10 Wrestling Returns That Must Happen In 2023

There are a number of high profile wrestling returns that could occur in 2023.

The Rock WWE SmackDown
WWE.com

2022 has been an absolutely wild year in wrestling, with a number of high-profile matches, events, and backstage incidents causing the industry to change entirely at its core. The drama caused by 'Brawl Out' and the resignation of Vince McMahon will have permutations for years to come, whilst shows such as Forbidden Door and Clash at the Castle helped move the conversation back towards wrestling itself.

There has been some excellent storytelling on display too, with the CM Punk and MJF feud being an all-time great example of creating a new megastar despite the former's obvious issues. Roman Reigns' epic title reign continues to deliver every week as he and the rest of The Bloodline, particularly Sami Zayn, endeavour to craft one of the best storylines WWE has had in years.

One of the biggest stories of the year is that 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin returned to in-ring action at this year's WrestleMania, although it feels like a lifetime since it happened. 'The Rattlesnake' was the undoubted highlight of the two-night event as his return showed a new generation of fans why he is one of the best to ever do it.

Hopefully, in 2023 there will be some more memorable returns that will be as successful...

10. Tiffany Stratton

Tiffany Stratton
WWE

Tiffany Stratton was a standout performer on NXT 2.0 and could develop into a huge star, which is why she is set for a huge 2023 when she is able to return from injury. The performer has been wrestling professionally for less than a year, which does not show when her performances are often among the most assured on the developmental roster.

After suffering an injury in her match against Wendy Choo in August there has been little word on a potential return for the former gymnast. She could return to NXT to conclude her business with the slumbering superstar, or pursue the women's title that is currently being held by Mandy Rose.

However, Stratton is one of the few performers from WWE's new crop of talent that could be promoted to the main roster very quickly as she has easily grasped the fundamentals and only needs to refine her character a little bit more. She could be called up around the Royal Rumble and join RAW or SmackDown as a member of the talented women's division, where she will inevitably become a world champion at some point in the future.


9. Pat McAfee

Pat McAfee
WWE.com

Pat McAfee set a new standard for celebrity performers in his matches throughout the past few years and his work on commentary was also widely praised by fans. Ever since appearing as an arrogant and brash outsider on NXT he immediately stood out due to his fiery promos that contrasted with the usual scripted nature of WWE's verbal exchanges.

Profiling the former NFL punter alongside Adam Cole was a great move that resulted in one of the best matches of 2020 at NXT TakeOver XXX. He followed this up with a great showing at War Games against the Undisputed Era and had further feuds against Austin Theory and Baron Corbin earlier this year.

McAfee is a very busy man as he also works for ESPN as an American Football analyst and has a very successful podcast, which may prevent him from working in WWE as frequently as he did before. However, there is an easy opportunity to have the multi-media sensation appear at WrestleMania next year in another exhibition match, which would make for a great mid-card attraction on the 'Show of Shows.'


8. Randy Orton

Randy Orton Riddle RK-Bro
WWE.com

History will be kind to Randy Orton's WWE career, as his long tenure with the company has undoubtedly made him a legend within the sport, despite him having many detractors throughout the years. Orton has had many highs and lows in his career but when fans last saw him he was one of the best parts of the promotion alongside Matt Riddle.

R-K-Bro was organically getting over with the fans to a huge degree and was seemingly setting up Riddle and Orton to have a big feud which would put the former on course for superstardom. Instead, due to Randy's latest injury problems the partnership and eventual split have been put on hold indefinitely, with further updates on 'The Viper's' condition being somewhat worrying.

If in fact, Orton is able to return to the ring then he must complete his work with the 'Original Bro,' as his mentee has somewhat floundered without him. It would also be unfair for the 'Apex Predator' not to have the opportunity to end his career on his own terms, so having one final full-time run would be a great thing to see in 2023.


7. Charlotte Flair

Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

She may not always be the most popular member of the WWE roster, but Charlotte Flair is undoubtedly one of the most talented performers in the company when she is at her best. 'The Queen' has not been seen in the company since losing an "I Quit" match to Ronda Rousey at WrestleMania Backlash in May, so she is set for a return sometime soon.

Having her enter the Royal Rumble and put in a good showing seems like a no-brainer, but having her win the match once again should not be a consideration. It is key that in her next run she is pushed slowly toward her next inevitable title win, as fans will quickly sour on the performer if it appears that there is no appetite for her to be in the top spot.

If WWE takes its time in establishing Charlotte amongst the other big names in the women's division, such as Becky Lynch, Bianca Belair, and Ronda Rousey, then it won't be as hard to route for the performer. It may ruffle a few feathers but fans will be more willing to accept Flair as a champion if she is given time to settle in before being pushed to the top.


6. Logan Paul

Logan Paul
WWE.com

Logan Paul has defied all expectations as a celebrity performer and looks like a natural inside the ring, which should hopefully lead to him returning to WWE in 2023 after recovering from a serious knee injury. His latest outing against WWE Universal Champion Roman Reigns at Crown Jewel was outstanding, completely defying all expectations that could have been put on the social media star.

