10 Wrestling Matches We Didn’t Know Changed EVERYTHING
How a forgotten Goldust vs Starrdust B-PPV match has ended up changed the wrestling landscape.
Usually, the shifting trajectory of professional wrestling can be traced to a single match because that match promises change. The very idea is to make change happen.
The big, World Championship win is framed as the pinnacle of achievement, and often the genesis of a new era. Bret Hart's maiden 1992 reign gradually shifted the WWF away from magnetic if basic hoss battles powered by megastars; with the mainstream bubble burst, only the real wrestling fans remained. Bret Hart was the wrestler for the wrestling fan: an astute choice to lead what would be subsequently marketed as the New Generation.
'Stone Cold' Steve Austin captured the WWF Heavyweight Championship from Shawn Michaels at WrestleMania XIV in front of a roaring crowd adorned in those iconic 'Austin 3:16' black tees. In doing so, he was framed as the undisputed, super-over top star of the emerging Attitude Era. That match was designed to convey the idea of change, and the design was meticulous. Vince McMahon refused to crown Austin prematurely, willingly allowing Montreal to happen rather than present Austin's huge moment as a rushed political necessity.
The landscape also changes by accident.
That famous design, and the character itself, may not have exploded the industry, had he not made an impression in the mind of his boss - and on the whipped back of a 1996 opponent...
10. Triple H Vs. Buck Zumhofe - WWF Wrestling Challenge, April 25, 1995
At the time, this was thoroughly unremarkable New Generation undercard fare: beyond the electric, quietly revolutionary in-ring main event style, the WWF, deprived of star power, experimented with super-gimmicks divorced from reality.
Hunter Hearst Helmsley was one of many: a blue blood aristocrat character, he debuted, in a bizarre spot of trivia, opposite abhorrent, incestuous paedophile Buck Zumhofe. Helmsley entered the ring with his nose stuck firmly in the air, almost reaching the ceiling, before taking Zumfofe down with a few basic grappling holds. Flooring Zumfofe with a few European uppercuts, Helmsley unleashed a spinning back heel kick, but connected with the knee, betraying the snooty ring general pitch. After some clumsy Irish whip counters, Helmsley won with the quickly-abandoned Ace Crusher.
He stole that one from John 'Johnny Ace' Laurinaitis.
He also stole his position, years and years later, as the Head of Talent Relations and developmental head honcho after a controversial and epic main event career driven, in no small part, by his romantic association with Stephanie McMahon. The raw talent, who struggled to project himself as superior, was said to have brought "civility" to the World Wrestling Federation.
In reality, he altered the very complexion of it, onscreen and off.
Fittingly, the most divisive pro wrestling figure ever epitomised that legacy by both dominating a sterile and often boring main event scene and creating WWE's most critically-acclaimed in-ring product ever.
9. Paige & Emma Vs. The Bella Twins - WWE Monday Night RAW, February 23, 2015
The duration of this match was an insult. It lasted 30 seconds on a three hour episode of Monday Night RAW.
It wasn't just the duration; the way the finish was laid out framed the losers as something worse than that. Paige looked distressed on the apron, like she just couldn't wait to get at the Bella Twins. Emma tried to cool her down. It isn't worth it, she seemed to gesture. Keep your cool, and we'll get 'em in the context of a competitive match. We'll win the right way.
Emma and Paige swiftly lost after Brie Bella knocked Paige off the apron, and like a total numbskull, she checked on her opponent and walked, very slowly, into a Bella Buster. And that was that: a non-match that rendered ironic Paige's 'anti-Diva' nickname. Livid at her peers being booked to look like airhead afterthoughts, AJ Lee spearheaded a resistance on social media. #GiveDivasAChance trended in the wake of this abject match, marking the genesis point of the Divas/Women's Revolution.
Infuriatingly, WWE subsequently framed this as a concept of its own making, as marketed by Stephanie McMahon. Obnoxious, patronising and wildly out of touch, it is a testament to the talent that this all ultimately materialised as classic Last Man Standing matches and the earned main event of WrestleMania.
8. Shawn Michaels Vs. Diesel - WWF House Show, May 19, 1996
On Diesel's last night with the WWF, he went out on his back in time-honoured tradition to put over babyface WWF Champion (and close friend) Shawn Michaels. He then, alongside his Kliq buddies, transgressed on tradition by breaking kayfabe. The ruse was up, but the WWF preserved it to maintain the integrity of a fictional universe that hadn't yet revealed itself.
At the end of the match, heel Hunter Hearst Helmsley and babyface Razor Ramon entered the ring. The four men dropped all semblance of their characters to say goodbye to the WCW-bound Nash and Hall. This indulgence pissed off the talent that already resented the Kliq's politicking, and raised the ire of key office personnel. It hardly affected the WWF's fictional universe.
