10 Wrestling Promotions That Did WarGames Better Than WWE
*In William Regal's strong Blackpool accent* LETHAL LOCKDOWN!
Owned by WWE it may be, WarGames isn't best played in the sports entertainment market.
A stipulation dubbed 'The Match Beyond' can't operate under WWE's bygone PG ruling. Not successfully, anyway. The match is a feud-ender, a stipulation where lawlessness and anarchy are not only expected, but encouraged. It shouldn't be hauled out of storage because it's the next event on the WWE/NXT calendar.
It doesn't help that WWE is yet to host a singular standout example of the stipulation in action either. The glut of NXT battles and pair of WWE fights within the structure were memorable for the spots within - Tommaso Ciampa Air Raid Crashing Adam Cole from off the cage, IYO SKY diving off the cage with a bin over her head, et al - but can you remember anything about the bouts outside of the GIFable spots that were performed not to enhance the quality of the match, but to get clout on Wrestling Twitter?
No.
No one remembers The AOP being part of WWE's first NXT WarGames match. They're the missing piece that will prevent you from obtaining a full house in a pub quiz.
AEW Blood and Guts 2023, meanwhile, will forever be remembered - and it's yet to happen...
10. All Elite Wrestling
Indeed, AEW Blood and Guts 2023 is already a legendary clash.
Describing it as such may read as a biased take - again, the match hasn't happened yet at the time of submission - but it's the consensus opinion. The line-up is the strongest the match has ever had, it's an authentically heated feud that feels as such, and it'll mark the craved AEW arrival of Kota Ibushi. Revealed as The Elite's fifth man - smartly via video package, thus saving his first heroic pop for the match itself - Ibushi has been an AEW fan demand for years. If AEW is able to pull off his debut successfully, Blood and Guts 2023 will be a legendary clash.
It helps, too, that AEW already has a marginally strong track record with these matches. The Inner Circle vs. The Pinnacle in 2021 and The Jericho Appreciation Society vs. a Blackpool Combat Club-led unit of six in 2022 were both serviceable. They weren't perfect - Chris Jericho's comical fall of the cage in '21 onto a pile of conveniently-placed styrofoam was a particularly damning incident - but the matches both delivered on what the WarGames match represents.
AEW nailed the story, the character development, and the moments in these matches.
These felt like the first WarGames matches since the height of WCW.
9. Women Superstars Uncensored
History is history.
It's indisputable.
Pro wrestling history, however, is disputable, at least in WWE's eyes. There weren't 100,000 live in the AT&T Stadium for WrestleMania 32 but if it breaks a record, there was. Hulk Hogan didn't actually slam Andre The Giant for the first time at WrestleMania III, but it sounds better than having the moment occur on a nothing show in 1972. Randy Orton wasn't actually the youngest World Champion at 24-years-old, but when is WWE really going to bring Lou Thesz out of the archives for his title ascendancy at 21-years-old?
The point is, WWE's history of pro wrestling neglects to mention the history of pro wrestling. WWE, in WWE's eyes, is all that exists.
It's why, in 2019, they declared the WarGames battle between Rhea Ripley and Shayna Baszler's teams as the first all-female WarGames match - except it wasn't. Women Superstars Uncensored beat them to it in November 2011 at their aptly-titled Breaking Barriers pay-per-view, as the trios of Allysin Kay, Jessicka Havok, and Sassy Stephie, and Alicia, Britney Savage, and Mercedes Martinez waged war on each other.
The match was a superb take on WarGames, albeit with a minor change; the steel cage surrounded only one thing. All other rules applied, though, with the finish involving Havok threatening Martinez with a machete(!).
It was WarGames to a tee.
8. Major League Wrestling
Major League Wrestling won't be high on many fans' watchlists, but they were red-hot during their first early noughties stint. Evoking a super-indie vibe with a card full of ECW castoffs and whatever other goobers Court Bauer could find, the group was a creative success amidst financial ruins, closing down for over a decade before a return in 2017 summoned an initially raucous fanbase.
Their return brought with it the WarGames match, held in September 2018, but the company's greatest use of the stipulation came fifteen years earlier in 2003. Pitting a Steve Corino-led team against a unit led by Terry Funk, MLW nailed the conception, producing not a methodically planned, beat-for-beat match, but a scrap fought drunkenly outside a boozer in the early hours of the morning. The spots weren't coherent and the story wasn't immediately obvious to casual punters, however, the atmosphere inside the building told enough of a story.
