10 Wrestling Pay-Per-Views That Tried Something... Different

These shows went against the grain... for better or worse.

NWO Souled Out
WWE.com

For as long as there has been professional wrestling, there have been pay-per-view. Actually, that's a lie - the first wrestling pay-per-view wasn't until 1983 - but the two entities are so intertwined that it certainly feels like this statement is true.

For the longest time, PPVs were the focus of every major wrestling company on the planet. Weekly TV shows were scripted around building to the next big show and fans expected the shows they paid for to have the best matches, the top talent, and the most noteworthy moments.

The classic PPVs formula may not be as important as they once were (thanks WWE Network), but it still exists (thanks AEW). Whilst that formula hasn't changed much over the decades, sometimes wrestling companies take a punt and try something new with their major events.

Whether it's the way in which the shows are presented, how they're marketed, or the talent involved, the following ten shows all took a ga mble; some of them paid off and some of them, well, you'll find out shortly.

What will the next great PPVs innovation be? Who's to say, but they can certainly look to these ten examples for guidance on how to shake things up...

10. NJPW Wrestle Kingdom 14

Wrestle Kingdom 14 Tokyo Dome 2020
NJPWWorld

Since 1992, the Tokyo Dome in... well, Tokyo... has hosted a New Japan Pro Wrestling supercard on the 4th January. Since 2007, these events have been known as "Wrestle Kingdom" and now that word (if it's even a word) is synonymous with great wrestling, high-profile matches, and historic moments.

In 2020, New Japan took the big decision to end this long-standing formula and extend WrestleKingdom over two nights. Whilst they didn't ditch the 4th of January, they were still messing with a tradition that was hardwired into the DNA of pro wrestling.

Thankfully, the show was a huge success. Not only did New Japan repeat the formula for their next Wrestle Kingdom, but WWE also pinched the idea for WrestleMania 36. It's unclear whether or not the Mania would have been over two nights had it not been for the pandemic, but the fact that WrestleMania 37 also took place over two nights is very telling.

The first major wrestling show to go over two nights has already had a profound effect on the wrestling landscape. Here's to Wrestle Kingdom 30, which will probably take place over an entire month.


9. WWF WrestleMania II

WrestleMania 2 Poster
WWE

In 1985, Vince McMahon put on his first ever PPV - the original WrestleMania. The star-studded event was a huge success and propelled the WWF into the pop culture stratosphere. So, when it came to the next year's show, Vince decided not to play it safe and to try and innovate once again.

For WrestleMania II, Vince booked three different arenas across the country; the Nassau Coliseum in New York, the Rosemont Horizon in Illinois, and the Los Angeles Sports Memorial Arena in California with each event getting its own unique card and main event.

Despite the scale of McMahon's vision, the show was not received well. Fans and critics did not approve of the three-venue format and the fact that all the major matches failed to deliver didn't help either. McMahon scrapped the multiple venues idea and every live WrestleMania since has been broadcast from one place and one place only.

It's hard to see how this would have ever worked, especially with the limited technology the company had at the time. Although, with Mania now being a two-night event, now could be the time to try this again.


8. WCW Bash At The Beach 1995

Bash at the Beach 1995
WWE.com

WCW loved to host events in weird locations. The first ever episode of Monday Nitro came live from The Mall of America; Hog Wild came from Sturgis Motorcycle Rally; and everything they did in 2000 felt like it was being broadcast from the pits of hell. Weirdly though, only one of their seven "Bash at the Beach" shows took place on an actual beach.

The 1995 edition of the PPV came live from Huntingdon Beach in California, mere feet away from the Pacific Ocean. 9,500 fans hit the sand to watch bouts between Sting and Meng, Ric Flair and Randy Savage, and Hulk Hogan and Vader. The latter four even made a special appearance on an episode of Baywatch to promote WCW and actual footage from their respective matches were featured on the show.

