10 WWE Wrestlers Who Survived HORRIBLE Debuts

Patience! Sometimes, a wretched WWE debut isn't the creative death sentence it first appears.

Reverend D-Von Deacon Batista WWE
WWE

As the old saying goes, you only get one chance to make a first impression. This is especially true in wrestling. If you make a fool of yourself the first time you walk out on TV, then it will stay with you for the rest of your career. Just ask The Shockmaster.

A bad debut isn't ideal, but it doesn't have to be a death sentence. The wrestling gods can be benevolent enough to hand out a second chance, and the recipient can go on to have a career good enough to make everyone forget how much they sucked the first time around.

This list features everyone from cult heroes and main eventers to bonafide WWE Hall Of Famers. All of them had debuts that could be best described as...disappointing, but none of that mattered once they really hit their stride. 

We've taken a rather loose approach to the definition of 'debut'. Sometimes we're talking about a match, sometimes a promo segment; sometimes a wrestler will have been on TV before, but as a different character or as part of a developmental brand.

Either way, all of these workers had absolute shockers.

10. Danhausen

WWE Elimination Chamber 2026 Danhausen
WWE.com

Somebody on WWE's creative team had clearly been watching Se7en in the build-up to Elimination Chamber 2026, because that show was all about "WHAT'S IN THE BOX?!"

A large crate had been bouncing back and forth between Raw and SmackDown for weeks prior to the PLE. At the show itself, General Managers Adam Pearce and Nick Aldis pried the thing open to reveal some precious cargo inside. Was it Chris Jericho? Was it Vince McMahon? Was it the ghost of Bruno Sammartino? Nope, it was Danhausen!

The former AEW star and collector of teeth made a characteristically flamboyant arrival with dancing girls and bombastic music. Sadly, this did absolutely nothing for the crowd, who sat on their hands throughout. People were incredibly worried about Danhausen's future. His irreverent comedic style was too out there for a mainstream audience, or so it seemed.

Thankfully, over the next few months, he proved everyone wrong. 

Danhausen is currently one of the most over acts on WWE's roster. The company clearly loves him, as they push him at every possible opportunity. He's more successful now than he ever was in AEW and it's glorious to see.


9. LA Knight

X Wrestlers WWE Debuted In The WORST Way Possible Max Dupri Adam Pearce
WWE

This isn't technically a debut, as LA Knight had already appeared in NXT, but his main roster call-up was a complete disaster. In 2022, the former TNA Champion appeared on SmackDown as Max Dupri, the annoying head of talent agency Maximum Male Models. 

This was a gimmick straight out of the 1980s, and even then it would have been midcard at best. The worst part was that Knight wasn't expected to wrestle as Dupri, instead serving as a manager to Mace and Mansoor. Oops, sorry, that should be "ma.çé" and "mån.sôör". 

Mercifully, this entire angle was dropped almost as soon as Vince McMahon retired later that year. Knight publicly buried the Dupri persona and reverted back to his old ways. Shockingly, he got massively over. What a surprise! 

Though many feel Triple H has missed the boat on pushing Knight as a top star, he's now a very respected member of the roster with plenty of memorable moments under his belt. Considering he could have spent the rest of his career wearing a suit, that has got to be considered a win.


8. The Miz

The Miz WWE Diva Search
WWE.com

Given that his background was in reality TV (having appeared on MTV's The Real World prior to becoming a wrestler), you can see why The Miz was asked to host the Diva Search as his first big main roster gig in WWE. 

After first entering the system as a contestant on the 2004 series of Tough Enough, Miz re-emerged in July 2006. As the 'host' of SmackDown (whatever that meant), part of his responsibilities included letting audiences know how they could vote in the all-female talent competition. 

This led to an infamous segment on Raw: Miz forgot what he was supposed to say and was eaten alive by the audience for checking notes on his wrist. If you somehow haven't seen this, do yourself a favour and seek it out.