For all the pearl-clutching of breaking kayfabe, really, it takes something like Vince Russo's systemic desecration to alienate the audience - but to restore morale, Hunter was punished. Vince couldn't punish Nash and Hall, and Michaels was the WWF Champion. This wasn't close to his worst behaviour, anyway, and Hunter's punishment was a symbolic gesture.
This incident catalysed a butterfly effect. Austin was significantly more than a catchphrase, as much as history benefits from cinematic, signposted narrative. He was always going to become a superstar.
Still, he wouldn't have eliminated Jake Roberts from the 1997 King Of The Ring. Roberts had left the company in February of that year. With no born again Christian to ridicule, the Austin 3:16 catchphrase would not have been born.
7. Steve Austin Vs. Savio Vega - WWF In Your House: Beware Of Dog
Steve Austin arrived in the WWF, by the design of the creative team, as a dry technician in character and indeed name. Austin was dismayed; he had revolted against this exact perception in his hilarious, incendiary ECW stint, and petitioned for change. It was granted; drawing inspiration from the serial killer Richard “Iceman” Kuklinski, Austin evolved into a ruthless, indiscriminate badass complete with a more ferocious in-ring style.
Vince McMahon was taken with it immediately, and held tentative plans to crowd Austin as the King Of The Ring just six months into his WWF career. This was, of course, the back-up plan that resulted from the political requirement to scapegoat Hunter.
If Vince wasn't firmly convinced before the events of the ill-fated and fateful In Your House: Beware Of Dog pay-per-view, he sure as sh*t was throughout Austin's literally belting Caribbean Strap Match opposite Savio Vega. A match of immense physicality and intelligent drama, Austin brutalised Vega in such a convincing and ghoulish manner that Vince was unconcerned about the power failure and the imminent PR/scheduling headache. According to Bruce Prichard, he was simply too absorbed in the match in the moment.
In a blackened arena, Austin's clear star power illuminated everything, igniting the WWF's second, gigantic boom period.
6. Okato Vs. D'Angelo Dinero - TNA IMPACT, March 15, 2011
The absolute state of the best pro wrestler on the planet here. Kazuchika Okada epitomised TNA's fundamental inability to spot, build or preserve talent that hadn't arrived in its lap from WWE.
After a brief run as the nonentity 'Okada' character, very much a token Japanese act that, while obvious, was not particularly offensive by the standards of a North American promotion, Vince Russo repackaged the future Rainmaker as 'Okato'. Okato was modelled after Bruce Lee's Kato character in the 1960s Green Hornet TV show. Double retrograde, Okada was a joke under that black eye mask, under which Russo hid him because, in his words:
"You will never, ever, ever, ever, ever see the Japanese wrestlers or the Mexican wrestlers truly be over and draw money in American mainstream wrestling."
Russo said that years and years after Rey Mysterio, a performer boasting rich Mexican heritage, had gotten himself over as revolutionary superstar on US soil. Russo, a known cable TV junkie, watched a re-run and thought "F*ck it". New Japan Pro Wrestling, appalled at the presentation of its top prospect, also said "F*ck it," and severed ties with TNA. TNA effectively annoyed NJPW into creating the most critically acclaimed wrestler of all time. With Okada at the helm, a Japanese promotion took over Impact as the second biggest company in North America prior to the emergence of AEW.
At this year's G1 Supercard in Madison Square Garden, the same headlining "Japanese wrestler" Vince Russo made a mockery of outdrew, by orders of magnitude, any gate Russo ever managed at the helm of TNA.
5. The Undertaker Vs. Superfly Jimmy Snuka - WrestleMania VII
At WrestleMania VII, the emerging Undertaker character made swift work of Superfly Jimmy Snuka in a short, nondescript midcard match typical of the era. This was the genesis of the Dead Man's incredible Streak of wins on the Grandest Stage.
Obviously, nobody who watched predicted the events to come. That is because Undertaker's career remains and perhaps will forever remain unprecedented; this is a hoss performer who somehow conspired to join the elite workers a decade removed from his physical prime of 1997, in a reflection of his supernatural aura that also enriched it. 'Taker developed the resulting Streak not through meticulous design but the byproduct of consistent, sensible booking, from which WWE profited and had the nous to market as the most illustrious achievement in company history.
Over time, the strength of the WrestleMania brand sold itself. We have a reached a point by which the show sells out, or near enough, before the announcement of the card. The latter years of 'Taker's streak had much to do with it; the spectacle was so awesome, with so much significance, that WWE transitioned into the stadium era with no hesitation.
Everybody fantasy booked the Streak match all year 'round, and yet it was always better than any Reddit thread.
4. Daniel Bryan Vs. Sheamus - WWE WrestleMania XXVIII
So disrespectful and farcical that the entire fandom rejected it, from the greatest of humiliations sprang the greatest of modern babyface World Title victories.
