10 Wrestling Matches That Haven't Aged Well
Time has not been too kind to these wrestling matches...
While the professional wrestling landscape of modern times is far from perfect even on its best day, the fact fans now hold the ability to easily jump back and consume just about any and all wrasslin' content to have ever graced a squared-circle undoubtedly sits as one of the more universally cherished elements of this often barmy period in the business.
However, its through this stepping back in time that bouts and epic blow-offs from yesteryear have an unfortunate habit of not quite living up to the nostalgic memories you once had of a mouth-watering monster mash or game-changing title match.
Away from taking the shine off of contests that felt unmissable in the moment, bouts that were once seen as seemingly harmless ways to generate heat or long-awaited trips to the top of the mountain have all become rather difficult to take in due to the events and developments that would proceed them over the years.
From emotional Show of Shows finales that became increasingly painful to revisit, to highly-anticipated throwdowns that haven't stood the test of time, these matches were awesome or innocuous in the moment, but in 2022... not so much.
10. John Cena Vs. CM Punk (Money In The Bank 2011)
As this list with further illustrate before it reaches its conclusion, crowds have a funny ol' habit of being able to make or break just about any contest going down inside of wrasslin' ring.
And while the actual in-ring action seen going down on that fateful night in Chicago back at Money in the Back 2011 was far from terrible, the fact John Cena and CM Punk's WWE Championship skirmish sits as the only Meltzer-rated five-star WWE main roster match of the last decade or so tells a story of a bout far better in the moment than it is through a 2022 lens.
Sure, the nuclear noise heard within the Allstate Arena is one the duo would struggle to conjure up again in later efforts. But their epic clash on the road to WrestleMania 29 outclasses this pantomime PPV punch-up, and The Best in the World's recent All Elite exploits have cast a staggering shadow over the last few years of his WWE run in general.
As a moment in time and catalyst for momentary change, this contest still deserves all the love frequently sent its way. But when held up against more recent standards and the rivals' other battles, its five-star status feels increasingly questionable.
9. Charlotte Flair Vs. Natalya (NXT TakeOver)
With the WrestleMania show being well and truly stolen by the likes of Bianca Belair, Sasha Banks, and Becky Lynch over the last few years, it's easy to forget how painfully long it took for the freakishly talented women occupying the wrestling world to finally be given a shot at showing the blokes how its really done.
Hopping back to the first-ever TakeOver special in 2014 then, and it was during said first flicker of black and gold that the Women's Revolution truly began to catch fire.
That being said, for all of the progress undoubtedly made on the night by having Natalya and Charlotte Flair put on a match-of-the-night display in front of a rampant Full Sail, the aforementioned performances put on in more recent times by WWE's resident game-changers haven't been all that kind to the two Queens' NXT Women's Championship battle.
The presence of a certain blacklisted Nature Boy at ringside also doesn't do the contest any favours upon a rewatch either.
With WWE's stacked women's roster of NXT alumni now churning out bangers by the PPV, important contests like this were always destined to be dwarfed in quality as the bar continued to be raised.
8. 6-Man Hell In A Cell (Armageddon 2000)
The noise that greeted each now-legendary star as they made their way down to the monumental Hell in a Cell structure for an unprecedented six-man main event for the WWE Championship suggested more than one roof could be blown off inside of the Birmingham–Jefferson Civic Center.
Yet, what would ultimately follow amounted to little more than six dudes taking their turns trying to get their stuff in before going for various wanders around the arena.
An inevitable Vinnie Mac intervention only bloated the drama that bit more in a contrived setting of the stage for Rikishi's moment of sawdust slamming in the bout's closing stages. And a weak finish that saw Angle retain his gold after capitalising on a Stone Cold stunner was diluted even further with the champ ending the night on his back courtesy of yet another Steve Austin PPV-closing-stunner.
Whether due to not being aided by the lofty standards set by prior Hell in a Cell wars or due to trying to give too many feature players a reason for being there in the first place, this one made for a fun set of visuals but doesn't sit as one of the Attitude Era's crowning achievements for a reason.
7. Goldberg Vs. Hulk Hogan (WCW Nitro 1998)
In a move that many would attempt to replicate but few would ever really successfully recapture, WCW's handling of Bill Goldberg and his all-encompassing streak inevitably set the stage for the mother of all monster mashes inside of the Georgia Dome on an episode of WCW Nitro in July 1998.
The fact Eric Bischoff was able to convince 40,000 folks to cram inside of the venue for the mouth-watering collision between Hulk Hogan and Da Man tells you all you need to know about how anticipated this seemingly inevitable crowing moment was during the height of the company's success.
And while, once again, the noise produced by those watching on suggested we were witnessing an all-time classic, the actual physical showing from the two hulking forces left a lot to be desired, in all honesty.
No one was ever expecting a Steamboat/Savage clinic from the two infamously limited workers. But outside of an exhilarating final minute or so, the remainder of this drawn-out meaty match, with its numerous cheap heat spots and dull tests of strength, can be filed directly under the word "skip".
6. Triple H Vs. Shawn Michaels Vs. Chris Benoit (WrestleMania XX)
In the show-closing visual of WrestleMania XX, WWE appeared to have captured lightning in a bottle with the emotional parading around of new World Heavyweight Champion Chris Benoit alongside long-time pal and then-reigning WWE Champion Eddie Guerrero in front of a sold-out Madison Square Garden.
But an image and preceding bout that looked destined to sit as one of the most replayed and adored in company history was ultimately rendered understandably meaningless on the back of Benoit's horrendous acts during his last moments.
