Austin's neck, that's for sure.
Owen Hart and Steve Austin were at the peak of their powers in 1997, two men with the world at their feet, making the WWE Intercontinental Championship the über-credible title that people lust for even today. Their SummerSlam 1997 title match was well on its way to becoming an all-time classic when Hart hit Austin with that piledriver, stopping time and the match simultaneously.
Ever the professional (aside from the slightly unprofessional execution of the piledriver just moments earlier), Hart stalled for time as Austin desperately clung onto whatever sentience he had, eventually working towards the weakest roll-up in wrestling history and a victory for the stricken babyface. All memory of the match itself was obliterated in a botch that would ring loud through pro wrestling history.
Nobody remembers the intensity of the match; only the travesty of the piledriver.
6. WWE Royal Rumble 2005 Match
The greatest comedy of errors in WWE history?
Quite possibly.
The finish of the 2005 Royal Rumble should have been simple but instead, it gave fans some of the most hilarious visuals in pro wrestling history. You don't want to wish ill on anyone, but Vince McMahon tearing both of his quads as he desperately runs down to the ring to save the day before hilariously having to dictate everything from a sitting position? Feed that into the veins.
Until the unfortunate botch that saw Batista and John Cena hit the floor at the exact same time (what are the odds?), the 2005 Royal Rumble was memorable only for a bunch of grizzled veterans bullying Daniel Puder and Gene Snitsky attempting to murder Paul London via decapitation. The rest of the Rumble was fine enough, a standard battle royal that featured a pretty great Edge performance and workmanlike efforts from those most workhorses of wrestlers; Jericho, Rey, Benoit and Eddie.
The botch changed all that. In a parallel world, Batista dumps Cena over the top and everything after the show goes as it did, but the world has McMahon's exploding legs cruelly taken away from it. When booking the Royal Rumble, the very last thing you want is for the finish to be botched.
Saying that, Asuka kicking thin air so violently it caused Nikki Bella to fall off the apron at the 2018 Royal Rumble probably counts as well, no?
5. London & Kendrick Vs. Taylor & Regal Vs. MNM Vs. The Hardy Boyz - WWE Armageddon 2006
Before you get into the whole 'Joey Mercury's face explodes' thing, how awesome does that match look on paper?
The Hardy Boyz are one of the most popular tag teams in the history of pro wrestling, while London and Kendrick were basically a way more athletic and dynamic version of the two, just less popular. MNM were, for a while, WWE's only decent tag team, and Taylor and Regal brought thug-nosed British grit to the table with aplomb.
But yeah, Joey Mercury's face exploded, and everything else fell apart from there. It is difficult to focus entirely on a plunder match when one of your colleagues is gushing blood from his face, one presumes. This was a ladder match, and all it took was one convoluted spot to go slightly wrong for Mercury's face to be in peril, by which it is meant 'obliterated'.
You know something is bad when John Morrison describes taking a ladder full-pelt in the throat as 'lucky'.
What should and could have been an all-time great WWE tag team ladder match became an exercise in damage limitation, as well as (for all intents and purposes) the end of Joey Mercury's in-ring career.
4. Ronda Rousey Vs. Becky Lynch Vs. Charlotte Flair - WrestleMania 35
You could probably make a convincing argument that WWE botched this match before the bell even rang. Why was Charlotte Flair involved? The entire wrestling world wanted this to be a major singles match between Becky Lynch and Ronda Rousey, yet 2435-time women's champion Flair was shunted in there for what, because there wasn't a tall blonde involved?
For shame, WWE booking team, for shame.
If that wasn't bad enough, the first women's match to main event WWE WrestleMania ended with a botch, with a three-count that should never have happened and a crowd with the wind knocked well and truly out of their sails. If this is building to some sort of mega bout between Ronday and Becky, it gets a pass, but that clearly isn't the case.
