10 Wrestling Mistakes That Made Matches Better

When real botches create real drama in scripted world.

Great Sasuke Jushin Liger Botch
NJPW

Few things derail a potentially great wrestling match like a botch. To illustrate this, rewind your minds to WWE Super ShowDown 2019

Goldberg vs. The Undertaker was all action, and looked like it would finish respectably until the former WCW Champion's head went crashing into the ring post after a dodged corner Spear. With Goldberg legitimately concussed, a sloppy, dangerous mess unfolded.

Bill nearly killed 'Taker by dropping him on his head with what was supposed to be a Jackhammer. He then failed to get up for the match-ending Chokeslam, though Goldberg's ringside collapse after the bell was the hardest thing to watch.

At least the ageing duo had the concussion as an excuse. This wasn't the case with Aleister Black vs. Lars Sullivan at NXT TakeOver: Chicago II, in which a whiffed Black Mass kick rendered a triumphant monster-slaying a total farce.

But mistakes need not ruin a match, provided nobody is incapacitated. Sometimes, a little roughness enhances the drama instead of taking you out of it, though the wrestlers' response is absolutely critical. Improvising when things go wrong is difficult, but not impossible, and it's something that Goldberg mastered himself 21 years before Super ShowDown...

10. Goldberg Vs. Diamond Dallas Page (WCW Halloween Havoc 1998)

Goldberg DDP
WWE

WCW Halloween Havoc 1998's main event is more famous for one of wrestling's worst technical botches than anything that happened between the ropes. Goldberg and Diamond Dallas Page took to the ring after a horrific Hollywood Hogan vs. The (Ultimate) Warrior clash famously labelled a "disaster" by then-WCW employee Gene Okurland, but the pay-per-view ran three-and-a-half hours rather than the standard three. Thus, the feed was cut with the main event still underway, leaving those who'd paid for the event staring at a black screen.

Fortunately, fans were treated to a fun, bruising encounter when the match aired on Nitro for free the following evening, though things almost went very, very wrong when Goldberg botched his corner spear spot.

Big Bad Bill flew through the turnbuckles as DDP leapt out of the way, crashing into the ring post. His shoulder was wrecked. Rather than working his usual bulldozer style, Goldberg was forced to adapt. Page, thinking on his feet, took advantage of his one-armed opponent with some snapping limb work, exposing the monster's legitimate vulnerability in the kayfabe realm. Later, Goldberg knocked himself loopy by spearing DDP so hard his head spiked into the mat.

Working on autopilot, a concussed Goldberg struggled to get Page up for the Jackhammer, his ailments bringing gritty realism to what could've been a rudimentary victory. Listening to DDP telling the story himself is almost as big a hoot as the bout.


9. Titus Worldslide (WWE Greatest Royal Rumble 2018)

Titus O'Neil Slide Titus Worldside
WWE

WWE's 50-man Greatest Royal Rumble was one of the stipulation's lesser bouts by design.

The goal wasn't to deliver an all-timer crammed with big-name returns, hair-raising showdowns, and the Rumble's trademark drama but a fun, breezy encounter for a wrestling-deprived Saudi Arabian crowd. To that end, it succeeded. An audience of 60,000 crammed into the King Abdullah International Stadium to watch some of WWE's biggest stars mingle with unlikely debutants (Dan Matha, Babatunde), returnees (The Great Khali, Hornswoggle) and whatever Hiroki Sumi is, with Braun Strowman's record 13 eliminations earning him a shiny commemorative belt.

Ultimately, the Greatest Royal Rumble will go down as a 6/10 match with a 10/10 botch.

Titus Worldslide was 2018's best wrestling meme. As Titus O'Neil sped down the ramp at full pelt, lost his footing, when arse over tit, and skidded under the ring, everyone watching at home lost their minds. Michael Cole and co. couldn't keep it together in the announce booth either and Titus, to his credit, took it extremely well, even when WWE came out with a commemorative t-shirt. Sadly, he lasted just under five minutes before getting thrown out.


8. Sgt. Slaughter Vs. Pat Patterson (WWF At Madison Square Garden - 4 May 1981)

Sgt. Slaughter Blood
WWE

A dirty, grimy fight befitting the build, Sgt. Slaughter vs. Pat Patterson was set up when Sarge called the former Intercontinental Champion "yellow." Slaughter then bullheadedly challenged Pat to break his Cobra Cutch submission for a $10,000 prize (double the usual total) and Patterson came within a hair of doing so in their first match, prompting the heel to let the hold go and destroy his foe with a chair. Broken up by Dominic Denucci, Tony Garea, and Rick Martel, its lingering heat led to the Alley Fight.

