The most infamous entry on this list, Mickie James is probably the most talented female wrestler on the list as well. Having had successful title runs in both WWE and TNA, Mickie had a pretty decent career for a women's wrestler and earned a good bit of fan support in both companies. However, it was Mickie's pre-fame pictures that really drove fans crazy. While Mickie was working as Alexis Laree on the independent wrestling scene in the late 1990s and early 2000s, Mickie was simply not making enough money to support herself. She decided to pose naked for Leg Show magazine in 2000 and was featured on the cover of the July 2001 issue of Naughty Neighbors magazine. Normally, this wouldn't be a big deal because plenty of women turn to adult modeling when they need to make ends meet but what made Mickie's case different was how racy the pictures were. This was not a typical Playboy-type pictorial but more of a pornographic, Hustler-type shoot. These shots of Mickie left absolutely nothing to the imagination and showed her before she had her plastic surgery. The pictures are also a source of embarrassment for her personally, since she refuses to talk about them or even acknowledge that they exist. Let me assure you, dear reader, the pictures absolutely do exist.
