10 WWE Champions Who Deserved Longer Runs

Great performers, lacklustre reigns.

Bob Backlund
WWE.com

In the eyes of many, WWE’s world titles don’t mean as much as they used to. Whereas once they would mark a wrestler as The Guy, the face of the company and most likely its top earner, nowadays there’s so much going on that the belt can get lost in the shuffle.

And yet, it can still do wonders for a superstar. Just look at Drew McIntyre, a former also-ran who has been transformed into a bonafide main eventer in no small part due to a well booked, lengthy run as champ.

Transitional champions will likely remain a part of wrestling forever, but then there are those performers who have every attribute to be a respectable, money making champion, and yet never seem to spend long carrying the strap. Fate might intervene, or, more often, Vince McMahon might get bored.

These wrestlers all had their moment in the spotlight, but for some of them it was just that - a moment. Had the bookers held their nerve or simply thought more about the long term plans for their workers, they could have had something really special.

10. Christian

Lita Women's Champion
WWE.com

Christian’s initial title run was a bit of a proxy win. In the wake of Edge’s shock retirement and relinquishing of the belt, it was decided that his best pal and former tag partner was the next best thing, and Captain Charisma won the vacant strap at 2011’s Extreme Rules.

Not the way he’d like to have won it, perhaps, but no one could say he didn’t deserve it. One of the more undersung talents of his generation, Christian had absolutely everything going for him. He had proved himself as a main eventer in TNA - surely the stage was set for a similar run in WWE.

Well, sort of. He went on to perform in some of the best matches of his career against Randy Orton, with whom he had exceptional chemistry, but the Viper was clearly WWE’s guy for the future. Christian held the belt twice, for a combined run of about a month. He was also booked as a consistently cowardly, whining heel - it was a role he played well, but not necessarily the best use of his skills.

Now retired, Christian has a superb career to look back on, but this aspect could have been far better.


9. Rob Van Dam

Lita Women's Champion
WWE.com

ECW One Night Stand 2006 is one of the iconic pay per views of the 2000s. Before WWE completely ruined the brand, the events were a chance to luxuriate in grubby, blood soaked nostalgia with Paul Heyman and the boys. RVD winning the world belt from John Cena was the perfect way to cap this off.

It was no less than Van Dam deserved, either. Perennially over, an innovative performer, one of the most watchable men in the business, RVD should have been champion prior to this, and certainly should have been given another shot with the belt.

Did he ruin it for himself? Ultimately, yes. RVD lost the strap after being pulled over by the law carrying some substances he shouldn’t have been. But there are stars before and since who have been forgiven for indiscretions far, far worse than Van Dam’s.

He left the company shortly after, and while he has made appearances since, they’ve never been anywhere close to this level. With a performer as popular as RVD, it just seems like money being left on the table.


8. Lita

Lita Womens Champ
WWE

Between Lita and Trish Stratus, the women’s division was in a better place in the early ‘00s than it would be for the next 15 years or so. Admittedly it pretty much comprised those two entirely, but their chemistry and workrate made for great matches, before WWE lost interest a few years down the line.

While Stratus enjoyed several lengthy and well deserved title runs, her opponent was underserved when it came to time with the belt. She enjoyed four runs, but these accumulated to a total of 160 days.

The brevity of these runs was primarily symptomatic of the hotshot booking of WWE’s women’s division at the time, with the likes of Molly Holly and Victoria taking their turns - worthy performers, but not at the standard of Lita or Trish.

She would have thrived in today’s women’s division. While she was a major part of the Attitude Era and the years that followed, a better run with the belt would have been well deserved.


7. Kane

Kane Champion
WWE

In a sense, Kane doesn’t really need a belt. Like Bray Wyatt in his Fiend persona after him, Kane’s innate monstrousness transcends WWE championships. It doesn’t really compute that the Big Red Machine, who in kayfabe is this tortured psychopath who exists solely to dish out pain, would be all that bothered about winning the title.

And yet, with all that Glenn Jacobs has given to the business, it’s a shame he was never given a decent run with the top belt. Kane has usually been booked pretty well throughout his career, lingering near the top of the card for most of it. There’s no denying his in ring ability, nor the impact of his character when used properly.

When he has held the gold, it has never lasted any decent length of time. He boasts one reasonably lengthy run in his twilight years, which seems like a thank you for time served, and was pretty incident free. His sole win at the peak of his career lasted a whopping 24 hours.


6. Ted DiBiase

Ted DiBiase WWE Champion
WWE

Arguably one of the best heel characters WWE ever had and a WrestleMania headliner, the Million Dollar Man had just one world title shot, and that was expunged from the records. In terms of kayfabe, DiBiase didn’t win the belt - he was handed it by Andre The Giant who was working for him.

Even for wrestling, that’s taking the piss, and storyline-wise it was only just that DiBiase was stripped of the title and stricken from the record books as a champ. There’s got to be a line drawn somewhere, after all.

In terms of his contributions to the business, though, DiBiase would have been well worthy of a shot with the top prize. He is quite rightly a Hall of Famer, and has won just about everything else there is to win, but the grand prize eluded him throughout his career.

