10 Wrestling Stables Ruined By ONE Member
There's always one stablemate who spoils everyone else's fun.
Wrestling stables are great.
No, really, they are. Factions are a tried-and-tested way of establishing new talent or prolonging the careers of legends, and there's just been this bad ass vibe to the idea that groups of wrestlers run roughshod like some sort of ball-booting gang since the days of The Four Horsemen, D-Generation X and the nWo. Guess what? All three of those iconic groups are featured on this here list.
Shocked? Don't be. You may well be remembering their glory days through a favourable, nostalgically fuzzy lens - the truth is that even the best had their wobbly moments. Or, more accurately, their wobbly members (ooer!) that temporarily stopped the fun and made each stable seem...less excellent than fans wanted them to be.
Other examples range between more modern disasters that were waiting to happen and forgotten relics from the past that really should've been better. It's just a pity that one specific stablemate had to go and ruin things for everybody else by either outright sucking or never being a good fit for the gimmick from the off.
There's always one, isn't there?
10. The Riott Squad (Sarah Logan)
Behold Liv Morgan staring at Sarah Logan like she's from outer space.
The Riott Squad were always a bit crap, being honest, but they're somehow less crap now that Ruby Riott and Liv are a gruesome twosome. Logan never really felt like she belonged - her hunt-loving 'she wolf' character was at odds with the other pair's punky rebel style.
It certainly didn't help that WWE tried to book the trio like the worst high school bullies of all the times. They were more likely to spill paint all over the backstage area than credibly challenge babyfaces or look like any kind of threat at all to the top female champs.
Poor Sarah was like the class bully that Ruby and Liv only kept around so they wouldn't be bullied themselves. It didn't work, and their odd dynamic meant the Riotts began sinking within a matter of months. Then, they lingered around like a bad smell pre-split and Logan leaving the company.
9. The Forgotten Sons (Jaxson Ryker)
This is a bit of an odd one, because it really seemed like bearded bros Jaxson Ryker, Steve Cutler and Wesley Blake were onto something a few years ago. Their Forgotten Sons biker gang was decidedly Sons Of Anarchy, but it fit the NXT product.
Hopes were high once the group crashed on SmackDown in early-2020.
As it often does though, social media got right in the way. Ryker's outspoken support for President Trump amidst sensitive real-life issues hardly endeared him to some backstage (like Kevin Owens, who himself publicly bashed Jaxson for his behaviour online) and caused WWE to take the Sons off TV.
Their momentum halted overnight; the threesome went from looking like surefire future SmackDown Tag-Team Champs to an obscure trivia question answer 10 years from now. Cutler and Blake have since returned as 'King' Corbin's lackeys, and Ryker is back on Raw with Elias, but the Sons are no more because of the latter's actions.
8. Million Dollar Corporation (King Kong Bundy)
It's painful for this 90s kid to admit, but 1995 WWF sucked.
Main eventers like Bret Hart, Shawn Michaels and The Undertaker were forced to work with a rag-tag bunch of midcarders who couldn't hang at their level. That's why guys like Mabel won King Of The Ring, and it's why someone suggested the fed bring back 80s behemoth King Kong Bundy for one last run.
This was a terrible idea - Bundy wasn't the Hulk Hogan-bothering beast of before. Worse, the WWF lumped him in with Ted DiBiase's crew and tried to cast the egg-shaped antique of a bygone era as the main muscle of his Million Dollar Corporation.
Tatanka, who had just turned heel, Kama and Bam Bam Bigelow (who should've been the only muscle ol' Ted needed) struggled to offset Bundy's weaknesses. DiBiase at least upgraded later in the year by ditching the flagging WrestleMania II headliner and replacing him with big Sid.
7. Team Bella (Alicia Fox)
WWE were obsessed with quasi-gang warfare when they decided to call up a raft of women from NXT in 2015. Charlotte Flair and Becky Lynch combined with Paige to form 'Team PCB', and Sasha Banks created 'Team B.A.D' with Tamina and Naomi. That left the Bella Twins to...do this.
Yay Team Bella? Yay Alicia Fox?
Granted, Foxy might've been real-life pals with Nikki and Brie behind the scenes, but that didn't once come across on TV. In fact, any and all interactions this threesome had were hellish awkward in practice. It looked for all the world like Alicia was only there 'cause the other two squads had three members too.
The truth is that Team Bella actually formed before both PCB and B.A.D. Think about that; Alicia, Nikki and Brie had more time than anyone else to work on their chemistry. They couldn't click, and that meant Fox was the ultimate third wheel.
6. The Revolution (Asya)
WCW was a flaky, drooping mess by the time Shane Douglas rallied the troops to form The Revolution in late-1999. The idea had merit on the surface though. The 'Franchise' enlisted other perpetually overlooked talents like Chris Benoit, Dean Malenko and Perry Saturn, then targeted the established oldies holding them down.
It was another 'shoot'-style WCW angle, but it had a chance.
Sadly (and typically), the promotion f*cked everything up almost immediately. Benoit left the group mere months into it's run as part of a sting storyline with Malenko, but it seemed likely that he'd be replaced by someone else who fit - Eddie Guerrero, maybe? Nah, mate. Asya.