What goes oft-forgotten is that MLW legally owned the rights to use 'The Match Beyond', with WWE having neglected to file a copyright, instead reaching a deal with MLW in 2018 after they began using the stipulation, too, in 2017. WWE's carelessness was MLW's gain in this case - and what a gain it was.
7. Ring Of Honor
S.C.U.M led a life similar to what The nWo did in WCW.
Comprised, initially, of three once-popular babyfaces - Kevin Steen, Jimmy Jacobs, and Steve Corino - the stable peaked in this first form. The addition of a horde of mid-card goobers in one night soured the credibility of the group and when Steen was ejected, they were toast.
They were toast two months later anyway, as that was the penalty for losing the last, to date, Steel Cage Warfare match to a Steen-led ROH contingent of Michael Elgin, Jay Lethal, and BJ Whitmer.
S.C.U.M's Jimmy Jacobs, Rhino, Rhett Titus, and the dreadful Cliff Compton wrestled the ROH group to a well-worked WarGames-lite match. It wasn't dissimilar to the peak-WCW WarGames matches, as S.C.U.M undermined the babyfaces at every opportunity, using the man advantage for precisely what it was designed for. Kevin Steen's involvement in the contest is what pushes it above the prior two Steel Cage Warfare matches as he'd undergone a sudden transition back into the babyface role, putting his devotion to ROH itself into question.
The finish was a little dumb, with Jacobs saving Steen from Steve Corino setting him ablaze only to receive a Package Piledriver for his troubles, but the match was a lot of fun, serving as a substantial conclusion to the year-long storyline.
6. Extreme Championship Wrestling
ECW cultivated a success story out of being grungey and alternative. Much of their actual success has gone lost to time outside of the big-hitting angles and moments because of that underground appeal, but one gem worth digging deep for is the 1994 Ultimate Jeopardy match between Terry Funk and Shane Douglas' quartets.
Though not blow-away great - WarGames matches rarely were either - ECW's WarGames variant was a divine take on WCW's solitary positive stipulation. It played under the same rules, too, outside of the one-ring set-up, and added forfeits for each competitor, which was an additional layer of storytelling majesty that ECW rarely receives credit for.
Funk led a brilliant performance throughout, perfectly channelling his babyface-in-peril style against Shane Douglas, who was the established top heel in ECW at the time. Douglas was vying for Funk's ECW World Heavyweight Championship, which was Terry's penalty if he were to be pinned, and this came across marvellously when he surrounded himself in the match with three heavy-hitting goons in Mr Hughes, Johnny Grunge, and Rocco Rock. He was everything ECW needed you to hate: the good-looking, chiselled blue chipper battering the icon of everything ECW embodied.
The match is scrappy in places and the audience is quiet at times, but the 1994 Ultimate Jeopardy match came together strongly as a respectable storytelling device.
5. Game Changer Wrestling
WarGames, at its best, is a match designed for blood feuds. Promotional warfare, maybe, but blood feuds through and through.
It's why the 2021 WarGames match worked so well for GCW, as it pitted a Nick Gage-led unit of company lifers against the villainous 44OH! faction, headed up by Rickey Shane Page. The match was a hoot, and looked straight out of a nineties mashup of WCW and ECW, being both storytelling and slaughterously-ripe.
Adopting the established rules of the match with a scaffold at ringside because hey, this is GCW, partner, this was fought with the intensity and ferocity with which the match desired. Each fist, each slam, each head-spiking bump was delivered with an extra dash of bloodthirstiness in a match that quite literally oozed bloodthirstiness. The two-ring setup was a claret-coated mess by the match's end, the end itself coming after Rickey Shane Page had been sent flying off the scaffold into an ocean of weaponry.
That wasn't as murderous as the match got, though; instead, that would be when Alex Colon flawlessly Spanish Flyed Atticus Cogar off the scaffold onto a door that had been placed in-ring.
The added perilousness of the regularly shaking scaffold made this one a hard - good - watch.
4. Smoky Mountain Wrestling
You'll struggle to find a better hidden gem of a promotion from the nineties than Smoky Mountain Wrestling.
The short-lived group, running from 1991 to 1995, was spearheaded by Jim Cornette, with Cornette adopting the WarGames idea from his preceding employer. Dubbing the match Rage In A Cage, the bout also employed an elimination-style ruling, where pinfalls, submissions, knockouts, and handcuffing an opponent to the cage were acceptable grounds for elimination.