With his charisma, character, and in-ring ability (which admittedly was on the wane in WWE but still there), he could have put on a great programme with anyone on the card. His career was still great, but the gold would have tipped it over the edge.


5. Sasha Banks

Sasha Banks
WWE

Alongside Bayley, Sasha Banks has been one of the stand out stars of 2020. The slow burn of their disintegrating friendship is a rare example of patient booking in the company’s recent history, and especially during the empty arena days, their character work and in ring action is a highlight of every show.

Now that they’ve split, Sasha has been thrust into the face role, and the smart money is on her taking Bayley’s Smackdown Women’s Championship off her. When she does, let’s hope she gets a strong, lengthy run with the gold, because Sasha’s title runs have been strangely limp so far.

Banks’ five runs with Raw’s top prize add up to 106 days on top. She’s one of the best talents in the division, and WWE clearly recognises this in her booking at large, and yet every time they book her with the belt, they seem to get cold feet.

There are clearly only bright things ahead for Sasha Banks, but her next title run needs to be a long one. It’s the least she deserves.


4. Bob Backlund

Bob Backlund Wwf
WWE.com

For clarity, we’re not talking about Backlund’s time with the championship in the late ‘70s going into the early ‘80s. The Hall of Famer was well served by the-then WWWF, and continued to hold the belt for an incredibly long stretch going into the nascent WWF days.

Times change, though, and with the dawning of Hulkamania, the straight laced Backlund wasn’t so much of a draw as he once was. He left the company in 1984, and it seemed the curtains were closed on an incredible career.

There was life in the old dog yet, though, and Bob returned in 1992 for a feud with Bret Hart. It had mixed results, but at its best, Backlund was sensational. He reinvented himself as a crazed heel, an old man incensed by the newfangled ways of Hart and Michaels’ generation. It was a wild shift, but at the same time a natural one.

He held the top belt for two days as WWE transitioned it from Hart to Diesel. Really it was better fortune than he could have expected - and yet, Backlund was so fun that a lengthier reign might not have been such a bad idea.


3. Finn Bálor

Finn Balor Universal Champion SummerSlam 2016
WWE

The former Prince Devitt is currently in his second run, and second world title reign, with NXT, where he has found himself perennially hovering around the top of the card. One of the brand’s more established names, he has not been lacking time with the NXT top prize.

It’s his fateful run with the Universal Championship that we’re focusing on here, a belt that seems to have been cursed from the off. The big red strap was met with deserving scorn on its unveiling, but when fans learned the inaugural title match was to be between Bálor and Seth Rollins, appetites were whetted.

Action-wise, the SummerSlam 2016 bout didn’t disappoint. It was fast and flowing as you’d expect, with great high spots and a worthy winner in Bálor. Tragedy struck, though: Bálor tore a muscle, and was forced to vacate the belt the next night.

That was it for Finn as far as the top spot on the main roster went. He had some great matches after, including a cracking title shot against Brock Lesnar, but he seems to have fallen out of Vince’s plans. As long as he’s having a nice time in NXT, though, we’re happy.


2. Gail Kim

Gail Kim Women's Championship
WWE

Of all the baffling decisions WWE made with their women’s division in the early ‘00s (and beyond), their treatment of Gail Kim still seems the most bizarre. She came to WWE in 2002 following a solid run in the indies and quickly proved her credentials, winning the title a month after debuting.

This was as good as things got, and Kim was swiftly let go in a cost cutting measure. She migrated to TNA, where she set the world on fire, putting on great matches with Awesome Kong and going a long way to redefining women’s wrestling, which was in a dark age over at WWE.

Vince couldn’t resist snapping her back up in 2008, where she once again did precisely nothing. Upon her release she returned to TNA and embarked on a second run every bit as good as her first, complete with lengthy title runs and excellent matches.

WWE had an enormously talented superstar on their hands in Gail Kim and completely squandered her talents not once but twice. You can’t say they’re not consistent.


1. Eddie Guerrero

Eddie Guerrero
WWE

Nowadays, Eddie Guerrero is unquestionably one of the best ever to do it. His untimely death in 2005 left the wrestling world shaken, and perhaps thinking that we had taken Latino Heat for granted while he was still with us. His sole WWE championship run speaks to this: in that company, and WCW before it, he was a headline act before he was ever given a chance to shine in the main event.

His win at 2004’s No Way Out will forever be one of the ultimate wrestling feelgood moments, and he had some good times as champ, not least his excellent match with Kurt Angle at WrestleMania XX.

The belt was taken off him before too long (his reign wasn’t short, but Lesnar, JBL, and Cena at either side of him were champ for far longer) - the theory was the pressure was getting to him - and he passed away before he had the chance to regain it.

As a bonafide megastar, no doubt WWE intended on giving Guerrero another run with the gold. The fact he never got to strut his stuff as champ again is just another sad element of this terrible tale.


In this post: 
Bob Backlund
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Yorkshire-based writer of screenplays, essays, and fiction. Big fan of having a laugh. Read more of my stuff @ www.twotownsover.com (if you want!)