10 Wrestling 'Truths' We’ll Never Get An Answer To
Unsolved mysteries.

Wrestling fans like to think they know everything.
That's not a knock, because everyone has those pontificating moments in which they correct fellow enthusiasts or ring off ridiculously deep knowledge from bygone issues of The Wrestling Observer, but it's true. As a fandom, wrestling lovers far and wide like to know the ins and outs of absolutely everything the industry has to offer.
Sometimes, that's impossible. There are things nobody on the outer circle will ever know. Is that painful? Yes and no. Whilst it would be great to be some all-seeing grappling deity who has the answer to any question posed, that's unrealistic. The fact is that some 'truths' remain unsolved, and explanations behind them may never come out.
This is a cool mix of business decisions, real-life drama and what might've happened in the future had certain events not unfolded as they did. All of them share one thing in common: the men and women involved are either incapable of revealing the truth or probably don't want to. That leaves curious wrestling fans playing detective or relying on rumours.
The plot thickens...
10. Would Vince McMahon Have Stayed Off TV?

The 11 June 2007 episode of Raw ended with a fiery inferno that teased the demise of Vince McMahon's on screen character. Some WWE insiders suggested that McMahon boldly said, "Well, I can't be on TV if I'm dead", and those same folks explained that Vince was tired of pulling double duty in front of and behind the camera anyway.
The fallout from the Chris Benoit tragedy forced WWE to abandon the angle, but would McMahon have resisted the urge to return? Probably not. It would've been so sports entertainment had the company booked an out for his on air "death". Even so, it is fascinating to think that Vince, after a decade of playing authority, was sick of performing.
The likely outcome is that McMahon would've been gone for six months or so before showing back up as though nothing had happened. That, much like scripting an excuse, would've been classic WWE. It's hard to imagine he'd never show up again.
No-one will ever know.
9. Who Would've Ended The Undertaker's Streak?

Brock Lesnar was the man handpicked by The Undertaker to end his long-running WrestleMania winning streak and put the '1' in '21-1'. Industry critics and casual fans alike were stunned when Lesnar toppled 'Taker in 2014 and scuffed one of WWE's most perfect gimmicks.
That almost never happened.
Lesnar was absent from the promotion between 2004-2012, meaning someone else had to be considered long before he was. Going further, nobody could've predicted with any accuracy that Brock would return at all. In other words, a Lesnar-less WWE couldn't exactly book him to end such a famous winning run. They'd have had to choose someone else.
Countless names were rumoured as streak-beaters over the years, but it almost seemed like 'Taker's streak would remain intact forever (some might wish that had been the case). Without Brock's 2012 comeback, there'd be no streak-conquering 'Beast'.
8. Would CM Punk Have Ever Headlined WrestleMania?

Despite shocking everyone by returning to the WWE sphere as a Backstage host last year, it remains unlikely that CM Punk will ever wrestle in a McMahon ring again. The guy doesn't need to, and he's the kind of dude who's smart enough to realise how much of a colossal letdown it'd be if he didn't live up to expectations.
"Didn't live up to expectations" would sum up his first run, at least to Punk.
Punk became the longest reigning World Champion of his generation, but that wasn't his Holy Grail. No, the former ROH and internet darling coveted a main event berth at WrestleMania, and it drove him daft that WWE wouldn't make it happen. Learning his fate for 'Mania XXX, apparently, was the final straw before he left in 2014.
Had Punk stuck around, there's a slight chance WWE would've reconsidered and put him in a headline position eventually. He'd have been an excellent opponent for the likes of Roman Reigns, Brock Lesnar or Daniel Bryan (to name a few), and might've been granted his ultimate wish eventually.
7. Who Was The Original Anonymous Raw GM Pick?

Was the 'Anonymous Raw GM' going to be the launching pad for a brand new wrestler? Would it be revealed that a legendary puppet master was pulling strings from behind the scenes? Was it me, Austin? Was it me all along, Austin? Who knows?
The original plan can't have been Hornswoggle though.
His unveiling in 2012 was a total letdown, and it felt like a cop out too. Later, lil' Horny claimed he was supposed to embark on a run as a despotic ruler who'd run Raw ruthlessly, but ex-WWE writer Kevin Eck disputed that by claiming the company didn't actually have a long-term plan at all.
It's hard to know who to believe. Surely they had something in mind that'd resolve the storyline and be more satisfying than Hornswoggle - even if WWE didn't have concrete plans, someone from creative must've pitched a better reveal than what happened.
6. Just How Different Was WCW 2001 Going To Be?

In 2000-2001, Eric Bischoff scrambled to put together a deal that'd let him buy WCW and save the organisation from either fading away into oblivion or becoming part of Vince McMahon's portfolio. Eventually, the latter happened, and Bischoff was helpless to do anything about it. Without the promise of a TV slot, WCW didn't appeal to him or his backers.
So much for the 'Big Bang'.
That's a show Bisch and cohorts wanted to promote in May 2001. It would've been a fresh beginning for the brand, and an attempt to relaunch WCW as a viable commodity capable of competing with the WWF. The question is this: Just how different was Eric's new WCW going to be to the old one?
Bischoff has touched on this via his '83 Weeks' podcast, but even he's unsure of what WCW 2.0 would've looked like. He and his partners hadn't reached that point yet, and McMahon's stunningly cheap (somewhere in the region of $2.5m) purchase of WCW's shell stopped plans in their tracks.
5. Was Montreal An Elaborate Work?

