10 WWE Attitude Era Gimmicks That Didn't Get Over

These guys were more at home in the Platitude Era.

meat wwe
WWE.com

The Attitude era! It was the hottest time in wrestling, and the best time to be fan! Everybody was over! The product was amazing! Why did it ever end?!

Such statements are today considered wrestling truisms, and time and nostalgia have only served to cement such myths.

In fact, though the Attitude era was one of the most profitable in the history of the business, it was far from the most creatively abundant. Yes, the wrestlers were far more over than they are in today's age of 50-50 booking, but for the most part superstar status was reserved for a select few at the top.

Vast swathes of the WWF's roster failed to make even the faintest of susurrations, either through bad booking, a terrible gimmick, or unfortunate timing. In many cases it was all three.

Today, they are mere footnotes from a time still considered the high-point of the industry. But despite their limited achievements, the also-rans of the period aren't forgotten.

10. Brakkus

brakkus wwe
WWE.com

Vince McMahon's unusual fondness for beefy muscle-heads is well documented, as is his steadfast belief that sheer brawn is enough to get a guy over in lieu of any actual talent. He's wrong of course, but sadly for wrestling fans, he has never wavered in his belief.

Achim 'Brakkus' Albrecht was just one of a plethora of identikit hunks WWF expected to be a roaring success based on physique alone. Guess what? He wasn't.

Brakkus (occasionally spelt 'Brakus' for the sake of variety) was as beefy as they came. Unfortunately, beef was all he brought to the table. After an initial run with the company in 1996, WWF decided to spread the misery by shipping Brakkus to ECW for seasoning, where he regularly draped his parent company's banner over his defeated opponents.

After a year away, the Teutonic titan was finally deemed ready for a Stamford recall, and creative had a sure fire way to guarantee his success this time around: chainmail! Brakkus still didn't have a gimmick, or any personality whatsoever for that matter... but he did wear chainmail. Hulking to the ring like some sort of German knight, Brakkus soon became a tearaway superstar.

Wait, no, he didn't. He was an unmitigated failure, and was gone from the company by the end of the year.


9. L.O.D. 2000

LOD 2000
WWE.com

The past is like a foreign country, so they say. They do things differently there.

For wrestling promoters however, the itch to go abroad is too hard to resist. Few industries are so fueled by nostalgia, as relics from a bygone age are repeatedly dredged up to trade on fans' fond memories of days past.

It works too; wrestling is a business based on constant rotation, as guys have to disappear to remain fresh. During the Attitude era however, the past didn't just feel like a foreign country, but a different planet. The entire ethos of the company had shifted such that the extravagant, comic-book characters of the early-'90s no longer had a place.

The Legion of Doom's 1997 WWF return put this fact into sharp focus. Only five years had passed since The Road Warrior's last appearance in the company, but amongst the brash, 'mature' characters now populating Raw, they felt like an anachronism.

Attempts to update the team 'for the new Millennium' as L.O.D. 2000 didn't help. The pair had cool new helmets, though Hawk immediately threw his into the crowd. Sunny offered nothing, and was inexplicably replaced by Droz. Not long after, WWF crassly began to exploit Hawk's real-life alcohol issues, but it was clear the Legion were doomed. Before the new millennium even arrived, L.O.D. 2000 were out the door.


8. Beaver Cleavage

Beaver Cleavage, mother
WWE.com

Despite dreadful ring attire which made them look like a hideous hybrid twixt Roddy Piper and The Ascension, Glenn Ruth and Chaz Warrington managed to achieve a modicum of success as metal-heads Mosh and Thrasher of The Headbangers.

However, a serious knee injury to Thrasher curtailed their run in 1999, and Warrington obviously couldn't continue in singles competition as just Mosh. Can you imagine? A repackaging was in order.

Naturally, the first thing that came to Vince McMahon's mind was an incestuous mother-son gimmick based on 1960s comedy Leave It To Beaver. Rechristened 'Beaver Cleavage', Warrington exchanged sexual innuendos with his 'mother' Mrs. Cleavage (Marianna Komlos) in a series of vignettes as uncomfortable for viewers as the performers.