Even after the Diva Search wrapped up, it wasn't clear that Miz would be employed for much longer. It was only when he formed a tag-team with John Morrison that his career really started to pick up and he began his journey to becoming the company stalwart he is today.


7. Becky Lynch

Becky Lynch NXT
WWE

There's a long list of stereotypical, moderately-offensive nationality-based gimmicks in wrestling. From Tito Santana as 'El Matador' to Rusev's pro-Russia character (even though he's from Bulgaria), wrestling bookers definitely aren't afraid to take the easy option when it comes to non-American talent.

One country that has suffered this curse more than most is Ireland. Up until very recently, if you were an Irish wrestler in WWE, then you would either wear green, have a tin whistle in your entrance music, or (in the case of Becky), dance your way down to the ring. 

Before her 2014 debut match in NXT, Lynch was told to go out and do her best Michael Flatley impression. Her now-infamous Irish jig gimmick made her look like a complete chump and was thankfully dropped shortly thereafter. 

The worst part about this whole debacle? She couldn't even dance! Becky looked like she was trying to flick something off the bottom of her shoes rather than pay homage to her culture. As we all know, Lynch is one of the biggest stars in WWE right now, but things could have gone very differently.


6. Daniel Bryan

Daniel Bryan Justin Roberts SummerSlam 2010
WWE

On 7 June 2010, the landscape of WWE changed forever...or so we thought. That episode of Raw saw the arrival of Nexus, a group of rookies from the first season of NXT looking to make an impact. However, the next time they appeared on screen, their numbers had mysteriously fallen from 8 to 7.

Daniel Bryan, one of the finest independent wrestlers in the world at the time, had not only been fired from the group, but from the entire company. His crime? Choking ring announcer Justin Roberts with a tie, an act deemed too violent by WWE's sponsors. 

This could have been the end of the 'American Dragon', but it turns out it was the best thing that ever happened to him.

Bryan would make his return to WWE against Nexus at SummerSlam 2010. Whilst that group died a slow, painful death, he was allowed to pursue his own singles career, and we all know how that ended. If Bryan had stayed in the Nexus, he might have gone down with the sinking ship. Maybe this was his plan all along.

Vegans can see into the future, right?


5. Eddie Guerrero

Eddie Guerrero WWE Debut Injury
WWE

It's one thing to lose your WWE debut match, but to lose your debut and get injured? That doesn't bear thinking about. That's what happened to Eddie Guerrero, who almost blew his entire career in one night. 

'Latino Heat' was part of the iconic Radicalz stable of ex-WCW wrestlers who jumped ship to WWE in early 2000. On the 3 February edition of SmackDown, Guerrero teamed up with Perry Saturn for his first official match against the New Age Outlaws. That new duo had been booked to win, but something went horribly wrong. 

Guerrero dislocated his elbow when executing his trademark Frog Splash. Upon realising he was hurt, he panicked, and told Road Dogg to pin him. As a result, he and Saturn lost the match in under 5 minutes. Not only did Guerrero look like a loser, but he was now out of action for several weeks. 

It's actually incredible that WWE didn't cut him on the spot.

Clearly they saw Eddie's potential. After a topsy-turvy few years, Guerrero achieved his full potential by winning the WWE Title in 2004; and he did it without breaking his own arm this time.


4. Batista

Deacon Batista
WWE.com

Looking at the gigantic, hulking frame of Dave Bautista in 2002, Vince McMahon decided: 'Hmm, this guy should carry a collection box!'. Thus, the short-lived (but memorable for all the wrong reasons) character of 'Deacon Batista' was born. 

The future Hollywood star made his debut as the silent henchman of D-Von Dudley, who was going through his 'Reverend' phase, on SmackDown. Whilst Bubba's brother rallied against the sins of man, Batista just stood there doing nothing, and for bloody ages. 

His earliest matches in WWE were tag bouts with D-Von by his side. That included an early feud with his future Evolution partner Randy Orton. Batista eventually split from the Rev in late 2002, getting drafted to Raw and taking on the persona we all know and love today. 

