10 WWE Decisions That Enraged The IWC

WWE made a questionable decision? Quick, to the internet!

undertaker streak wrestlemania
WWE.com

The make-up of the Internet Wrestling Community has changed drastically over the years, but for many wrestling fans, "the IWC" remains the ultimate pejorative. The label will forever be associated with unrealistic expectations, entitlement, and unfathomable levels of self-importance, no matter how vast the group becomes.

The IWC was much easier to define years ago, before the internet and social media had totally consumed the sport. Anyone who has ever clicked on a wrestling news website or scrolled through WWE's Twitter account can now be deemed part of the collective, making the group impossible to pigeonhole.

The internet is still home to some of wrestling's harshest critics, however, and when WWE do something daft, the loudest voices are often those who still conform to old IWC stereotypes.

There's truth to the argument that WWE could spend more time listening to their audience, but the bulk of their decisions are made with casual fans in mind, not those who fit the old IWC mould. Thus, WWE will inevitably let them down, and when they do, you're damn sure going to hear about it.

Whether justified or otherwise, here are the moments that whipped the hardcore fanbase into an angry frenzy...

10. Sheamus Squashes Daniel Bryan

Sheamus Daniel Bryan
WWE.com

Daniel Bryan’s perceived mistreatment was the source of much fan outrage throughout his WWE run, to the point where we could probably fill a list with his examples alone. We’ll stick to just a couple for variety’s sake, but for many fans, his 18-second loss to Sheamus at WrestleMania XXVIII is as egregious as it gets.

DB was regularly stealing the show as a heel World Heavyweight Champion at the time, and 105 days into his reign, he was tasked with defending the belt against the 2012 Royal Rumble winner.

In the most notorious loss of his career, Bryan dropped the belt after just a single Brogue Kick, and if this was WWE’s idea of the heel getting his comeuppance, it totally backfired. Bryan was immensely popular in spite of his alignment, and the initial shock soon turned to anger, showing just how poorly WWE had gauged the situation.

The criticism was particularly prevalent on the internet, where Bryan’s support was always strong. The one positive of this situation is that it was one of many dismal events responsible for triggering The “Yes!” Movement, and DB’s eventual surge to glory at WrestleMania XXX - but the initial reaction was one of rage.


9. The Rock Defeats CM Punk

The Rock CM Punk Royal Rumble 2013
WWE.com

Holding the WWE Championship for 434 days is no mean feat, but CM Punk’s lengthy reign wasn’t always as glorious as the timescale suggests.

Punk had the belt, but he was rarely treated as “the guy,” and often found himself booked in John Cena’s shadow. Nonetheless, he ran through a vast array of challengers as WWE Champion, and his immense support endured among the IWC.

Unfortunately, Punk’s reign ended in the worst way possible. WWE decided that The Rock’s forthcoming WrestleMania rematch with Cena required some extra juice, and had ‘The Great One’ defeat Punk at the 2013 Royal Rumble. Rock/Cena II became a title fight, and Punk lost the gold to a semi-retired part-timer who wasn’t there for the long haul, and would scurry back to Hollywood after ‘Mania.

Losing to Rocky essentially proved the points Punk made when he dropped his “Pipe Bomb" in 2011. The Chicagoan only ever headlined a PPV when he was defending his belt versus Cena or The Rock, and wound up dropping it to the embodiment of everything he raged against. The internet’s response was one of complete dismay, and Cena/Rock II turned out to be a big disappointment.


8. Jinder Mahal Wins The WWE Championship

Jinder Mahal
WWE.com

Jinder Mahal’s sudden ascent to the top of the card came out of nowhere. At the start of April, Mahal was a career-long enhancement talent more used to jobbing on Main Event than headlining pay-per-views. He wasn’t over, he had no credibility, and with years of hard losses under his belt, it looked like he’d never be pushed.

Mahal was crowned number one contender to Randy Orton’s WWE Championship on April 18th, and won the belt little over a month later. He’d gone from complete nobody to the focal point of all SmackDown programming, and the ongoing backlash has been predictably venomous. Mahal’s biggest critics will say his elevation is a disgrace to the belt, and while such reactions tend to get blown out of proportion, it’s hard to argue that he’s a deserving champion.