WCW's Chyna rip off sucked any enthusiasm fans had for The Revolution out of every arena she strolled into. A promising stable nosedived as soon as she joined, because people could see that Vince Russo was far more interested in booking a D-Generation X imposter than coming up with something new.
5. Nation Of Domination (Ahmed Johnson)
Above, you'll see Nation Of Domination chief Faarooq leading his men into battle as a rowdy WWF crowd looks on. The Nation figurehead is closely followed by new recruits Kama Mustafa, D'Lo Brown and Ahmed Johnson. Wait, Ahmed Johnson?! As in, the same dude who had feuded with the stable for almost nine months?
Yep.
Despite diluting the Nation's initial concept by adding Savio Vega and Crush into the mix at the start of 1997, the WWF somehow thought it'd be wise to double down and create a 'New' version of the faction once those lads left. They settled on Ahmed, probs because nobody would see it coming.
Why would they? Johnson had been Faarooq's main enemy since late-1996, and the pair had engaged in several violent scraps on TV and pay-per-view as Ahmed valiantly fought against the numbers game. This made no sense whatsoever, which is why it lasted two months.
4. The Heenan Family (Brooklyn Brawler)
It'd be a bold-faced lie to claim that every single member of The Heenan Family was a top-line star. That's not really how managers worked back in the 1980s - they had their main guys, sure, but pro wrestling viewed Bobby Heenan, Jimmy Hart and others as miracle workers who could get anyone over.
That's presumably why they stuck Bobby with an obvious jobber.
Heenan took time out from guiding the likes of André The Giant, The Brainbusters and Rick Rude to introduce the Brooklyn Brawler. His entire purpose was to look like a "ham and egger" that Bobby could mould into a star. That was supposed to stick it to Family defector the Red Rooster.
The problem? Well, Brawler was an obvious step down from André or future clients like Mr. Perfect and Ric Flair. He was literally enhancement talent who'd been dressed up in a gimmick to give him a little more juice. It was never going to work, and he made Heenan's stable of wrestlers look weaker by association.
3. New World Order (The Giant)
You won't hear any complaints from this writer when WCW fanatics point to the nWo and declare it one of the best ideas in wrestling history. Together, Kevin Nash and Scott Hall were dynamite as The Outsiders, and their alliance with a newly-turned Hulk Hogan was bad f'n ass.
It didn't even hurt the group when Ted DiBiase was unveiled as a financial backer who could help them take over. It did, however, knacker proceedings when recent Hogan enemy and anti-nWo force The Giant turned his back on the Dungeon Of Doom to become the renegade band's latest member in September 1996.
What a stupid bloody move that was.
Obviously, the nWo would go on to round up any Tom, Dick or Harry who fancied donning one of those t-shirts, but The Giant started that trend. Though he was a big name fans took seriously, he had no business suddenly turning to link up with Hulk and the boys.
Utter nonsense.
2. The Four Horsemen (Paul Roma/Jeff Jarrett)
Think of this as two for the price of one.
The Four Horsemen's original tight-knit feel was watered down significantly by the time 1993 rolled around, and yet nobody could've predicted what was to come. Longstanding members Ric Flair and Arn Anderson welcomed career midcarder Paul Roma to their exclusive club, and WCW fans collectively wondered what the creative nucleus were smoking during meetings.
Roma was a solid hand, but he wasn't on par with Flair or Anderson.
If that Horsemen incarnation wanted to be the worse in the faction's rich history, then it'd have to stave off competition from the 1997 version; that year, Flair and Anderson were flanked by Chris Benoit, Steve McMichael and Jeff Jarrett. That's Jarrett in his country singer garb from the WWF days.
It was a poor fit, and it didn't work out. Even 'Mongo' McMichael, with his Super Bowl ring and party-loving lifestyle, jived better with The Horseman gimmick than Jarrett. This was an embarrassment for everyone involved, and every bit as bad as the Roma experiment.
1. D-Generation X (Rick Rude)
Nothing screams 'Attitude', 'Anti-establishment' or 'Degenerate' like Rick Rude in a suit.
That's a joke, of course. It has baffled yours truly forever that the very first iteration of the iconic D-Generation X faction was Shawn Michaels, Triple H, Chyna and a stuffy, corporate-looking type. Rude looked positively mortified to even be there when Shawn and Hunter were making dick jokes or bragging about sexual exploits like Stifler from American Pie.
Rick was introduced as HBK's "insurance policy". He was supposed to be a heater for Michaels like Diesel and Sid had been before, but he wasn't necessary. Shawn already had Triple H and Chyna, so nobody was really sure why his clearly outgoing and anti-authority character would stomach a toned-down Rude.
The formerly 'Ravishing' one's awkward appearances spoiled some of DX's fun during the early days. Mercifully, Rude bolted for WCW before the end of 1997 and let the rabble-rousers get on with pushing the envelope.
What other wrestling stables were ruined by one member? For more like this, check out 5 Ups & 2 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Dec 25) and 10 Best Wrestling PPVs Of 2020!