The contest between Benoit and DX-buddies-turned-bitter-enemies Shawn Michaels and Triple H over said world title came equipped with just the right mix of pulsating drama and jaw-dropping physical prowess expected of three of the greatest workers of their generation. However, the harrowing Benoit double-murder suicide that would unfold in 2007 has since all-but erased this once-cherished contest from WWE history and the minds of many a fan who originally watched the Showcase of the Immortal moment unfold.
5. Kane Vs. The Undertaker (Unforgiven: In Your House 1998)
In yet another example of the idea of a contest being much more tantalising than the eventual end product, hot on the heels of a WrestleMania XIV brotherly collision, Kane and The Undertaker were set to duke it out in WWE's first-ever Inferno match.
What could go wrong, eh?
In truth, actually getting through the fiery contest without either man being seriously damaged or incinerated was no doubt seen as a job well done for all involved. And those in attendance at Unforgiven: In Your House 1998 seemed to genuinely lap up every blaze that accompanied the various bumps taken by both battling bros in the ring.
Yet, the action only really began to heat up the second both men left the much-hyped burning squared circle late in the match. And while the sight of The Big Red Machine's arm being set alight as he squirmed back up the ramp was jaw-dropping at the time, watching the Mayor of Knox County slowly position himself and carefully allow the flames to take over his fully prepared arm doesn't quite elicit the same response all these years later.
It still ranks as the best Inferno match in WWE history, though. Admittedly, that's not saying too much.
4. Eugene Vs. Umaga (WWE Raw 2007)
For a whole host of reasons, it's not difficult to see why WWE aren't in too much of a rush to relive the many humiliating and uncomfortable scenarios fans were forced to witness involving Eugene.
On top of being made into the butt of many an insensitive and tone deaf joke, Eugene also ended up on the receiving end of his fair share of childish bullying over the course of his questionable time within the Sports Entertainment sphere. And one of the most awkward instances of live tormenting the now-Be-A-STAR-advocating-company pumped onto their flagship inevitably involved the Chairman of the Board himself.
After accidentally spilling his drink on Vince McMahon backstage in the lead-up to his Battle of the Billionaires hair vs. hair match at WrestleMania 23, Eugene's "boo boo" was rewarded with an impromptu match against the dominant Umaga. Of course, Eric Bischoff's nephew was quickly dispatched, but McMahon wasn't done there.
Sending a message to his 'Mania rival Donald Trump, Eugene was promptly shaved bald in front of an unsettled Raw crowd and given a "billionaire b*tch slap" for good measure, too.
But at least this icky programme led to both billionaires eating stunners on the Grandest Stage, eh?
3. Hulk Hogan Vs. Andre The Giant (WrestleMania III)
Billed as "the irresistible force meeting the immovable object", the sight of the titanic Andre the Giant turning on one-time pal Hulk Hogan in the lead-up to a WrestleMania III super fight was enough to produce a much-disputed 93,173 event attendance for arguably the biggest wrestling event in the sport's history.
While still a main event to behold mostly due to the sheer audible excitement being generated by the visual of these two larger than life superstars squaring up to each other inside of the squared circle, this was again a case of the hype far exceeding the in-ring end product.
With Andre's back being an absolute mess coming into the Showcase bout, The Hulkster wasn't even sure if his great adversary would be in a position to take the now legendary powerslam. According to Hogan himself, Andre even rejected his first attempt to pull off the monumental feat early in the match, despite it being a part of the original plan.
Away from that Pontiac Silverdome-popping slam heard around the world, though, there's a reason this 'Mania III conclusion came away with Meltzer's "Worst Worked Match of the Year" award in 1987. And the admittedly iconic contest has only lost more of its physical shine with age.
2. The Rock Vs. Mankind (Royal Rumble 1999)
With the knowledge of just how catastrophic unprotected headshots and moves involving a performer throwing themselves head-first at an adversary can be to the folks involved, looking back on some of the more sickening acts of steel chair violence to have occupied the wrestling world over the last few decades makes for a seriously unnerving revisit.
Never one to shy away from the more extreme side of life, even Mick Foley has since gone on record to admit that he may have gone a little too far when it came to making a barbaric impact on the night of his Royal Rumble 1999 I Quit match with The Rock.
Utterly bludgeoning the Mankind man with a steel chair whilst Foley's hands were cuffed behind his back, the devastating shots to the hardcore legend's head were only made worse with the realisation that his wife and kids were in attendance for the massacre.
While there's still definitely a place for the more extreme and savage corners of pro wrestling, watching a grown man be repeatedly pulverised by a metal object was excruciating then and doesn't need to be repeated any time soon.
1. Shawn Michaels Vs. Bret Hart (WrestleMania XII)
In Bret "The Hitman" Hart you had undoubtedly the finest in-ring performer of his generation and defending WWE Champion coming into 'Mania XII. Opposite him was a Heartbreak Kid determined to make good on his second Royal Rumble win in a row and go one better than he did the previous year against one-time pal Diesel.
Throwing the two out-of-this-world workers into a contest for 60 whole minutes looked like a recipe for guaranteed success on the Grandest Stage. However, the reality of an hour (plus extra time) of these two masters of their craft aimlessly battling over the richest prize in the game wasn't all it was cracked up to be for those in attendance.
The lukewarm reception to the Show of Shows main event and what acted as WWE's first-ever televised Iron Man match was slightly salvaged by the likes of Dave Meltzer and many other wrestling critics re-assessing the lacklustre bout in the immediate aftermath.
Yet, with the match-type being very much evolved and perfected as the years would roll by - with Bayley and Sasha Banks' NXT TakeOver: Respect outing arguably sitting as the finest to date - this over-indulgent damp squib of an Iron Man misfire has seen its acclaimed status be gradually diminished to the point where it now sits as one of the most disappointing 'Mania show-closers of all time.