Sheamus booted a distracted Bryan in the face at WrestleMania XXVIII in stunt booking that drastically misjudged fan sentiment. In that picture alone, two 'YES!' signs can be seen held aloft. Sheamus was the clear, jovial, babyface in the dreaded Cena mould; Bryan in contrast was the infinitely more interesting performer. WWE, of course, went with Sheamus, in an effectively satirical development that simply astonished and pissed off fans into screaming along with his call-and-response with as much defiance as Bryan had.
This bizarre, tone-deaf accident babyfaced Bryan more effectively than anything WWE has designed in years and years, bringing into focus just how comically ineffective the machine is. Beyond the truncated reign, the rise of Daniel Bryan, a genius of his own making, made it abundantly plain that the in-house development prospects were not enough to maintain WWE's popularity nor dominance. His success revised WWE's recruitment policy, catalysing the second NXT era. In a weird parallel, WWE is still trying to get the Brogue Kick over, in that it is Baron Corbin and not, say, Finn Bálor headlining four consecutive pay-per-views in 2019.
WWE is still resistant to change following the match that changed everything.
3. The Rock Vs. Steve Austin - WWF WrestleMania X-Seven
This match - fought between two super-over megastars, at the biggest and best event of the company's most popular and lucrative period - put an end to it.
It wasn't a disaster. It was incredible. Austin and Rock perfected the crazed crowd brawling beloved of the time, and perfectly intersected the themes of personal hatred and professional respect. They laid in the chair shots and the closed fists, but utilisied the most devastating weapons of the other to claim victory at whatever cost.
Austin of course claimed victory at the ultimate cost, his very soul, in a shocking storyline development that, while audacious and not without creeping fan support, torpedoed the WWF's popularity. It hardly mattered that the turn was performed so brilliantly by all three players. Rock sold as if near death, Austin look remorseless and monstrous, and Mr. McMahon looked slightly appalled at just how unhinged Austin had become in pursuit of the WWF Championship.
Incredible match, incredible angle, crippling decision. Ratings and house show attendances plummeted almost immediately - despite that creeping sentiment, it transpired that fans could not bring themselves to hate Austin - and the subsequent Invasion folly ruined everything, too.
The biggest star in wrestling, and its inconceivable inter-promotional war, both died in 2001.
2. Jeff Jarrett Vs. Chyna - WWF No Mercy 1999
An improbable triumph of a comedy spectacle in itself, the Good Housekeeping match also had massive repercussions on the pro wrestling industry.
Using the audacious, potentially damaging finish as leverage ahead of his impending exit from the WWF, Jarrett asked for the hundreds of thousands of dollars that he was due per his agreement. In fact, per the November 15, 1999 Wrestling Observer Newsletter, Jarrett successfully negotiated "a higher number, significantly so, than he would have eventually received under normal circumstances."
This obviously pissed Vince McMahon off, so much so that the WWF doctored footage of Jeff Jarrett into the RAW/Nitro simulcast - he wasn't physically present in Panama City - purely so that he could make an example of him. With WCW "Capital G, double O, double N, double E, gone", and faced with a WWF that would rather convolutedly bury than re-sign him, Jarrett was left with no mainstream options in which to make significant money.
And so, the persona non grata of dying mainstream US wrestling sought to create his own competition by founding TNA. In the process, he introduced a raft of generation-defining performers and created several indelible moments of utter, f*ck-brained hilarity.
1. Goldust Vs. Stardust - WWE Fastlane 2015
Cody, in a bid to preserve his standing as the Lightbringer, has placed on record his thanks to WWE. The company paid him a handsome salary, developed his talent, and he would not be where he is without it, etc..
It feels very political.
The events of Double Or Nothing weekend cast Cody as a man with an ax to grind, or a throne to break, more accurately. He was not happy in WWE, or at least wasn't fulfilled. This is why he left. Dustin Rhodes was more outspoken than his brother about their now infamous Fastlane match at 2015 - he deemed it "sh*t" in an interview with WrestlingInc - but also revealed that "Cody wasn't happy with it".
Not coincidentally, perhaps, he left WWE just over a year later.
The match clarified Cody's lot. It was a shared dream between two brothers to wrestle on the Grandest Stage, but the WWE committee mangled the pitch and rushed it, apathetically, on the Fastlane pay-per-view. The story was bizarre, too: the...inter-dimensional (?) Cody acted tormented at failing to capture or live up to his brother's alter-ego. WWE in effect took real, hefty human drama and somehow made weird, space-age B-movie farce.
The Double Or Nothing masterpiece was its tonal opposite. It may not have happened - and AEW may not have happened - had Cody not realised what happens to lifelong creative aspirations in an oppressive environment.