10 Wrestling Matches That Were Controversially CANCELLED

"Card Subject To Change" isn't always just a carny promotional safety net.

Roman Reigns Goldberg
WWE

Is it any wonder why wrestling has thrived as an escapist form of entertainment for so long? Have you looked outside? The real world will forever be scarier than the one existing on the other side of the screen on whichever night of the week is your favourite.

Roman Reigns is a menacing presence alongside his tortured and belittled family members, but at least he'll never do anything to hurt yours. Jon Moxley is a scary individual reminiscent of the last guy you'd want to see down a dark alley, but only if you're the guy across the ring from him (and perhaps the heckler that was bantered off the face of the planet during his 2022 return to television).

And while we're on Shield members, Seth Rollins is that local oddball on public transport you like to see doing well, just as long as they're not making eye contact with you. No such worry when you're eyeballing the television and singing along with him.

Even WWE itself has the sort of dysfunctional authority hierarchy you'd hate to be a part of in your own life, and it's at least an escape from the real version which releases all your favourite wrestlers every few months.

Dominik Mysterio Vs Mustafa Ali disappeared from view for this very reason in 2023, and it's not the only one to require a similar last-minute change...

10. Jon Moxley Vs Brian Kendrick (AEW Dynamite, Feb 2nd 2022)

Jon Moxley Brian Kendrick
AEW

Jon Moxley Vs Brian Kendrick was, for a scant few hours, the latest in a seemingly endless line of match graphics Tony Khan had at his disposal thanks to his ability to bring wrestlers in on long and short term deals to mix with the great and the good of his regular roster.

That was until - following the announcement - a 2013 interview with Kendrick resurfaced, referencing a number of conspiracy theories on matters including but not limited to the Holocaust, 9/11 and Sandy Hook.

As more conversation was sparked around the offensive remarks, Tony Khan tweeted the following;

"We've been made aware of the abhorrent & offensive comments made in the past by Brian Kendrick. There is no room in AEW for the views expressed by Brian. We think it's best for all that Brian be pulled from tonight's card as we gather more info. We'll announce a replacement bout ASAP."

Kendrick was replaced by Wheeler Yuta that night, and as of writing still hasn't wrestled for the company since.


9. Goldberg Vs Roman Reigns (WWE WrestleMania 36)

Goldberg Roman Reigns
WWE

The graphic above may as well be a farewell to 'The Big Dog' as much as a monument to a lost WrestleMania match.

Roman Reigns was certain to dethrone Bill Goldberg for the Universal Championship at WrestleMania 36, but instead the ‘Tribal Chief’ took a decision that made him more of a locker room leader than any blue piece of leather ever could have done - he went home.

2020’s ‘Show Of Shows’ was the first major wrestling event to be impacted by the onset of lockdowns enforced by a new and terrifying global pandemic. Electing to run the event from their makeshift Performance Center television studio, Vince McMahon - knowing about as little as anybody else did in those early days - forged ahead, and nearly every major talent gingerly obliged. Reigns wasn’t as easily convinced.

With newborns at home, fresh memories of the relatively time he’d taken away to battle leukaemia, and a clearer head than many, the Number One contender glanced at the bigger picture and thought better of it.

Braun Strowman was instead inserted as an eleventh hour replacement, and Reigns wasn’t seen again until a SummerSlam return that proved transformative for his entire career.


8. CM Punk Vs Ricky Starks (AEW All Out 2023)

AEW Collision CM Punk Ricky Starks
AEW

Though a graphic was never produced and an official announcement was never made, CM Punk Vs Ricky Starks was as good as sold shortly before the former's acrimonious exit from the company.

With All In and All Out just seven days apart, several big names had to have multiple stories on the go at once, and Punk's Wembley showdown with Samoa Joe was paired neatly with his ongoing dispute with 'Absolute' over several absorbing weeks on Collision.

Starks brought everything to the boil between the two when - having lost conclusively to "Real World Champion" Punk on television, he whipped guest referee Ricky Steamboat with his belt. A strap match looked sure to be the stipulation coming out of All in, but when the conversation moved to everything that happened behind the camera rather than in front of it, Ricky Starks was short one opponent.