Watch this match. It's the kind of brawl largely lost to time in wrestling's athletic evolution, with the lack of referee hammering home that this was a scrap, not a wrestling match, and this was reflected in the work. Patterson and Slaughter brought a bar fight to Madison Square Garden.

Sarge's accidental gusher raised everything a notch. He flew into the ring post, flopping back down with one of his trademark theatrical bumps. His face was cloaked within seconds. Later, dizzy from the blood loss and with plasma seeping into his eyes, Slaughter's blind brass-knuckle flailing was that of a desperate, dying fighter, and there was nothing fake about it.


7. Big Van Vader Vs. Stan Hansen (NJPW Super Fight In Tokyo Dome 1990)

Vader Japan
Courtesy: Matchaftermatch.wordpress.com

In which Vader's eye literally pops out of its socket.

Vader and Stan Hansen were as stiff and nasty as they were big and beefy. For Hansen, the snugness with which he worked wasn't entirely a matter of choice. Wrestling folklore states that the Unsinkable Battleship's poor eyesight meant that if he didn't throw everything into every shot, it'd either look too soft or he'd miss completely, thus exposing his act. This led to a 27-year career of jaw-rattlingly hard-hitting battles with anyone willing to respond in kind.

No American wrestler could rival Hansen's stiffness other than Vader, whom Stan wrestled for the first time in February 1990. The eyeball near-disaster came after a typically barbaric striking exchange. In it, Hansen accidentally caught Vader's eye with a thumb. Out it popped, creating one of wrestling's most horrifying visuals, but Leon White - that hard, hard bastard - pushed it back in, held it in place with his eyelid, and fought Hansen to a no contest.

The image might be more iconic than the match itself (how couldn't it be?), but not scripted, kayfabe act could ever generate such a shocked response.


6. The Undertaker Vs. Mankind (WWE King Of The Ring 1998)

Mankind Undertaker Hell in a Cell 1
WWE Network

Mankind's first Hell In A Cell bump in his and The Undertaker's famous King of the Ring 1998 match was very much planned. It was Terry Funk's idea, with 'Taker asking Foley "Mick, do you want to die?', when presented with it, though he eventually agreed. 21 years later, the sight of Mankind being thrown to his near-death from 20ft high remains iconic.

That Foley returned to the match, let alone took another bump from atop the cell, is remarkable. That second fall wasn't meant to happen, though. Undertaker's Chokeslam was supposed to plant Mankind on top of the structure's roof, not through it, which, according to Funk, is how the prop guy had designed the set. Panels would sag under the performers' weight without giving way completely.

But the panel did give way, and Mick's body crashed into the mat below. 'Taker later revealed that he thought Foley was dead but he couldn't break character to react. Mick, meanwhile, called it the "best and worst Chokeslam I ever took," claiming that the only reason he had survived was that he was too exhausted to properly lift his body for the move.

Either way, his second fall to hell somehow escalated the horror of the first.


5. Kurt Angle Vs. Shane McMahon (WWE King Of The Ring 2001)

King Of The Ring 2001 Kurt Angle Shane McMahon Glass
WWE.com

Owner of the worst worked punches and loosest triangle hold in pro wrestling he may be, but Shane McMahon has always been an entertaining crash test dummy.

While veering close to redundant in 2022, even as recently as 2019, he could work an enjoyable arena-wide brawl with The Miz and excel as a dirtbag against the Graveyard Dogs, though King of the Ring 2001's clash with Kurt Angle will always be his most critically revered bout.

Their Street Fight's most memorable moment is Angle belly-to-belly suplexing McMahon through a glass "KOR" panel. Unfortunately for the performers' bodies, that's where things went wrong. Whoever had prepared the glass hadn't gimmicked it to shatter on impact, meaning Angle's first attempt saw Shane's body bounce off the panel and land right on his head. They didn't give up, though. Angle suplexed McMahon through the pane on his second attempt. He then tried to put him through another, and again, the glass held firm.

Shane's body took a pounding, and these spots gone wrong not only helped put the Olympian over as a vicious, unrelenting bully, but also McMahon's ability to take a beating.


