10 WWE Evolution Impulse Reactions

Women's Wrestling Entertainment.

Becky Lynch Charlotte
WWE

Evolution was the best WWE pay-per-view of the year.

If that feels familiar, it's because it opened up this very piece for Hell In A Cell last month. In spite of unthinkable factors that have impacted the company over the past few months, the post-SummerSlam spell has resulted in something of a hot streak creatively - or at least whatever masquerades as one in 2018 anyway.

In fact, the only thing that stood in the way of Evolution reaching rarified air as a perfect pay-per-view was every mention of the next one.

The chorus of boos that enveloped the Crown Jewel graphic during the broadcast were telling not just of the wider audience's attitude towards the event but the general emotion of this particular Nassau Coliseum crowd - they were willing to buy into company propaganda but only for forces of good rather than evil.

And this show was a force of good.

Historic performers over-delivered on basement expectations. Wrestlers only known for their Network presence fought and won as supershow superstars. The main eventers wrestled f*cking honest-to-goodness main events, not pretend positions pontificated on for patronising plaudits.

Yes, Evolution was the best WWE pay-per-view of the year. But then one only had to listen to any promo during the night to realise why. It had to be...

10. Darkness Falls

But first a quick note on the one number fudged by WWE in the build-up and execution of this show.

There'll be no analysis at time of writing of the Rhea Ripley/Dakota Kai NXT UK Women's Championship match because;

a) It was a dark match deemed unworthy of a spot on the one-hour kickoff. But then that's probably because;

b) WWE haven't actually got an NXT UK Women's Championship.

In a rare case of the organisation failing to prepare and preparing to fail, the stuttering debut of the British offshoot has resulted in taped tournament matches not even making air in time for the pay-per-view designed to celebrate the winner.

At the risk of not spoiling the entire surprise for those that actually watch week to week, let's just say one of the two women in this match took home the title, at least justifying a place on this card with a top challenger from the field. Both Ripley and Kai can feel hard done to for not getting the spots initially promoted for this show, but here's hoping a show that mirrored NXT TakeOvers past allows for - like those did - a spot on the weekly broadcast for this match to find an audience beyond the Uniondale locals.


9. Kicking Off In Style

Natalya Press Conference
WWE

A panel anchored by safest-broadcaster-in-the-company Renee Young is thankfully the norm every month, but her placement at the front of the most important night in WWE women's wrestling history was augmented by Beth Phoenix and Paige's contextualised commentary on some of the greatest moments in a chequered past.

Guest spots weren't overplayed. Eve Torres, Carmella, R-Truth and Michael Cole all added much in their brief moments, as did the company's decision to run a red carpet as the show progressed.

The interviews had all the right beats for the inaugural and important event even if much of the content was repetitious.

Sasha Banks and Alexa Bliss were again on message following their historic Abu Dhabi encounter, but so they absolutely should even if the company wants to make more about the business than the battle. Ronda Rousey spoke in and out of character for her seemingly genuine appreciation for the sense of systemic support - a concept lost to predominantly male-led professional wrestling for decades. Stephanie McMahon even dared to suggest she called Triple H "Paul" back at the homestead even if we all know they live the gimmick 24/7.

WWE were getting it all right, alright...


8. Open For (This) Business

Mickie James Trish Stratus
WWE

...and the decision to start the show proper with Trish Stratus and Lita Vs Mickie James and Alicia Fox was absolutely inspired.

On paper it appeared one of the bigger matches on the show, but WWE shrewdly visualised the possible pitfalls in Alexa Bliss' late write-out and Trish and Lita's potential (though not-actually-realised) propensity for a botch or two and gave the quartet a white hot crowd to wrestle in front of.

The atmosphere was frustratingly unfamiliar. Thanks to three hour Raws and force fed super-service via the WWE Network, the company have made it so that hardly anybody or thing gets a reaction like these superstars did - but what loud and throaty breaths of fresh air they were.