It was negative-to-positive stuff for him in the end. Starks versus last-minute replacement Bryan Danielson at All Out was the best match of his career, but for now at least, the CM Punk saga remains unfinished.


7. Shawn Michaels Vs Dean Douglas (WWE In Your House 4)

Shawn Michaels Dean Douglas
WWE

A lighting bolt in the ring but a lightning rod for just about everything else, 1995 Shawn Michaels was as much a maverick as he was a miserable presence to be around, per just about every account of the time.

To this day there's disagreement around the specific severity of the beating he took when a Syracuse bar scuffle between wrestlers and patrons/marines got out of hand, but it was enough to rule 'HBK' out of a planned Intercontinental Championship defence against Dean Douglas at In Your House 4.

If only that were the end of the story.

Douglas' on-camera involvement (and what came next) added to the conspiratorial nature of the suspicions. Michaels had previous (and future) with not losing titles, and Douglas was a known political enemy of The Kliq. The very same Kliq that featured Razor Ramon, the man that immediately dethroned 'The Dean' reducing the length of his reign to a matter of minutes.


6. Jeff Jarrett Vs Hulk Hogan (NWA:TNA, 2003)

Hulk Hogan Jeff Jarrett NJPW
New Japan

When Jeff Jarrett burst into a NJPW press conference and waffled Hulk Hogan over the head with a guitar, the wrestling world buzzed about the prospect of the two fighting for the first time in three long and industry-altering years.

The last time they'd shared space together, WCW was falling apart at the seams with them at the heart of the demise. Bash At The Beach 2000's pathetic worked shoot angle between the two men and Vince Russo was as representative of the creative collapse as any other blunder that year, but money was left on the table with them to have a worked programme as a result.

It looked as though Jarrett's NWA: TNA would be the place, and as Hogan's blood splattered onto 'Double J's bright white jeans and t-shirt, the upstart group had crafted a money-drawing visual powerful enough to sell Bound For Glory 2003 as their maiden three hour pay-per-view.

It never came to pass. Hogan cited knee and hip issues ruling him out of the match, though multiple people suggested that 'The Hulkster' was using the talks as a bargaining chip to make a return to WWE. They may have been onto something - Hogan wrestled for the market leader in 2005 and 2006 before he finally landed, disastrously, with the group in 2010.


5. Hangman Page Vs PAC (AEW Double Or Nothing 2019)

Hangman Page PAC
AEW

"Creative differences" were cited as the reason why the first angle AEW ever shot for the first pay-per-view they were ever set to promote didn't go ahead back in 2019, and the saga of the lost Hangman Page Vs PAC Double Or Nothing 2019 match doesn't end there.

With PAC out of the question for the May 25th show in Las Vegas (more on that later) Page was forced to be "The Joker" in a clandestine pre-show Battle Royal that was now conveniently for the Number One Contendership to the AEW World Heavyweight Championship.

The differences in question supposedly were to do with PAC's commitments elsewhere at the time. As Open the Dream Gate Championship for Dragon Gate, he wasn't in the position to lose via pinfall on such a high profile stage. This resulted in another piece of AEW trivia best confined to the past - the first official match in company history was a surprise booking for a Wrestlegate Pro show in Nottingham, England, and in the clean finishes promotion...went to a disqualification.


4. Bret Hart Vs Shawn Michaels (WWE King Of The Ring 1997)

Bret Hart Shawn Michaels King Of The Ring 1997
WWE

WWE television had become unmissable in the summer of 1997, driven mostly by the actions of an irrepressible Stone Cold Steve Austin and some key retoolings of company mainstays Bret Hart, Shawn Michaels and The Undertaker.

That energy wasn’t exactly evident for the 1997 King Of The Ring though. The tournament field obscured Mankind’s awesome babyface turn but revealed Triple H as a winner still not ready for his spot, and Undertaker’s humdrum feud with Faarooq was overwhelmed by the first teases of Kane’s existence and an Ahmed Johnson mini-feud on the side. They we’re going to get away with all that though, because one the very same night they had former Hollywood Blondes Steve Austin and Brian Pillman wrestling for the first time in WWE, and Bret Hart taking on Shawn Michaels for the first time since WrestleMania XII.

