10 Wrestling Matches That Inadvertently Became Infamous
The detriment of hindsight.
As an industry, professional wrestling's fundamental driver is to convince audiences that a predetermined contest pitting rival performers against one another is worth investing money, time and emotional energy.
Each live event, television show and pay-per-view broadcast is (in theory) designed to be unmissable. WWE in particular have long attempted to fuse the urgency of a live sporting event with the theatrical chops of a broadway show. This presentation is more crucial now than ever before to ensure the safety of their television rights in vastly changing times for the way in which people digest content.
Of course, there is only ever so much juice in every fruit. Subsequently, the business follows a pattern of each encounter allegedly meaning even more than the last in order to re-energise fans for whatever storylines and angles they want to pursue next month. The wheels keep turning.
However some contests buck the trend, and become substantially more interesting after they've actually happened. Reviewed retrospectively, an entirely new subtext emerges around certain matches and their outcomes, with some unthinkable circumstances remaining unknown until detailed analysis in the aftermath.
Already attempting to manage pre-ordained expectations chasing fleeting glory, these performers had no idea just how infamous their matches would accidentally become.
10. Edge Vs Alberto Del Rio (WrestleMania 27)
There are few performers that get to exit the business as a victor in a WrestleMania title match, but Edge's World Heavyweight Title clash with Alberto Del Rio subsequently became an unexpected retirement match for 'The Rated-R Superstar'.
Mounting injuries forced him out of the industry in 2011 after repeated numbness in his arms and neck was ultimately diagnosed as cervical spinal stenosis. As he'd explain in a tearful abdication of the World Title, the condition was too serious to afford him any further action. Noting the scale of the gamble should he elect to continue wrestling, he revealed that doctors refused to clear him for fear of paralysis or even death should something go wrong.
Interestingly, though partially down to the years of abuse he'd put his body through as a professional wrestler, a spear to Brodus Clay shortly before the Del Rio match caused him visible discomfort and triggered the overall review of his status. Whilst unaware of the potential severity of his ailment during the WrestleMania 27 encounter, it's retrospectively frightening to consider what could have happened as the two clashed.
His eventual (and somewhat surprising) victory only makes his thankfully safe pursuit through the match that bit sweeter.
9. Stone Cold Steve Austin Vs Kane Vs The Undertaker Vs Mankind (Capital Carnage)
With an electric crowd reacting favourably during another climactic Attitude Era main event, Stone Cold Steve Austin, The Undertaker, Kane and Mankind were unaware of a real-life drama occurring mere feet away at ringside.
December 1998's Capital Carnage was the company's return to UK Pay-Per-View after the critically acclaimed One Night Only event in 1997, as the organisation continued with the upgraded house show format they'd stick to until bringing television tapings across the Atlantic in in 2004.
The commercial success of another riotous WWE card was sadly overshadowed by a Bell's Palsy relapse suffered by Jim Ross midway through the main event match. It concluded a desperately sad weekend for Ross, who had learned of the news that his mother had passed away upon landing in London for the show.
A robust professional, the mourning JR insisted on calling the show, but was undone by the stress levels he was presumably stifling in order to perform to the best of his abilities.
Remarkably completing the broadcast, Ross was taken off television and given time to recover. But the cynical pencil of Vince Russo scripted the perennial fan favourite to return as an embittered heel, p*ssed off with the world for neglecting his continued suffering.
It was abhorrent treatment of the ever-reliable Oklahoman, and was thankfully dropped around the time Ross returned to full time commentary duties in April 1999.
8. Bret Hart Vs Terry Funk (WCW Thunder)
On December 19th 1999, Bret Hart suffered two brutal shots to his head in a match against Goldberg that would ultimately end his career. After receiving a stiff kick as well as Big Bill's failure to stop his head colliding with the arena floor during 'The Hitman's ringpost figure four leglock, Hart suffered upwards of three concussions and would be left with a crushing post-concussion syndrome diagnosis.
However, due to a combination of issues ranging from injury mismanagement from WCW to a fundamental misunderstanding of the dangers concussions can cause at the time, Bret continued to wrestle through the suffering for a full month before the diagnosis caused him to immediately vacate the company's World Heavyweight Title and completely re-evaluate the rest of his life.
It's upsetting to watch the legendary 'Excellence of Execution' struggle through any of his follow-up matches in such visible discomfort, but the worst case of WCW neglect was on show during in his hardcore rules match with Terry Funk on the January 6th edition of company B-show Thunder.
Predictably, Hart took significant punishment in the weapons brawl, including a wince-inducing running chairshot from Funk that connects with Bret's cranium despite his last-minute rush to get his arms up and block. He's later tipped out of a cart full of weapons headfirst, with the plunder cascading out onto him as he writhes in pain. Naturally, the physically destructive brawl ended in a vapid non-finish.