Dun, dun, duuuuuuuuuun!
Yes, it's the 'Montreal Screwjob', and yes, it's been talked about ad nauseam since 1997. Somehow, it's still something that gets the old brain matter whirring, if only because some people don't buy it as the shoot it was presented as. Kevin Nash, for example, believes it was a work that was meticulously devious.
Bret Hart, meanwhile, would likely shake his head if anyone dared suggest he wasn't screwed over at Survivor Series '97 before jetting off for WCW. Something seems fishy about it all, but only Hart, Shawn Michaels, Vince McMahon, Earl Hebner and possibly a few others know the real story.
Nobody involved at ground level has been forthcoming with sensationalist news that it was fabricated in 23 years however. Perhaps that says it all, and yet conspiracy theorists still cling onto the upturn in WWF business and bloated sum Hart received from WCW as possible pointers.
4. Was Owen Hart Going To Retire From Wrestling?

VICE's 'Dark Side Of The Ring' episode on Owen Hart is a grim watch. It includes personal footage (shared by his widow Martha) that shows Owen wishing upon the stars he could make enough money from wrestling to retire and spend more time with his family. That, it appears, was his plan.
How long would he have kept wrestling? That's the million dollar question.
Had Hart not tragically passed away at Over The Edge 1999, he may have retired from the ring a few years later. On the doc, Martha revealed that her husband repeatedly tried to quit wrestling so he could work as a fireman and be home more. The gruelling road life clearly didn't appeal much to a humble family man like Owen.
The sad thing is that nobody will ever know how long Hart would've kept going. Chris Jericho pointed out on his podcast that Owen would've had blistering matches with emerging talents like himself, Kurt Angle and Chris Benoit. Maybe/maybe not - he could've called it quits before they found their feet in the company.
3. Would WrestleMania's Failure Have Ruined WWE?

As legend has it, Vince McMahon put everything he had behind the very first WrestleMania. His bold 1985 experiment was reportedly a make or break moment in his career as the figurehead of the WWF, and may have killed his aspirations for growth and expansion had it flopped.
Wrestling fans have heard all those dramatic claims from Bruce Prichard, Hulk Hogan and others on podcasts over the years, but McMahon has rarely spoken that in-depth about it. He did give a glimpse into his psyche at the time on WWE's own 'True Story Of WrestleMania' DVD in 2011, but that was an in-house piece. It's hardly shocking that Vince went along with the story.
It makes him look like a daring genius.
Of course, putting all his financial eggs in one basket for one solitary event was ballsy, and nobody should dismiss McMahon's bravery. If it's true that 'Mania's failure could've killed his WWF off as an industry titan, then he deserves immense credit for taking that risk.
2. Was There A Serious Plot To Kill Vince McMahon?

Jim Ross left listeners slack-jawed when he told a story about his bathroom-related horror in the 1980s on his podcast. Whilst attending a meeting with Bill Watts to discuss Vince McMahon's expansion plans for the WWF and how to counteract them, JR was horrified to hear a few NWA promoters talk about murdering Vince.
At least he was in the right place - Ross was trying to take a sh*t at the time.
When he told Watts what had happened later, a laid back 'Cowboy' told him that the promoters wouldn't do anything and were just blowing off steam. He told Jim not to worry about it and began talking business without batting an eyelid. JR struggled to get over what he'd heard from the stalls though, and rightfully so.
Watts' coolness suggested that this maybe wasn't an isolated incident, or that he'd witnessed similar threats before without action. Ross said the McMahon story wasn't "expounded upon" by the people involved. Obviously, nothing actually came of it. Was it as serious as it sounded, or just frustrated old-timers talking out of turn?
1. Did Anything Happen Between Randy & Stephanie?

Yikes.
This is a sensitive one, but it's been the source of endless rumour and innuendo since internet message boards and chat rooms became a thing. Probably even before that, in some circles. People are fascinated by gossip that Randy Savage romanced a young Stephanie McMahon before leaving the WWF in 1994 (had this happened in '94, then Steph would've been either 17 or 18 years old, depending on the exact date).
Gorgeous George, who was Randy's girlfriend in the late-'90s, claims that Savage told her everything during an ecstasy-fuelled beach trip one day. That followed on from The Hannibal TV's interviewer stating that Savage's brother Lanny Poffo had already told him about Randy's involvement with Stephanie "off the record".
It's a questionable situation, and only Randy, Steph and maybe one or two others properly know if anything really did happen between the pair. There has to be a reason why Vince went from wishing Savage well after his WCW jump to encouraging his inner circle "never to bring that man's name up again" though.
The mystery goes on.
-
What other wrestling truths will we never have answers to? For more WWE, check out 10 Things You Learn Binge Watching Every WWE Raw From 1993 and 10 Wrestling Gimmicks Created By The Last People You’d Expect!