Jinder has never been over at any point in his WWE career, TV ratings have plummeted since his push began (save for a curiosity-born spike this week), and Backlash ticket says stalled as soon as the Orton match was announced.

His run prove beneficial in the Indian market, but the company are already suffering domestically. Many fans have already written him off, and all available metrics show that Mahal’s ascension has bombed.


7. The Burial Of Zack Ryder

Zack Ryder Wheelchair
WWE.com

Few wrestlers have ever been buried as mercilessly as Zack Ryder. Frustrated with his role in the company, the underused grappler hit the internet with his Z! True Long Island Story YouTube series in 2011, building a sizeable cult following along the way. He crowned himself WWE Internet Champion, and before long, arenas were filling with chants of “We want Ryder,” even as the man himself sat at home, unused.

WWE eventually relented, and Zack became a massively popular midcard babyface. He won the United States Championship, and with his popularity peaking in fall 2011, he looked set for a prolong pushed towards the card's upper echelons.

Unfortunately, WWE decided they didn’t like the fact that Zack had gotten himself over on his own accord. The put him in an emasculating relationship angle with Eve Torres and John Cena, then had Kane destroy him not only with a Chokeslam through the Raw set, but by pushing the wheelchair-bound Ryder off the set in February.

Ryder’s push was over, and he has never truly recovered. Those who’d latched onto his journey through the YouTube clips were understandably incensed, but there was nothing they could do.


6. Christian’s Two-Day Title Reign

Randy Orton, Christian, Handshake
WWE.com

While Christian will likely be inducted into the WWE Hall Of Fame someday, his World Title record is absolutely dismal. Debuting in 1998, it took until 2011 before he finally won the big one, and when he defeated Alberto Del Rio at Extreme Rules, it felt like a well overdue pat on the back for a multi-talented worker.

The reign wasn’t to last, however. Christian dropped the belt to Randy Orton just two days later, and the outcry was severe. Christian’s run had ended before it had truly started, and the anger came not only because ‘Captain Charisma’ had been dethroned, but because fans were utterly sick of seeing the same two guys on top (Orton and John Cena). Christian represented something new, fresh, and original.

Christian eventually reclaimed the gold two months later, but his second run was nothing to write home about either, and Orton took the World Heavyweight Championship back by summer's end. In total, Christian held the belt for just 30 days, marking him as one of the least effective top champions in WWE history.

He left the title picture weaker than when he’d entered, and his booking remains as disappointing today as it was back then.


5. Roman Reigns Wins The 2015 Rumble

Roman Reigns The Rock
WWE.com

The Royal Rumble is always one of WWE’s most eagerly anticipated annual events, but recent years have only served-up colossal doses of disappointment. 2015 wasn’t quite as egregious as the year before (we’ll get to that…), but it was bad, and marked the first wholesale rejection of Roman Reigns as a main event performer.

The recently returned Daniel Bryan was eliminated shockingly early in the bout. He was many fans’ favourite to win, and while anyone else would have been disappointing in comparison, Reigns was the worst possible choice in terms of crowd reaction. His victory was abundantly clear as Kane and Big Show - The Authority’s two corporate stooges - joylessly cleared the ring of all surviving babyfaces, before Reigns made his inevitable comeback to score an unpopular victory.

Even The Rock couldn’t save Roman from the crowd’s vitriol, and the online reaction was fierce. #CancelWWENetwork started trending on Twitter immediately after the show, with the cancellation page crashing as fans bombarded the site.

The backlash ultimately did nothing to sway WWE’s course, as Reigns remains a highly-pushed star in 2017, but the outpouring made it clear their handpicked golden boy would never become an IWC favourite.


4. John Cena Kills The Nexus

John Cena Wade Barrett STFU 2010
WWE.com

As WWE’s franchise player for over a decade now, John Cena has stepped over plenty of upcoming superstars on his way to the top. From Damien Sandow to Bray Wyatt, countless wrestlers have fallen to the unstoppable Cena juggernaut over the years - but The Nexus might just be the most impressive tanking of all.

Cena fell victim to the group’s memorable debut in 2010, and soon became the face of WWE’s fight against the rampaging Nexus. With Wade Barrett’s crew surging, Cena was tasked with assembling a team of WWE-loyal wrestlers to face them at SummerSlam, where they’d presumably put the villains over, continuing one of the hottest angles WWE had produced in years.