Poor Rod Zapata. Stuck between a rock and a hard place, Zapata counted Rousey's shoulders to the mat despite one of those shoulders being nowhere near aforementioned mat. Zapata claimed that Rousey was in severe pain due to a broken hand and needed to finish the match but that doesn't exactly make this botched finish okay. Something about that explanation doesn't sit, in truth.
Will Becky and Ronda get a chance to right this wrong in the future? WWE's bottomless chequebook will surely do all it can to make that happen.
3. Eddie Guerrero Vs. Rey Mysterio - WWE SummerSlam 2005
What is it with WWE and putting together convoluted storylines for what should be simple feuds? Eddie Guerrero and Rey Mysterio were WWE Tag Team Champions, but a desire to see who was the best led to a match at WrestleMania 21. That match was hampered by a poor choice of mask on Mysterio's part, but it didn't seem to hinder Rey too much, as he eventually got the win. That set in motion Eddie's downward spiral as professional jealousy became too much for Latino Heat to handle.
Why did Dominik need to be brought into it all?
He didn't, obviously, but the feud climaxed in a ladder match for custody of Dominik. The ridiculous stipulation was easy enough to ignore for the most part, as Eddie and Rey went to work and put on a tremendous match, one more suited to the WWE world than their more famous matches in WCW.
Everything was going swimmingly until Eddie found himself with a clear run for the briefcase. This wasn't supposed to be the finish, as Eddie's wife Vickie should have been out there to push her beau off the ladder, doing the right thing at the right time. Unfortunately for the match, Vickie was in the wrong place at this right time; she was nowhere to be seen. Rey eventually pulled Eddie down after what felt like an age. The 'effin and jeffin' that subsequently flowed from the mouth of Eddie Guerrero spoke for itself. Latino Heat, indeed.
Vickie eventually sauntered out three minutes later as the spot was reprised, but the cat was out of the bag.
2. Hulk Hogan Vs. Sting - WCW Starrcade 1997
WCW, what a mess you were. Despite incredible popularity and bucketloads of momentum, the long-defunct promotion still managed to stay on top of reinventing the term 'f*ck up'. No episode of Monday Nitro or monthly pay-per-view seemed to pass without one major botch or another.
They don't come much bigger than a botched finish in what should have been the biggest match in company history. If the finish to Sting vs. Hulk Hogan at WWE Starrcade '97 had gone as planned, who knows what the current wrestling landscape might look like? Sure, WCW would have surely put itself out of business eventually, but what would WWE look like?
We all know what should have happened, and we all know what happened. Hulk Hogan should have been awarded the victory thanks to a fast count by dastardly nWo referee Nick Patrick, only for Bret Hart to mark his debut by restarting the match, allowing Sting to win via submission. The so-billed 'Match of the Century' should have ended with Sting as WCW World Heavyweight Champion and the nWo done for.
Alas, Nick Patrick "forgot" to count slow, and the whole thing fell apart in trademark WCW style: because Hulk Hogan was an egomaniac.
1. The Undertaker Vs. Brock Lesnar - WWE WrestleMania XXX
Most of the botches on this list were major mess-ups - big-time botches that changed the atmosphere in the arena and rendered the rest of the match almost irrelevant. The most consequential botch in modern wrestling history was the opposite, a seemingly innocuous moment that led to what should have been the most monumental moment becoming a weird, underwhelming damp squib of an affair. It isn't fair to say the end of The Streak was botched, but that match was definitely ruined by a moment that didn't go to plan.
Undertaker vs. Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania XXX wasn't necessarily destined to be a classic, but it would have been a whole lot better if Undertaker didn't pick up a concussion some five minutes into the match.
As the two were grappling on the outside, Bork's strength got the better of him, and he somehow managed to tip over the Deadman like some sort of great oak. 'Taker's head was left unprotected as it smacked the ringside mat, rendering Undertaker largely useless through the rest of the match.
The plan was obviously not for Undertaker to get a concussion five minutes in, so this definitely goes down as a monumental botch that did more to ruin the match in question than anything else on this list. The end of The Streak should have been truly epic.
Oh, to go back in time...