Nassau Coliseum were thirsty for Attitude Era throwbacks and got them in spades. Lita - sporting a tasteful nod to her TV-14 attire of old - chucked a moonsault that generate gasps of wonder rather than worry. Stratus wrestled like she hadn't actually missed a day since her 2006 retirement, particular during electric segments with longstanding rival Mickie James.

An Alicia Fox botch at the end couldn't halt fan enthusiasm for the card overall, nor the momentum the show was already building in a way Michael Cole couldn't even bullsh*t about.


7. Kids Rock

Battle Royal Evolution
WWE

The 'Miss WrestleMania' battle royal at 2009's 25th edition of the pay-per-view was the true nadir of what we were once forced to call the Divas Division.

A match so bad that aforementioned openers Trish Stratus and Lita pie-faced it before it even came to be, the multi-woman match was embarrassingly pitched as an over-long p*ss break culminating in a dated Santino Marella-in-drag gag.

As bad were the entrances. Given no time to even wrestle, the women were forced to enter to the strains of some utterly abhorrent Kid Rock sexualisation call-to-arms whilst cavorting against his weathered frame. The whole thing was excruciatingly WWE, or at least, what WWE was, anyway.

There seemed a rather pointed atonement in ensuring every combatant got an individually specialised entrance, and the match itself would have been the best battle royal of the year had All In not managed to intricately book one as if it was a vital midcard rocket-strapper.

The work was solid - even from those that weren't capable of it when they were full-timers - with the old guard all earning a moment in the spotlight before the current crop stole the final third.

A Nia Jax win inspired little, but the match overall inspired hope in the company's ability to do this stuff again and again until the aforementioned Kid Rock atrocity is finally forgotten.


6. Storm Front

Toni Storm Io Shirai
WWE.com

Toni Storm's Mae Young Classic victory over Io Shirai wasn't half as foreshadowed as her debutant victory on NXT UK a fortnight earlier, not least because Shirai will join the rank-and-file of the division any day now along with the winner of the 2018 tournament.

The two deserved huge credit for their effort in simply getting the audience to care so soon after throwing such full-voiced enthusiasm into the opening two matches. Like Full Sail's home promotion NXT, the Mae Young Classic remains a niche interest to many, but the crowd that packed the Nassau Coliseum were ready and willing to invest - and the wrestlers were more than able to pay that off.

Storm and Shirai arguably had greater pressure on them than Shayna Baszler and Kairi Sane one year earlier. As this entire event proved, inaugural efforts have something of an advantage, but the novelty factor was no longer going to be enough to get them over the line.

The pair didn't need it. Storm had her best WWE match to date, whilst Io showed tantalising teases of what the company have on their hands before she's inevitably destroyed by the main roster.


5. Six Stars

Bayley Natalya Sasha Banks
WWE

Wrestling with something to prove - because notes on commentary that Bayley and Sasha's 2015 feud had something to do with the WWE Women's Evolution rather than commenting on how it was the turning point for the entire project - 'The Boss & Hug Connection' joined the typically marginalised Natalya and The Riott Squad in turning filler into killer with the surprise package of the night.

The babyfaces were in Hart hot pink. Tellingly, their execution was largely excellent when they finally put their skills together against the comprehensively cohesive heels.

Employing a devious and delightful quick tag game, Ruby Riott, Liv Morgan and Sarah Logan dominated throughout after inventively splitting Bayley's ribs on the inside of the steel post. 'The Hugger's hot tag to 'The Boss' was perhaps the most earned pop of the evening, and the crew still resisted the urge to race to what was ultimately the best finish of the evening.

After Bayley sacrificed her body for Banks, she made a tag to Natalya who unleashed her best ever double Sharpshooter, before the NXT graduates unleashed their own rapid-fire tags to learn from their mistakes and claim the win.

They knew they deserved more, so they went and took it. It was the entire pay-per-view in a microcosm.


4. Horsin' Around

Shayna Baszler Kairi Sane
WWE.com

The involvement of Marina Shafir and Jessamyn Duke in Shayna Baszler's clash with Kairi Sane brought another stellar effort between the 2017 Mae Young Classic finalists to a climactic close, with 'The Queen Of Spades' becoming the first two-time holder of one of wrestling's most prestigious titles.