Wrong.

Cena reportedly refused to lose, and fundamentally rewrote the match, mounting one of the most “LOLCENAWINS” moments of his career by almost single-handedly slaying The Nexus. Their momentum was broken, and their credibility shot to pieces, but the onslaught continued through John’s feud with Barrett in the aftermath, which concluded with a literal (chair-based) burial at TLC 2010.

Cena’s mauling of the group angered all who bore witness to it, and gave the IWC yet another reason to rage against the face of the company.


3. Triple H Defeats CM Punk

Triple H CM Punk Night of Champions 2011
WWE.com

Just like Daniel Bryan, CM Punk’s booking was often the root cause of widespread fan outrage throughout his tenure with the company.

The decision to have him lose to Triple H at Night Of Champions 2011 was one of the most destructive of Punk’s career, and brought the acclaimed Summer Of Punk storyline crashing down in the most disappointing way imaginable.

Punk was the talk of the wrestling world that year, and his cathartic Money In The Bank 2011 victory over John Cena remains one of the modern era’s most iconic moments. Unfortunately, WWE set about botching the storyline thereafter, first by bringing Punk back to television way too early, then by having him fall to Alberto Del Rio upon returning prior to entering a feud with Triple H and Kevin Nash.

‘The Game’ defeated Punk that October, and the outrage was swift. The corporate boogeyman had quashed the rebellion once and for all, and the Summer Of Punk was over. It was a needless outcome that Triple H gained nothing from, and ultimately played a major role in Punk’s eventual departure from the company in 2014.


2. Daniel Bryan’s Exclusion From The 2014 Royal Rumble

Batista Royal Rumble 2014
WWE

The “Yes!” Movement was peaking in January 2014.

Famously branded a “B+ player” by Triple H, the perception was that Daniel Bryan had spent the bulk of his WWE career held down by management. This manifested as an immense groundswell of support among the fans, whose belief in Bryan only grew with every passing disappointment, making him a genuine folk hero, and comfortably the most popular wrestler in the world.

The Royal Rumble should have been his moment. Bryan lost to Bray Wyatt early in the evening, but that wouldn’t have mattered had he won the Rumble like many had expected. DB was never announced as a participant, however, and while the crowd spent much of the match chanting for him, they were left disappointed. All 30 entrants came and went. Bryan was nowhere to be found.

Batista emerged as a universally rejected winner, and fans were incensed at Bryan’s exclusion. The backlash stretched as far as Mick Foley, who asked “does WWE actually hate their own audience? I’ve never been so disgusted with a PPV” in a tweet he has since deleted, before taking the argument to Facebook.

His voice was just one of thousands, however, and the IWC was ablaze with fury over the ensuing weeks.


1. Brock Lesnar Beats The Streak

Paul Heyman, left, celebrates with Brock Lesnar after his win over the Undertaker during Wrestlemania XXX at the Mercedes-Benz Super Dome in New Orleans on Sunday, April 6, 2014. (Jonathan Bachman/AP Images for WWE)
Jonathan Bachman/AP

Ending The Undertaker’s WrestleMania streak was always going to cause controversy, no matter who had the honour.

It was an integral component of ‘The Deadman’s’ incredible legacy, and without it, it’s hard to imagine him ever becoming the transcendent icon he is today. Thus, many fans felt that ‘Taker should have gone undefeated at ‘Mania until retirement, keeping his record unspoiled, and leaving him with a perfect accomplishment to hang his career on.

All WWE records are made to eventually be broken, however. The company are obsessed with “making history” and “creating moments,” and in having Brock Lesnar become the 1 in 21-1, that’s exactly what they did.

The reaction was loud and divisive. Shock washed over the arena, creating memes out of stunned audience members, and the internet was mad. Very mad…

The reaction never truly dissipated, and there are plenty of fans who still believe that Lesnar beating ‘Taker was one of the most egregious decisions WWE have ever made.

‘The Deadman’s’ next loss to Roman Reigns provoked a similar reaction earlier this year, but it couldn’t match the outrage that boiled over in the wake of The Streak’s demise.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.