10 WWE Innovations That Nobody Wanted
If at first you don't succeed, keep making terrible additions to the product...
In the ever-evolving world of professional wrestling, WWE has always been at the forefront of innovation, constantly seeking new ways to entertain its global audience.
That sentence might sound like WhatCulture is drinking the Kool-Aid, but even when they were on the ropes in the 1990s, Vince McMahon and his band of yes-men were coming up with ideas that changed the world of graps forever. 1996 - a year hardly held aloft as an all-time great period - is hard-coded into the DNA of the promotion. The Bronson Reed Vs. Braun Strowman feud, to use one example, does not happen without SummerSlam's Boiler Room Brawl.
That was then...
Sadly, not all ideas hit the mark, especially the ones since WWE stopped having to compete with wrasslin' down South on Mondays.
From force-feeding fans gimmick matches at the same time every year, to taking up precious time at the biggest show on the calendar with concerts, recent attempts at shaking up the status quo often left viewers scratching their heads rather than cheering in excitement.
It's unlikely that any of these 10 innovations helped get new fans in, or did anything for those who'd been watching for years, except get them to stop watching of course.
10. 40-Man Royal Rumble Match
Bigger isn't better.
In the year the brand split was finally put out of its misery, WWE tried to make us think the roster was stacked by throwing 10 more wrestlers into the big over the top rope slugfest that starts the year. Everybody loves the Royal Rumble match, so whisper this one as quietly as you can: the spells where it's just people half-heartedly pushing each other against the ropes get boring... and this match had a lot of that.
Let's face it, there weren't a lot of contenders either. Maybe John Cena. Possibly CM Punk. But, if you thought anybody other than Alberto Del Rio was going over, you were young and naïve.
It's telling that nobody says they should try this again. If you ask the average wrestling fan what they remember about this match, they're more like to answer with: "Is that the one where Alex Riley got eliminated early by mistake?", "Didn't Santino Marella almost win?", or "Why does Michael Cole keep saying Diesel like that?"
Within a year the brand extension was over and the match was down to 30 again. It was the right call after this match went on for way too long.
9. Celebrity Guest Hosts
The idea of Celebrity Guest Hosts on Raw seemed promising/ WWE has done a great job of blending sports entertainment with popular culture - but this time it didn't work.
Most celebrities lacked wrestling knowledge, leading to awkward segments where they appeared out of place and, in the case of Jeremy Piven, got the name of WWE's second biggest pay-per-view wrong. Besides, most of them were there more for promotion than a genuine love for wrestling. This alienated viewers and failed to engage casual viewers. Was a fan of Black Sabbath about to watch two hours of wrestling because Ozzy Osbourne was hosting? Unlikely.
The focus on celebrity hosts often overshadowed the wrestling itself too. Shifting the spotlight to non-wrestling personalities detracted from the in-ring action and storylines. Fans tune in to see their favourite wrestlers perform and advance their feuds, not to watch a celebrity fumble through a poorly scripted segment.
The quality of hosts varied greatly. While some celebrities, like Hugh Jackman and Bob Barker, embraced their roles and delivered entertaining segments, others were forgettable or cringeworthy. This inconsistency made the guest host gimmick feel like a gamble rather than a reliable source of entertainment.
While the idea had potential, and worked on occasions when wrestlers were in charge, Celebrity Guest Hosts ultimately did more harm than good.
8. Raw Underground
Shane McMahon's introduction of Raw Underground was an attempt to inject a more adult feel into Monday Night Raw, but the concept itself was confusing.
The strange last hour of the show aimed to present a gritty, fight-club atmosphere, but it was a jarring change from the rest of Raw. The sudden shift in tone was strange for viewers, making it difficult to take seriously. The lack of clear rules and structure further muddled the segments, leaving fans unsure of what they were watching.
Not only that, but Underground often featured quick, chaotic brawls that did nothing for storylines, making it feel like filler content rather than a meaningful addition to the show. The absence of real crowd reactions due to the pandemic also stripped away the energy that might have made these segments more engaging.