4. The Undertaker Vs. Shawn Michaels (WWE WrestleMania 25)

WrestleMania 25 Undertaker Botched Dive
WWE.com

A popular choice when discussing the greatest WWE match of all time, The Undertaker vs. Shawn Michaels at WrestleMania 25 is a stone-cold dramatic classic that finished highly on many a Match of the Year ballot, and had the crowd so hot that the World Heavyweight and WWE Championship bouts that followed didn't have a hope of getting over.

The contest almost ended in disaster as Undertaker attempt to dive over the top rope. Michaels was on the outside and supposed to pull the cameraman in his way to take the bump and cushion 'The Phenom's' fall, but said cameraman (Sim Snuka in disguise) failed. This meant one of WWE's biggest legends crashing into the floor head-first, then lying around for an uncomfortably long period of time, prompting a "Jesus Christ, he might be dead!" response.

Undertaker would eventually recover to answer the 10-count, keep fighting, and conclude one of his most legendary matches. While the contest was already on its way to greatness, it was impossible not to be gripped after his horrendous bump. Yes, 'Taker likely came within an inch of paralysis, and it was the narrowest of narrow escapes, but the scariness put the world on edge.


3. Kevin Owens Vs. CJ Parker (NXT TakeOver: R Evolution)

CJ Parker Kevin Owens
WWE

One of the most important events in NXT's growth, TakeOver: R Evolution was bookended by Kevin Owens, who swerved "best friend" Sami Zayn after a main event victory over Neville, destroying the new NXT Champion to shockingly set up the WWE chapter of their years-long feud.

It was KO's first night under WWE's developmental banner. In R Evolution's opener, he walked out for a debut match against CJ Parker with genuine tears in his eyes, overwhelmed to finally be there. What followed should have been a straightforward battering. Parker would land a few slithers of offense but ultimately absorb Owens' signature spots, get the p*ss kicked out of him, and leave. That's pretty much what happened, though the intensity was amplified when CJ blasted KO with a mistimed palm strike out of the corner.

Owens' nose was busted open on impact. Parker cut his hand as well, but fighting through this shoot injury made Big Kev look even tougher and more uncompromising in victory, as he was made to labour through genuine hardship on this false finish.

Hurt as he was, though, Owens' real predicament was nothing compared to the worked one he'd put Zayn in later on.


2. The Young Bucks Vs. Lucha Brothers (AEW All Out 2019)

Young Bucks Lucha Brothers
AEW

A Marmite match for its sheer volume of crazy spots, The Young Bucks and Lucha Brothers' Escarlea de la Muerte bout delighted some but disgusted others. These guys were out of control. To put over the kayfabe idea that they were willing to kill themselves and each other to end the feud, they indulged in spots that gave the impression they were shoot willing to kill themselves and each other to end the feud.

The closing stretch saw Pentagon Jr. level up after having his mask torn from his face, sparking a vengeful fire inside him. After retrieving his veil, Penta and Rey Fenix put Nick Jackson in the dirt, then went after Matt, preparing a double stomp/package piledriver combo on a bridged ladder.

The ladder didn't snap. It didn't even come close to giving way, in fact, and while Jackson's head clearly avoided a rung, the implication was that his skull had been driven into cold, ungiving steel.

Seconds later, the Lucha Brothers retrieved the belts. The ladder breaking as intended would have been an effective finish too, just not as brutal as the one we got.


1. The Great Sasuke Vs. Jushin Liger (NJPW Super J Cup 1994)

Great Sasuke Jushin Liger Botch
NJPW

One of the most legendary single nights of wrestling in puroresu history, NJPW's first Super J Cup developed a near-mythical aura amongst '90s tape traders thanks, primarily, to its two epic closing matches.

Jushin Thunder Liger met The Great Sasuke in the second-to-last bout. Liger's one-sided mat wrestling clinic unravelled when Sasuke made it his kind of fight, turning the tide with strikes, speed, and high-flying, building to a breathtaking final act unhindered by a botch that should've seen it fly completely off the rails.

As seen in the above gif, Sasuke slipped on the ropes while trying to springboard onto the turning Liger. What followed was a masterclass in improvisation as the duo twisted the spot into the match's psychology.

With Sasuke decked, Liger mockingly applauded his fallen opponent as he sold the bump, his victory now a certainty. Liger assumed he had time. Thus, he got cocky, took his foot off the gas, and spent a second too long setting up for the end. This allowed Sasuke to leap to his feet and take advantage of an opponent who'd willingly disarmed himself, pinning him with a Hurricanarana roll-up. Immediate comeuppance for Liger's belittling.


Watch Next


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.