Whilst Bash at the Beach '95 was far from the first wrestling show to take place outside, the sand and sea against the backdrop of the bright blue California sky makes this one of the most recognisable wrestling Pay-Per-View settings ever and one many fans wish would make a comeback.


7. ECW One Night Stand 2005

Paul Heyman ECW One Night Stand 3
WWE.com

ECW One Night Stand from 2005 is still talked about as one of the greatest wrestling events ever. Four years after it had died an embarrassing death, Extreme Championship Wrestling rose from the ashes of a flaming table to give the world "one last show". Emanating from the Hammerstein Ballroom (the site of the original ECW's final PPV), One Night Stand was jam-packed with nostalgia from the Philadelphia promotion's heyday.

Tommy Dreamer, The Sandman, Mike Awesome, The Dudley Boyz, and more put on violent matches the likes of which had never been seen on WWE programming - yes, despite being labelled as "ECW" One Night Stand, this show was put on and promoted by the WWE. WWE contracted wrestlers even appeared and performed on the show with none other than Stone Cold helping to close out the night.

This show wasn't different purely because of the hardcore matches; this was WWE acknowledging and celebrating a company other than themselves. The show felt (and still feels) totally unique and its success led to the revival of ECW as a third brand for the company. Although, the less said about that, the better.


6. WCW Souled Out 1997

nWo Souled Out
Wiki

At Bash At The Beach 1996, the wrestling world was shaken to its core when Hulk Hogan dropped the leg on morality and formed the New World Order. The nWo gave the wrestling business a much-needed shot in the arm and took WCW to new heights, pushing the WWF to get more creative with its counter-programming.

To test the popularity of the group, WCW ran Souled Out in January 1997; a show themed around and hosted by the nWo. In kayfabe, the nWo had total control over this show; every match was "nWo vs WCW"; nWo members Eric Bischoff and Ted DiBiase were on commentary; the nWo's personal referee, Nick Patrick, officiated every single match on the card. It was a total takeover that was also, sadly, a total flop.

The PPV absolutely bombed. The matches had very little heat to them, the constant nWo presence felt overwhelming, and the main event ended in a DQ which is never a good sign. Whilst there would be nWo vs WCW matches again, this was the only Pay-Per-View to solely feature that kind of bout. "Too Sweet" this was not.


5. WWE Hell In A Cell 2016

Sasha Banks Charlotte Hell In A Cell
WWE.com

To say "women haven't always had the best time in WWE" is a bit like saying that "an ice cube wouldn't have the best time on Bondi Beach". For decades, female performers in the company were treated like a sideshow attraction, which is actually a little unfair to sideshow attractions.

Things are far from perfect now, but huge strides have been taken over the last few years to elevate women's wrestling to the level it deserves. Multiple strides were made at Hell in a Cell 2016, where the Raw Women's Championship match between Charlotte Flair and Sasha Banks was the first all-female encounter to take place inside the titular structure.

Furthermore, Flair and Banks actually closed this show out, making them the first women ever to headline a WWE PPV. To put this into perspective - less than a month earlier, Charlotte vs Sasha became only the second-ever women's match to headline an episode of Raw.

Women competing in Hell in a Cell and main eventing PPVs is more commonplace these days, but that would not be the case were it not for this match. Hell in a Cell 2016 was a huge risk for WWE - one that, thankfully, paid off.


4. TNA Lockdown 2005

TNA Lockdown
Impact Wrestling

Many wrestling historians will tell you that the first ever steel cage match took place all the way back in 1937. Sixty-eight years later, Total Nonstop Action thought "what if we did that, but more?". The result was Lockdown 2005; a Pay-Per-View where every single match was contested between six sides of steel.

Variations included a strap match, a tables match, and a "Prince of Darkness" match - a two-out-of-three falls bout where the wrestlers were blindfolded for the final fall. And Vince Russo wasn't even writing for TNA at this point (shocking, I know). The PPV was pretty well received and Lockdown went on to become an annual fixture in TNA's calendar. What's more, Lockdown is widely credited with influencing WWE's decision to begin running "gimmick PPVs".