For the wrestlers, being on Underground was an obvious demotion. Performers were thrown into segments with little context or purpose, which did nothing to elevate their status or build new stars, especially for those called up from NXT for these lacklustre brawls. This misuse of talent frustrated fans who wanted to see their favourite wrestlers in proper storylines.
Nobody was disappointed when this experiment came to a screeching halt just after it began. Also: why on earth did they have dancing girls on the show in 2020? Let's just pretend it never happened.
7. Million Dollar Mania
Million Dollar Mania was an ambitious attempt to boost ratings by giving away large sums of money to viewers, but it was another misstep from Vince McMahon in a time when WWE was desperate to improve ratings.
Vince announced the scheme in 2008 as the main event of Raw, where he complained about people who don't watch the show, then suggested if they still didn't tune in knowing they could win a share of $1 million each week, they weren't fans he wanted anyway. It was a real old man yells at cloud moment from the former chairman.
From the start, the drawn out segments on Raw felt awkward and forced, especially when Vince made live calls to fans. Technical difficulties and awkward interactions were common, and not funny, making the segments more cringe-worthy than entertaining. Fans who were still tuning in didn't want their wrestling interrupted by clunky giveaways.
The focus on cash prizes overshadowed the wrestling; nobody was tuning it to win money unless they already liked WWE, so the whole thing was pointless. This nonsense took up some of the longest segments on Raw, but thankfully it only lasted for three weeks.
McMahon gave away almost $3 million across three episodes of Raw, then found himself crushed by the set after it exploded for some reason. His accountant probably said to pull the plug, lucky for us.
6. Bragging Rights
The Bragging Rights pay-per-view was supposed to be the ultimate showdown between Raw and SmackDown, but it quickly became clear that the gimmick wasn't going to work.
Then there were the stakes... or lack thereof. The winning brand got a trophy, but so what? There were no real consequences or rewards for the victors, making the matches feel as significant as mid-card filler. Without something tangible on the line, it was hard for fans to care about the outcomes.
The event also had a knack for interrupting ongoing storylines. Wrestlers in the middle of heated feuds were suddenly expected to play nice for the sake of brand loyalty. This abrupt shift felt forced and took the wind out of rivalries that fans were actually invested in.
And let’s talk about brand loyalty. Wrestlers were switching brands more often than they changed ring gear. Expecting fans to believe in their undying loyalty to a brand they might have just joined was a stretch. This inconsistency made the whole premise feel pointless.
In the end, Bragging Rights was a forgettable blip on the WWE calendar that disappeared after two years.
5. 24/7 Championship
WWE’s 24/7 Championship was supposed to be a fun nod to the old Hardcore title with its wild 24/7 rule, but it just didn’t hit the same way. The Hardcore strap worked because it was all about chaos and violent matches that fit perfectly with the Attitude Era’s edgier vibe. The 24/7 belt, on the other hand, went full comedy, turning into more of a slapstick routine than serious competition. This made it hard for fans to take it seriously.
The constant title changes didn’t help either. Sure, the Hardcore Championship had quick title swaps, but those matches felt urgent and dangerous - and the comedy was better. With the 24/7 title, it was like a revolving door, with champions changing through the most devistating move in sports entertainment multiple times in one night. This made it tough for fans to get invested in any storyline or champion.
The 24/7 segments often overshadowed more important storylines. While the comedy bits were sometimes funny, they took up screen time that could’ve been used to build up other wrestlers. Fans who wanted serious wrestling content were left frustrated.
So, while the 24/7 Championship aimed to bring some unpredictable fun to WWE, it ended up being more of a forgettable gimmick that couldn’t live up to the Hardcore Championship’s legacy. Nikki Cross literally dropping it in the crash summed the whole thing up well.
4. Anonymous Raw General Manager
The Anonymous Raw General Manager was supposed to add some mystery and intrigue to Raw, but it quickly got tedious.
The anonymous nature of the GM meant there was no accountability. Decisions came through emails read by Michael Cole, who uttered the most unbearable catchphrase each time. Without a human face to relate to or rally against, it was hard for fans to care about the GM’s decisions. Watching babyfaces feud with a computer was the dregs of wrestling.