At the height of Russo-mania, the former Mosh derided the gimmick in a convoluted worked-shoot angle, as the theme of domestic violence was introduced to an already unspeakably awful affair.

A returning Thrasher finally put everybody out of their misery, as he revealed Komlos to be fabricating her battery claims. After much headbanging from fans in their absence, The Headbangers were mercifully reformed.

Isn't it odd that an incest angle didn't get over? And not even for the first time.


7. The Truth Commission

The Truth Commission
WWE.com

Racism and wrestling have gone hand in hand for decades. Unfortunately, this has often manifested itself in the form of foreign heels who we're supposed to hate simply because of where they hail.

Rarely - very rarely - there has been a heel character reviled because he's a racist. The USWA's Truth Commission were a stable of such villains: a white separatist paramilitary faction inspired by South Africa's almost identically named Truth and Reconcilation Commission.

Thankfully, apartheid was abolished by the time the group made their 1997 debut in WWF, but the fact made the gimmick utterly meaningless. The band's only South African, The Commandant (actor Robin Smith), was soon replaced by Don Callis, as the purpose of the coterie's existence became further unclear. Instead of inciting hatred amongst the fans by espousing a pro-apartheid message, Callis (now known as 'The Jackyl') instead acted more like a cult leader for his troupe of racist soldiers.

It was a mess of conflicting ideas, and unsurprisingly, no-one cared in the slightest. Vince McMahon, possibly cursing the fall of apartheid, dismissed the group save for what he obviously saw as its only worthwhile asset: the near seven foot tall Interrogator. We got Kurrgan out of the deal. Thanks for nothing, Nelson Mandela.


6. Marc Mero

Marc Mero
WWE.com

Despite being in the promotion for three years, the only thing Marc Mero managed to achieve in WWF was to introduce fans to Sable. In that regard, he was one of the most significant wrestlers of the Attitude era.

But on his own merit, he was absolutely nothing. Debuting as 'the Wildman' in 1996, fans were simply more interested in Mero's spectacularly attractive wife than the former Johnny B. Badd. If anything, being associated with such a desirable woman decreased Mero's popularity, as many male viewers resented his marriage to the blonde beauty.

After Sable's popularity necessitated the pair go their separate ways, Mero adopted a jealous heel persona as he attempted to drive his wife out of the company. Unfortunately, it was rubbish.

When Mero left the company, he was reportedly earning a guaranteed $350,000 per annum. Since his arrival in 1996, he made virtually no impact on the product whatsoever. Money well spent, then.


5. Naked Mideon

naked mideon
WWE.com

Sex sells, it's a well known adage. Much of WWF's success during the Attitude Era was down to the ramped-up levels of raunchiness on Raw, as a primarily adolescent audience tuned in for a glimpse of buxom beauties such as Sable, Lita, and Trish Stratus.

A less commonly held belief is that sex sells in the form of flabby naked men. Save for a very specific subset of society, it's an axiom that has never rung true.

It didn't work for Dennis Knight either. After being forced into satanic servitude by evil Ministry of Darkness leader The Undertaker, a broken and beaten Mideon took to streaking between matches wearing nothing but a fanny-pack and a thong.

Such is the subtle spectrum of awfulness for Attitude era wrestling, it's hard to know if this gimmick was more or less degrading for Knight than being a pig farmer. What is certain, is that nobody was tuning in to see a naked Phineas I. Godwinn. Those who were should be ashamed.


4. Meat

meat terri runnells
WWE.com

Whereas having an almost flawless physique counts for more than it should to WWE top brass, it is seldom enough in the eyes of the fans. However, being the son of a former world champion should give a would-be grappler that added bit of legitimacy. It didn't for poor Shawn Stasiak.

Though taking the name 'Stasiak' away from him may have lowered the pressure of living up to his veritable father Stan, turning the second-generation star into a sex-slave and calling him 'Meat' did him no favours.

Honestly, a sex-slave called 'Meat'. Doesn't sound too appetising does it? It wasn't, as Stasiak was forced to play second fiddle as the personal boy-toy to the execrable Pretty Mean Sisters, often blaming defeats on being worn out from their pre-match sexual exploits. It wasn't long before a programme involving Beaver Cleavage signaled the end of his entirely forgettable run.