7. Jeff Jarrett Vs Chyna (No Mercy 1999)
Chyna and Jeff Jarrett over-delivered in their No Mercy 'Good Housekeeping' melee, but for 'Double J', it represented one last payday from Vince McMahon that would sever their working relationship forever.
Jarrett became something of a ventriloquist's dummy for WWE's head writer Vince Russo in August 1999. Cast as a rampant misogynist, the reigning Intercontinental Champion was abusive towards manager Debra and other female talent in the organisation as a build-up to his eventual dispute with Chyna.
The two had battled once at Unforgiven in September, with the 'Ninth Wonder of the World' proving Jarrett's equal only to be cheated out of the title by incompetent refereeing. Before their October rematch though, noted Jarrett supporter Vince Russo shockingly left WWE for WCW alongside creative colleagues Ed Ferrara and Bill Banks.
It was during this period that Jeff's contract lapsed, but management failed to notice this until the day of No Mercy when the Intercontinental Champion revealed he'd be leaving for WCW immediately following the broadcast.
Threatening to take the secondary strap with him, Jarrett insisted on a payout ranging from $300,000 to $500,000 and/or stock options (depending on which version of the story is to be believed) in order to go out and lose as planned. McMahon acquiesced, and Jarrett gleefully contributed to an outstanding brawl significantly richer than he was earlier in the day.
6. Booker T Vs Buff Bagwell (WWE Raw)
As WWE's picks to test the waters with a rebranded WCW production, Buff Bagwell and Booker T were effectively fed to the wolves as they disastrously closed a 2001 Monday Night Raw broadcast.
As existing World Heavyweight Champion and a well-known workhorse inexorably linked to the Atlanta organisation, Booker was a salient choice to represent the re-badged outfit as WWE figured out how best to implement the brand.
Bagwell was a stranger selection, but his entire hiring appeared justified by a crowd reaction experiment conducted by Vince McMahon on the night he acquired his struggling rival. Engaging in a rather convoluted thumbs up/thumbs down straw poll with his audience, 'The Stuff' drew an inexplicably loud response.
The volume was still turned up when he made his in-ring debut alongside the former Harlem Heat member in July, but the Tacoma, Washington crowd were ruthless in their flat rejection of the contest.
It was a self-fulfilling prophecy for the company. WWE had spent years brainwashing their core audience to disavow anything remotely associated with WCW, and it had worked remarkably well. The abrupt request to accept the branding, the stars or even the commentators fell on deaf ears and loud dismissal.
Both were mercifully booed, and noticeably flailed under the pressure. A not-very-good match gradually got worse, before company heels Steve Austin and Kurt Angle ran in and decked 'babyface' Booker to a deafening pop.
Bagwell joined them, but took a kicking of his own after helping the real stars literally throw the Champion out of the building.
5. Shawn Michaels Vs Diesel (Madison Square Garden, May 19th 1996)
It's a tale well told, but serendipitously became one of the most important moments in the history of WWE.
A sold out Madison Square Garden house show crowd bore witness to an extremely rare contravention of kayfabe following a steel cage WWE Title match between Shawn Michaels and Diesel. The latter was doing the honours for his best friend as was tradition on a performer's final night with an organisation. 'Big Daddy Cool' was heading south.
So too was Razor Ramon. The pair's exit hadn't gone without notice by selections of the typically plugged-in New York market. Discerning fans in the crowd that night had peppered Scott Hall with 'You Sold Out' chants during his match with Hunter Hearst Helmsley, and given Nash similar treatment in the topliner.
Disdain turned to disbelief midway through Shawn Michaels' celebrations. Razor entered to embrace with his long-time rival, then Shawn appeared to give the floored Diesel a kiss of life before 'Too Sweet'ing him back to health. They were all joined by Hunter, sharing in-ring hugs and high fives as fan jaws dropped at the heel/babyface lines suddenly blurred by reality.
Though reluctantly approved by Vince McMahon, the 'Curtain Call' caused further toxicity amongst a roster of disgruntled and underpaid wrestlers during tough financial times. The statement punishment went to Helmsley, including axing his planned King of the Ring 1996 victory. Eventual winner Steve Austin cut an industry-altering promo in the spot he wasn't intended to have, and a seismic shift had quietly begun.
4. The 2014 Royal Rumble Match
Much will be made about a man that didn't appear in the 2014 Royal Rumble match, but arguably the most controversial iteration of the 30-man battle royal had an additional sting in the tail for another bonafide main event star.