Tensions ran high in the build, but they infamously ran too high when Hart and Michaels were involved in real backstage fight on June 6th. ‘The Hitman’ was reinjured and the bout was rendered untenable.

Austin Vs Michaels was reasonably deemed a suitable replacement for the pay-per-view (the battle of the former Blondes was bumped to Raw the night after), but yet more drama between ‘The Excellence Of Execution’ and ‘The Heartbreak Kid’ only heightened the hunger for their on-screen showdown.


3. Zelina Vega & Carmella Vs Liv Morgan & Toni Storm (WWE SmackDown, September 10th 2021)

Zelina Vega Toni Storm
WWE

Fans raced to Zelina Vega's defence in 2021 when, a day short of the 20th anniversary of her Father's tragic passing on September 11th 2001, her SmackDown match was cut at the last minute.

Vega was supposed to team with Carmella against Liv Morgan and Toni Storm, and noted that Vince McMahon was the one responsible for the change. She added that he'd called her personally to apologise too.

"A lot of people were really upset, but I felt like a lot of the anger was misguided,I was disappointed, but I also knew it wasn't a personal thing...when it got cut, Vince McMahon called me and apologised because he wanted to make sure that I knew, 'Listen, this wasn't done to you personally or anything, it was literally just [the time], I had to make that call and I'm so sorry.'"

Moved to comment specifically because of the support she'd received, she added;

"...the outpouring of love I felt that day and a bunch of other days too is incredible. Without the fans, we'd literally be nowhere. Just know it wasn't something done personally to me. To have a boss to care enough to call you and go 'Look, I'm sorry' that's important."

With the matter addressed publicly, the teams eventually worked together seven days later, with Morgan and Storm picking up the win via count out.


2. Roman Reigns Vs Adam Pearce (WWE Royal Rumble 2021)

Roman Reigns Adam Pearce
WWE

There'll be books written about WWE's output during the pandemic one day, and depending on the detail they'll potentially be as depressing as the rolling lockdowns themselves.

Flashpoints of creativity were rule-proving exceptions between 2020-21, as WWE somehow made their 2018-19 "we're sorry it's awful, we'll fix it, honestly" era look like 1980s Mid South by comparison. Never had stuff just happened with a randomness alien to just about every scripted show in history, and by the time January 2021 came around they decided to let a potential Universal Championship match between Roman Reigns and Adam Pearce marinate as if it were the real deal. Far from the biggest creative crime committed in The ThunderDome, but really weird and dumb to look at all the same.

Pearce had tried and failed to get a handle on Roman's increased megalomania on SmackDown, and worked himself into a shoot long enough to get slapped on the graphic for seven days. Kevin Owens was the eventual replacement, trying one last time to wrestle the belt away from 'The Tribal Chief' before going to the back of the line for a full 12 months until he got another crack.


1. Taz Vs Sabu (ECW Barely Legal '97)

Sabu Taz ECW
WWE.com

The payoff to a near-two year rivalry did indeed go down on Extreme Championship Wrestling's historic first pay-per-view, but a match that felt like it may never happen almost hit the skids in late-1996 when the entire event looked to be as good as done.

Facts trumped fiction for the hardcore outfit at the time, when the infamous "Mass Transit" incident occurred, resulting in a Christmas Eve cancellation of Barely Legal altogether. The 17-year-old barely-trained Erich 'Mass Transit' Kulas lied his way into a substitute spot and was bladed so brutally by New Jack that blood literally squirted out of his head, and this was enough to send the providers running for the hills. Ostensibly forever.

After one full year of unanswered call-outs following a nasty split at November To Remember 1995, Taz and Sabu finally stared each other down at the 1996 version of the event on November 16th. It fell exactly one week before Kulas' bloodletting and the winter of the company's discontent. The destination was dead.

There was no singular showdown Paul Heyman had exerted more patience with than the battle between 'The Human Suplex Machine' and the 'Homicidal, Suicidal, Genocidal' madman. To give fans the long-awaited first taste in November only to lose it (and everything else the shows had been building towards) seven days later was a darkness-before-the-dawn period like few others in wrestling history.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.