It remains unclear how WWE should go about profiling Paul, who is a polarising figure, to say the least. He has undeniable babyface energy when he is performing inside the ring, but also has a detestable side that exudes arrogant charisma which would make him a great heel.

WWE has hardly scratched the surface of the potential crossover appeal of Logan as a superstar, who has already brought in other infamous figures such as his brother Jake. For many fans, the Paul experience will mean nothing on a cultural level as he has a following almost entirely consisting of younger people. However, his in-ring talents and charisma on the microphone mean that he also has the traditional wrestling skills to make it as a huge star in the business.


5. Cody Rhodes

Cody Rhodes WWE Champion
WWE

The 'American Nightmare' Cody Rhodes made his triumphant return to WWE at WrestleMania this year, shocking the world by leaving the company he helped create to go back to where he started his career. Amazingly, Cody managed to maintain his momentum under the booking of Vince McMahon before suffering an unfortunate injury that has seen him out of action for most of the year.

That was not before putting on an excellent performance against Seth Rollins at Hell in a Cell, which solidified his position as a main event concern in the company. For this reason, Rhodes should be considered a favourite for the Royal Rumble provided he is fit and ready to compete by late January.

He could also be the man to finally dethrone Roman Reigns as world champion, as there are very few viable options left for the promotion to take in that regard. Cody's decision to leave AEW, only to win the WWE title at WrestleMania a year later would make for one of the wildest modern-day changes in an industry that is always wildly fluctuating.


4. John Cena

Austin Theory John Cena
Instagram/@austin_theory

In many ways, John Cena is very similar to Randy Orton in that his legacy in wrestling is quite mixed but undoubtedly important. For much of the past two decades, the most polarising man in sports entertainment has been pushed above every other star he came up against, but this has changed in recent years,

The 16-time world champion has always worked hard whenever he has returned and has gone some way to improve his relationship with the fans. His most recent feuds with Roman Reigns and Bray Wyatt have shown that Cena is willing and able to put over the stars of today, as he is not able to perform full-time he can lose and go away for a while.

There are a number of superstars who could benefit from being put in a feud against the Hollywood star, such as the up-and-coming Austin Theory, or a returning Cody Rhodes. If he is able to work any of WWE's big four premium live events in 2023 then it is obvious to try and get John Cena back for another run.


3. CM Punk

CM Punk
AEW

After a tumultuous but mostly excellent 2022, CM Punk may feel like his time in wrestling has come to an end. 'Brawl Out' may be one of the most memorable moments of the year, but the acrimonious nature of the event may mean that he no longer has a future in AEW.

If this is the case then fans can at least look back at his time in the company as one of the best year-long runs in wrestling history. His debut was one of the finest pieces of wrestling television that have been produced, whilst his feuds with Eddie Kingston and MJF allowed fans to remember just how great of a performer Punk is at his best.

Whilst a feud with The Elite would cause a meltdown in the wrestling world, it has become far too unlikely that he will ever return to the company. It has also become far more likely that he could join WWE, as the change in leadership and his own circumstances may inspire Punk to do the unthinkable and return to the company he left in 2014.

He could feud with absolutely anyone in WWE and it would be massive, but having him come out at the Royal Rumble or WrestleMania would be one of the most seismic returns in wrestling history.


2. The Rock

The Rock WrestleMania
WWE

There are rumours of The Rock returning to wrestling every year as he is quite possibly the biggest star wrestling has ever produced, whilst simultaneously still being young enough to perform at a high level. The 'People's Champion' has not had an in-ring program in WWE since his two-match series with John Cena at WrestleMania 28 and 29.

However, there is one match that the whole wrestling world is screaming into existence which is that the 'Brahma Bull' returns to challenge his cousin Roman Reigns to decide who really is the 'Head of the Table'. It would quite possibly be the biggest wrestling match of the past twenty years since The Rock himself challenged 'Hollywood' Hulk Hogan at WrestleMania X8.

The 'Great One' would of course be welcomed back into the fold by the fans and it is almost a certainty that if he were to return it would be to face off against the 'Tribal Chief.' A match between the two megastars would undoubtedly make WrestleMania 39 the most hotly anticipated event of the year.


1. Big E

Big E
WWE

Hopefully, Big E is in fact able to return to the ring after suffering a broken neck in March - the loudest member of the New Day is an extremely beloved figure who deserves another run in the company.

The former WWE Champion was just starting to be considered as a main event figure in the company before his deeply unfortunate injury occurred, but there is certainly scope for a return befitting of the man who has earned it. Big E has been a part of the WWE main roster for a decade and has worked tirelessly on his own and as a part of his legendary team alongside Xavier Woods and Kofi Kingston to get to the top.

It is perhaps insensitive to fantasy book the return of a man who has to prioritise his health first and foremost, so it is simpler just to say that as long as he does return to our screens in 2023 then it will be one of the best things to happen in wrestling all year.


Watch Next


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I like wrestling a lot and writing about it is fun. Thanks for reading!