On a night where fans were so vociferous in their support of Daniel Bryan that lifetime babyface Rey Mysterio was hounded out of the match with boos, WWE elected to grossly mistreat the only other superstar in the contest that could have stemmed the tide of scorn.
CM Punk had entered at #1 as part of a power play from The Authority's 'Director of Operations' Kane, who allegedly was positioned as a roadblock for the 'Best In The World' ahead of his planned WrestleMania opponent Triple H. Entering in a gutsy 49-minute display, Punk was cruelly dispatched after making the final four when Kane pulled him over the ropes to the floor and chokeslammed him through the announce table. It was the last straw for a disgruntled audience that ripped shreds out of eventual winner Batista in the aftermath.
As covered extensively in podcasts and interviews since, the match would prove to be CM Punk's last. Electing to walk away from the company the very next day, Punk's growing frustrations with the organisation boiled over before the following evening's Monday Night Raw, with his exit unintentionally guiding a path for Bryan's eventual ascent.
3. The Bella Twins Vs Paige & Emma (WWE Raw)
In an unending quest for strong quarter-hour ratings, it hadn't been uncommon since the figure-grabbing 'Crash TV' era during the late 1990s for matches to run needlessly short on Monday Night Raw. But when a tag team match pitting The Bella Twins against Paige and Emma was allotted just over 30 seconds during a typically bloated three-hour Raw in February 2015, Twitter users galvanised to fight a battle on behalf of the company's top females.
#GiveDivasAChance became a worldwide trend for days as more and more users piled on to highlight the rampant inequality that existed between male and female performers. Many noted the stark contrast between the treatment of women on the main roster in comparison to their NXT counterparts, where Women's Title matches featuring Charlotte, Sasha Banks, Becky Lynch and Bayley were routinely stealing the show.
Ironically, it had been Paige and Emma's choice war at NXT Arrival just under a year earlier that kicked open a door for the developmental 'Four Horsewomen' to command the time they had richly deserved, but the abject failure of the philosophy in transit to the main roster was becoming increasingly problematic.
Vince McMahon's 'We hear you. Keep Watching' tweet in response to the movement did at least foreshadow the gradual shift.
2. The Godfather & Val Venis Vs Jeff Jarrett & The Blue Blazer (WWE Raw)
A nothing tag team match buried in the middle of a rambunctious and overloaded edition of Monday Night Raw was not a fitting end to Owen Hart's televised life and career as a professional wrestler, but his performance was in keeping with his almost unmatched consistency regardless of what he'd been tasked with.
A bastion of saccharine sanctimony under the guise of The Blue Blazer, Owen adjusted his in-ring style accordingly and flustering sex-crazed personas Val Venis and The Godfather with his array of high flying and technical assaults.
In a match surrounded by several of the Godfather's 'Ho's and Women's Champion Debra, fans chanted 'We Want Puppies' for the bulk of the short encounter which distracted both Jerry Lawler and Jim Ross from remotely attempting to call the smooth action in the ring.
Fans facing the hard camera even shot the contest middle fingers whilst 'The King' asked how Ross could even try and focus on the wrestling moves, before JR parked his commentary to hawk SummerSlam tickets by suggesting 'there'll be plenty of puppies on display there'.
Owen's family, friends and contemporaries universally mourned his tragic death the following Sunday, with many stating how he was simply too good for this world. His outstanding talent certainly deserved far more than the Attitude Era could ever afford him.
1. Chris Benoit Vs Elijah Burke (ECW On Sci-Fi)
On commentary, Joey Styles noted how 'Mr McMahon would have wanted the show to go on' as the strains of Chris Benoit's entrance music rang through the Time Warner Cable Arena in Charlotte, North Carolina.
Having apparently passed away as a result of a mysterious limousine explosion weeks earlier, his supposed death dominated proceedings on all three brands, even warranting inclusion in discussion midway the fairly uneventful tournament to determine a new ECW World Champion.
Six days later, the distasteful angle was immediately dropped. Vince himself opened Monday Night Raw in an empty arena to formally announce the deaths of Benoit, his wife Nancy, and son Daniel to his television audience.
The tournament semi final match against Elijah Burke would prove to be 'The Rabid Wolverine's last ever encounter. Uncharacteristically missing a weekend house show in Beaumont, Texas having murdered Nancy on the Friday and Daniel the next day, Benoit was dead himself by the time he was due to be facing CM Punk in the finale he advanced to by virtue of this pedestrian semi-final victory.
As usual, fans erupted for a diving headbutt that turned the tide for 'The Crippler' in the match, but Benoit's pained expression as he grasped at his aching cranium made for uneasy foreshadowing on rewatch.