Events like "Extreme Rules", "Hell in a Cell", and "TLC" didn't exist before Lockdown, but in the years following this first event WWE slowly began these implementing themed shows. So yes, Lockdown 2005 was a success, but it did result in years of boring PPVs and the slow stagnation of once-exciting gimmicks, so judge for yourself to what extent.


3. All In

All In
Twitter/@NickJacksonYB

On 16th May 2017, a tweet from Dave Meltzer changed the wrestling world. When asked by fan @TheWWEGuy_ on Twitter whether Ring of Honor could sell out a 10,000 seat arena, Meltzer replied with "Not any time soon". This response drew one of its own from a certain Cody Rhodes, who simply put "I'll take that bet, Dave".

Less than a year-and-a-half later, All In took place at the Sears Centre Arena in Chicago. Orchestrated by Cody and The Young Bucks, All In was a celebration of everything in pro wrestling outside of WWE. Performers from Ring of Honor, New Japan, the NWA, and various other indie promotions all took to the ring to show off what they could do and, in the process, sold 11,263 tickets.

The impact of All In cannot be understated and is still being felt to this very day. It changed the way the wrestling world viewed the independent scene, gave many young wrestlers their biggest platform ever, and oh yeah, something about some guy called Tony being there? All In didn't just try something new, it deliberately attempted to shake up the status quo of wrestling at the time and it damn well succeeded.


2. WWF This Tuesday In Texas

WWE This Tuesday In Texas
WWE.com

Prior to 1993, the only other Pay-Per-Views the WWF ran that were not its "Big Four" were The Wrestling Classic, No Holds Barred: The Match/The Movie, and This Tuesday in Texas. That last one is particularly interesting because it took place just six days after Survivor Series 1991.

The show was an attempt to establish Tuesdays as a secondary day for Pay-Per-Views alongside Sundays. It was shorter than a usual WWF event, but was also about half the price and featured the bumper matches of Hulk Hogan vs The Undertaker in a WWF Championship rematch from Survivor Series and the in-ring return of Randy Savage against Jake "The Snake" Roberts. Was this enough to entice new customers?

The short answer: no.

The long answer: noooooooooo.

The show drew a buyrate of 1.0 - approximately 400,000 buys - which was considered a failure by the WWF. Plans for future Tuesday events were cancelled and the company didn't run a big show on that day of the week until 13 years later with the inaugural Taboo Tuesday.

So the WWF couldn't pull off a weeknight PPV in 1991, but a decade later, one company managed to make it work...


1. TNA Weekly PPV #1

NWA TNA weekly
Impact Wrestling

For the first two years of its life, TNA existed solely on PPV. On Wednesday 19th June 2002, NWA-TNA (as it was known) aired "Weekly PPV #1" for fans to buy at the cost of just $9.99. The two-hour show featured talent such as AJ Styles, Jerry Lynn, Psicosis, Ken Shamrock, Scott Hall, and, of course, Jeff Jarrett.

The show closed with Shamrock defeating Malice (formerly "The Wall" in WCW) to win the vacant NWA Worlds Heavyweight Championship, beginning a new era for that belt and for the world of wrestling in general. TNA would put out 114 "Weekly PPVs" until it switched focus to its new cable TV show, Impact!, which, against all odds, still runs to this day.

The Weekly PPVs allowed TNA to find its footing in its early years without the need for a TV deal. It gave the promotion time to establish a fanbase and to build up stars so that, by the time it finally hit our screens, it had a captive audience ready to watch it. It may not have seemed like much special at the time, but those Weekly PPVs actually played a very important part in shaping wrestling's modern make-up.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Jacob Simmons has a great many passions, including rock music, giving acclaimed films three-and-a-half stars, watching random clips from The Simpsons on YouTube at 3am, and writing about himself in the third person.