Plus, the storyline dragged on way too long without a satisfying payoff. Fans were dying to know who the Anonymous GM was, but the reveal kept getting pushed back, leading to frustration. When the big reveal finally happened, long after the gimmick had disappeared, it was Hornswoggle, which felt more like a joke than a rewarding conclusion. Vince McMahon definitely kept 'Swoggle in his office, in a box that said in case of emergency break here, because he was used as the payoff for way too many plots.
The gimmick also messed with the flow of the show. The GM’s emails constantly interrupted matches and segments, breaking the momentum and making Raw a marathon to watch. Having the main event of WrestleMania interrupted by that infuriating Apple ringtone doesn't get mentioned enough in lists of the worst moments in WWE history.
3. Crown Jewel Championship
The Crown Jewel Championship has been introduced in a ploy to make the events in Saudi Arabia have more meaning.
Let's face it: the belt feels like a token gesture rather than a meaningful addition to WWE’s roster of titles. Unlike other championships with rich histories and significant stakes, the Crown Jewel Championship is only going to be defended once a year. Remember the Greatest Royal Rumble title? Exactly.
The whole thing opens up a load of questions that aren't even that interesting. It's just another thing that exists.
Does a wrestler have to keep their world title for a whole year to defend it? How else would they be in the match again a year later? Are they expected to carry it even if they lose their world title?
The biggest question should be: why are we supposed to care? The fact that WWE keeps bragging about how much the belt is worth, despite releasing wrestlers every year due to budgeting issues, isn't a good look for the company either.
Everybody will tune in for the show, see this belt handed to the winner, then assume it won't be seen on TV again. Life goes on.
2. Live Concerts at WrestleMania
99% of people use the live performances at WrestleMania as a bathroom break... probably.
This doesn't include when wrestlers have been played to the ring; those performances are still to do with the matches at least.
No, it's about those performances that disrupt the show. The Granddaddy of Them All is already very long, and adding concerts only stretches that runtime. Fans are there to watch wrestling, not to see whichever music star WWE has heard of that year.
Vince McMahon has always seen wrestling as a form of entertainment that goes hand-in-hand with popular culture, so it makes sense that he'd want acts like Flo Rida, Kid Rock, and Pitbull to bring extra eyes to the show - but who's spending $50 on 'Mania to see 10 minutes of live music they could watch on YouTube?
After the rock 'n' wrestling era, it wasn't until 'Mania X8 that WWE starting having bands perform in mini-gigs. Can you believe they had the audacity to get Saliva to play the event's theme song "Superstar" to open the show? Limp Bizkit played a year later, then WWE cooled off with the performances.
By 'Mania 25, Kid Rock was doing a medley of his songs and WWE has never looked back. Neither did fans, as they made their way from their seats to the bathrooms en masse.
1. Stipulation Themed Events
Stipulation-themed pay-per-views like Hell in a Cell and TLC: Tables, Ladders & Chairs, were introduced so fans would get excited about seeing these bouts every year. Ironically, that's what killed off some of their best match types. What a shame...
The forced nature of these stipulations undermined the storytelling. Not every feud needs to end inside Hell in a Cell, but the themed pay-per-views required it. This lead to matches that felt contrived, with stipulations shoehorned in rather than organically developed through the storyline. It also made for some of the worst Hell in a Cell matches in WWE history.
The overuse of certain stipulations lessened their significance. Hell in a Cell matches were once rare and reserved for the most intense rivalries. By making them an annual occurrence, the mystique and specialness of these matches was completely diminished. Fans became desensitised to the brutality (or lack thereof in the PG Era) and spectacle, reducing their overall impact.
This entry has focused on HIAC matches, but the same happened for the Elimination Chamber and TLC matches as well. If a feud was coming to an end in May, you knew it wouldn't have one of those stipulations.
To give credit where it's due: Breaking Point was a good idea, having every match end in a submission. But, for every one of those, there's a PPV called Fatal 4-Way to tip the scales back into terrible.