'Menacing Church Man' is not one of the most exciting ideas in the world. Thankfully, he wasn't trapped in this cartoonish nightmare for too long and was quickly scooped up by Triple H's new group. The success of Evolution quickly washed the taste of the Deacon out of everyone's mouths, but Batista probably never went to church again!


3. Edge

Edge Debut
WWE.com

Daniel Bryan might've caused Justin Roberts some discomfort during his WWE debut, but at least he didn't full-on injure someone. That, however, was the fate which befell one of his WrestleMania 37 opponents: 'Rated-R Superstar' Edge.

After weeks of teasing his arrival in vignettes, the long-haired Canadian heartthrob had his very first televised Raw match on 22 June 1998. His opponent was José Estrada Jr, who you might remember as a member of Los Boricuas alongside Savio Vega.

Edge was supposed to go over strong in his debut, but he might have tried a little too hard. The newbie went to hit a somersault senton to Estrada outside of the ring, and accidentally (legitimately) injured the Puerto Rican's neck. José was unable to get back in the ring, so his young opponent was declared the winner via countout. 

Getting a reputation as unsafe can seriously hamper a wrestler's career. Look at Public Enemy, the ECW team who were bullied out of WWE for being too stiff. Luckily for our favourite spear-addicted 'Ultimate Opportunist', he was given another chance and made his pay-per-view debut at SummerSlam about a month later.

We're sure Estrada was thrilled.


2. The Rock

The Rock Debut
WWE

This might be cheating slightly as The Rock's WWE debut was a runaway success from a kayfabe perspective. The company's first ever third-generation superstar was part of a 5-on-5 elimination match at the 1996 Survivor Series. 

As Rocky Maivia, he eliminated Crush and Goldust to win the bout for his team and end the night as the sole survivor. Unfortunately, he did so while looking like a massive dweeb. With floppy hair, tassels and a level of forced smile usually reserved for real estate agents, Rocky was simply inviting people to bully him.

His impressive in-ring display couldn't overcome the god-awful presentation WWE had saddled him with, and crowds immediately decided they didn't like this blue chipper with a silver spoon in his mouth. 

Their treatment of him only got worse over the next few months. Crowds fully turned against this bland babyface, as chants of "Die Rocky Die" rang out in arenas across the country. Of course, this would all be forgotten when he turned heel, joined the Nation Of Domination and changed his name to 'The Rock'.

The rest, as they say, is history.


1. Steve Austin

The Ringmaster Steve Austin Ted DiBiase Brother Love
WWE.com

It turns out that Dwayne Johnson wasn't the only major 'Attitude Era' star to overcome a shoddy first gimmick. 

'Stunning' Steve Austin was one of the most exciting midcard prospects in WCW. A gifted wrestler with decent mic skills, he improved his talking ability during a short stint in ECW. So, naturally, when he finally made it to WWE, they decided to make him mute. 

As 'The Ringmaster', Austin was put into an unlikely partnership with Ted DiBiase. 'The Million Dollar Man' did all the talking, and Austin just stood there clutching the Million Dollar belt (probably thinking about what he was gonna have for his tea later - raw potatoes, presumably).

By early 1996, Austin was sick of this one-note gimmick. After seeing Bruce Willis in Pulp Fiction, he decided to shave his head and embrace his trash-talking Texan roots. The end result was the newly rechristened 'Stone Cold', and the rest, as they say...wait a second, we've already done that. 

Both Austin and The Rock are key examples of wrestlers 'getting good' by embracing their true personalities as part of their gimmicks. There's a reason why Rocky Maivia and The Ringmaster never main-evented WrestleMania, put it that way.


Contributor
Contributor

Jacob Simmons has a great many passions, including rock music, giving acclaimed films three-and-a-half stars, watching random clips from The Simpsons on YouTube at 3am, and writing about himself in the third person.