Playing out as a proper old-school WarGames match, wherein the heel manager blindingly leads his stable to dominance from within the ring only to have his men dumped out and be left to fend for himself, the match brilliantly boiled down to Cornette himself - who led The Heavenly Bodies and The Bruise Brothers into the story-heavy battle - submitting to the late Bob Armstrong, who was fighting within an inch of his life to survive for his team - consisting of sons Scott and Steve, and The Rock'N'Roll Express - whom the crowd was firmly behind.
The match was a lot of fun for an early-nineties indie and although it doesn't provide the same molten reactions as the WCW WarGames matches of the era were, it's worth a gander for the characteristically excellent heroic display from Ricky Morton. It's oft-forgotten how beloved he and Robert Gibson were at their peak.
3. IMPACT Wrestling
IMPACT Wrestling has actually made use of WarGames tropes three times, but nobody recalls a memorable Wednesday, Bloody Wednesday match or a Hardcore War, for the best. They're dull, monotonous, lifeless affairs that fail in comparison to the group's real standout stipulation: Lethal Lockdown.
Established in 2005, the stipulation provided the backbone for the Lockdown pay-per-view, the coup de grace of which was 2007's battle between Christian Cage and Kurt Angle's quintets. Pitting Cage, AJ Styles, Tomko, Abyss, and Scott Steiner against Angle, Sting, Jeff Jarrett, Samoa Joe, and Rhino, the match was heavy throughout and became a chaotic brawl when Jarrett arrived.
The match also offered one of the only times where a multi-man cage match's participants leaving the structure made sense; you could feel the anger and the hatred of the entrants. The cage was there for temporary confinement, but nobody was keeping them in there the whole match and it made perfect sense because of how it was executed. Rhino, in Goring Tomko through the door, provided the gateway to freedom in a sickening shot that legitimately busted the door's chain.
Other heavy-hitting spots included Angle tossing Styles off the roof of the cage and Jarrett thwacking Abyss with a thumbtack-filled guitar, but neither sound compared to the vibration of a steel-busting Gore.
2. World Championship Wrestling
There were 31 WarGames matches throughout WCW history and no, they weren't all masterclasses in the stipulation - but how can you shun them from the conversation?
The latter-day examples should be left untouched, but travel back to the late eighties and early nineties to witness the match's peak. The epics between Sting, Ric Flair, and Dusty Rhodes-led squads are pro wrestling royalty. Rhodes, particularly, is a legend of the stipulation for his miraculous performance against The Four Horsemen at the 1987 Great American Bash, setting the example for a gutsy babyface performance, a common WarGames trope almost four decades later.
Even in the mid-nineties, the match was a roaring fire and was used greatly to put over the hierarchy that was ongoing within the promotion. The nWo were the rulers and this was made clear in battles opposite a glut of WCW do-gooders. The prime example of this was from the '96 Fall Brawl, as Hollywood Hogan, Kevin Nash, Scott Hall, and *sigh* nWo Sting triumphed over Ric Flair, Lex Luger, Arn Anderson, and the real Sting in a match that served as a major coup for the Hogan-led unit.
After that, check out Sting's Squadron vs. The Dangerous Alliance from WrestleWar 1992. It is the best WarGames match of all time that marked the beginning of the end for the Paul E. Dangerously-fronted alliance.
It's not quite the best WarGames-like match, though...
1. Ring Of Honor, Again
There has never been as good a period of interpromotional bloodshed as when ROH and CZW waged war in 2006.
It felt real, which every interpromotional feud should do, because these were Combat Zone Wrestling guys - having forged a reputation for, y'know, being hard f*ckers - invading the primarily honor-based and traditionalist Ring of Honor. It was authentically a meeting of two minds and their Cage of Death match was CZW's best offering of the stipulation.
Though the structure lacked a roof, had the cage planted on the venue's floor rather than the ring apron, and had its surrounding area doused with an arsenal of weaponry, all other WarGames rules applied for what was a well-booked and well-executed match. It's a lengthy one at forty-plus minutes, but no minute feels like it's dragging on with a molten pro-ROH audience soaking it all in.
The match is a solid piece of character development for Homicide, too, ahead of his ROH World Championship ascendancy just five months later. He'd been bubbling as an outstanding mid-card act and was evidently on the verge of becoming a breakthrough talent; his performance here was reminiscent of Sting's from Fall Brawl 1997, the ROH contingent being weary of trusting him and then, when he pinned Necro Butcher, talk about a moment.
ROH, much like the namesake event two months prior, was the Ring of Homicide.