After covertly recording a row between Davey Boy Smith and Steve Blackman, Stasiak received his marching orders in 1999. The rotten taste of Meat was gone.


3. Steve Blackman

steve blackman kendo
WWE.com

Steve Blackman has one of the most compelling backstories in wrestling, yet oddly it was an apparent lack of personality that precluded him from real success during WWF's boom period.

As early as September 1989, Blackman was close to signing for the promotion after a series of successful house show appearances. But before he could sign on the dotted line in Stamford, he found himself instead fighting for his life.

Blackman, a former bodybuilder, had an impressive physique and was the master of an array of martial arts. However, whilst fulfilling an obligation to a friend to work in South Africa, all his training and toughness could not prevent him succumbing to a single mosquito bite.

The Stampede Wrestling alumni was bedridden for two years with malaria and dysentery, as his promising wrestling career ground to a halt. It took half a decade for him to recover, as he gradually restored his muscle mass, adding tae kwon do to his arsenal as a means of physical therapy.

Blackman eventually earned another tryout with WWF in 1997, and this time no disease-carrying insect was going to waylay him.

He struggled to make an impact. The company made no attempt to capitalise on his fascinating tale of recovery from the brink of death, and instead gave him a couple of sticks and called him 'the Lethal Weapon'. For all intents and purposes, Blackman was just a man in black trousers and nothing more.

His lack of charisma saw him meander around the mid-card until WWF decided to focus on his universal blandness by putting him in comedy skits with Al Snow. The big joke was that Blackman was not a funny guy. Hilarious!

Insisting a guy is boring is never likely to make him less so, and eventually, 'the Silent Assassin' slipped off the radar before retiring from wrestling in 2002. In something of self-fulfilling prophecy, Blackman now works as bond dealer - quite a far cry from the world of martial arts.


2. Tiger Ali Singh

tiger ali singh vince mcmahon
WWE.com

When Tiger Ali Singh signed for the WWF in 1997, the promotion laid on a huge jamboree for the announcement at the Toronto SkyDome. The company hoped to break into the Asian market by promoting Singh, and looked to give the new acquisition an immediate boost by having him win the second Kuwait Cup.

Singh made his official WWF debut not long after, but was soon put on ice as the company transitioned into the Attitude era.

When he reappeared, everything had changed. Singh was no longer presented as the marketable face of the WWF in Asia, but instead adopted an outdated, borderline racist wealthy Middle Eastern gimmick in the mold of Ted DiBiase.

Singh and his manservant Babu looked to use their fortune to humiliate fans. It was not popular. Worse than that however, was that Singh was absolutely appalling in the ring. There was no pay-off for such a terrible gimmick.

Bret Hart had introduced Singh to Vince McMahon as 'the Asian Hulk Hogan'. Little did he know he was referring to his wrestling ability (though Hogan was 100x the wrestler Singh was).


1. 'Dr. Death' Steve Williams

Steve Williams  WWE
WWE.com

When Jim Ross brought his long-term friend and legitimate hardman 'Dr. Death' Steve Williams to the WWF in order to compete in the inaugural 'Brawl For All' shoot contest, the company were so convinced he would win that they paid him the purse in advance.

Did someone once say something about counting chickens before they've hatched? Instead of fixing the competition to ensure their investment would be successful, Vince Russo insisted on a legitimate shoot, and when a battered and worn-out Williams succumbed to Bart Gunn in the first round, there were red-faces all around.

The boys in the back were giddy with delight; as head of talent relations, Ross was far from popular at the time, and seeing his guy humiliated gave them the utmost pleasure.

It was a disaster for Williams. The intention was for him to storm the tournament, and after establishing himself as a legitimate bad-ass, challenge the super-over Steve Austin. Instead, first round defeat left him looking a complete joke. The fans could never take him seriously from that point on, and that was that for 'Dr. Death'.


Editorial Team
Editorial Team

Benjamin was born in 1987, and is still not dead. He variously enjoys classical music, old-school adventure games (they're not dead), and walks on the beach (albeit short - asthma, you know). He's currently trying to compile a comprehensive history of video game music, yet denies accusations that he purposefully targets niche audiences. He's often wrong about these things.