Shayna's a phenom beyond hyperbole in NXT. A vital cog in the TakeOver machine, her matches bring heft to those cards few others do, and her chemistry with sublime babyface Sane was again reflected in a thrilling battle of f*cking good versus f*cking evil.

The tight 12 minutes afforded were all the duo needed to tell a tale already-well told since Shayna's 2017 debut. A brutish bully with a terrifying and tight submission game, Baszler's merciless mantra made life miserable for others in the division until Sane sailed in to save the day earlier this year.

Kairi's convincing pass-out after the numbers overwhelmed her late on was layered with tragedy and asked questions of Baszler's ability to conclusively take her in a fair fight despite her long periods of dominance.

To that end it was yet another match immaculately booked and worked. Evolution indeed.


3. Match Of The Year?

Becky Lynch
WWE.com

Ronda Rousey's placement at the top of this card made all the sense in the world from a WWE promotional point of view. To them she was the missing piece of a puzzle they'd intentionally laboured over assembling. But as the show approached it became increasingly apparent how one feud - and one particular combatant - had become the story in WWE women's wrestling.

For better or worse, the Becky Lynch heel turn has fuelled her 'Straight Fire' in a way she inexplicably couldn't convince those backstage of when she was a genuinely beloved babyface.

Growing the character from indignant shades of gray to pitch black hatred, Lynch's performance in the role has been one of the standout successes of 2018, with reward for her exceptional work with Charlotte coming in the form of this heavily-hyped Last Woman Standing match.

It's a formula 'The Queen' already knows well. Long relied upon as a safe pair of hands in a headline spot, she had her best (nearly) topliner to date. It was the best contest in their series. It was the best Last (Wo)Man Standing battle in forever and it was, quite possibly, the best singles match of the year.

Rousey stole the show at WrestleMania in a tag match exquisitely engineered to get her over to the world in one night. Becky Lynch and Charlotte Flair fought hard for years to get here, and fought harder to prove their worth. And they both won big.


2. Ronda Valley

Nikki Bella Ronda Rousey
WWE

At 14:15, the Evolution main event between Raw Women's Champion Ronda Rousey and newly-returned and turned Nikki Bella was perhaps five minutes too long, but it speaks to the quality of the entire card that there was room here for any criticism whatsoever.

The pair were unable to follow the scintillating scrap one match earlier, but were so satisfyingly over that crowd responses again made up for a match that otherwise may have lost its way.

Ronda's inexperience again crept in, but considering how literally inexperienced she is that's hardly a stick worth beating her with. Toning down the trash-talk is the next step in solidifying Rousey as the babyface star of this generation, but Nikki was in such riveting form as a heel here that it didn't even matter.

The inch-perfect obnoxiousness of The Bella Twins is a marvellous sight to behold. Either Brie and Nikki have their fingers on the pulse of the fanbase or the company does, because virtually everything they've done since making an uninvited return to the main roster has been skillfully sycophantic and sinister as per the demands of the role.

The twins may not belong as deep in the conversation of the women's division past as they'd like, but they again proved how - if they wish - they can still be a huge part of its future.


1. Curtain Call

Evolution Curtain Call
WWE

WWE have a deft touch for dramatic sentiment when there's little to actually applaud, so it shouldn't have come as much of a surprise when they trotted out the entire crew of wrestlers to clap off the show as the roaring success they were determined for it to be.

For once though, why not?

Intentionally equitable in ensuring everybody got to enjoy the praise heaped upon the main event and the show itself, the final curtain fell on a night so successful that it's hard to imagine the company won't do it again.

Either as an annual event or transparent deflection of negative public opinion, Evolution took hold of the narrative on the night even away from the publicised equality mission the company's been on for the better part of three years.

It was great wrestling not just for great wrestling's sake but for a bigger purpose for the performers themselves. Stephanie McMahon might be delivering a sales pitch everytime she goes near a live microphone, but with their words and their bodies the women - without exception - delivered a messages of hope and solidarity that actually mattered. That's worth even more than a standing ovation.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.